-
Welcome to Smogon! Take a moment to read the Introduction to Smogon for a run-down on everything Smogon, and make sure you take some time to read the global rules.
NOC Bigvivor Mafia Game Thread Day 5
- Thread starter Tommy
- Start date
probably not worth putting too much stock on this as it may incentivize a protective role to claim but it would definitely explain scum nk coordination.
ultimately if there was a watcher on nuxl or Haruno and they caught any actions (Haruno) or two actions (Nuxl) it may be worth claiming. Aside from that idk what good could come if this angle.
This is acc p valid to ask and would make the tribe twist make more sense, I dig it as a theory
Arguably it’s likely considering the arsonist could have won v early for a game this size, 2 kills from time to time makes that role seem more balanced?
CaffeineBoost If Texas is town in ur eyes what do you make of yesterday’s dilemma
Under normal circumstances / in most cases
Later. I'm talking to peoples at the moment.
So 99% of the time if there was a watcher in separatists they know the doc and killer but not which is which (since prob all targeted you)
Would we even want them to claim?
didn't address this at first given i had no real read on texas himself but i feel like wanting to vote texas here and the instant dismissal of the haruno/texas pair claim is scum behavior -- looks worse after last night's flip
Well that got answered and I agree lol
No, or more specifically not yet
There’s still time. Role madness might suggest other options or my theory could just be wrong. I just want takes on it
NGL current stance is Caffeine bc I’m still tinfoiling him trying to TvTvTvT us. Opens the door to accusations that I killed Haruno for town cred or to implicate Sam as scum for being wrong about Texas
Prob not tho
Do you think Texas is town after the flip?
also US defended m2h in that same post, but then m2h's recent posts
vote UncleSam
and curious to hear Nuxl Spiderz thoughts on this ^
considering it's a game with a lot of new players, feels townish so i think more likely it's US scum & attempting to sway m2h by expressing dislike of the previous m2h push (which, from what i saw, wasn't even that strong of a push). not clearing m2h or anything, more arguing US is just scum here
vote UncleSam
and curious to hear Nuxl Spiderz thoughts on this ^
Texas himself is NAI, it’s role madness
But I’m not sure if Texas would push a Haruno kill anyway
I implore you all to read Haruno's role PM.
fucking nm it turns out I did not read it.
I misread it and thought whoever targeted Haruno's target would instead target Haruno.
This is literally level 1 deduction but
This feels scummy bc voting Sam is the obvious thing to happen after this nightkill. Clouds was in the group with Haruno and could have killed them in order to try and vote Sam.
Someone has to say it
Not to mention I think we all already p much agreed that if Sam and M2H is T/S then Sam is the S so this isn’t anything new