Mafia vs Village Raiders of the Lost Mafia - Game Over, Town Wins!

if anyone has any information that they think is relevant to finding scum they should go public.

people shouldnt just share their temple info willy nilly because that is more likely to help scum imo than help town.

Former Hope i've seen countless games lost because a mole was set up on the first cycle. i've seen very few games lost because town decided to wait a little too long to get going.
 
right the issue with a mole is if we give them everything i.e. full roleclaims, which i think is a terrible idea
i genuinely dont see what harm comes out of telling nuxl the temple we visited - its like asking for role name claims, which is something untrusted town leaders have done before.
 
zorbees said:
if anyone has any information that they think is relevant to finding scum they should go public.

people shouldnt just share their temple info willy nilly because that is more likely to help scum imo than help town.

Former Hope i've seen countless games lost because a mole was set up on the first cycle. i've seen very few games lost because town decided to wait a little too long to get going.
Click to expand...
So what you believe, is that we should just sit around and no lynch. Until someone can be publicly confirmed or finds scum?

Because that's what your suggesting.
 
we're giving scum time to do whatever they want??
like you're ignoring the positives of getting town organized in favor of skirting the chance that nuxl could be scum - when if he was idt hed be getting much benefit from the temples we visited
 
rssp1 i just feel like its more likely that scum finds something interesting than a town leader find something useful out of temple stuff. For example, the temples that require someone to idle or the temples that people are supposed to go to a bunch of times in a row were probably visited by people with weaker roles. if the mafia knows which people went to which temples, they can narrow down who has a useful role. then there is the fact that the mafia might have more info on the temples than we do, considering the old trope of the mafias being the "informed" factions.

I also don't really see how we are going to find anything useful out of it. Like there are only a small handful of temples that involve alignment. Also I think it will be really hard to know if someone is lying about which temple they went to, considering the wide array of different possible results.
 
mulling this over because im not sure who to pick. few other people seem err to me but i think this is the worst one

Vote Lady Salamence

has a very weird claim(neighborizer who seems to have got one extra vote overnight) which doesn't make sense in an OC and whose role name hints heavily toward cultists.
 
if i can defend myself: OM room can vouch for me that yeti made a pm thread titled RotLM Neighbor PM between the two of us

as for my role name, now that you say it i can see the cultist hit but i feel like that wouldn't make sense? idk how to explain myself without laying myself straight out on the line by saying what my role name was
 
Samantha NatalieToday at 9:39 AM
anyway ye i made a 'neighborhood' with OM room which made a pm thread w/ him
also my vote counts for more now i think? idrgi
i thought my role was like an escort or something
an
and i can like stop some1 from doing something
elikToday at 9:40 AM
uh what is your exact role name?
Samantha NatalieToday at 9:40 AM
but it made a pm thread
whcih seems like a bad escort lol
hold on let me open the pm
Priest iirc
elikToday at 9:41 AM
what does your action say?
so you could interpret that you have
a neighborhood and +X vote?
Samantha NatalieToday at 9:41 AM
i can choose one per night to "join a neighborhood with you"
it doesn't say shit about voting
my n1 result included
"your vote now counts for two today"
so probably not a hook then
mayor i guess
elikToday at 9:42 AM
you might be a neighborizer?
Samantha NatalieToday at 9:42 AM
i don't recognize that role
elikToday at 9:42 AM
in NOCs it's used to make a PM conversation overnight with another player
Samantha NatalieToday at 9:42 AM
ooh that sounds fun in NOC
elikToday at 9:42 AM
and as such they can discuss the game without knowing each other's alignments
Samantha NatalieToday at 9:42 AM
never played a NOC i think
elikToday at 9:42 AM
but i really don't see why you'd have that here?
Samantha NatalieToday at 9:42 AM
but sounds fun for a NOC
yea idk
my guess cuirrently is that i can steal his vote
elikToday at 9:43 AM
or maybe both of your votes are boosted by 1?
Samantha NatalieToday at 9:43 AM
mb
elikToday at 9:43 AM
no idk
i just don't know
Samantha NatalieToday at 9:43 AM
same
elikToday at 9:43 AM
have you talked to OM room in there?
Samantha NatalieToday at 9:43 AM
not the most productive of convos:
om: Cool
Hi
me: mostly just curious what this does
him: lol
me: in my defense its been years
him: i dont play much either
me: oic
paraphrased
elikToday at 9:44 AM
lmfao
that's valid
have you contacted anyone else in the game so far?
Samantha NatalieToday at 9:45 AM
ive read the thread
nobody's reached out to me
i was sick mon and had 2 dr appts, a train ride, class and homework tuesday
you're the first i've spoken to directly
and obv om room
and yeti
but that's obvious i guess lol
elikToday at 9:46 AM
ah okay


OM room
the problem is OM room hasn't responded to me after claiming so i have no way how to verify this or not. he's been subsequently MIA
 
Lady Salamence said:
if i can defend myself: OM room can vouch for me that yeti made a pm thread titled RotLM Neighbor PM between the two of us

as for my role name, now that you say it i can see the cultist hit but i feel like that wouldn't make sense? idk how to explain myself without laying myself straight out on the line by saying what my role name was
Click to expand...

ugh yeah. OM room has disappeared so it's almost impossible for me to verify this. I just don't know why a neighborizer would exist in an OC
 
requesting time for om room to confirm or for another night to swing by so i can Mr. Rogers someone else? i picked at random from the list NGL so my mistake on picking someone who subsequently went awol
 
You must log in or register to reply here.
Back
Top