NOC Pokemon Mystery Dungeon NOCfia DX

Also since it seems to be part of the topic of (relevant) discussion:
I didn't consider the possibility that one of Clarinet's partners could be the rolecop as I posted "I think I know Clarinet's role". Probably because I was so focused on Clarinet at the time. It did occur to me a bit afterwards at some point before hammer, but I never thought to correct it. The main thing going through my head at the time was:
 
M2H said:
He then took it a step further and said that "he thinks he knows who the rolecop is" and voted clarinet in a way that made it seem that he already knew that clarinet was a rolecop -- this is confusing to me pre-clarinet flip
Click to expand...
Btw I would like to point out that "I think I know who the rolecop is" implies that I knew that there was a rolecop all along. This is not what I said. Please stop using your psychology major to cyberbully rabbits on the internet.
 
beetlejuice_4.jpg

You called?
 
Prolly going to be an unpopular take, but I'm leaning towards voting TBZ. His slot of Fen is just how Fen has played 2 scum games in a row.

That said, I probably won't fight against the m2h, I just don't want to actually vote m2h myself.
 
M2H said:
heal how could you
Click to expand...
I mean I can try to persuade people off you a bit, but I'm not going to go crazy defending you.

The truth is some of the points people have been making against you are entirely plausible, though not definitive. it's up to you to show us that you're not scum from this point.

my vote is not going on you though.
 
Hi HeaLnDeaL

Just want to clarify a few things:
  • I definitely can acknowledge that it seems like your meta falls into a space of play which I'm more likely to believe to be scummy. That's good to be clear on. The volume of stuff where you seem unwilling to make a call on anything is a lot, so I guess I do find that hard.
  • I think that saying I'm butt-hurt about the robotic thing is rather unfair. Even if my reasons are wrong, from my perspectives they're reasons, which I'd like to believe I wouldn't just come around to cause someone called me robotic. There's definitely times in my life where I've thought someone's bad because they say something about me I don't like, but this is not one of them lol.
  • When I say "nothing till deadline" I definitely am not saying you needed to be around till deadline. I think that is a misunderstanding. I just mean that your last two posts in that crucial phase of the game were very low on interaction and establishing what you think of the situation and there was nothing from you. I don't care about how you react to the self-hammer, slip, etc. - if you're away you're away - but I care how you reacted to the stage of the game when you did post, namely 5 schia 4 clar, which is quite a volatile place for things to be in, and perhaps immediately after (but not the whole time up till the hammer). I just feel like you were in a position to put skin in the game at this moment, and you could have offered something, but you didn't.
  • I find you to be quite an amicable poster and I appreciate that, regardless of what your alignment is.
  • With the schia vote, even if you believe day 1 is rvs, it feels off to me to bind your vote in such a way. And it seemed like you chose to not put that vote in the context of your read on Clarinet when Nuxl pushed you on it, which does feel bad given Clarinet's flip.
  • Also re: you definitely did not answer Nuxl's question properly, you literally said
 
##UNVOTE
##VOTE ZAROCO

m2h likely either town with a really hard read or scum spewing town (either instance makes heal likely town)

dopog has good contributions and tonally just seems town? sort of get that vibe from pb but less so bc tone is like v neutral

schia's a slot that im prob gonna ignore bc nuxl was the nightkill and idk how to interpret that

rest of you fucks are like not sticking out enough in my mind (i dont get why caffbo is uni town rn but I'd also not lynch him over slots like zaroco and Haruno whose posts don't really make sense to me and also caffbo is here to ping me so i dont afk)
 
Panic Station : this was your response when I asked about you going against your meta read on M2H.
Panic Station said:
2) Do you count fluff in the post ratio? Saying he's done more scumhunting than me is a blatant lie.
Click to expand...
Ok, I get that a lot of the posts were fluffy but you definitely doubled down on your thought M2H was town - as in you OG said scum M2H usually wouldn't shoot the breeze? I guess I just want to see how you progressed to revising that aspect?

Agree with you that that M2H's votes on schia and Clarinet do not look good. The self-hammer thing is much less compelling to me than M2H pushing the vc to 4 schia 4 clar.
 
You must log in or register to reply here.
Back
Top