NOC D6 Mafia Game Thread [Day 4; Deadline June 1 at 6 PM EST]

Status
Not open for further replies.
Samoyed said:
Admitting that you’ve done wrong is not towny and is entirely mafialike
Click to expand...

I mean legitimately what do you expect me to do when the entire case against me is based on my tone. All I can do is explain why my tone might be different, continue to play the game, and hope that over time I will begin to look better.
 
Frankly, just because Hannah defended me doesn't make either of us scum. Town defending town in this game is entirely possible. With that said I don't know how I feel about Hannah. Her entrance was fairly good and felt genuine. Samoyed can you explain why you voted for Hannah in the first place.
 
Samo, my opinion on this Mew wagon is a thumbsup emoji
Out of everyone, Mew felt most directionless and uncertain. They give off an awkward vibe, seems to be apologetic for screwing things up
 
Last edited:
apricity doesn't deserve townleans

Athena feels strong, I get positive vibes but it's debatable whether that translates to town or scum. Gut says town, but don't quote me on that (yet)

DS. is another player that needs to deliver more meat
 
Samo is fun and courageous, I tend to give townlean to this sort of players, but it's too early, ask me later

XnadrojX flavorless

vote Hannahh cause her posts have been a bit fluffy and Mew has plenty of votes already
 
MewtwoHidden said:
I mean legitimately what do you expect me to do when the entire case against me is based on my tone. All I can do is explain why my tone might be different, continue to play the game, and hope that over time I will begin to look better.
Click to expand...
You can’t hope over time to look better you have to make yourself look better and right now you’re failing
 
MewtwoHidden said:
Frankly, just because Hannah defended me doesn't make either of us scum. Town defending town in this game is entirely possible. With that said I don't know how I feel about Hannah. Her entrance was fairly good and felt genuine. Samoyed can you explain why you voted for Hannah in the first place.
Click to expand...
now you’re defending Hannah because you like that they defended you
This sort of insecurity is very evil
 
Samoyed said:
now you’re defending Hannah because you like that they defended you
This sort of insecurity is very evil
Click to expand...

I have Hannah as a neutral. I liked her entry. I think her defense of me isn't entirely logical but I'm not so sure if I expect that from her. I do think you are using her as a soft target and I don't like that.
 
CaffeineBoost said:
This feels like a somewhat blind wagon. I don't think that struggling to find a serious vote on Day 1 of all days is really much of a reason to lynch Mewtwo.
Click to expand...
CaffeineBoost said:
Is this why you voted? Posts 45 and 46 would suggest that you voted Mewtwo on an OMGUS.


And until now you haven't really provided any reason as to why you voted for Mewtwo.
Mind clarifying your mindset here?
Click to expand...
 
MewtwoHidden said:
I have Hannah as a neutral. I liked her entry. I think her defense of me isn't entirely logical but I'm not so sure if I expect that from her. I do think you are using her as a soft target and I don't like that.
Click to expand...
Hannahh said:
Some town cred going to M2H right now for admitting what they've done is weird, against their playstyle, and slightly scummy. If they don't change how they act tho :shrug: will turn into a scumlean. The way Dusk is being less than usual aggro (or maybe like 75% of the games we've been in I've seen him being extremely aggro) so I'm slightly sring him for that.

I guess as of right now M2H and Hal seem like town, Dusk seems slightly scummy, and Athena is a gut read town but I have no reason as to why.
Click to expand...
her Defense of you is halfhearted and won’t have any impact on the future of the game unless I persecute it
 
CaffeineBoost said:
This seems like a pseudo RVS vote reason more than anything else. The comment on this being a potential slip seems like it's jumping to conclusions.

Not really getting anything from Dusk vs Mewtwo. Both raise some fair points but I think this is just the result of Dusk misreading what Mewtwo said and that, if anything, it's probably TvT.
Click to expand...
CaffeineBoost said:
I don't think mewtwo's vote shifting is really much of a reason to lynch him. Mewtwo is one of the few people who have posted anything of any substance and the reasoning behind each vote is sound enough to justify a vote at this stage.
Click to expand...
 
Clarinet said:
Mew, how do you feel about Caffeine?
Click to expand...

I haven't developed a solid read on him yet as most of what he's done is just defend me and question people that are voting me, which I like, but I can't help but feel that scum!Caffeine might be trying to give himself town cred for opposing my lynch if it did go through.

I just think its weird that Samo thinks Hannah defending me is bad when Caffeine has defended me much more profusely.
 
Neutral on Clarinet. Right now I think Samoyd is acting a bit weird. Quite a bit of filler as well as the tunnelling on Mewtwo.
Samoyed said:
You can’t hope over time to look better you have to make yourself look better and right now you’re failing
Click to expand...
Samoyed said:
now you’re defending Hannah because you like that they defended you
This sort of insecurity is very evil
Click to expand...
These kinds of posts makes it seem to me that Sam is actively looking for ways to lynch Mewtwo. Pressuring Hannah for defending Mewtwo but not me also seems a bit strange given how vocal I've been on my opinion on the Mewtwo wagon. Idk how you wouldn't notice that.
Unvote: Mewtwo
Vote: Samoyd
Scum lean for now. Also Mewtwo is a town lean. Their defence seems towny.
 
Status
Not open for further replies.
Back
Top