I'll start by immediately approving our STAB options in
Hurricane and
Sludge Bomb. Both have shown up in multiple sets and seems like very safe calls. I'll also be blacklisting
Calm Mind, as I agree with the sentiment that immediate boosting of SpA and SpD at the same time stacked with Stamina procs is a dangerous combination.
spoo said:Name: Bulky Wincon
Move 1: Nasty Plot
Move 2: Hurricane
Move 3: Body Press/Flamethrower
Move 4: Roost
Ability: Stamina
Item: Heavy-Duty Boots
EVs: 252 HP / 4 Def / 252 SpA
Nature: Modest
Zetalz said:Name: SpDef Nasty Plot
Move 1: Nasty Plot
Move 2: Roost
Move 3: Hurricane
Move 4: Heat Wave/Earth Power
Ability: Stamina
Item: Heavy-Duty Boots
EVs: 252 HP / 4 Def / 252 SpD
Nature: Calm
Here we have two slightly different takes on a Nasty Plot sweeper, one opting for more power with SpA investment, and one opting for more bulk with SpD investment. Given 30b's natural bulk and ability to (relatively) passively gain more, it's turned into a pretty good base for a setup sweeper, and I think
Nasty Plot serves well as a boost to 30b's attacking power without making it too overwhelming to take down. However, discussion around SpD boosting alongside this means I will hold off on approving this for now. Between SpD boosting and Nasty Plot, I am currently more inclined to approve Nasty Plot.
I am not quite ready to make a decision on Heat Wave/Flamethrower and Earth Power. Our initial assessment in the beginning of the thread was that most types of coverage wouldn't be absolutely necessary, but it seems that opinions of Body Press's efficacy have gone down since then, bringing these moves to the forefront as alternatives to hit Steel types. I definitely want to see more discussion regarding these.
Da Pizza Man said:Name: Double Dance
Move 1: Hurricane
Move 2: Nasty Plot
Move 3: Amnesia
Move 4: Roost
Ability: Stamina
Item: Heavy-Duty Boots
EVs: 248 HP / 252 SpD / 8 Def
Nature: Calm
Amnesia combined with Nasty Plot is definitely a higher opportunity cost compared to just Calm Mind by itself, but there is still potential to snowball out of control alongside Stamina boosts. To bring in another move that was suggested but not part of a moveset,
Cosmic Power does not boost SpD as fast, but instead brings its own Defense boosts to make 30b harder to break on both sides, whereas an opponent could at least play around an Amnesia booster by minimizing Stamina activations until they can land a strong physical hit.
snake_rattler said:Name: Acid Armor + Body Press
Move 1: Acid Armor
Move 2: Body Press
Move 3: Sludge Bomb (/ Mystical Fire?)
Move 4: Roost
Ability: Stamina
Item: Heavy-Duty Boots
EVs: 248 HP / 252 SpD / 8 Spe
Nature: Calm
Rabia said:name: Substitute + Acid Armor
move 1: Substitute
move 2: Acid Armor
move 3: Body Press
move 4: Roost / Sludge Bomb
ability: Stamina
item: Heavy-Duty Boots / Black Sludge
evs: 252 HP / 148 SpD / 108 Spe
nature: Calm
These two sets both look to build on our access to Body Press and natural Defense stacking in Stamina by adding
Acid Armor on top of it. I'm fine with the move by itself, as it fits in with all of the Defense boosting this Pokemon already does and gets Body Press to a useful point much faster, but with the uncertainty surrounding SpD boosting, I'd like to hold off on approving this.
Mystical Fire shows up in snake_rattler's set, but I don't really have any strong opinions on it. It's weaker than the proposed Heat Wave/Flamethrower, and at the same time the SpA drop, though weaker than SpD boosting, is a bit awkward. I would like to see more opinions on this, both on its own and as an alternative to any Fire coverage we get.
Gaboswampert said:Name: DualDef Stall
Move 1: Toxic/Roost
Move 2: Body Press/Roost
Move 3: Amnesia
Move 4: Will-O-Wisp/Substitute/Roost/Haze
Ability: Stamina
Item: Heavy-Duty Boots
EVs: 252 HP / 4 Def / 252 SpD
Nature: Calm
To begin with, this set isn't really a setup sweeper set, as its goal is stall out the opponent and passively build up Stamina boosts to get Body Press's damage up.
Will-O-Wisp in combination with Stamina makes me hesitate, as this can really ramp up the difficulty of breaking 30b from the physical side.
Haze is sort of interesting, but I'm not sure it will be run when Toxapex exists as a Poison-type that is also one of the best (and only) Hazers in the meta. I will need more justification for both of these.
To summarize:
- Approved: Hurricane, Sludge Bomb
- Want more discussion (in rough order from "most likely to be approved" to "least likely to be approved"): Nasty Plot, Acid Armor, Heat Wave/Flamethrower, Earth Power, Mystical Fire, Will-O-Wisp, Haze, Cosmic Power, Amnesia
- Blacklisted: Calm Mind
In addition to getting more discussion on all the moves I listed, I want to bring back the subject of Ice coverage, as it has gone unsubmitted so far. It was deemed mostly just a bonus, rather than anything necessary, at the beginning of the thread, but I wanted to see if opinions have changed since then.
I will also now take this opportunity to open set submissions for the other discussed archetypes (defensive pivot, wall, and tank). I will give approximately
48-72 hours for discussion before I make my next round of approvals.