-
Check out the relaunch of our general collection, with classic designs and new ones by our very own Pissog!
-
Welcome to Smogon! Take a moment to read the Introduction to Smogon for a run-down on everything Smogon, and make sure you take some time to read the global rules.
NOC 11p gen 1 closed setup (D4 End: Dec 25 at 5 PM PST)
- Thread starter Nuxl
- Start date
Quick thoughts
Duskfall is a town lean for me. his progression on former seems genuinely town-motivated. Most of his "wtf town/game" really rocks with me.
Clarient is a town read. He almost seems too incompetent to be scum with some of these posts that I've been reading. But I would say there some towny post there as well that rocks with me.
Tbz is a gambling roll for me I am going to still hold on to his flavor claim early day 1 being a town action. Regardless he will fall to Poe sooner or later if he continues to play like this. That vote on clever seems interesting though.(null-town)
Eagle early progression was wonky but genuine He continues to be genuine in his progression. (Town)
SB was a gut town read but now I just can't trust his recent content. null-scum
Shub - was my main day 1 lynch target because I kinda lost patience with the long-lasting silence. I originally Fos Shub for what their post was worth. The players who were in my radar group kinda brushed shub off. When shub came at the end of the day, their reads were unfavorable and I suspect shub of disclosing reads that could contribute to town destruction with minimal effort. Shub makes the most sense here. In conclusion, it is the non-vibe-able content and potential scum pivot slot. There is nothing strong here. Shub seems to be the best lynch. (scum read)
Caffeine boost other than him being a potential shub associate. I would think they are town/solo third-party/solo town. He continues to have weird vote progression so I will keep an eye on this. I don't see this slot being a threat as of now. null-scum
I Will address Clever(scum lean) in another post
Duskfall is a town lean for me. his progression on former seems genuinely town-motivated. Most of his "wtf town/game" really rocks with me.
Clarient is a town read. He almost seems too incompetent to be scum with some of these posts that I've been reading. But I would say there some towny post there as well that rocks with me.
Tbz is a gambling roll for me I am going to still hold on to his flavor claim early day 1 being a town action. Regardless he will fall to Poe sooner or later if he continues to play like this. That vote on clever seems interesting though.(null-town)
Eagle early progression was wonky but genuine He continues to be genuine in his progression. (Town)
SB was a gut town read but now I just can't trust his recent content. null-scum
Shub - was my main day 1 lynch target because I kinda lost patience with the long-lasting silence. I originally Fos Shub for what their post was worth. The players who were in my radar group kinda brushed shub off. When shub came at the end of the day, their reads were unfavorable and I suspect shub of disclosing reads that could contribute to town destruction with minimal effort. Shub makes the most sense here. In conclusion, it is the non-vibe-able content and potential scum pivot slot. There is nothing strong here. Shub seems to be the best lynch. (scum read)
Caffeine boost other than him being a potential shub associate. I would think they are town/solo third-party/solo town. He continues to have weird vote progression so I will keep an eye on this. I don't see this slot being a threat as of now. null-scum
I Will address Clever(scum lean) in another post
LMAO i tried to sleep, kept on thinking about possible scumteams, go to post and bgb basically reads my mind
Duskfall98 what are your thoughts on shubaka/sb/one of celever or caffbo as a scumteam
because that's what i think it is
Duskfall98 what are your thoughts on shubaka/sb/one of celever or caffbo as a scumteam
because that's what i think it is
Yes
Yall may be incompatible with each other but surely with shub. I just think there some scum fuckery going on here that I haven't yet found.
Shub is my #1 vote
Clever is my # 2 vote
Caffeine is my #3 vote
Dont want to add to the unenjoyment but I would like to see what you think of "what if shub flips scum/town"
Normally I would agree but that can be easily manipulated/fake.
Your are playing very well. in terms of town reads, it seems they are genuinely made. I do kinda vibe with that aspect. but if I look from a different perspective, I could see
1. Your already town read/ town soft a scum mate
2. Shub is their for potential bus and the other 3 are mislynch material
3. Setting up town to hit a brick wall
Celever* why am I bad
Did you have a reason you town read him. I would like to see your viewpoint
which one?
