NOC Charge Me Up! Mafia GAME OVER MAFIA (psy, Laurel, af) WINS!

Celever said:
yeah, he came up with the whole "scum probably stockpiled charges on Celever" theory

like I guess I see it not being novel content if you think we're S/S but I'm gonna be honest I don't think I ever come up with that theory myself lol
Click to expand...

i mean with all due respect to your "i am the obvious target for charges im so good at mafia" approach this game i'd think that the first thought most people would think when they hear someone go "i have 4 charges!" is "oh there was coordination here" not "ah four people independently came to the conclusion that this one player in a fairy otherwise good cast is the best charge target"
 
a fairy said:
here's some reads i think.

realiti is town here. i dont see a world where realiti pulls this stunt as scum, his behavior d1 was fine which i've historically used to read him, but really i dont see any world where he pulls this stunt and i fully believe he would've targeted neon n1 to have neon clear him on his behalf. his play reminds me of how people were sussing AG for the mayor stuff last game for no good reason.
laurel i wouldnt be surprised if they were scum, i think. i didnt like their reaction to the metaread from d1, but i dont know what to make of their involvement since. i suppose i should be scumreading the since celever isn't and realiti is but that's a pretty low level and not great reason to do so, feels like.
duskfall i think is town here, on the condition that celever isn't*. i think a scum duskfall doesn't get ignored/TRd by all the people he is - sorry to you specifically but as a new player your scum read on him isn't what im looking for when i look for scumreads by people who've played with him before if that makes sense, celever's SR on him is notable but also very clearly understadandable given their debate.
*celever is suspicious, i think. maybe i've got it flipped and duskfall is scum, but outside of the context of the argument earlier today i'd find it hard to think duskfall was scum, which makes me think about that argument under that light. the more i think about how celever has reacted to pressure the more i feel like if i was the one pressuring him it'd be setting off my scumread alarm bells.
i can see pulsar being scum, and i think it's more possible than town. admittedly this comes off me not paying attention to her during the celever/duskfall debates, but i def can see a world where scum celever okays pulsar to distance via taking tommy's side. scum pulsar in a tvt or scum tommy situation would've also probably gone, oh shit celever is unkillable at night, let's amplify the suspicion on them. probably a shade more scum than celever.
you i dont have much thoughts about but you don't feel coached which is good i think since i feel like a newbie player would feel coached if that makes sense? id honestly leave that spot blank but it seems weird to give you a bunch of reads and not read you so hence its inclusion.
i've yet to see psy play scum but psy feels like psy normally does in games, which makes me think towny. i know there was a theory that psy wouldn't be able to keep up his posting behavior as scum, but that was also thrown around months ago and i dont even remember who had the theory. never seen a psy scum game in the games ive played w/ him but current psy is standard psy it feels like.

i can't get three lines of thoughts on anyone else, tbh. Etay is welcome to show up at any time, ipl has Opinions but so does everyone else he just had the bad luck of being a sub with opinions, ehmcee and joey sure are playing this game and i definitely have thoughts on them (a cute lie, a joke, sarcastic)
Click to expand...
Thank you fairy
 
Psypsypsypsypsythe said:
i kinda disagree at least as far as joey is concerned and i feel like celever has at least said why he trs laurel. mc is an outlier here though
Click to expand...

I think his treatment of joey went quickly from omgussing to pocketing and his treatment of the slot overall doesn't feel free scum/scum aligned but rather someone trying to manipulate joey
 
Psypsypsypsypsythe said:
fairys posting was pretty bad yesterday but today felt like a step up consistent with how she usually is going from d1 -> d2. and then she posted that readlist which i dont really like so

ipl is someone i have under a magnifying glass right now. depending what he says going forth i think his spot could vary wildly. ill say he feels different than he did in 2mafs
Click to expand...
IPL is 99% town
 
a fairy said:
i mean with all due respect to your "i am the obvious target for charges im so good at mafia" approach this game i'd think that the first thought most people would think when they hear someone go "i have 4 charges!" is "oh there was coordination here" not "ah four people independently came to the conclusion that this one player in a fairy otherwise good cast is the best charge target"
Click to expand...
NGL when I got 4 shots, my first thought was just "lol people really didn't think about their votes that much oh well"
 
You must log in or register to reply here.
Back
Top