Vullaby has always been a borderline Pokémon in both SM and SS, and I can easily sympathize with the people who voted Ban in the original suspect test. I, too, was tempted to do so, just to see what kind of meta was on the other side. That being said, I think that the best way to think about this suspect is to consider Vullaby not in isolation, but for the overall metagame it created.
This gets to a fundamental disagreement I have with some of the Vull-banners. The reason that we ban broken Pokémon is to because they make the metagame uncompetitive in some way; to be broken is to be unhealthy. If banning something makes every subsequent meta worse, that to me is a clear indication that it was never broken in the first place. This is where my thoughts on Vullaby currently stand: while our understanding of its strengths have not changed, we now know infinitely more of its impact from the meta that has developed in its absence. I want Vullaby back because it is clearer to me now that its overall influence was positive.
1. On the current meta
It's no secret that I'm not a fan of the current meta. I hoped that it would stabilize to something enjoyable eventually, but we're nearly a year out from Vullaby's ban with no sign of improvement. I'll be echoing the complaints that top players have had with this meta for months.
- The 17 Speed tier is too saturated, leading to frequent game-deciding 50/50s
This continues to be the most infuriating aspect of this meta. Natu/Grookey/Mienfoo interactions are absolutely toxic, as fighting checks often lack the longevity to check the latter two Pokémon long term - leading to situations where each Pokémon becomes an emergency luck-based check for itself and for both other Pokémon (provided Natu/Mienfoo are healthy enough to take a Glide). This wouldn't be a problem if these interactions were avoidable, but in late game scenarios choosing not to risk a speed tie usually means taking huge damage or sacking an entire Pokémon. I can't tell you how many of my games come down to unavoidable speed ties, particularly nail-biters where both my opponent and I are playing well. That is perhaps the most tragic effect of the 17 Spe tier for enjoyability: The closest and most exciting games are the most likely to come down to speed ties in the endgame.
I'll give a quick example of the type of
game I'm talking about. Soulwind and I were neck and neck for most of the early game, but a devastating min roll on his Grookey puts me quite behind. My only path to winning became forcing speed ties over and over again. Soulwind attempted to play completely safe by preserving the Mienfoo on turn 24, but ultimately sees that with his koffing down his only Grookey stop is his own Mienfoo, and is forced to go for the Hammer Grookey vs Mienfoo speed tie to win the game. The previous game was almost the exact same story, coming down to a last turn Grookey vs Mienfoo tie. I was looking forward to the series and prepared extensively, but in the end the result of each game felt completely out of my hands. Our team tournaments have similar problems: perhaps the most famous case in SCL was
teal6 vs dcae, where dcae was able to deny lucking teal6 by (accurately) claiming that teal6 lost on the spot if he had won the forced Mienfoo tie. I could probably dig up dozens of games decided by forced ties, but their existence is not really in dispute.
- Lack of diversity
wesh papillon said:I think its fair to say that Vulla also completly invalidates a large portion of the nicher mons. A lot of the recently "discovered" fight and psy checks and completly worthless in a vullaby meta. Forcing you into an even stricter mold then u did before, as you now have 4 required mons, (the poison and steel are even more restrictive now too!), making the last 2 slots really the only flexible and expressive slots in 90% of cases (the pool for that one is also reduced woo)
I fully disagree on this point: one of the big selling points of banning Vullaby at the time was that it was holding back a ton of Pokémon and without it we would get some much-needed diversity, but team structures have remained as rigid as ever. The number of Viable Pokémon has remained virtually unchanged: for every Pokémon freed from Vull's oppression, another has fallen from grace. We gained Natu, Carvahna, and Tyrunt at the expense of Timburr, Onix and Ponyta-Galar (not to mention Vullaby itself and the consequent Scraggy ban). The only reasonable case for the Vull meta being more restrictive is that balance has four required slots (compared to the three we have in this meta: Mienfoo, Mienfoo counter, Steel), but to claim that how you fill those slots isn't flexible and expressive indicates clear lack of knowledge of that meta. The Vullaby meta actually had more viable options within the required slots than we have now: Timburr was a viable second option to Mienfoo, and Foongus and Mareanie were considered just as good as Koffing as fighting checks.
