NOC JOAT 10 Game Thread [Completed, GG Mafia]

Celever said:
There are two parallel routes of game theory.

Are the mafia bad at being mafia? Solve inactive slots because the mafia are either inactive or are posting badly enough to get found.

Are the mafia good at being mafia? Solve among active players ASAP to try and find them through one shot role power (more important with only one shot).

This is ignoring that we have 2 good subs this game (1, because Bossaru thought this was a tournament)
Click to expand...
It's not that important. Mute point really.
 
ZippyDoo200 said:
I did that dude, lol.

I said the posts before were inhuman (wolfy pretending) and the ones where you were just chatting were human (no pretend).

Then later on, and now, you are straining to try and get me off of my read.
Click to expand...
Right but you haven’t pointed out how they were wolfy pretending. Like this is what I was saying in the post game, even if your reads are great (which I mean this one isn’t) they’re worthless unless you properly case them so that other people can see your point of view.

Like I don’t mind being the guinea pig and you scumreading me to develop the skill lol
 
ZippyDoo200 said:
Not saying what you're saying is not important.

I mean that talking about my theory in general is not productive to this game.
Click to expand...
Oh, sorta fair but actually I think they hold value. Consistency reads are probably the most powerful type of read and if people get into game theory they can be found via lack of consistency in their own words

Of course some people are quirky and vibe with different game theory routes from one day to the next (guilty) but they’re still a pretty useful tool if people get involved in the chat
 
Celever said:
Right but you haven’t pointed out how they were wolfy pretending. Like this is what I was saying in the post game, even if your reads are great (which I mean this one isn’t) they’re worthless unless you properly case them so that other people can see your point of view.

Like I don’t mind being the guinea pig and you scumreading me to develop the skill lol
Click to expand...
I am not pointing to something specific in one post and saying "this is wolfy pretending"

I am pointing to a change in tone over multiple posts, the ones where you were talking about princess bride, and saying "they appear more comfortable talking about princess bride than they do about the game" and then voting them.


A lot of the "reasoning" you guys ask for seems super arbitrary to me.
 
ZippyDoo200 said:
I am not pointing to something specific in one post and saying "this is wolfy pretending"

I am pointing to a change in tone over multiple posts, the ones where you were talking about princess bride, and saying "they appear more comfortable talking about princess bride than they do about the game" and then voting them.


A lot of the "reasoning" you guys ask for seems super arbitrary to me.
Click to expand...
In order to make the case that I feel more comfortable talking about The Princess Bride you first have to demonstrate that I was less comfortable before then though, right? Like your case is a comparative one so you need to case the two points you’re comparing.
 
Celever said:
In order to make the case that I feel more comfortable talking about The Princess Bride you first have to demonstrate that I was less comfortable before then though, right? Like your case is a comparative one so you need to case the two points you’re comparing.
Click to expand...
Okay well ill tell you what.

I'm gonna go smoke a joint with my sister and then we can come back and just shoot the shit for a little bit. I haven't actually played with you yet in a meaningful way and we mostly just bickered and disagreed in the post-game chat.

unvote
 
You must log in or register to reply here.
Back
Top