Smogon Simple Questions & Suggestions Thread

How do we ask permission to hold a poll/discussion? Who do we ask?

I started a poll in RoA (Should Dig/Fly be unbanned in Gen 1) and it was deleted because I didn't ask permission first. I'm sure Smogon values it's forum member's opinions, so it would be great if we could allow people to talk about things and share ideas :blobthumbsup:
 

Plague von Karma

Banned deucer.
How do we ask permission to hold a poll/discussion? Who do we ask?
Usually, people will ask Lutra first. However, there have been three threads regarding Dig/Fly already, so I'm not sure if it'd be approved. I know there's someone else who's wanted to give their takes on this specific topic as well. If all else fails, go to the first thread I linked and revive the discussion I guess?
 

Plague von Karma

Banned deucer.
I apologise for not asking - this should be made clearer. If there are three threads I think it would be constructive to have a poll so we can get a good idea of how people feel.
Two of the threads were locked for not asking and didn't really have any discussion. If you're interested in context, the first I linked was specifically for gathering opinions back in 2015, which I believe led to the ban on Showdown in the first place?

Generally though, I'd suggest asking Lutra to make a post. Make a constructive take on the topic when making the OP.
 

dhelmise

banend doosre
is a Site Content Manageris a Battle Simulator Administratoris a Top Social Media Contributoris a Community Leaderis a Programmeris a Community Contributoris a Top Contributoris a Top Smogon Media Contributoris a Top Dedicated Tournament Hostis a Smogon Discord Contributor Alumnus
Social Media Head
Two of the threads were locked for not asking and didn't really have any discussion. If you're interested in context, the first I linked was specifically for gathering opinions back in 2015, which I believe led to the ban on Showdown in the first place?

Generally though, I'd suggest asking Lutra to make a post. Make a constructive take on the topic when making the OP.
Or just ask any of the forum mods (me, Rage, Earthworm, Lutra, Ransei, kjdaas, Arai, FriendOfMrGolem120)
 

Celever

i am town
is a Community Contributor
Where would I post things that have to do with Rom Hacks, an example being discussing Pokemon Unbound?
We don’t have a place for ROM hacks on our forum due to the technically illegal nature of them. We straddle the line with playthrough threads in the Orange Islands subforum, but we don’t have discussion threads about them, nor is it at all acceptable to share links of ROM hacks or other emulation tools even in a thread where you catalogue your playthrough.
 
We don’t have a place for ROM hacks on our forum due to the technically illegal nature of them. We straddle the line with playthrough threads in the Orange Islands subforum, but we don’t have discussion threads about them, nor is it at all acceptable to share links of ROM hacks or other emulation tools even in a thread where you catalogue your playthrough.
Ah, okay. Makes sense. Thank you anyway!
 
Question, am I allowed to post a team on RMT SS other teams that is a different non official format with different format rules? I want to get my competitive Pixelmon team rated.
 

Martin

A monoid in the category of endofunctors
is a Smogon Discord Contributoris a Forum Moderator Alumnusis a Community Contributor Alumnusis a Contributor Alumnus
Responding to this late; sry if someone already answered this in the same way on page 108/109/110.
This question isn't very "simple" but it applies to all of the gens so I will ask it here. I am trying to figure out how to optimize EV spreads for bulk with the combination of HP and Def/SpDef. Taking a look at the damage formula on Bulbapedia it looks like for this purpose you can simplify it to be this: (HP left after the attack)=(HP stat with 0 EVs + (EVs invested ÷ 4)) – (252 ÷((Def/SpDef stat with 0 EVs + (EVs invested ÷ 4)) × 1.1 if it has a +Def/SpDef Nature) + 2). I got 252 by plugging in 100 as the base power of the move and 300 as the Atk/SpAtk stat, pretty sure that they can just be whatever (also pretty sure that the modifier doesn't matter either). Does this all look right? Is there a website that can run formulas like this? Did someone else already make some sort of resource for this purpose?
Use one of these tools:

https://pokestudio.altervista.org/defevs.php - only includes mons up to gen 4 but u can insert custom stat spreads and it has a bunch of modifiers as well as the option to determine a nature if u don’t know what nature you want to use.

https://www.terresquall.com/apps/pokemon-ev-optimiser/ - better if u don’t need to calculate nature or look at the niche modifiers in the first one

You can estimate overall bulk quite simply, but it will only give you info for one side; I’m not sure how you’d find overall-overall by hand it, and really there’s not much point using it when you could just use one of the above tools instead. If you’re interested though:
Code:
[Sp.]Def × HP ÷ 100, rounded to the nearest whole number
As a rule of thumb: if you want maximum overall bulk instead of a benchmark, you want to try and balance the two defense stats. If there is one really low stat alongside two high stats, it is most efficient to dump all your leftover EVs into that stat (e.g. Toxapex has barely any HP and sky-high defenses, so it’s most efficient to max that out before looking at defensive benchmarks; Melmetal has high HP alongside pitiful SpD, so there’s no point dumping into HP; same goes for Guzzlord, Conkeldurr, Excadrill (this one’s a bit more specialised), etc.) In the vast majority of cases it will be best to just dump into HP, as moving 5 points out of HP just makes you faint 5 damage earlier, but in some fringe cases it is fractionally more efficient to balance stats before maxing out HP. The only cases you really need to care about are instances where something has an excessive HP stat and a deficient defensive stat.
 
Last edited:

Users Who Are Viewing This Thread (Users: 1, Guests: 2)

Top