NOC Nomination Mafia Game Thread

zorbees said:
i think i have, back when i was a more common noc player before this latest resurgence, i just remember metal sonic as being really spazzy and I don't see how what he has been doing has been alignment indicative one way or another
Click to expand...

Oh, that's what he normally does? Good to know. It still bothers me though. It's flighty and changes without much logic or reason, which still reads scum to me.
 
Hitmonleet said:
He keeps bringing up things like DBZ mafia, so I assumed he was a vet that came back.

What I mean is, can you detail your thoughts on your suspects (Thunder, Granny, and Hawkie), and how your thoughts have changed since you said you suspected them.
Click to expand...
Thunder - no content /little content , i remember mostly from pages 1-7

Granny - followed hawkie like crazy no one call him/her out until I did early on

Hawkie - is my town read for obv reasons

Speculated that at least 1 mafia was on sonic because it was a quick wagon
 
eeeeeeeehhhh i still dont think hitmonleet is scum, believe it or not

newer players tend to scumread me for the dumbest reasons -> cos i don't type like a upper-class aristocrat

earlio pretty much detailed it pretty well during rvs, i tend to get that a lot
 
then again mafia is a hard game to learn in general and like newer players really cant tell town from scum correctly for like 1 year so i dont really blame them
usually following the biggest town leaders results in a win but they never learn anything that way
 
Hawkie said:
Granny Pie has switched lynches and reads a lot today and I think that's more indicative of a relatively new player taking in the situation and trying to play the game properly
Click to expand...

you keep defending grannie pie like you've seen her role pm or something

like i dont even have so much love for granny pie except the name and avatar
 
Thunder~BALLZ said:
Granny Pie honestly look terrible right now. "I want to stay loyal to Hawkie" stop attaching yourself to people and get your own damn reads.
Click to expand...
Granny Pie said:
I don't have a problem with Asek. Sure, his questions were a little invading, but that just feels to me like a lost townie trying to get any solid info on his side. It could also be scummy, but I don't know enough yet
I like how Haruno just jumps in and starts scum-tunnelling. It feels efficient and helpful, like what Hawkie was doing at the beginning of the game.
Jalmont is also fine right now. I'm sorry that I don't post a lot. Again, I don't know a lot yet, and that's what I got for you.
Metal Sonic... bothers me. He's erratic. He's desperate. And he doesn't give us a lot of good reasoning. So I guess I'm right back wh where I started. Lynch Metal Sonic.
Thunderballz is a little suspect, but I can't get a solid read on him. I keep looking for solid "this person's scum, this person's town" reads, but I can't do that correctly with my little experience and little personal knowledge of these people's playstyles. That being said, Thunderballz def responded to his pressure, but not nearly as much and not nearly as thoroughly as Metal Sonic did. Maybe he's just got better control, but Sonic reads way more scum to me than TBZ.
I want to remain loyal to Hawkie, 'cause he likes me, and has got some stuff done in thr first day. But I do keep in mind that his "pressuring" could have feasibly just nudged an edgy townie into scum-looking. If Metal Sonic flips townie, I'm not sure I'll look at Hawkie the same way, especially as now that everyone is focusing on Metal Sonic, Hawkie slipped away from leading the lynch wagon. If Metal Sonic's scum, then Hawkie's clean af. But if Metal Sonic's clean, then I think we all should watch Hawkie with a bit more scrutiny.
Click to expand...
I'm working on it.
 
let me take a moment to consolidate how i feel about everyone cos i dont have a very strong feel for anyone scum atm
mmight be a lurker

Metal Sonic

town
Earlio
zorbees
Jalmont
Hitmonleet
Hawkie
King_
Asek
Granny Pie
Haruno
Thunder~BALLZ
scum

tsk this is pretty bad
 
ok i just reread the game because i didnt have a strong scumread and that was pretty bad, so i did and i have found a scum!

lynch king

tballz recent responses have been a little better so i'm keeping him on the watchlist for now but king is really scummy if u look at everything

1 by 1 he's pretty ok but if u look at everything he's quite bad so i'm gonna stick this here and see which scumpartners defends him
 
Granny Pie said:
I don't have a problem with Asek. Sure, his questions were a little invading, but that just feels to me like a lost townie trying to get any solid info on his side. It could also be scummy, but I don't know enough yet
I like how Haruno just jumps in and starts scum-tunnelling. It feels efficient and helpful, like what Hawkie was doing at the beginning of the game.
Jalmont is also fine right now. I'm sorry that I don't post a lot. Again, I don't know a lot yet, and that's what I got for you.
Metal Sonic... bothers me. He's erratic. He's desperate. And he doesn't give us a lot of good reasoning. So I guess I'm right back wh where I started. Lynch Metal Sonic.
Thunderballz is a little suspect, but I can't get a solid read on him. I keep looking for solid "this person's scum, this person's town" reads, but I can't do that correctly with my little experience and little personal knowledge of these people's playstyles. That being said, Thunderballz def responded to his pressure, but not nearly as much and not nearly as thoroughly as Metal Sonic did. Maybe he's just got better control, but Sonic reads way more scum to me than TBZ.
I want to remain loyal to Hawkie, 'cause he likes me, and has got some stuff done in thr first day. But I do keep in mind that his "pressuring" could have feasibly just nudged an edgy townie into scum-looking. If Metal Sonic flips townie, I'm not sure I'll look at Hawkie the same way, especially as now that everyone is focusing on Metal Sonic, Hawkie slipped away from leading the lynch wagon. If Metal Sonic's scum, then Hawkie's clean af. But if Metal Sonic's clean, then I think we all should watch Hawkie with a bit more scrutiny.
Click to expand...
Seems balls af if someone is immediately willing to going for one of the big wall posters so suspicious ._.
 
Don't understand Granny Pie being scumread lol.

Since when does a mafia goonie publicly latch on to another player and publicly post about following them.

zorbees said:
that entire post by hitmonleet cements he is scum to me, his reads are the most basic of the basic

metal sonic = shifty, probably scum (no, its just how metal sonic always is)
hawkie = contributing a lot, probably town (probably, but if certain people flip scum i'm going to be skeptical of hawkie)
jalmont = i like when he tries (everyone does)
thunderballz = why even mention him if you don't have anything to say
grannypie = another non-read that you are hedging on
Click to expand...

reminds me of matrix d1 he gave similar bread n butter reads d1 and was lynched as scum d2
 
You must log in or register to reply here.
Back
Top