BigFatMantis said:It's also important to note that for team tournaments with subs, it may be easier to enforce this with a stricter time deadline since you always have the option to sub somebody in, but I think it'd be a good idea to keep it consistent all around. And one other thing to note - what happens if you schedule for "tomorrow" or "in a few hours" but immediately realize you couldn't do it? Surely you aren't DQ'd 5 minutes after the scheduling simply because you set a time to fight less than 24 hours away. Something like this should have at least a 1-2 hour grace period after scheduling to prevent huge act fishes. Or on the other hand, the rule only applies after 24 hours passes since scheduling is also a thing that could be considered. Gotta be careful that the rule is going to make sense in all scenarios - we are here to play Pokemon after all, not act fish.
I like this exception proposal, and in general I think this post is really good. One thing that's admittedly slightly off topic is that like time offers like 'in a few hours' and 'tomorrow' (especially when time zones are involved) should just straight up be strongly discouraged - I don't really think you can put a rule in place but people should not schedule that way. offer time areas you can make it. not that hard. ppl should really be able to schedule a specific clear time to play. I also kinda think that cases like changing 15-20 minutes should be treated differently than saying no this entire day doesn't work.
johnnyg2 said:I’m of the opinion this is something that should be up to the host’s discretion rather than a hard and fast rule if someone should be awarded an act win for a reschedule. I think there are many people in this community that would rather fish for an activity win than actually play the game, as the joy is in winning rather than playing Pokemon.
Setting a hard deadline at x time rewards people looking at the clock and being like “ok my opp told me an hour before he/she needs an extra 15-20 minutes, time to call for an activity win”. Is this behavior we want to reward? To those above, I absolutely agree, I want people to respect my time too and I try very hard to respect other’s as well (except when I got Brazil’s timezone backwards and made fruhdazi wait bc I was at the doc’s office into haxing him, I’m sorry :( ). If you just straight up no show, it should be an act win regardless of when it is. But this feels ripe for abuse. I think this discord post by D4 sums it up well:
Well known tour players could start abusing this and get away it, but pikachufan123 claiming act on abr for example feels like it would be an outrage. To me, the downside of the current policy is it puts a lot of pressure on the host when one party is asking for an act win on a reschedule. Hosts already have enough shit to deal w, but to me, this is better than the alternative.
if there had to be a time, I agree w jirachee above. 24 hrs feels very generous, but it’s certainly better than 48 hrs (I play almost all of my tours games before Friday, does that mean if my opp doesn’t respond immediately and my or their schedule changes by an hour, one party can ask for an act win? Feels not great)
I think I want to specifically hammer home that
it should not matter who you are playing, it could be soulwind or it could be some rando who signed up for their first tournament. If they no-show or fail to schedule or need to reschedule last-minute or anything, you get a forfeit win. end of discussion. people might act fish more vs soul etc but if they just schedule and show up to their games and do their damn responsibility as a player they have nothing to worry about.
(also no-shows should be you get a win. END OF STORY. does not matter anything else that's going on its a forfeit win if you want, you can extend the courtesy of rescheduling but that's being extremely nice and should never be expected)
anyway jirachee's post is also pretty good don't have anything super specific. maybe an alternate solution is to over time infract people who're constantly needing to reschedule? once or twice is fine whatever you had something real. but more start asking questions. the problem i see with this is that this is really hard to monitor (esp w a lot of scheduling conversations happening in private) - maybe we could encourage people to tell the hosts when they get a request to reschedule? that seems like it would be rarely followed.
i guess another question is like - if you schedule to a time and then asked to reschedule & can't find a time then what result should be given? I think a coinflip in this situation is totally unacceptable & would push for a forfeit win (going back to my original proposal). maybe a compromise would be to allow reschedules & say hey if you give enough warning then we expect both sides to make a good faith effort to get their game done, but ultimately if even after good effort from both parties no time could be found you are taking a loss. This is the same as my previous proposal except that instead of trying to reschedule being merely a courtesy the slighted party can extend, it's a required action.