NOC 16P Role Madness Mafia (CANCELLED)

Also I made the tierlist thing
my-image (6).png
 
This thread will now become the place where I Frankenstein together a shittily balanced game with entirely moronic ideas, such as an announcer who is limited to posting quotes from songs and/or song names
 
like if you have 12 town you can spare stuff for vanity/flavor/less-than-helpful roles like announcer or whatever ehmcee's got. when you've only got 3 mafia you've gotta fit in protection (bg, redirect, rb, etc), some investigatory (watcher, tracker, rolecop, etc), and then something else potentially. ymmv per game but like, a recent 3-player mafia had a safeguard (target a mafia, they're immune to night roles), a rolecop(?), and then a... backup? whatever ipl's noc game was where hh won
 
Jesus fracking christ, how is the game going this badly on a meta level too

M2H said:
I'm going to be honest. If I had to make a hero vote this game it would be to vote celever. I'm not going to do that because I think it's premature but I'm not getting good vibes from the thread atp. That could be because if the situation with pulsar and me feeling off because the current facts seem to indicate I was wrong on my most solid sr, but I find it hard to believe that I feel this much dread at the thread when all the active, experienced players are town.
Click to expand...

This is based, I'm glad we're on the same page.

Celever said:
They started getting paranoid to the point where they were forcing some strange content and reads. I don’t think pulsar was scummy enough (or notably scummy at all tbh) to make that paranoia rational at all
Click to expand...
This feels like projection, your reads have made a lot less sense to me so far. Not to the level of bluedoom but still

genisu said:
actually would yall prefer a evening dl, like 9:30pm -8? instead of waiting
Click to expand...
IF IT ACTUALLY KEEPS THE GAME ON TRACK THEN I FULLY SUPPORT IT you hecking nincompoop
 
Celever said:
First time host :P

which ones
Click to expand...
Mainly mine. You continuously say you townread me and then throw shade in the same breath? It's been happening for a while and now you're agreeing with literally everything from Pulsar without argument? You read like someone who's trying to play both sides of an argument, probably shading me just in case M2H (who I've gone along with a lot) turns out to be unpopular later
 
I should also mention that your early pioneering of the joey vote is suspicious in its own right. Now that the rest of us have examined it, it seems like there's agreement that it's more of a "least bad" option in a thread where "don't kick the cop" brainrot is taking hold. You seem to share this perspective, yet you didn't seem to pursue better leads that wouldn't force us to essentially nullvote, most notably pre-claim Pulsar.
 
I wont be online for like the 7 hours before deadline so...

- Pulsar won't be voted because of cop claim and no one else did.

- Joey is announcer, which wont get voted out as well.

- I had a feeling that a fairy was scum, but she was proactive in the thread even when people started going off topic.

- Saber: was suspicious but because he has newbie + young combo I wouldn't vote him.

- I have a weird feeling than one of Celever or M2H is scum. Just a feeling though.

- Ehmcee, emerald and flanders behaviour look town to me

- Apparently everyone is fine with Jalmont being kind of inactive.

- Skip, hydro and blue are null.

- I'm suspicious of neon. He has like 9 pages of posts and the majority of his posts are off topic and actively initiates them.

- Dreamuur ????????. If we are struggling to find someone suspicious it could mean this inactive slot was scum. However it makes no sense to vote them right now.
 
Last edited:
StupidFlandrs48 said:
Mainly mine. You continuously say you townread me and then throw shade in the same breath? It's been happening for a while and now you're agreeing with literally everything from Pulsar without argument? You read like someone who's trying to play both sides of an argument, probably shading me just in case M2H (who I've gone along with a lot) turns out to be unpopular later
Click to expand...
I've clearly detailed my progression on you tmk. I townread you out of the gate, but then the "it was obviously a joke" is not something I get it at all which scumpinged me (made me feel you might be scum). You're still overall a townlean for me right now, and I haven't wavered from that.

I don't think you and M2H are a duo at all and I also hope that you don't think that. Most of your townpinging is that you're creating novel content so sheeping M2H is a bad way to go.
StupidFlandrs48 said:
I should also mention that your early pioneering of the joey vote is suspicious in its own right. Now that the rest of us have examined it, it seems like there's agreement that it's more of a "least bad" option in a thread where "don't kick the cop" brainrot is taking hold. You seem to share this perspective, yet you didn't seem to pursue better leads that wouldn't force us to essentially nullvote, most notably pre-claim Pulsar.
Click to expand...
I pioneered joey way before this, and I've directly talked to you about this before (which when I pointed out to you that you were wrong about how I've pushed joey you just didn't reply to that post lol). I pushed joey during the pulsar wagon. In fact I pushed joey slightly before the pulsar wagon. If other people decided to agree with my push in the wake of pulsar's claim that's on them. I thought joey was above rand scum.
 
Celever said:
Neon - I think it's prob a fair assessment that he's been a bit less memey than before, but he's also just kinda posted less which is I think what drives the view? At least when he has posted he has had a bit more content to it, but I'd argue it's about the same percentage as his more recent games.
skipper - interesting. that would be a bit of a return to form for his earlier style of gameplay though wasn't my perception.
Flandrs - largely agree with this year
joey - fair
Emerald - I do think Emerald feeling a bit unnotable is valid but surprising. I remember he had a huge burst of content mid-day that wasn't interfaced with much, and it was part of a long catchup for me so I don't really remember what he said. But he probably has actually contributed more than this blurb would say, maybe worth ISOing him.
Alice - interesting. I do actually think that Alice's content has been pretty barren, it's a lot of "I agree" without adding more to the conversation. She's secretly flying under the radar quite a bit, upon reflection.
bluedoom - that one's a short ISO I think it'd be cool to have a proper read on him from you by the end of the day
Hydro - Hydro usually does get better later in the game IMO. I think this has been a decent start for him, though still a little under where he would normally be. My read on that is just that the game is a mite too active for him though
M2H - this is extremely valid yeah lol. I do think it's more of an old gamer stylistic thing than anything else, realiti and M2H are from the same Smogon era.
saber - fair
JALMONT - it does feel like his contribution is a bit lesser than normal, but I think that's probably typical for a closed setup game like this? especially because he doesn't have many of his older friends to volley with in here (potentially any of them lowk)
Ehmcee - this is a valid take tbh. I think Ehmcee should prob be a name that gets considered more this game, even if I townread him for a somewhat self-serving reason (because if I'm right my brain will make a serotonin)
Click to expand...
Everyone else gets long descriptions and I'm just fair
 
You must log in or register to reply here.
Back
Top