what a world, what a world
-
Welcome to Smogon! Take a moment to read the Introduction to Smogon for a run-down on everything Smogon, and make sure you take some time to read the global rules.
NOC Bigvivor Mafia Game Thread Day 5
- Thread starter Tommy
- Start date
there's no reason to assume that as a gospel truth, no.
I’ve been agreeing with clouds all game but oddly enough yea I buy this fully
Me, because it’s true lmao read his old messages
Vote Celever
It’s not like I’m doing a ton myself and I can be missing a lot .
but I feel like he’s pushing blame onto a lot of people a ton which has been referenced earlier. I keep flip flopping with how I feel about clouds but I do think he made a point regarding Celever and the Drookez situation.
Idk he just comes off to me as someone jumpy to bandwagon and against different people in a way that unsettles me + I’ve been iffy on caff and Celever for a little while now. The recent additions on the threat (up to like page 106) are just kinda feeding into it
I’m assuming he rebuttals more and I will probably have something to say about that too
It’s not like I’m doing a ton myself and I can be missing a lot .
but I feel like he’s pushing blame onto a lot of people a ton which has been referenced earlier. I keep flip flopping with how I feel about clouds but I do think he made a point regarding Celever and the Drookez situation.
Idk he just comes off to me as someone jumpy to bandwagon and against different people in a way that unsettles me + I’ve been iffy on caff and Celever for a little while now. The recent additions on the threat (up to like page 106) are just kinda feeding into it
I’m assuming he rebuttals more and I will probably have something to say about that too
I almost want to follow you on this just on the frequency with which celever just says factually incorrect things, but I'll hold off on that for now.
To address some of the recent comments:
1) Why did you target clouds with whatever action? I did whatever I did to clouds honestly not for a specific reason other than I had to use the action on someone and I picked someone that wasn't a big scum suspect in most people's views (that's on my tribe of course). Another reason is that clouds is cute so maybe he can benefit from the action (yes i am biased but tbf i didn't know what to do)
2) Do you town read clouds? Yes, in a sense. As I said, my action would benefit my target so I would need to give it to someone I think of as likely townie. Of course, I have no proof clouds is 100% town.
3) Why does clouds town read you? Obviously I cannot answer for clouds. However, I will say that if I were to receive it from someone I would also view them as town. This is because the action is a "beneficial" in a sense that it makes someone better, so giving it to the mafia as part of their role wouldn't make sense because a mafia with this role would just target within their faction. It also doesn't make sense to give it to a third party because they typically work alone and using this action would not make sense with their win con.
Hope this clears a few things up!
1) Why did you target clouds with whatever action? I did whatever I did to clouds honestly not for a specific reason other than I had to use the action on someone and I picked someone that wasn't a big scum suspect in most people's views (that's on my tribe of course). Another reason is that clouds is cute so maybe he can benefit from the action (yes i am biased but tbf i didn't know what to do)
2) Do you town read clouds? Yes, in a sense. As I said, my action would benefit my target so I would need to give it to someone I think of as likely townie. Of course, I have no proof clouds is 100% town.
3) Why does clouds town read you? Obviously I cannot answer for clouds. However, I will say that if I were to receive it from someone I would also view them as town. This is because the action is a "beneficial" in a sense that it makes someone better, so giving it to the mafia as part of their role wouldn't make sense because a mafia with this role would just target within their faction. It also doesn't make sense to give it to a third party because they typically work alone and using this action would not make sense with their win con.
Hope this clears a few things up!
It would definitely be an odd scum role given that it is providing a kill list to players who can kill, but then why would they be providing a list if they are scum and can already kill.
I would be INCLINED to say Clouds is heavily likely (maybe confirmed) to be town off of that if you are town, but I say that with some degree of caution because I don't think I fully understand the role either.
Since Hydro's priority was [2] and Dyo is saying Clouds priority is > that (probs [3] I'm assuming), that means there is at least one more unknown player with the suggest ability.
Still have no idea how that works though Duskfall98 given that one copy of the role ability has been flipped, can you describe how that ability works generally?
Still have no idea how that works though Duskfall98 given that one copy of the role ability has been flipped, can you describe how that ability works generally?