Copland said:It's been said before, but with the survey coming up, I just want to reiterate some points from a few pages back regarding sleep. For most of the player base, discussion about sleep moves/sleep clause in Gen 9 OU did not start until Darkrai started running the move. And it's clear to see why. Just to break down why Darkrai, particularly the lead Focus Sash set, is the issue and not Sleep:
- The most meta status absorbers (Gliscor, Gholdengo) have losing matchups into Darkrai. Gholdengo in particular has strong matchups into Ninetales-Alola and Iron Valiant, the other strong users of Hypnosis.
- Lead Darkrai's speed tier + Focus Sash guarantees it is able to roll the Hypnosis lottery at least once. Iron Valiant must use Booster, removing a layer of security for missing Hypnosis.
- Darkrai has Nasty Plot. This means that it can boost its power at double the rate of CM Iron Valiant, the other offensive user of Hypnosis. (I have yet to see SD Hypnosis Valiant.)
- No other sleep move user is particularly strong at this time. Iron Valiant is the weakest it's ever been, and would rather have Encore or coverage in its last moveslot. Ninetales-Alola is similarly at an all-time low, and has opportunity cost in using Hypnosis (either allowing opposing weather to be set, not clicking Veil immediately, or wasting a Veil turn to roll for sleep). Amoonguss struggles to find targets for Spore in a Gliscor meta, and even if it does vs. Offense, Amoonguss cannot itself generate offensive pressure after landing its sleep move. Gholdengo is less popular than it used to be, but is nonetheless a huge hurdle for Valiant, A-Ninetales, and Amoonguss alike.
I have no issue with Sleep Clause not being perfectly replicable on cartridge. PS is a simulator, after all. Removing a status mechanic from the game because Sleep Clause is "unfaithful" to the cartridge experience is silly; Smogon's ban list is not even replicable on cartridge. Sleep is no more uncompetitive than paralysis, imo, but when used to exert offensive pressure, it elevates an otherwise balanced mon to uncompetitive levels. I see a Darkrai suspect as the correct move at this time, not a Sleep ban.
^
^
ATTENTION. BASED TAKE ABOVE. PLEASE LEAVE BEHIND ANY CRINGE OPINIONS WHEN ENTERING THE AREA!!!!
But seriously though, do y'all remember before Darkrai was unbanned? Hypnosis wasn't even on the top 3 Valiant sets. It was considered an option for a wasted 4th slot, a Hail Mary, a sidegrade to Destiny Bond if anything, and of course very, very outclassed by Encore. Even without Gliscor we had plenty of sleep absorbers (sus shroom, dozo, hatt, pex, ghold) and plenty of mons that won even after a hypnosis (glowking, dirge, clod). And, although some people claim otherwise, I did not see a single red card spore amoonguss or sleep powder lilligant-h on ladder, nor did I even see either of those pokemon at all, really. So what changed? The only thing I can think of is that Sun, and by proxy Lilligant-H is more viable with Gouging Fire and Roaring Moon being released, and Zapdos isn't quite as common, buffing Valiant slightly. This doesn't seem like enough to do a complete 180 and say the moves are broken, does it? It becomes increasingly clear that DARKRAI IS THE ISSUE. It has a fast speed tier, fast boosting, decent bulk, and coverage and power enough to threaten the entire tier. These qualities PLUS sleep are the issue, and even lacking a few of them (ival lacks coverage and fast boosting, amoonguss lacks ability to capitalize on its own sleep, lilligant lacks bulk and a good speed tier outside of sun) can keep something not busted.
That being said, if you want to ban Sleep because you think it's inherently a stupid mechanic and our current Sleep Clause is a product of an older smogon with less restrictions, that's fine.