Not sure how to feel about this one. We have quite a difference in reads/ lynch candidates.
I am interested in why shub is town.?
What do you think of celver being "competent" scum?
I can see a Duskfall / Clarient case but it feels like a stretch.
You really said I might be frozen scum.
I seem to be gaining some ground here oh boy... that said I'm probably a decent wagon since my flip tells you who you should probably vote in LYLO... assuming I'm right.
I really don't wanna iso Clarinet but I'll have to at some point. Thing is idt I can get anything from Clarinet from this game alone so I have to read through... probably his most recent town and scum game at least. I'll put that off a bit longer.
I haven't actually done a big ol reads list yet so I might as well do one:
TR: Celever, there are some specific bits of logic which idt Celever considers as scum. I only ever doubt this if Eagle turns out to be scum.
TL: Eagle and SB. Eagle is a weird case but I kinda trust Celever on this. SB has been more active than I originally thought so putting a null read on them doesn't feel right, especially since their content seems good. I'm a bit unsure about SB for the time being though.
Null: TBZ, Shub, Clarinet. TBZ gives me, as usual, nothing to go off of. Shub's similar in that idt they've done anything inherently bad but unlike SB they don't have that much activity or good content. I'm not giving a read on Clarinet until I feel qualified enough to do so since they're an enigma wrapped in a mystery with sprinkles of puzzles.
Some weird corner of sus: Dusk? Idk it's not that I think he's scum, I just think he's a bit sus. I don't wanna vote him rn but I also don't want him to live to lylo. Idk how to describe how I feel about Dusk properly... everyone in null I have no opinion of but I have conflicting opinions of Dusk. I think I need to think about this in the tub.
SR: BGB as has already been stated many times. I plan to come out of the other end of this tunnel because nothing they've said since I entered it has changed my mind.
Current mood on the day's proceedings: I'm tempted to request a thunderdome between BGB and myself because I'm pretty sure if you vote him he'll flip red and if you vote me you'll probably follow it up in lylo w/ a BGB vote... also it clears up the whole me & shub mess.
I really don't wanna iso Clarinet but I'll have to at some point. Thing is idt I can get anything from Clarinet from this game alone so I have to read through... probably his most recent town and scum game at least. I'll put that off a bit longer.
I haven't actually done a big ol reads list yet so I might as well do one:
TR: Celever, there are some specific bits of logic which idt Celever considers as scum. I only ever doubt this if Eagle turns out to be scum.
TL: Eagle and SB. Eagle is a weird case but I kinda trust Celever on this. SB has been more active than I originally thought so putting a null read on them doesn't feel right, especially since their content seems good. I'm a bit unsure about SB for the time being though.
Null: TBZ, Shub, Clarinet. TBZ gives me, as usual, nothing to go off of. Shub's similar in that idt they've done anything inherently bad but unlike SB they don't have that much activity or good content. I'm not giving a read on Clarinet until I feel qualified enough to do so since they're an enigma wrapped in a mystery with sprinkles of puzzles.
Some weird corner of sus: Dusk? Idk it's not that I think he's scum, I just think he's a bit sus. I don't wanna vote him rn but I also don't want him to live to lylo. Idk how to describe how I feel about Dusk properly... everyone in null I have no opinion of but I have conflicting opinions of Dusk. I think I need to think about this in the tub.
SR: BGB as has already been stated many times. I plan to come out of the other end of this tunnel because nothing they've said since I entered it has changed my mind.
Current mood on the day's proceedings: I'm tempted to request a thunderdome between BGB and myself because I'm pretty sure if you vote him he'll flip red and if you vote me you'll probably follow it up in lylo w/ a BGB vote... also it clears up the whole me & shub mess.
gummybears, Celever posted detailed analysis D1 when there was no need to, he gave 110% on thread when nobody cared
guess I was impressed with his ISOs
this ^ innocent curiosity, that's how I would describe .SB
he's my most confident town lean
shubaka17 let me get yo town core n scum pool
and of course your scum partners
and of course your scum partners
Based on what you see do you think the town is being more self-destructive or scum being more manipulative/Galaxy brain this game? Neither is an option too.
It's possible but I am in no way confident enough to say that is the actually team right now, shub looks bad off D1 so I'd like to start there though