NOC Charge Me Up! Mafia GAME OVER MAFIA (psy, Laurel, af) WINS!

btw pulsar, ipl, and dusk, I really dont feel like going thread hunting to look for why you voted celever, could yall give your reasons?
ipl’s + dusk’s + I just woke up for a dream where he was a bank who offered a plan that a shady insurance salesman based in a strip club also did
 
laurel who do u think the scumteam is and whats your read on celever

i think its like psy pulsar and (tommy?) i’d be more sure on the first two. i initially thought tommy was town but i feel like he’d be bringing more value as town? It’s possible he’s just busy.

idk i really feel like celever is town but its also possible he is hard pocketing me because everyone else scum reads him. My main reason for the town celever is that he claimed very early on and I don’t think he’d take his role as scum. There are way better options than being action immune on the scum team, doesn’t it also mean he wouldn’t be able to carry a nightkill? That seems really crippling as scum.

i think celever is the kind of guy to want to live until the very end so to me it makes more sense he’d take this as town and not as scum
 
Partly but also not really, the fact that people aren’t claiming their charges en masse is making it far harder

Based on who’s claimed, perhaps the theory doesn’t work. The main way I think it would work was if Laurel open wolfed and outed the theory his own team executed, which I’m not ruling out.

but I still think circle charging is outright the worst strategy mafia could do, so if the view is they either circle charged or threw all their charges on town / on scum and then I still think the latter is likelier. Certain things so far haven’t added up and I’m inclined to believe that at least one person has lied about their charge target already, although I also think the one I have in mind is prob town motivated lie and the second possible lie probably isn’t

for the open wolf theory to be possible my team would be me pulsar and emerald. why would we all claim if that were true? I think you can safely rule out that option from your POV.
 
All in all after Emerald’s showing yesterday his towncred has superseded the fact he voted for me in my mind and that is basically the only effect of the vote stacking belief being pealed back anyway, the importance of it was overstated

ok ftr what im taking away from this is that you thought the scum were voting you until you didnt want to vote the people who charged you, meaning that you only really considered it as a means to vote certain people, rather than actual find it scummy

you cant really say something is scummy then decide "oh wait but not for those guys!", it makes it seem that you never believed it was scummy in the first place!
 
ok ftr what im taking away from this is that you thought the scum were voting you until you didnt want to vote the people who charged you, meaning that you only really considered it as a means to vote certain people, rather than actual find it scummy

you cant really say something is scummy then decide "oh wait but not for those guys!", it makes it seem that you never believed it was scummy in the first place!
Celever should probably give his take on this but i interpret it as he thought that 3 charges on him was a possibility but at this point he finds me townlean, and if charges started getting outed it would be pretty bad if that strategy were true to see 1 townlean 3 unknown on celever
 
Celever should probably give his take on this but i interpret it as he thought that 3 charges on him was a possibility but at this point he finds me townlean, and if charges started getting outed it would be pretty bad if that strategy were true to see 1 townlean 3 unknown on celever

3/4 of the charges have claimed, me, you, and pulsar
 
ok ftr what im taking away from this is that you thought the scum were voting you until you didnt want to vote the people who charged you, meaning that you only really considered it as a means to vote certain people, rather than actual find it scummy

you cant really say something is scummy then decide "oh wait but not for those guys!", it makes it seem that you never believed it was scummy in the first place!
??? This is the most uncharitable way you could possibly try to interpret that post give it a rest
 
Scum stockpiling charges on me was a viable and probable theory, partly because as much as I expected to receive a couple votes 4 is a lot, and partly because I didn’t think it totally fit the cast here. But the rationale has been successfully challenged because Ehmcee pointed out its 1.5% for 4 votes at full rand, and the people who’ve claimed to charge me pretty much make sense (I actually don’t get why Laurel would charge me over others necessarily but it’s also not exactly outlandish lol) but I assume the third is Etay because we played Big Brother together recently, and I think Emerald and pulsar both make sense to charge me.

The theory was either correct or it wasn’t and there is evidence that this could have easily happened organically as more information has come to light.

It’s called changing your mind based on solving, something I know you haven’t done much this game.
 
Scum stockpiling charges on me was a viable and probable theory, partly because as much as I expected to receive a couple votes 4 is a lot, and partly because I didn’t think it totally fit the cast here. But the rationale has been successfully challenged because Ehmcee pointed out its 1.5% for 4 votes at full rand, and the people who’ve claimed to charge me pretty much make sense (I actually don’t get why Laurel would charge me over others necessarily but it’s also not exactly outlandish lol) but I assume the third is Etay because we played Big Brother together recently, and I think Emerald and pulsar both make sense to charge me.

The theory was either correct or it wasn’t and there is evidence that this could have easily happened organically as more information has come to light.

It’s called changing your mind based on solving, something I know you haven’t done much this game.

i picked u cuz ur my bestie
 
am i alone in thinking id rather vote celever to help figure out the celever/tommy/ipl/pulsar tangled web?
No people already shared who they’d rather vote between me and Tommy yesterday and between those 2 they tended to say me

Though pulsar is probably more popular than me and IPL is last place so maybe
 
No people already shared who they’d rather vote between me and Tommy yesterday and between those 2 they tended to say me

Though pulsar is probably more popular than me and IPL is last place so maybe

fascinating to me that you assumed the other option i was considering was tommy

and not laurel like the thread has been heading in the direction of
 
Back
Top