I'm still undecided on Ceruledge, but I see a lot of support for a ban coming from the community. What I'm not seeing, however, is hard evidence. Instead, the arguments I've seen are framed around a lot of hypotheticals:
if Ceruledge is the right set and
if it has the right tera type and
if it gets setup opportunity and
if the opponent is running this or that specific check and
if there are no hazards on the Ceruledge user's side of the field, it just 6-0s. But how often does this happen in practice? Ceruledge's defensive typing is awkward to say the least, sporting 5 weaknesses to common offensive typings. Of the Pokemon in the High and Good tiers of the viability list, all mons but (non-Tera Ground/Water) Iron Moth and Jirachi* either commonly run moves to hit Ceruledge supereffectively or can hit it with strong STAB special attacks that make Ceruledge easy to revenge kill. As a result, in order to trigger Weak Armor and get that game-ending potential it is being suspected for, it is highly dependent on having the right tera type to tank the move of whatever physical attacker is front of it and trigger its ability - preferably with enough health to spare to be outside of the range of this or that priority move. And it is with this in mind that I protest this line of argument that Ceruledge can just kinda get past any of its numerous checks so easily, because while it
theoretically can, it is highly dependent on getting the right matchups and the right field conditions in order to take full advantage of this. Yes, Tera Ghost and Tera Fire can help it break past its defensive checks, but these types are not helpful defensively and getting a Weak Armor boost is difficult. Yes, Close Combat can help it break past (non-tera'd) Garganacl and Tyranitar, but only if you are willing to make your matchup vs offense (if forgoing Sneak) or your matchup vs bulkier teams (if forgoing Poltergeist) generally worse. Yes, Balloon + Tera Fairy turns most Chomps and Treads into setup fodder, but Balloon sets are very telegraphed and require good prediction or team support so that it comes in with its Balloon unpopped vs a mon it has a favorable matchup against.
It is not like you have to go out of your way in the builder to have checks to Ceruledge either. Personally I've found that as long as I have at least something that can outspeed unboosted Ceruledge and eat a +2 Sneak, I don't have to plan around it much in the builder. Garchomp is a top 5 mon in the tier and annoys Ceruledge in many ways, whether it is through Scale Shot to break through sash sets, Dragon Tail to phaze it out, or simply EQ to OHKO or heavily damage most Ceru sets. It also has Rough Skin and potentially Rocky Helmet to help it take out weakened Ceruledge if it clicks Sneak or Bitter Blade. Besides this, we have several powerful and popular priority users that can revenge kill it: Greninja (also can eat any one hit from Ceru besides CC), Azumarill, Lokix, and - after it has tera'd - Scizor and Metagross (you may have to tera the latter to not get Sneaked on though). Defensively, things get a little dicier and defensive teams can more easily get overwhelmed by a snowballing Ceru as they tend to have less hard hitters and prio options to beat it back, but there's still several decent checks like the aforementioned Garg and Ttar, Rhyperior (who can even tank a +2 CC from full), Mandibuzz (only struggles with Tera Fairy and Sash sets), and several bulky Waters. I would also like to add that I don't find balance to be great right now and this only has so much to do with Ceruledge, as such teams are generally just liable to get overwhelmed by the offensive onslaught of threats like Latios, Ogerpon-C, SD Chomp, Keldeo etc. Beyond all of aforementioned checks, it's far from impossible to play around Ceruledge with faster soft checks as long as you don't give it a free SD or Weak Armor boost. Zapdos can annoy it with strong special hits and Static, threats like Keldeo, Terrakion, H-Arcanine, Rotom-W, and several other threats outspeed and threaten it with an OHKO, and many more circumstantial counterplay exists besides these.
What I'd like to see are some decent quality replays that demonstrate that Ceruledge does all that people say it does in practice, because the only times I've seen Ceruledge pull off the sweeps it's capable of was on ladder, and admittedly I was less convinced in these situations that Ceruledge was obviously busted than that my opponent simply made mistakes that led to an L. On the other hand, if I look at the replays from the recent UUSA vs the world tournament, currently the best resource of fairly high-quality UU gaming in the current metagame, I do not see Ceruledge getting out of hand basically ever. I'm not going to go over each individual replay right now, but in most of these games Ceruledge either picks up one or two (revenge) kills before getting RK'd or forced out, or it doesn't really find the opportunity to come out until the end and then doesn't find itself in a position to where it can set up a sweep. The one replay where Ceruledge arguably does something silly is in
g1 of the Aislinn vs starmaster series, where Aislinn is using a rather niche Ceruledge set (BU Lefties w/ Tera Normal) that manages to 1v1 a Garganacl before also taking starmaster's Ditto down due to a surprise tera type. It should be noted that she only gets to do this here because starmaster decides to U-Turn with a +2 Torn instead of clicking Bleakwind Storm. Not to downplay Ceruledge's threat level, it's obviously really strong and I can see myself voting ban after all, but I can't do so in the absence of replays where good players doing what they can to prevent a Ceru sweep nevertheless get overwhelmed by it.
*somewhat offtopic rant on Jirachi:
Hide
Jirachi, by the way, is terrible. Being the freest Ceruledge setup bait in the world is bad enough, but even outside of that, it has a lot of undesirable qualities. It is entirely dependent on rather weak contact moves to do damage, which is kind of a liability in a meta where contact moves are very easy to punish (Ceruledge Weak Armor, Zapdos Static, Rocky Helmet Chomp/Mola/Shroom). This prevents Scarf sets from easily running through teams by Iron Head flinching its way through checks, which is one of the main reasons you'd wanna run Scarf Rachi anyway. Scarf, by the way, also is undesirable in that it falls short of being able to revenge kill +1 Chomp. More utility-oriented sets are even more prone to letting things get in more or less for free, including some of the most common and best mons in the meta like Zapdos, Iron Treads, TankChomp, and even Scizor. Having Rachi as a part of your defensive core forces the rest of your team in an awkward position where it is necessary to have reliable, long-term counterplay to all of said threats (and more). That Jirachi gets to be considered "good" in this metagame is, for one, wrong, but for two, could only the case because it is one of the few somewhat reliable Latios switchins we have - perhaps a sign that Latios is really what ought to go, as it is much better than Ceruledge at bumping mediocrities up to viability. But I digress.