Okay, finished reread, I'm ditching all dusk paranoia until further notice. Post #256 is good, sam vote then almost instant unvote is super non-agenday and eod attempted lynch swing is still town.
Hannah reads good overall and never kills hal imo
Sam/Dusk/Hannah/Me town circle
Unordered poe:
---------------------------------------------------------
Jordan
Caf had 4 TR's throughout D1: Mewtwo/Hal/Me/Jordan, Mewtwo was a white knight read, Hal/Me reads read extremely pockety in hindsight, Jordan read doesn't feel like these two read at all. His reasons are always gut and feel almost apologetic, like this one
Nadroj has similarly shown themselves to be invested in the game as town but I don't really have much experience playing with them so I'm not confident enough to say they're a town read just yet.
Interesting is that caf is unwavering in this townread, but after he becomes the main wagon D2 and is asked to find a partner for clarinet he jumps on jordan which feels almost like anti-spew.
But, like with Hannah, Hal towncircled him so it's kind of weird to kill him. His posts overall read pretty good.
Case town!Clarinet
D2 is horrible. He spends the first half of the day voting clarinet, then jumps to caf as soon as caf becomes the leading wagon. Lynch this
Case scum!Clarinet
I don't see jordan being a third here bc of votals around votal 1.2:
Clarinet (4)- Athena_57, XnadrojX,
CaffeineBoost, MewtwoHidden
Athena_57 (2)- apricity, DS.
MewtwoHidden (3)- Samoyed, Clarinet
DS. (1)- bluedoom
Most important thing here is that in a scum!clarinet+jordan world I really doubt caf jumps on as well. Jordan/Caf bussing individually is possible but Clarinet wasn't close to doomed here so a double bus seems excessive
So I'm almost tempted to say Jordan is scum if and only if Clarinet is town
--------------------------------------------
Clarinet
I was gonna say clear this slot until LYLO but holy fuck this day looks bad and the slip could be real?
--------------------------------------------
Whydon
I want to say votal 1.3 looks pretty bad for him regardless of Clarinet's alignment? Here, whydon is the most recently placed vote
MewtwoHidden (4)- Samoyed, Clarinet, Duskfall98, Whydon
Clarinet (3)- Athena_57, XnadrojX,
CaffeineBoost
bluedoom (2)- apricity, MewtwoHidden
Athena_57 (1)- DS.
DS. (1)- bluedoom
Scum!Clarinet ==> whydon made the counterwagon the top contender
Town!Clarinet ==> We have double town wagons so him/caf splitting up makes sense
Honestly this slot is pretty close to null but the poe is pretty small so he'll probably end up getting the axe
---------------------------------------------
Vooper
I like voop. He reads town. But he's not town circle territory and the hal kill makes the most sense in a scumteam with Dusk/Voop imo bc I feel like they respect him the most.
----------------------------------------------
Scummiest 3 people imo are Clarinet/Jordan/Whydon so this would be my lynchpool if I had to lock it in rn
But idt clarinet/jordan are paired so if the one of those we flip first flips scum I swap out the other for Vooper.
I feel like we should spend the day figuring out which one of clarinet/jordan needs to go (leaning clarinet but really want a second opinion from sam here)
A possibility is we just get rid of whydon today bc he needs to go at some point so we have more time to come to a decision wrt the other two
