NOC Smalltown Hotel Mafia - Game Thread (MAFIA WINS)

JALMONT said:
I think the psy vs dusk argument is probably the most important world to understand rn. After that please read my post on roles. Everything else is skippable. Happy to summarize the game for you if necessary


I don't think dusk was joking and I think it's unfair to penalize psy for that when his concern is much more valid. but i would concede there's a world in which a town player would see things like that IF they thought dusk was joking and psy truly was approaching it for an actual "policy because role exists" and not "policy because dusk said he's swapping all the roles regardless"
Click to expand...

I was in fact not joking but still trying to be funny
 
Aura Guardian said:
That's very fair. I confess that a certain... influence... makes me less inclined to take things seriously right now. Because when I try, the relevant posts make my eyes glaze over.
Click to expand...
Oh, yeah that was not intended as a criticism lol. I understand the lack of AI content :wo:

With that said I think the circumstance prob won't change that much so could be worth giving it a little more of a try yk :smogonbird:
 
OH wait ty for posting Hydro I actually did mean to scumlean you and forgot.

You entered twice LMAO what's up with that? Like "gm" into "hi" and then confirmed the second time, but posted multiple times after the first gm IIRC. Came back to a "what's going on" etc. it doesn't feel very legitimate.
 
Celever said:
Reads atm

Town Tier:
skippergamez -- Far more content-filled ISO than I previously thought, and overall good vibes. Has been contributing pretty well actually. Gave a premature reads list that really wasn't thought through that well but this is a playstyle quirk Smogon is more anti than other spaces, and especially if we take him at his word that this is the most serious mafia game he's played I don't view that as too indicative. Everything else is good so far.

Townlean Tier:
Eli -- Good vibes, reasonably contributory. Eli is a pro at looking like town, though. Considering a large bulk of his own content is also commentary, don't love his push on me for doing the same thing that much lol.

LS -- Not as confident in this one because I actually think I just like LS' personality and that can def cloud my judgement, but I have found her to be useful in some of the more contentious and heated parts of the thread, attempting to provide some reason to things. Def posting on-meta, too, but I don't put that much stock into meta.

Tommy -- Bottom of townlean. Arguing with Psy is an effective way to accrue towncred at all times, but their other contributions to thread have also just been useful. Tommy is also just a pro at looking like town, though. Eager to see his reads.

Psy Tier:
Psy -- :smogduck::psyangry::psycry::psyglad::psygrump::psytear::psynervous::psysad::psysly::psywoke:

Neutral and Not Here Tier:
AG -- No AI content, really

realiti -- Is literally not here

Hydro -- No AI content, really

JALMONT -- Entirety of content is dissociative game theory stuff. Nothing to particularly read into alignment-wise at this stage.

Scumlean Tier:
apricity -- The skipper vote was really terrible. Threatening to gladiate over a self-admitted level-1 read is directly anti-town, especially one that was already debunked.

master oden -- Post quantity to content quantity ratio is dire. Probably do not gel with their playstyle at all considering Tommy said the crazy amount of defensiveness to a single vote is typical of them, but if they don't want that to happen they need to contribute more.

Maf Tier:
M24 -- Absolutely no progression this game to the extent that it is a negative amount of progression. Tiny content quantity so this is still entirely malleable, but when they have come in and made posts it's been largely irrelevant to threadstate (meaning they won't get picked up on it) and the vote following Hal is just, bizarre. Really needed to provide reasoning there one way or the other.
Click to expand...
if you dont gel with my playstyle tbh thats a you problem not a me problem. thats not relevant to this discussion, but everything else seems fine (including me needing to contribute more). ive been 50% trolling and 50% trying to play the game w/o tryharding which is sort of how i am. i'll attempt tmrw to get a readlist down but for now may as well respond to this. good post- but i feel like M24 doesnt have enough content to jump to that conclusion so quickly? clearing skipper is odd too- i could def see skipper being coached by someone atm as mafia considering that they're new but very knowledgable. idk just food for thought. i dont think u should be towncoring people d1 regardless lol
 
Celever said:
Wait considering the later post about Psy and myself having a brief discourse on Jalmont's activity and that being presented in a negative fashion, was this supposed to be a joke? Doesn't give that vibe to me tbh lol
Click to expand...

lol kinda i mean game start looked like it was super soon after role pm rand so they didnt have a full day to prepare, more like an hour or so

not something i took too seriously since i came in late anyway

would my response matter either way to you
 
Nuxl said:
lol kinda i mean game start looked like it was super soon after role pm rand so they didnt have a full day to prepare, more like an hour or so

not something i took too seriously since i came in late anyway

would my response matter either way to you
Click to expand...
.....no, not really.
 
master oden said:
if you dont gel with my playstyle tbh thats a you problem not a me problem. thats not relevant to this discussion, but everything else seems fine (including me needing to contribute more). ive been 50% trolling and 50% trying to play the game w/o tryharding which is sort of how i am. i'll attempt tmrw to get a readlist down but for now may as well respond to this. good post- but i feel like M24 doesnt have enough content to jump to that conclusion so quickly? clearing skipper is odd too- i could def see skipper being coached by someone atm as mafia considering that they're new but very knowledgable. idk just food for thought. i dont think u should be towncoring people d1 regardless lol
Click to expand...
Town and Maf for me there isn't like redchecked / cleared or whatever. Just a cut above townlean or scumlean. Redchecked / Cleared would be its own tier.
 
You must log in or register to reply here.
Back
Top