BPGXMG said:Even with not being forced to run Fake Out, I strongly doubt Mega Lopunny will be as good as it was in ORAS. The metagame is filled to the brim with >100 base speed scarfers that outspeed and KO it, because in this gen, Lopunny has no more defensive merit. In ORAS it had somewhat passable bulk, but now, it's pretty awful. Nomal/Fighting is also a terrible defensive typing, with just about no merit whatsoever. This makes its utility options harder to utilize effectively.
Now, I've been going off on the defensive side, but offensively, it's not half as good as what it used to be. There are Steel types that aren't weak to fighting everywhere, and they can handle Lopunny well. Ghost types are more abundant (which makes it harder to spam HJK, the more powerful STAB that can hit steels), Fairies are far more abundant and so is good physical bulk in general. What truly hurts Mega Lopunny, however, is the lacking power. 136 base attack initially seems good, but then you realize that it has no boosting item, and it just falls flat on its face. More and more offensive mons are bulky, like Zygarde and Bulu, and while Lopunny has extensive coverage to hit them, said coverage is rather weak on anything else - it NEEDS to be a super-effective hit or it's just bouncing off.
Overall, I see Mega Lopunny in A or even A- rank, to be honest. It can't keep up with the ever-rising bulk of the meta, and there are tons of mons that can outspeed and KO. I don't see it dropping to UU (though next gen I really do see that happening) but it's just not that good anymore.
I think you're underselling MLop. A lot of the things you say that have changed to make it worse were things it had to deal with in ORAS anyway, which was arguably a bulkier meta than SUMO. 136 Base attack with no boosting item seems average, but lopunny has high-powered stabs. Lopunny's HJK is about equal in power to Kartana's leaf blade.
I want to address a couple things.
Utility: Lopunny isn't a utility mon, but it still has some utility. A PuP on the switch gives it real power. A fast healing wish means it doesn't have to live a hit to bring in that other mon. Fake out will still be useful, just like it is useful on MMedi. Offensive teams often rely on repeated fake out chip to take out boosted sweepers. For example, MLop chunks offensive Landot for about 25% with fake out.
Defensive/offensive answers and bulky mons: Here's some things lopunny dealt with last meta -
bulky mons - hippo, skarm, mvenu, amoong, clef, megabro, reuni
scarfers that can OHKO - keld, lati, chomp, landot
priority -
talonflame, mpinsir
And some calcs against the bulkiest attackers in the meta -
252 Atk Lopunny-Mega High Jump Kick vs. 4 HP / 0 Def Zygarde: 186-220 (51.9 - 61.4%) -- guaranteed 2HKO after Stealth Rock
252 Atk Lopunny-Mega Return vs. 0 HP / 4 Def Tapu Bulu: 153-181 (54.4 - 64.4%) -- guaranteed 2HKO after Stealth Rock and Grassy Terrain recovery
252 Atk Lopunny-Mega High Jump Kick vs. 248 HP / 0 Def Magearna: 195-231 (53.7 - 63.6%) -- guaranteed 2HKO after Stealth Rock
252 Atk Lopunny-Mega High Jump Kick vs. 92 HP / 0 Def Mawile: 252-297 (95.4 - 112.5%) -- guaranteed OHKO after Stealth Rock (edit: ye lol mmaw isn't that bulky but that's a nice ohko)
That's a fine damage output for a breaker. It KOs zygarde and bulky mage on the switch. It needs hazards to get it's ohkos and 2hkos, but so do a lot of breakers, and hazards are abundant and easy to keep down right now.
The rise of ghost types is a good thing, as they can't hit lop with their ghost stab, and it
can hit them with its stab. Free switchins to choice locked gengar and predicted mimikyu shadow claws, both of which it OHKO's after rocks.
I don't entirely disagree with your points; I think some new threats and some old defensive ones that came back will give it trouble. It'll almost require hazards to be down or else it'll be switching out a lot when it fails to reach certain 2hkos. And tbh I agree with your viability placement (I thought you were gonna say B+ or something after that post).