NOC Pokemon Mystery Dungeon Mafia - Explorers - Game Thread (Game Over!)

OH COME ON
1000079738.jpg
 
I have important thoughts but I'm still 5 pages behind and need to head to work, will be posting a bit later when I'm bored at work
 
since I woke up like 12 hours ago most of the discussion has been either about laurel's bpv gift and him reacting to the pressure or M2H using faulty mech spec and getting into a spat with genisu
I guess that's pretty fair, yeah. I don't know if that means we need an extension, if anything it's argument against having an extension because some of the players ran out of meaningful stuff to discuss.

The partial massclaim felt like a crutch because the game seemed hard but it actively harmed us so that's cool
 
I guess that's pretty fair, yeah. I don't know if that means we need an extension, if anything it's argument against having an extension because some of the players ran out of meaningful stuff to discuss.

The partial massclaim felt like a crutch because the game seemed hard but it actively harmed us so that's cool
who are mafia/ good lynches in your book
 
mm ok, I kinda want to trust Tommy's read on Laurel since it looks like he knows how to read laurel correctly but I do think Tommy's playstyle as town makes him susceptible to tunneling
 
mm ok, I kinda want to trust Tommy's read on Laurel since it looks like he knows how to read laurel correctly but I do think Tommy's playstyle as town makes him susceptible to tunneling
Tommy for sure tunnels as town sometimes, but I agree that his Laurel case is fine. Laurel isn't interacting with the thread as he really should, and his playstyle is that he comes into his own at the end of the game and tends to be more distant throughout the rest of it, but... he's also been less distant throughout the rest of it than he usually is, despite not actually being contributive.

It's like a tinge above rand scum for me and is an ok vote if we're trying to vote out scum, but it doesn't do much for gamestate, especially if he's town lol
 
Shane, JALMONT, or Hydro. would settle for a fairy or Laurel as options that are more popular already.
wouldn't join on Shane/Jalmont but would join on af/laurel/hydro

I think Jalmont feels v different from his previous game where he was buddies with you. I think him stonewalling the town is stupid but he looks more solvey? I'm not saying that the only way he knows to play as scum is to just no vote and ghost from the thread, last game was clearly a bad game for him. But I'm not feeling a scum!Jalmont here.
 
wouldn't join on Shane/Jalmont but would join on af/laurel/hydro

I think Jalmont feels v different from his previous game where he was buddies with you. I think him stonewalling the town is stupid but he looks more solvey? I'm not saying that the only way he knows to play as scum is to just no vote and ghost from the thread, last game was clearly a bad game for him. But I'm not feeling a scum!Jalmont here.
oh JALMONT for sure is playing different from his previous game, but he's also playing different from his most recent town game. idk why he's going through a chain of re-evolving himself but I guess he is :P

agree that he looks more solvey than last game (low bar) but I still think it's less than normal. and I still don't think he's a vig, I think he needs to be on the table for literal policy reasons lol.
 
I'm not as hard into him being scum as before but I also don't have much reason to believe he's town, basically. but in the latter part of D2 that's not a nullread, it's a scumread, and he also lied about his role so
 
Back
Top