To simplify the building process of pre-Vull and post-Vull to 4 required slots vs 3 required slot is also a gross oversimplification of how building works in LC. This notion of "required slots" is a bit deceptive, as you can't actually just do anything you want with the remaining slots and still have a viable team. You still have to account for the rest of the A rank mons within those slots: usually you need a Koffing check, some sort of priority if you aren't running Grookey, a Tyrunt answer, a Grookey check if you are't running Koffing, etc. An underappreciated aspect of Vullaby was just how much role compression it performed on virtually every team it was on. Even the offensive sets could still double as secondary fighting checks, grookey checks, emergency checks to all kinds of sweepers with endure, hazard removal, and the list goes on. While it is true that Vullaby mandated its own slot (the narrative that it forced two slots is false; steel types and stealth rocks are still obligatory on every team), it freed up remaining slots from having to check a wide variety of offensive threats. As someone who has built extensively in every iteration of SS, I have never noticed any difference in expressiveness as a result of the Vullaby ban.
The interpretation of all of these graphs looks more or less like a wash. I can believe that the graphs aren't a consistent indication of metagame diversity, but levi's ladder stats are similarly meaningless: I think to use any metric where vhue takes up multiple top places in any good faith argument about LC at a competitive level is ridiculous. Levi is right to point out that LC's current popularity relative to last year further invalidates the statistics, though the implication that that popularity has anything at all to do with Vullaby's ban and not the obvious results of Freezai's success is pretty weak. The metric I've always used to differentiate diversity between generations is amount of mons in A and B rank: it's generally accepted that ORAS is the most diverse metagame we've ever had, and this is directly reflected by that VR having almost twice as many viable Pokémon as the current one. The post-Vullaby VR is, predictably, almost indistinguishable in terms of variety of viable options (the pre-Vull tier list actually has slightly more options in A rank). I think any measurement is likely to be a bit fuzzy on this point (I recognize that using viability, a subjective measure that doesn't account for usage or centralization is flawed), but I think that the other sides abstract claim of diversity has been thus far just as baseless.
2. What Vullaby brings to the table
While most of the newer anti-Vullaby people acknowledge the problems with the current meta, they just don't understand or don't remember why the Vullaby meta didn't have similar problems with speed ties and luck-based interactions. Ace is thus far the only person to note some of the play differences between the metas, and does so well:
Acehunter1 said:Argument for freeing Vullaby: Flexibility
This point might be a combination of both competitivity and diversity, but one thing I have noticed that I really like by playing Vullaby meta the last few days, is that the games feel less linear. There are way more options open during play. While in the current meta, there are "default" or "safe" options, like switching Poison on Fight, Mienfoo on Steel, or Natu on Ferroseed, with Vullaby in the meta, I have noticed that it is much less clear. As examples, going Vullaby check on Vullaby is not always the default option, since that could be dangerous due to trap. In a Mienfoo vs Mienfoo lead mirror, Fake Out isn't always good because it risks giving Vullaby a boost, but not Faking Out risks getting punished by opposing Fake Out. In a Mienfoo vs Vullaby scenario, Fake Out might or might not be good depending on the sets, Vullaby can click Knock, Brave Bird or U-Turn viably but everything it clicks could be punished severely, and likewise, anything Mienfoo clicks can be rewarding or bad. Switch-ins to Fighting types aren't always the Fight check, since Vullaby is often a good if not better option depending on what the Fighter clicks. Those are only examples, a lot more occurs ingame. You could say some similar things are present in the current meta too, but I feel that it occurs much less often. There are more "free", difficulty punishable moves to click (aka moves that are heavily favored in terms of risk-reward), the options are more 50/50-like (default or not default), and that overall, the current meta is more linear. The most blatant example of this is probably the lead. Playing for the suspect test made me realize how in Vullaby meta, often there isn't an objectively best lead for either player, since any lead could be good or bad against something. This is in stark contrast to the "default" Mienfoo leads and anti-Mienfoo leads we see in the current meta, and boy have I ever said how much I hate "brainlessly" leading Mienfoo in the current meta. In Vullaby meta, I feel like almost anything could be viably led, depending on the opponent's team on preview. This could be a point of a greater diversity or a greater flexibility in plays, but the gameplay being less linear and having more options makes the meta drastically more fun to play, at least to me. This is probably the most important thing I've noticed, and the reason that has helped me the most to come to a decision.
