As for the rest of the post, I would say that Caff pretty much always assumes the commentator role, though I actually don't recall if I have played a game where he was mafia.I don’t really have any suspicions on anyone right now. I’m glad Psy has been un-caps-locking more, they don’t strike me as someone I’m worried about being scum right now. Celever strikes me as less scumread and more ‘fucking with psy’, either genuinely or as a ‘bit’ (also now has me concerned for my d2 activity bc as I’m typing they’ve said I’ve promised greatness d2 on which I definitely don’t expect to live up to, nor do I think I promised). Don’t have much of a read on Caff other than thinking if he was scum surely he does something more than just side commentary. My interactions with Vizh have been pretty pedestrian in my eyes. I’m super confused where these group-wide realiti town reads are coming from because I’ve gotten zero leaning from them yet.
Realiti is a player who tends to post little and high quality, and my vibe without backlogging is that that is applicable here, though it also kind of the optimal playstyle for a player to have should they roll mafia. I do think it's plausible realiti townread was bandwagoned on for towncred groupthink "look I'm one of you guys" reasons by at least one mafia, though that would be NAI for realiti themself.