Cool Weapon Mafia Game Thread

@ Caff Mmk, I guess comparing your readlists it is mostly consistent, I can buy that.

Vote: Laurel

Anyway, I can see thinking "yeah 1 of 3 of these people are mafia" argument for Tommy/hal/idr who the third person was being made even if I don't buy it, but I dislike this last page. It feels like silently changing the reason for voting hal to keep the vote instead of reevaluating. I also don't really see their other reads progressing much like their original scumread on LS just got dropped, which feels a bit weird + kind of feels opportunistic with more people openly townreading LS.

If someone can explain the hal vote to me that'd be good bc I haven't really gotten anything from his posts. The main thing I can remember is Laurel pushing him for meta reasons.

I kind of think the realiti voteswitch is town. If his strat is to rely on his roleclaim to save him as mafia (which seems to have been his strat regardless of align here) I think he keeps his vote down on Caff who tbh is probably more lynchable on average than hal. It seems like the more dangerous action for trying to squeak by.
 
@ Caff Mmk, I guess comparing your readlists it is mostly consistent, I can buy that.

Vote: Laurel

Anyway, I can see thinking "yeah 1 of 3 of these people are mafia" argument for Tommy/hal/idr who the third person was being made even if I don't buy it, but I dislike this last page. It feels like silently changing the reason for voting hal to keep the vote instead of reevaluating. I also don't really see their other reads progressing much like their original scumread on LS just got dropped, which feels a bit weird + kind of feels opportunistic with more people openly townreading LS.

If someone can explain the hal vote to me that'd be good bc I haven't really gotten anything from his posts. The main thing I can remember is Laurel pushing him for meta reasons.

I kind of think the realiti voteswitch is town. If his strat is to rely on his roleclaim to save him as mafia (which seems to have been his strat regardless of align here) I think he keeps his vote down on Caff who tbh is probably more lynchable on average than hal. It seems like the more dangerous action for trying to squeak by.

Atheist game, let's go, everyone's town except Tommy.
 
@ Caff Mmk, I guess comparing your readlists it is mostly consistent, I can buy that.

Vote: Laurel

Anyway, I can see thinking "yeah 1 of 3 of these people are mafia" argument for Tommy/hal/idr who the third person was being made even if I don't buy it, but I dislike this last page. It feels like silently changing the reason for voting hal to keep the vote instead of reevaluating. I also don't really see their other reads progressing much like their original scumread on LS just got dropped, which feels a bit weird + kind of feels opportunistic with more people openly townreading LS.

If someone can explain the hal vote to me that'd be good bc I haven't really gotten anything from his posts. The main thing I can remember is Laurel pushing him for meta reasons.

I kind of think the realiti voteswitch is town. If his strat is to rely on his roleclaim to save him as mafia (which seems to have been his strat regardless of align here) I think he keeps his vote down on Caff who tbh is probably more lynchable on average than hal. It seems like the more dangerous action for trying to squeak by.

I made my reason for voting Hal very clear but okay. You're saying you don't like my posts but don't remember what they say?

Sus as fuck

Either Apricity is town and you're mafia or you're both mafia. Either way this is free.

Vote SB
 
@ Caff Mmk, I guess comparing your readlists it is mostly consistent, I can buy that.

Vote: Laurel

Anyway, I can see thinking "yeah 1 of 3 of these people are mafia" argument for Tommy/hal/idr who the third person was being made even if I don't buy it, but I dislike this last page. It feels like silently changing the reason for voting hal to keep the vote instead of reevaluating. I also don't really see their other reads progressing much like their original scumread on LS just got dropped, which feels a bit weird + kind of feels opportunistic with more people openly townreading LS.

If someone can explain the hal vote to me that'd be good bc I haven't really gotten anything from his posts. The main thing I can remember is Laurel pushing him for meta reasons.

I kind of think the realiti voteswitch is town. If his strat is to rely on his roleclaim to save him as mafia (which seems to have been his strat regardless of align here) I think he keeps his vote down on Caff who tbh is probably more lynchable on average than hal. It seems like the more dangerous action for trying to squeak by.
that's the host...
 
fwiw I still think SB is kinda grotty, but not for any of the stuff on this last page

" You're saying you don't like my posts but don't remember what they say? " from Laurel feels extremely disingenuous - not the least bc it's reasonable that someone forget the specifics of posts they find underwhelming (dare i say, forgettable) but also like

the leap from "idl the meta aspects of your read" to "they don't even remember the details of my read" is itself a mischaracterization
 
Back
Top