NOC 2d3 Mafia - Game Over, Town Win! (and postgame is up)

[apricity]

texas is bleeding town because he was drunk?

this is actually pretty much it yeah

i believe in it though

 

[apricity]

i have actual reasons for townreading caff and dusk

but what do you think about them

 

[vooper]

i have actual reasons for townreading caff and dusk

but what do you think about them

town lean on caff cause the tone of his posts reads like town but ive never seen his scum game. sometimes it feels like he is just doing filler posts randomly to get town cred but they are funny filler posts so i get why he posted them if he was town lol i want him to talk with substance more

null on dusk cause not enough stuff yada yada yada really dont think he has done anything aside from scum read me and heal and other random fillers

 

[smogon account]

unvote
No longer suspicious of lazer
I'm currently working on a caffeineboost apricity team
I don't think the 5 players in apricitys town block are all town
Not sure where votes sit but certainly intent to vote caffeineboost

 

[smogon account]

I like viper
We can be friends I think
Nuxl also slightly towny
Healndeal hard claimed vanilla and I see no reason to think he's lying tbh

 

[Nuxl]

Unofficial Vote Count(think this is right)
HealnDeal(2): caffeineboost apricity
Viper(1): duskfall
Apricity(3): viper, IFML, heal
ImmaFirinMahLazer(2): nuxl, texas
not voting: smogon account

ty for posting, glad u got ur thoughts out. makes me feel a bit better about ur slot

Duskfall98 you've been lurking this thread a few times today. please post something of substance

 

[Nuxl]

apricity at L-2 above

 

[Nuxl]

Hey Nuxl, you seem experienced for a first timer. This means one of several things.

1. You have played live games hence the specific mention of forum games in your signup post.
2. You have played forum games and are a compulsive liar
3. You are actually in the Sicilian Mafia and have learnt the game through real life.

Pick. My read on you will depend greatly on the option you choose.

chose my option, interested in hearing this answer, honored you think i could be lying here lol

thinking about it, am kinda confused why you think my experience out of the game is important enough for you to make a read on me versus analyzing what i'm saying ingame though. why is that important enough to deduce what your read of me is? and why would i lie here?

I'm currently working on a caffeineboost apricity team
I don't think the 5 players in apricitys town block are all town
Not sure where votes sit but certainly intent to vote caffeineboost

are texas/dusk null slots for u atm? cuz u didnt mention em.

vote duskfall98

i have a bad feeling about voting lazer rn, but i really think this slot needs to speak up more

 

[ImmaFirinMahLazer]

Please explain everything that went through your mind while writing this. Leave nothing out.

Heres the inner working's of my mind


Neutral read: Seems very experienced, He really doesnt say much with his posts, however with what he has said most of the time, it doesnt need further explanation.

This phrase "i agree with nuxl that heal's post and claim feels sincere and also agree with apricit'y's vote that it is as a result extremely suspect" and this phrase "heal's recent post is very stiff tho, catching my attention" jumped out to me early game, just felt like something someone who's played a lot of mafia would say. However lots of it could be considered filler but its just early game.



"Would love to see more detailed posts from him later, however could be not saying much as hes trying to not seem like a big threat as a power role, or that hes trying to seem helpful as town but not be too helpful as hes scum. Dont have a good read on him yet tho."


I would love to hear more fleshed out thoughts from you, as I think it would help town a lot but I feel as you're not saying much as you are trying to stay undetected

This is what was going through my mind as I typed the original reading

 

[JALMONT]

I'm posting a votecount soon.

 

[JALMONT]

VOTECOUNT

Duskfall98 (1): Nuxl
IFML (1): Texas
Heal (2): CaffeineBoost, apricity
apricity (3): Viper, Heal, IFML

ImmaFirinMahLazer I counted your vote this time but in the future please bold your vote - makes it hard for me to keep track otherwise. Thanks

obv if i messed up let me know etc etc

 

[Texas Cloverleaf]

Need to sleep on it but I think the lazer wagon is good

 

[Nuxl]

Hi Duskfall98 what's up

 

[Duskfall98]

HealnDeal: I am pretty confident he is not vt by his way too early claim. Either he is scum trying to get some town cred, or he is a town power role trying to avoid being killed by mafia throuh claiming vt imo. Only problem with a bus on him is we may force him to reclaim and then get eliminated tonight as a power role. His actions are scummy enough to me though that it's worth the risk. Also the whole how viper is typing thing is still out there to me, I feel like no one is addressing that even though we should be.

apricity: The whole aggressiveness thing I can't follow. Hal is pretty much always like that I think, as scum last game he started firing out insults when he was read as scum. He hasn't gone that far so much this game so I am going to say he is not as aggressive as he could be. The fact he doesn't seem to bothered about people scumreading him, example:

Neither of these three things will happen. But if you vote heal I might join you.

