what do you think of dopog and uto exactly ? also, what is your read on smogonaccount ?
-
Welcome to Smogon! Take a moment to read the Introduction to Smogon for a run-down on everything Smogon, and make sure you take some time to read the global rules.
NOC Death on the Dance Floor [Game Over: X Wins]
- Thread starter Panic Station
- Start date
this seems to be a conclusion rather than something that prompted your change of opinion ?
dopog is very much in the poe since d1 so it doesn't seem that far fetched that his teammate would throw him under the bus here ?
the initial conclusion was a team with heal+poke+(dopog, uturn, maaaaybe tennyson)
after heal says "we should lynch dopog uturn" in mylo, that makes me revise my conclusion to heal+poke+tennyson
unless you think heal is bussing in mylo?
you are voting uto, why this vote over the two above ?
are preparations complete yet ?
BLOODYRAIN10001 you are being lynched btw so maybe give us more than that
there are zero reads in there please commit to stances on players if you are town ?
I don't think scum heal is above panicking with no day chat at least
what was your read on bloodyrain again ?
Yo! : )
Nothing I've really seen has shifted me from this.
vote Mega-Pokebattlerz
Mega-Pokebattlerz, why the Moody townlean?
Ok here are some things that stuck out to me:
1.
HeaL's scum reads feel not well thought through at all. It just doesn’t seem there is any critical process about whether the difference in my posting style reflects scum motivation, or whether or not making excuses is something scum uto would do. I guess if they sincerely believe it there is something there about the lack of new information in uto's reads post, but it seems really hypocritical to latch onto someone as a scumread for their lack of contribution, when HeaL also added very little information to the game D1.
Like I’m pretty sure this is scummy. Like HeaL is in my top 3 scum reads. but I really would appreciate someone lobbing in with their opinion on this - like given just how easy/shallow these scum reads are - this comes from scum right? (I really despise going into not well thought through enough to be scum sort of logic so I need help cutting through it)
This bleeds into the next one
2.
Energy: Where are you seeing HeaL’s confidence in their reads? What specifically is pinging that for you?
3.
Moodycloud: I get that M2H was fine with me being lynched but I think it’s misleading to suggest that M2H had a huge scumread on me given M2H’s #257?
Also why didn’t you answer my questions re: whether you had scum reads and about haruno? I don’t care if the answer was obvious, the lack of engagement on it is weird.
4.
smogon account: does it make more sense to vote mega given they're in both your possible scumteams, or is it a situation where you're more confident that HeaL is just scum so you just go with that? I want to hear you out on that
5.
bloody and smogon are in my re-read pile
bloody I probably skated over too easily because of posting style
but smog acc was particularly someone I wanted to reread after seeing this post from when they were on the main wagon -
Nothing I've really seen has shifted me from this.
vote Mega-Pokebattlerz
Mega-Pokebattlerz, why the Moody townlean?
Ok here are some things that stuck out to me:
1.
HeaL's scum reads feel not well thought through at all. It just doesn’t seem there is any critical process about whether the difference in my posting style reflects scum motivation, or whether or not making excuses is something scum uto would do. I guess if they sincerely believe it there is something there about the lack of new information in uto's reads post, but it seems really hypocritical to latch onto someone as a scumread for their lack of contribution, when HeaL also added very little information to the game D1.
Like I’m pretty sure this is scummy. Like HeaL is in my top 3 scum reads. but I really would appreciate someone lobbing in with their opinion on this - like given just how easy/shallow these scum reads are - this comes from scum right? (I really despise going into not well thought through enough to be scum sort of logic so I need help cutting through it)
This bleeds into the next one
2.
Energy: Where are you seeing HeaL’s confidence in their reads? What specifically is pinging that for you?
3.
Moodycloud: I get that M2H was fine with me being lynched but I think it’s misleading to suggest that M2H had a huge scumread on me given M2H’s #257?
Also why didn’t you answer my questions re: whether you had scum reads and about haruno? I don’t care if the answer was obvious, the lack of engagement on it is weird.
4.
smogon account: does it make more sense to vote mega given they're in both your possible scumteams, or is it a situation where you're more confident that HeaL is just scum so you just go with that? I want to hear you out on that
5.
bloody and smogon are in my re-read pile
bloody I probably skated over too easily because of posting style
but smog acc was particularly someone I wanted to reread after seeing this post from when they were on the main wagon -
My reads were a mess and I defaulted to haruno because it seemed like a tree stump we'd have to sort sooner or later
Why are you voting mega when your post seems to make a case against healndeal ?
Why are you voting mega when your post seems to make a case against healndeal ?
I've been trying to spot holes in people's logic but uh there are way too many slots with ??? logic for me to rely on that it seems
this makes sense to me but why didn't you answer the questions at the time?
and do you feel in a similar position with today's lynch given your reads post had little by way of people clearly scum from your pov?
rn I think I'm at something like this ?
Megapokebattlerz
Healndeal
Energy
Bloodyrain
Tennyson
Smogonaccount
Uto
dopog
Megapokebattlerz
Healndeal
Energy
Bloodyrain
Tennyson
Smogonaccount
Uto
dopog
pretty sure there is scum in uto/dopog at least or the m2h kill makes no sense
had smogonaccount as high town for all of d1 but now I'm like our solves just don't match, what does this mean ?
every solve I've come up with has at least one of uto/dopog/bloody in it (not confident in bloody being scum, have them scum with uto in all iterations where they are) so if they're all town then I guess I'm dead wrong
I could see myself losing patience with tennyson and lynching him but he probably flips town and then I take a mafia break for a few months at least
they're one of my stronger towns and I would lynch uturn to save bloody
I'm mostly comparing to their IC game and the methodical approach they have is easier for me to follow than most people
the only real concern I would have is that they were scum reading both haruno and moodycloud but that's a small complaint
did not feel that it was relevant I guess ? you mostly summed up my feeling about the haruno lynch over other slots in the same posts you asked me questions iirc
also dopog's d2 entrance felt to me like he thought he had to stay consistent with his mega vote but without engaging about that particular read with people at all ? When I read that post it feels like he'd be ending it with a healndeal vote
I lean town on them and tend to think that they're cleared from the other flips but they are not making any reads and are acting like a spectator to this game
vote dopog while I reread uto a bit