-
Check out the relaunch of our general collection, with classic designs and new ones by our very own Pissog!
-
Welcome to Smogon! Take a moment to read the Introduction to Smogon for a run-down on everything Smogon, and make sure you take some time to read the global rules.
NOC New World NOC - GAME OVER
- Thread starter Samoyed
- Start date
Thinking ahead, tonight the suspect pool (via POE)
Jalmont
DS
Whydon
(not adding nuxl because un CC'd vig, not adding myself because it's pretty clear heal has to be mafia here and there's no conceivable way to spin Heal and I as Scum v Scum)
If we assume DS is town, which role wise, makes sense, then we can figure out mafia tonight by having DS block one of them (and DS should state target prior to day ending) I'm going to randomize idling my doctor shot or using it on either nuxl or DS, (so idle, DS, Nuxl), which does present a chance to make a false positive, but it also maybe cuts back on the chance DS is scum (plus, if DS is town and finds the correct person, then we just win).
Ie, DS is the lynchpin. If they are town, we can't lose this game. If not, we don't really have a great way to figure that out because a result can be faked.
Jalmont
DS
Whydon
(not adding nuxl because un CC'd vig, not adding myself because it's pretty clear heal has to be mafia here and there's no conceivable way to spin Heal and I as Scum v Scum)
If we assume DS is town, which role wise, makes sense, then we can figure out mafia tonight by having DS block one of them (and DS should state target prior to day ending) I'm going to randomize idling my doctor shot or using it on either nuxl or DS, (so idle, DS, Nuxl), which does present a chance to make a false positive, but it also maybe cuts back on the chance DS is scum (plus, if DS is town and finds the correct person, then we just win).
Ie, DS is the lynchpin. If they are town, we can't lose this game. If not, we don't really have a great way to figure that out because a result can be faked.
devils advocate is both heal and former are town and you are SK?
not a real scenario I don't think but this is a samoyed game
only issue I see with this is stating my target? I guess it helps if I die but if it's unnecessary if I'm just protected? Nuxl is IC at this point so I don't mind the swap between me or him but I don't get the idle choice either?
confirmed nuxl is SK
So is this MYLO or what?
I think it comes down to Heal vs. DS, which is good because since one isn't lying there's a good chance one of the kills can be stopped or redirected. I'm more inclined to believe DS mainly because I think redirector fits much better on a mafia team. The suspicion on NUxl by DS is pretty weird though and does throw me off because NUXL is obv town at this point. but yea
I think it comes down to Heal vs. DS, which is good because since one isn't lying there's a good chance one of the kills can be stopped or redirected. I'm more inclined to believe DS mainly because I think redirector fits much better on a mafia team. The suspicion on NUxl by DS is pretty weird though and does throw me off because NUXL is obv town at this point. but yea
Yeah it is, but there's a confirmed guilty on heal
Also, I will not know if I block a kill
what? I'm not suspicious of nuxl at all? I said yesterday he was modspewed town.
no, there's a confirmed guilty on Former.
Look at literally every action Former's done throughout this game, from "protecting" someone he scumleaned to self hammering to his big attitude change when the subs came in. If you guys think he's town over me, then I guess you as a town deserve to lose :/
There's literally no single action that former has done this entire game that is townie.
There's literally no single action that former has done this entire game that is townie.
Very clear that no town doctor blocked a kill night 1 or 2 because we had 2 townies die... like wtf?
probably thought that even night watcher was on him
