Hey, this thread hasn't been active in 4 months so I'll give my contributions on the new mons coming in with the DLC and seeing how they'll do in the metagame. I think it is timely for 2 reasons: 1) OMoTM is around the corner and Flipped isn't doing too bad with preliminary votes; and 2) a little project I was working on Google Sheets for the past week.
I've created a sheet that helps condense the information about flipped by providing the actual flipped stats instead of doing mental conversions in your head - which I made for Flipped mashups, but is still convenient for vanilla flipped (even if my strat works fairly well). I'm bringing this up because while it is still WIP, I think it helped me organise my thoughts in this first impressions post. I might clean it up and release it soon if there is any interest here, but rn I kinda want to add a feature that makes it more than just crawling through the builder - like a MadLibs feature for a teambuilding assistant.
But that's all in the idea generation stage at the moment. Without further ado, here my impressions on the new Pokemon in this format:
:arbok: Poison typing is always interesting but Arbok lacks the stats to leverage them despite high spec def and intimidate having some synergy with each other.
:sandslash-alola: :sandslash: I'm not sure I'm a fan of either of these Pokemon considering that their movepool is heavily physical leaning and they lack a deep special movepool to work with. Plus their stats are pretty abyssmal with any priority being enough to put 'em to sleep. This goes double for the 65/25 Alolan Sandslash.
:clefable: While Clefable does lose its optimised bulk, it does gain neat attacking stats and a relatively high speed tier. I know this was fairly highly last gen so I tried to pick a rank that reflected that since very little seems to have changed for it.
:ninetales: :ninetales-alola:
Alola Tales is good. The change from hail to snow is especially welcomed given that many mons don't have the luxury of having recovery here so chip stacks, but also because it boots alola tale's own defense. 100/81 is serviceable but 100/81 with a 1.5x boost is pretty solid. Add to the fact that it can set up veil for more frailer sweepers and I think it definitely has a place in the metagame.
Ninetales is gonna depend on how well the proto-mons abuse sun. Flipped has historically had utter bottom of the barrel gunk for chlorophyll mons, and defensive fires, so I'm not sure if this mon is as good as its tropical tundra cousin.
:poliwrath: :victreebel: Both of these guys have the G1 mon syndrome where their stats are middle grounds that get translated even worse into flipped.
Nevertheless, 90 offenses could be interesting for Poliwrath as a swift swim sweeper. Rn it's probably the strongest special swift swimmer and the second strongest physical swift swimmer. Rain has an uphill battle considering g9 flipped is dragon city with Dnite, Pult and even the odd kommo-o running around, and Poliwrath definitely isn't a strong Pokemon by any means. However, I think there could be a place for the frog in the tier.
Victreebel On paper it's a decent Sylveon counter, but it folds to Tera Fairy. However, it checks the other variants fairly well. >100/100 bulk plus strength sap is something to take a look at.
:golem: :golem-alola: You know these guys were almost going into the D-ranks. But do me a favour, go to team builder, pick OU and sort by defense. Yeah... This is what we're working with here. We will touch on the Mons here later, but right now I want you to focus on what is missing rather than what is there. If you pay close attention, you will note the absence of Rhyperior AND Regirock AND Aggron. All the things that outclass Golem. That
alone bumps up the niche of both to a solid B (despite their weaknesses to a
certain marten). Alolem also has 2 solid abilities. Magnet Pull traps steel types so something like Sylv in the back can clean up. Galvanise is more situational but Electric Hyper beam is most definitely a nuke if you play your cards right. Rock / Ground does seem more consistent than Rock / Electric however.
:dipplin: 40 HP drags down 95/80 bulk with eviolite. The type combo and special attacking stat is serviceable but I'm not sure how valuable these traits are considering the horrible 4MSS this mon has due to the absolute dearth of options it has.
:sinistcha: I think this stat distribution is slightly better than it would be in standard. It doubles down on the existing design of this mon as a physically defensive calm minder. The typing is always valuable for xyz physically offensive water type and it's signature move might as well be scald given how long Flipped games can be. Also, this mon abuses the heck out of screens.
:okidogi: As good as the speed is, the special coverage is absolutely gutted in this mon. This is like a poor man's Iron Hands, but at least Iron Hands is ballin with that juicy 155 speed stat and sufficient coverage with Tera Blast. 88 is the speed is bang on average, and 128 special defense does deserve a nod. But reduced physical attack and that miniscule defense stat raises cause for concern.