This makes me town read him. Mafia would tend to want to get people off them asap to try stop a bus I think.

IFML: I'm kinda neutral on, he has not done anything wildly scummy to me, sure maybe a bit defensive but that can easily happen as town if you are close to getting lynched. Also, not voting immediately could just be him trying to get his read correct and gather as much information as possible. There is no real reason to rush to a lynch, we have a lot of time. Even if some of us prefer to bus and put pressure on people, it doesn't mean IFML is going to take that course as town.

Smogon account: Keeping minimal involvement in the game I feel, hopefully he picks up his activity. Neutral on him now but if he doesn't get more involved I may begin to suspect as scum trying to fly below the radar.

Nuxl: I'm really unsure about tbh, lean town slightly but he seems like he has played before to me which makes me wonder why he would say he hasn't? Unless he really extensively researched everything about the game which I suppose is possible.

ok i am awake now


hal actually hasnt explained his reasoning for this yet and it is unsettling yet ppl are still sheeping him


the bias post was half a meme and half me pointing out that
1) hal has a good scum game
2) i know hal well outside of this game
3) hal has done smth that he did in his last scum game and that seems sus

also if you think getting hal out is easy idk what is going on in ur brain lol. he will kick and scream until you get your vote off him lmao



is no1 else a little put off by these posts?? he has not once given reasoning most of this stuff only thing i think he gave reasoning for was a nuxl town read



what tf lol, while i havent played a lot of mafia im p sure ending a day in 2/5th of the time by hammering only helps mafia. less time for them to slip up, early hammers can have a lot of faults, ect



an excuse for what? i never said that i would be reading him as scum purely because of a different game i said that since i know how he plays i will be on the lookout for it



what preconceived notions? all i have said is, once again, these 3 things
1) hal has a good scum game
2) i know hal well outside of this game
3) hal has done smth that he did in his last scum game and that seems sus

along with a joke about me being paranoid this game cause i dont want to lose to hal a 3rd time


until hal actually explains his reasoning on me im putting this here
vote apricity
if any1 says this is omgus im throwing you and your family in the trash can lol

in conclusion, please get off of me and if you want me to elaborate on any of this or explain smth better lmk

I did not say getting hal out of the game is easy. Trust me I know the exact opposite is true. I said it was easy to susp him on a bad reasoning such as he was scum last game so I don't trust him. Just because someone has a good scum game doesn't mean we should just off them at the start in case they are scum. Just to clear up this I have no problem with a scum read on hal, it's just this reasoning that I HATE. Can you forget about past problems you have with each other please, whatever they are?

Caffeine: Ok, I am aware his joking about scum is a joke. But the fact he's done it multiple times is slightly suspicious to me. I dunno, just seems like slightly guilty behaviour that he keeps emphasising it. It is not enough to actually bus him, but I wouldn't be surprised if he was scum.

Texas: Yeah I am just neutral here, nothing important to say so I won't. I will wait for more posts from him.

 

[Duskfall98]

Vote HealnDeal

 

[Nuxl]

Heal is at L-2

When you use the word bus do you mean wagon? They're entirely different

Who else would you feel comfortable lynching d1

 

[Duskfall98]

Heal is at L-2

When you use the word bus do you mean wagon? They're entirely different

Who else would you feel comfortable lynching d1

See I didn't even know they are different lol. How do you know this?

 

[Duskfall98]

I'd lynch either viper or healndeal still, but I don't see any reason to rush things.

 

[Nuxl]

See I didn't even know they are different lol. How do you know this?

I read up on stuff before I started playing

 

[Nuxl]

I'd lynch either viper or healndeal still, but I don't see any reason to rush things.

Ok noted.
Do you think viper and heal could be partners? Or do you think one of the two is scummy?

 

[Duskfall98]

Ok noted.
Do you think viper and heal could be partners? Or do you think one of the two is scummy?

I think it's unlikely but possible. Heal went for the throat of viper then when they both got scum read they seemed to turn their attention to hal, maybe they feel like they had distanced themselves enough at that point?

 

[Nuxl]

I think it's unlikely but possible. Heal went for the throat of viper then when they both got scum read they seemed to turn their attention to hal, maybe they feel like they had distanced themselves enough at that point?

I don't think viper tried to distance from heal at all

 

[Duskfall98]

Heal scum reading viper distances them though... Not saying I think they both are scum, I just don't think it's impossible.

 

[Duskfall98]

Do you think they could both be scum?

 

[Nuxl]

I don't think it's both, no