NOC Pokemon Mystery Dungeon Mafia - Explorers - Game Thread (Game Over!)

M2H said:
Scum backup that copies town roles is legitimately not likely from a game design perspective. Plus neon just reads as towny to me anyways, after lowering my default level of suspicion of him. :blobshrug:
Click to expand...
The first part is wrong, the second part is fine, yeah. Neon’s a bit better this game than last game.

To reiterate I’m not saying either of you are scum, just pushing this faulty mech is giving you a lot of S/S eq. There are half a dozen commonly scum roles that would be called a backup if they’re turned into a safeclaim.
 
M2H said:
Scum backup that copies town roles is legitimately not likely from a game design perspective. Plus neon just reads as towny to me anyways, after lowering my default level of suspicion of him. :blobshrug:
Click to expand...
Seems like you just ignored 3/4 roles he mentioned to say that the other one is unlikely but not impossible
 
a fairy said:
they did this last game w/ regards to the celever 1v1 w/ me where they ignored a buncha possibilities to go "there wasn't <this one situation>"
Click to expand...
bluedoom said:
I feel like that threw me off real hard because I wanted to vote celever otherwise but it possibly not being a 1v1 made me paranoid lmao
Click to expand...
And to be fair it wasn’t a 1v1 for any of the thought reasons, it was actually because a fairy suddenly turned into an omniguard

We were as confused as all you, we copped her and was told she was a doctor :psywoke:
 
joey said:
Seems like you just ignored 3/4 roles he mentioned to say that the other one is unlikely but not impossible
Click to expand...

I've never played with an absorber or gravedigger, but upon looking these up I don't think those roles are relevant to the discussion. The only role that could fake a town backup is a mafia mimic, because a mafia backup would get outed. I think neon is easily outed this game if he is mafia. His claim makes it highly probable that he is town.
 
M2H said:
I've never played with an absorber or gravedigger, but upon looking these up I don't think those roles are relevant to the discussion. The only role that could fake a town backup is a mafia mimic, because a mafia backup would get outed. I think neon is easily outed this game if he is mafia. His claim makes it highly probable that he is town.
Click to expand...
let's save it for after he copies an ability and uses it
 
a fairy said:
they did this last game w/ regards to the celever 1v1 w/ me where they ignored a buncha possibilities to go "there wasn't <this one situation>"
Click to expand...

I was spot on if you weren't an omniguard. A town safeguard was on my list which is why I wanted to finish the massclaim. And my mech on JOAT / role cop & bus driver / bodyguard not being on the same team was right and you fought me very hard on that point.
 
M2H said:
I've never played with an absorber or gravedigger, but upon looking these up I don't think those roles are relevant to the discussion. The only role that could fake a town backup is a mafia mimic, because a mafia backup would get outed. I think neon is easily outed this game if he is mafia. His claim makes it highly probable that he is town.
Click to expand...
Gravedigger can mean two things, and mafiascum wiki might give the one that's irrelevant here (you get the results someone got on the night they died / a night they were alive that you can pick). The other gravedigger is an absorber who grabs the ability of someone who has died. Thinking about it, with cardflip, that is a likelier inclusion in this setup.
 
M2H said:
I was spot on if you weren't an omniguard. A town safeguard was on my list which is why I wanted to finish the massclaim. And my mech on JOAT / role cop & bus driver / bodyguard not being on the same team was right and you fought me very hard on that point.
Click to expand...
a fairy said:
you weren't spot on there were many reasons the 1v1 wasn't real
Click to expand...
if a fairy was a doctor then pulsar would've died because of a strongman anyway so it really wasn't a 1v1
 
You must log in or register to reply here.
Back
Top