Ace captures the more immediate pathing differences between the Vullaby post-Vullaby metas, especially the far less linear early-games of the former. As much as ace talks up the flexibility of the Vullaby meta, I think that this still only scratches the surface of how much more interesting games in it were. For that I will build upon Eric's point about the offensive and defensive roles of Vullaby:
Éric said:Well, it was the single best offensive mon in the tier, meaning the Pokémon that was able to deal the most damage in every single game, for reasons I'll explain later. What's more, it did also have an incredibly potent defensive profile as well. Its typing granted it resistances to grass and ghost moves, while giving it immunities to ground and psychic. This means it checks a lot of Pokémon like Abra, Diglett or Grookey, which in turn means it is given many more turns to hit the field than most other Pokémon. In short, it was a mon that every time it hit the field it hit like a truck, while being one of the easier to hit the field at the same time. It doesn't help either that its natural bulk is so high it didn't even need Eviolite to survive any neutral attack, sometimes even after rocks. Every single team had a Vullaby, it offered too much. Also, it was the premiere defogger of the tier, which was another reason to use it in your team.
I obviously believe that Vullaby's offensive presence is overstated here, but the basic premise that Vullaby had enormous offensive and defensive roles on every team it was on is correct. What Eric does not capture here is the critical point that
it could not perform every possible role simultaneously. If Vullaby had consistent recovery that allowed it to stick around for the entire game it would certainly be broken, but this is not the case: between its rock weakness, recoil from its main STAB move and tendency to want to switch in on Pokemon like Mienfoo, Foongus and Grookey, in practice Vullaby's incredible utility is fleeting. Vullaby may only be able to come in and remain useful a few times per game, and properly choosing when to bring it in is very difficult. This is a huge part of the options that Ace mentions in his post: Vullaby's bulk and pivoting ability opens up an incredible amount of pathing options, many of which are ultimately wastes of Vullaby's offensive or defensive utility.
This is the greatest source of the higher skill ceiling that the Vullaby metagame had. Vullaby both opened up far less linear options in game and was itself difficult to use: inexperienced players had trouble knowing the best time to try to punch holes in the opposing team, or alternatively which Pokemon they should be saving Vull to check in the endgame. I saw this over and over again on ladder: a newer player would lead Vullaby, get knock off on one or two on my Pokemon to get off to a slight lead, but end up with a Vullaby far too weakened to be of any use in the middle or endgame with too little damage on my team to show for it. I encourage those voting in this suspect who weren't around during the Vullaby meta to watch replays and talk with those who were, as I don't think that the ladder is giving you an accurate picture of what it was actually like. The Vullaby meta, much more so than this one, will reward greater understanding of pathing that you will gain over time.
TL;DR: The lack of frequent game-deciding speed ties is the most immediate advantage of the Vullaby meta to this one, but that isn't the only positive aspect to be gained. Less luck is one aspect of a competitive metagame, but so is skill ceiling. Good metas should allow players to express their command over the game as much as possible, and the complex pathing of the Vullaby meta lends itself to this far more than our current relatively linear meta.
I will edit in some responses to some other points in this thread, as there are a lot of misinformed takes here (the argument that the 19 spe tier in the Vullaby meta was anywhere close to as influential as the 17 spe tier is in this meta, for example, is completely detached from reality).