-
Welcome to Smogon! Take a moment to read the Introduction to Smogon for a run-down on everything Smogon, and make sure you take some time to read the global rules.
NOC Animal Mafia ~Game Over~
- Thread starter Scarlet Firefly
- Start date
- Status
why would you not just say that you're a vt if you're an info role 
Why would he not say he's been redirected when it's public he was? It sounds more like a stupid mistake then an attempt to lie as I personally feel if a scum is lieing, they are going to be more careful with their lie compared to just saying something off handed or w/e.Why would he say "this guy is town" when he's been redirected if he remembered that he had been redirected what the fuck man
basically this yeahwhy would you not just say that you're a vt if you're an info role
shruggg, this is going just as well as I sort of expected but eh
scum are probably having a field day right now with these half-massclaims
It comes down to what's at stake. Right now the two main lynch options (XX and Haruno) are claiming to be BG (aka omni but same thing I guess for this) and Cop. Those roles, out of anything town has, are the two most valuable to town so accidentally lynching them would be terrible.
Which is why I would prefer to be absolutely certain someone is scum before potentially lynching the town cop, even if I have a scum read on them. Simply, what we would lose > what we would gain by waiting to be more sure before lynching them through results or whatever. But more so, I'd rather take the risk of losing the omniguard, or neither of them, before taking the risk of losing the cop.
that's exactly my point in that the most likely explanation is that he forgot about it
and in my view giving incorrect info to town as a town cop who's kind of pissed that they've been redirected is a big screw up while giving fake "safe" cop results under pressure and forgetting that you were supposed to be redirected is more believable
as in more likely to have happened
Okay, do this for me. There's two worlds right now
One where XX is town and forgot or w/e about the redirect and messed up
One where XX is mafia and fake claimed
My thought process right now is going into each of those worlds and seeing what would most likely happen. Like for example, I feel if XX was mafia fake claiming, he would mention the redirect or w/e and be less likely to not mention it while as town, just forgetting. Which is why I'm whatever responding to this
that was not an actual third party claim there are no wolves in this game stop
Dude's blown today up into a panic. He is dropping in my eyes.
Contradicting the redirect with results doesn't make sense as either alignment and is ultimately wifom though I believe it to be a scum slip, this redirect thing is not the only reason to lynch Jordan at all and he is flipping red
are you serious about this?
apricity joking about a 3rd party claim, when it is confirmed that there are none in the OP, and you're trying to use him saying that fakeclaiming is bad as a reason to scumread him?
Claim whale the vt with a headache
Explain this more please. Frankly, I think the kind of behavior he had is towny.
Anyways, thinking through things. I do think there is one possibility (but a really dumb one), he is simply inactive to the point where he isn't reading the thread thoroughly/not paying attention to the game. It would certainly explain why he didn't mention the redirect and well, why he hasn't been active at all.
ngl...that's a wimpy as hell theory but it's simple and right now my head hurts so I like simple dumb theories.
That quote is a separate point. Hal freaking out and pushing Haruno as lying though a detail of the info we have suggests Haruno probably isn't has not been helpful today.
The only thing Hal has done today is pad the gameposts with wild fonts and colors and been a distraction.
Coating a bad push in panic fluff still makes it a bad push.
?????????????????????????????????????????????????????????????????????????????????????????????????????????????????????????????????????????????????????????????????????????????????????????????????????????????????????????????????????????????????????????????????????????????????????????????????????????????????????????????????????????????????????????????????????????????????????????????????????????????????????????????????????????????????????????
OK SO IF SOMEONE CONTRADICTING YOUR OWN ROLE IS NOT BEING ABSOLUTELY CERTAIN WHAT STANDARD MUST WE REACH TO BE ABSOLUTELY CERTAIN SOMEONE IS MAFIA
- Status