Here's my solve process on tiger and my last argument against Celever.
6 people voted tiger in the end (although Neon swapped 1 min too late, tiger still would have been voted off with the rules). This suggests a minimum of 4 town on the bandwagon.
Tigershark is known for being a confused newbie player ever since the last game. Celever, Ehmcee, and a fairy should know this as the currently still living members from last game.
a fairy Ehmcee why did you vote tiger anyways?
Let's say tiger was scum. He was online before the deadline and even posted saying hi but never defended himself for whatever reason. If he was really scum he would have a chat available with teammates yelling at him to go and defend himself, but he didn't, so he couldn't have possibly been coached, since if you read him mafia, that means you are reading him as putting up an act of confused newbie while being coached.
Celever swapped his vote to tiger last minute, way after tiger showed up and went missing again. Celever is a pretty smart player I would say, and he certainly knows tiger was a newbie last game as he watched the entire game even after his death. He couldn't figure this out though last minute that tiger was unlikely to be mafia? Last game he also was unwilling to vote Rostam at all and wasn't fond of the idea of busing his teammate. I would call this a likely pattern.