:munkidori: As bad as the typing is for what it is trying to do, I can see this mon doing something. I would put it on the same level as okidogi but it does have notable advantages that transcend man's best frenemy. Firstly, it is a poison type. If you have played this tier or even daydreamed about it like I have, you would understand the enormity of this statement since one of the deadliest mons here starts with 's' and ends with 'ylveon'. Secondly, it gets nice options in Taunt, Parting Shot, U-turn, Fake Out, Toxic (!), etc. It also gets unique tools for something like Dragapult with Poltergeist. However, it doesn't really get a good STAB move with Poison and Psychic having like 2 good physical moves between the both of them. I also think somewhere along the line, Game Freak forgot this was a Psychic type and didn't give it Zen Headbutt. Odd specimen, but I am intrigued
:fezandipiti: Luckily, Game Freak remembered this was a Fairy type and gave it Play Rough. Poison typing, yadda yadda yadda. 99/70 bulk is disappointing since it's cleanly 2HKO'd by band Return and barely lives Pixie Plate DEdge into Quick Attack (Gl if rocks are up). As a fairy type physical attacker, competition is as intense as it gets. Especially since there's a catch-22 here with any coverage you fit not hitting Gholdengo or standard fairy type checks (think moth, volcarona, etc.). Toxic chain shenanigans could be interesting.
:ogerpon: :ogerpon-hearthflame: :ogerpon-wellspring: :ogerpon-cornerstone:
The ranking is Wellspring >/= Hearthflame > Cornerstone > Teal
Teal is gonna need a really solid justification why I'd use it over any other defensive grass and it's mask-bearing ilk. Cornerstone has promise but Rock/Grass is meh in this format. Sturdy is also far more situational than the other two abilities. Hearthflame and Wellspring seem neck and neck but the defensive utility Wellspring offers plus it's ability upon Terstalizing pushes it as the better choice. Hearthflame is a defensive fire type that doesn't check Pixie Plate Sylv let alone Banded. I'm sorry. WaterPon's typing plus special defense boost seem more in line with what the mon is trying to accomplish, and water absorb is a GOATed ability.
:weezing-galar: :weezing: Weezing-G is simply better than Weezing - hands down. That's just simple calculus. Now, the question is: Is Weez-g good? I'm going to say yes. You have a good typing into a lot of physical and special walls, plus Neutralizing Gas is a surprisingly good offensive ability with the ability to deny Regenerator.
:snorlax: Chansey is legal, but I reckon given how the pace of the metagame has picked up, Lax could have a niche. Also it gets encore now and can thus punish passive walls for passive plays.
:furret: Nice Tidy Up you got there, shame about the stats.
:Noctowl: Tinted Lens with Normal / Flying could have a use. But there are stronger Normal types available in this tier.
:ariados: Better webbers. Better Poisons. Better bugs. Better luck next time.
:politoed: I genuinely don't know. Seems like a worse version of Pelipper as a Drizzle breaker since it lacks the Weather Ball + Hurricane Combo, but being faster is definitely a plus.
:magcargo: A casualty of the Shell Smash ban. Rip, you would have been a worse torkoal.
:gligar: :piloswine: Most NFEs aren't good. These are no exception.
:mightyena: Flipping a poor stat spread only makes this worse.
:ludicolo: Okay as a swift swimmer. Definitely wanting for a bit more power but it'll do.
:shiftry: Windrider is a lot more situational here. Meowscarada is tankier on both sides of the spectrum as well. Could make a funny Mandibuzz counter.
:volbeat: :illumise: Worse stats plus little need for their prescence.
:crawdaunt: It was always frail and slow in standard play, but now it's also piss weak.
:milotic: 125 Attack and fairy decent speed make it an interesting Dragon Dancer. It does however have coverage issues with most water immunes handily dealing with it. But there is always the option to cheese with Hypnosis.
:chimecho: There is potential here. I could definitely see myself running it as a one-off but the attacking stat doesn't compensate for the pretty low bulk I feel. Probably look elsewhere for Psychic types.
:jirachi: Beautiful typing and non-butcherable stats. Doesn't like Gholdengo being here but if we're making relative comparison with DLC mons, I think it stands out. Functions as a Stealth Rocker, Scarfer and probably has the best typing and spread for a wish-pass mon. I think if we were looking at the metagame overall this would be in the B ranks but here I'm putting it a little higher.
