NOC Reinforcements SCUM WIN.

InfernoDragon218 said:
Also, I feel that we are basically just taking what Hal says at fact at this point. This is obviously not the best idea considering we have zero idea whether what he says is right, even though he is solidly town. I feel we are basing the reads on Texas’s as well just because he was town. I agree with you on Nuxl, but I’m not quite sure on Asek and I really think we are rushing a bit.
Click to expand...
Hm, quite a bit of saying something without actually trying to say it.
 
I’m going to nap but here’s some thought. If we are just lynching through the POE there’s an argument to make that we should just go through it in reverse order of usefulness ie lynch ifml today

Townreads are stronger than scumreads this game
 
Former Hope said:
Okay.... then what do you think we should do?
And what are your current reads of everyone?
Click to expand...

Personally, this is how I am leaning

Town: Energy, Apricity, Duskfall, FH
Not sure: Jailmont, Viper
Scum: Nuxl, IFML, Asek

I think Nuxl is the most scummy bc of his awkward demeanor, limited posting, and repeated attempts to seem like the great town player he was last game
 
InfernoDragon218 said:
Alright so I think lynching FH is the right choice here. He’s had some pretty scummy behavior including his constant attacks on hal and his attitude lately now that he seems to be the lynch. I’m not going to change my vote at the moment just to deliberate a little more but this is how I am leaning
Click to expand...
From this to a town read :blobthinking:

ngl Inferno, not a good look for you. Your read list looks like just a composition of other people's reads.
 
Former Hope said:
From this to a town read :blobthinking:

ngl Inferno, not a good look for you. Your read list looks like just a composition of other people's reads.
Click to expand...

Dude you can literally say anyone’s read list is a composition of other people’s. It’s the same people on a list

And on my opinion on you, yes the sudden change might seem odd. However, in that moment, I believed you were the best option of the ones there seemed to be general consensus on. I was still undecided on you in general, but saw you as the most scummy of our options at the moment
 
Former Hope said:
I agree that apricity isn't lock town by any case.

But here's what I see for the cop claiming.

We don't have a number of people that feel really towny. Which is a nice base. We also have a nice opportunity this game in that we have a cop and a back up cop.

If a cop claims today, they end up clearing both themselves and another play. But more importantly, it starts a clock for the number of turns the mafia can use their actions.

....and at this point I went back and realized it was a 2x strongman and not a 1x strongman like I thought.

See, with a 1x strongman, it would have worked out well since it would have forced them to use it on the first cop and then all they could do is hook the 2nd cop for a few turns, while we have two doctors that can heal them. However factoring in that they have two strongman's and not one, I don't really like that idea nearly as much.

Then again, there is a chance they used it last night. Frankly, a kill on texas was bold because any decent doctor should have been on him. Meaning (and I hope this is the case because if not, I'm sorry doc, that was a poor play) there's a good chance the doc did protect him lastnight and they burned a strongman on him. This is 100% speculation, but I really hope it's the case as if it's not, it's a sad thing for town.
Click to expand...

Please elaborate why doctor should have so obviously been on Texas.
 
InfernoDragon218 said:
Also, I feel that we are basically just taking what Hal says at fact at this point. This is obviously not the best idea considering we have zero idea whether what he says is right, even though he is solidly town. I feel we are basing the reads on Texas’s as well just because he was town. I agree with you on Nuxl, but I’m not quite sure on Asek and I really think we are rushing a bit.
Click to expand...

I’ve seen the name over and over, but who is hal and why is s/he solidly town.
 
apricity said:
Here’s the thing right

Mafia is like an arms race

Let’s take me and Texas last game. I conftowned texas because he was drunk posting on page 1. I can’t use that tell again because Texas knows I use that tell, so he’s able to emulate it as scum

So what you do is you use tells and don’t tell people what they are. I will never share my strong tells on relevant players and just stockpile them (ala arms race) until one day I need to share them. Which would destroy my stockpile

Does this make sense
Click to expand...

I'm a firm believer in playing how you want to play.

That doesn't mean everyone else should change and submit to how you want to play.

You do whatever you want, but that doesn't mean that everyone has to take you (or viper, since it applies to him) seriously. Which they shouldn't.
 
Energy said:
No. i don’t particularly care. i asked you a question because i’d like an answer. i’d want to hear your logic either way.
Click to expand...
Yeah you haven’t been super helpful and I have strong behavioral tells on viper and dusk, and Texas put himself between me and FH so I’ll assume there was some reason for that
 
apricity said:
I’m going to nap but here’s some thought. If we are just lynching through the POE there’s an argument to make that we should just go through it in reverse order of usefulness ie lynch ifml today

Townreads are stronger than scumreads this game
Click to expand...
This still sounds reasonable btw
 
You must log in or register to reply here.
Back
Top