A similar statement could be made in regards to Popcorn Celever, too.
-
Welcome to Smogon! Take a moment to read the Introduction to Smogon for a run-down on everything Smogon, and make sure you take some time to read the global rules.
NOC Lover's Dance: Engagement Party Game Thread (Mafia win)
- Thread starter Tommy
- Start date
There, Celever made two recorded reads, one on page one, and the other on page 5.
In VnV, Celever made two reads on day 1. Those two reads are the only actual reads (ignoring the joke one I put for 253 as a "not in game" read) listed.
Compared to Celever's 4 recorded reads during the predance (two before pairing, two after), I don't think this is the same Celever as in those two games.
In VnV, Celever made two reads on day 1. Those two reads are the only actual reads (ignoring the joke one I put for 253 as a "not in game" read) listed.
Compared to Celever's 4 recorded reads during the predance (two before pairing, two after), I don't think this is the same Celever as in those two games.
(At least in regards to quantity)
.
I agree with Neon
This is actually a really interesting and good framing ty. It makes this game kinda insane to think through though lol. Based on straight reads I feel like Neon / LS is the two scummiest people but would they really team up? In context yeah… but I also thought that about pulsar and skipper lol. Maybe this train of thought kinda just results in T/T or W/W
FWIW I still think it’s fine we voted out pulsar and skipper they truly had to go lol.
What’s irking me is I deeply scumread LS fsr I just think this has been one of the more inconsistent LSes in recent memory (including eg u-turning on when she was willing to vote) but I both think Psy is town and see very little scumbud equity between Psy and LS, and know that I can’t be scum, so that does only leave LS/Neon as an option. There’s a chance if I weren’t me then I would see Cel/LS as the likeliest scum pair and that makes me feel like I’m barking up the wrong tree a bit lol
Maybe it’s like Neon / Zippy? Would have been some extremely transparent buddying on Zippy’s part, but Neon also kicked things off with precluding the possibility of them pairing up, which is the only person who did that to anyone in the game I think. It feels scuffed but plausible.
I have nothing to contribute wrt Ehmcee ftr, our chat has barely been used. We need him to activity burst lol
I don’t understand this definition of reads at all fwiw. I had high read density in Popcorn, one of the highest on the town
Can you tl;dr it?
Thinking about it Ehmcee actually did kick off our PM chat with scumreading Psy, so probably if he is scum his buddy isn’t Psy. That’s basically the only content in there I think lol
I mean the ones that actually got on the sheet.
Either I missed a few or they were too speculative, weren't straight forward enough for my dense skulll, or were otherwise just not quite compatible with the concept of my spreadsheet.
i asked him what he thought on the pulsar vote, pointing out that even if all of the two other pairs get on they need one of us
he said it felt quick and wasnt sure about the mannerisms involved.
i pointed out that most of proposal cycle was discussing mannerisms and stuff.
he expresses concern about how insistent people are/how quick they want the vote to be moving. we talk a few messages about the gamestate of that.
i asked if this game's pulsar felt like joat's.
he says its more like vnv than it is joat.
he said it felt quick and wasnt sure about the mannerisms involved.
i pointed out that most of proposal cycle was discussing mannerisms and stuff.
he expresses concern about how insistent people are/how quick they want the vote to be moving. we talk a few messages about the gamestate of that.
i asked if this game's pulsar felt like joat's.
he says its more like vnv than it is joat.
I mean sure but even then using this game as the example I directly scumread pulsar after the pre-dance. I was wrong, but I still did lol.
All this is to say that I guess I don’t trust your sheet sorry
Like shit like "would you be doing this if you weren't scum?" is just too uncertain and just...weird to really be certain for me.
I guess I'm just not good at figuring out what is and isn't actually a read as opposed to just "alright let's get this vote over with" from you idk.I mean sure but even then using this game as the example I directly scumread pulsar after the pre-dance. I was wrong, but I still did lol.
All this is to say that I guess I don’t trust your sheet sorry
Ty this all feels fairly natural tbh and obviously he was …right about it? Wasn’t pulsar maf in vnv and JOAT idr lol
Because this doesn't exactly look like a read to me.
It just looks like "alright, let's get this over with".
Yeah that’s not what I’m referring to
This is incredibly limiting because the life of a town player is to be uncertain of everything, and the life of a mafia player is to pretend to be
Well then what were you referring to?
not reads
This is just a response to something that isn't even about this game.
Not even about pulsar, and saying someone is coasting != saying they're scum.
Do I even need to say why this isn't a pulsar scumread?
Just commentary over the whole game.
Has nothing to do with pulsar, and even then, "could honestly see" just feels like saying "there is a possibility of this being the scumteam" which, no shit applies to literally every combination of 1 gentleman and 1 lady that doesn't include someone who has already flipped town.
Just elaborating on the difference in my behavior, has nothing to do with pulsar at all.
Just going "oh shit yeah game mechanics"
more gamestate shit
closest to an actual direct read thus far, just calling them a good vote as opposed to saying one or both of them is scum/is a sr/etc.
also game mechanics shit.
Just critiquing Zippy's reads, closest to actually saying pulsar is scummy, but my brain doesn't quite equate "not towny" to "scummy".
Also keep in mind that that was posted around when I was playing TF2, and at that time I was just checking to see if there was anything new just to give me something to look at during the like 2 seconds I was waiting to respawn as opposed to actually putting shit on my sheet.
fundamentally EoD
A) is that really all I've posted today that is lacking asf LMAO sorry for sucking and B) I think based on this response that you figured out this is what I was referring to lol. I literally said she feels scum
Anyway I care more about you thinking I have 2 reads in Popcorn than this, but both show a flaw in the method
In my defense I wasn't there and I wasn't giving a shit and uh and...