:torterra: Waited all this time to get shell smash only for the move to be banned in Flipped. Tera Blast is still a good option for expanding coverage so all is not lost.
:infernape: This could have been better in Gen 8. Stat-line is like Tauros-Paldea-Blaze but with an actual defense stat. I think Infernape's movepool is the saving grace here with options like Knock Off, Will O' Wisp, U-turn, Slack Off, Iron Fist Mach Punch and Stealth Rocks. Being a Fire type that doesn't check Sylveon is a big deal when you're in the builder. It certainly gained options in Gen 9, but the metagame in Gen 8 seemed a lot more palatable to it overall.
:empoleon: Swords Dance Empoleon could be something that works but it doesn't appreciate Game Freak removing Defiant in exchange for Competitive. The typing is still decent to make up for it and the fact that it breaks a lot of walls with typing alone could be something to consider.
:ambipom: Typing and Movepool do not synergise with random 115 HP and 100 Special Defense.
:yanmega: A noticeable drop in special attack is not good news for a Pokemon that already struggles with power creep as is.
:gliscor: Yet another casualty of high defense --> bad special movepool, and really low special attack --> bad defense
:probopass: Good attacking stats, but very slow to make them work. It's also faster than I would like it to be for trick room. Could be interesting with magnet pull, who knows.
:mamoswine: I have no clue what this stat spread is ought to do. I think by virtue of its typing and speed it can make a fairly good cleaner, but the attacking stats are a bit too low for my tastes. Plus the typing isn't doing it any favours.
:dusknoir: Has the same issue as probopass but Poltergeist is a lot, lot more spammable and the niche it has as a TR sweeper sounds much better. Even for something like Chansey and Lax, what is stopping it from clicking something like Brick Break and targeting their low physical bulk.
:phione: :manaphy: Phione is never going to be good. Manaphy did gain a boost in power thanks to it getting Hydro Pump. Take Heart is also a nice spin on bulky set up variants. Tera Flying can even do funny stuff like nuking Waterpon but I reckon Energy Ball would be a more consistent option.
:darkrai: We could see this mon being unbanned. My main issue surrounds Nasty Plot and its serviceable bulk and attacking stats. There is also the issue of hypnosis being a move that robs HP off defensive main stays.
:shaymin: Sky forme is probably a bit too much for the metagame right now. Base Shaymin's typing isn't that good and it doesn't have anything flashy over other grass types.
:conkeldurr: Non-existent special movepool. Iron hands does this better.
:leavanny: Stat spread still leaves a lot to be desired and the typing offers very little defensive utility.
:swanna: Mediocre defensive stats and bad offenses. The typing is good which is a shame.
:chandelure: This is a funny physically defensive mon. The bulk is better than something like Gholdengo and it has the same advantage of being a Sylveon check. However, Gholdengo's recover is soo much better. Will O' Wisp and Fire Immunity do give it an advantage over Gholdengo so I wouldn't count it out.
:mienshao: GOAT. Regenerator special wall with all the utility that one could ask for.
:mandibuzz: A strong special attacker with good coverage. I could take or leave its typing but it can put in some work as it switches fairly well into something like Espeon.
:trevenant: If Trevenant kept its regular stats, it could be cool here. Shame it got a stat spread that goes nowhere.
:vikavolt: This could have been something if it was as fast as its dex entry states. 43 HP is seriously bad. On the plus side, it is the fastest webber that isn't Kriketune.
:ribombee: With how slim the option for Sticky Webs are, I'm inclined to put this higher. Vikavolt seems to have more compelling reasons to use it being faster and stronger, but Ribombee has a deeper utility movepool it can tap into. For example, stun spore offers utility and Skill Swap enables it to set up webs on Sylveon.
:kommo-o: Kommo-o was ranked lower than I expected last gen and I attribute this to the metagame being more unfavourable to it at them time. However with Tera, Kommo-o can change its type to steel and circumvent its crippling weakness to Quick Attack. That alone puts it higher.
:ursaluna-bloodmoon: Might ruffle a few feathers, but I think this mon makes up for its low bulk with its crazy speed stat and defenses. Tera Fairy Moonblast can also help it set up on Mienshao. This thing can take on a surprising amount of hits once it sheds its normal typing.
:cramorant: :morpeko: Not gonna put in the effort for these two.
I'll definitely overrate or underrate a few Pokemon since no first impression will ever end up being perfect. But hopefully the effort I put into this will be well worth the dividends. Especially considering this was a 2 hour time sink.
Visualised