NOC Pokemon Mystery Dungeon Mafia - Explorers - Game Thread (Game Over!)

StupidFlandrs48 said:
Is that how BPVs work? If the net result of BPV + gunshot changes nothing for him, why would he need to be notified about that
Click to expand...
well I've played eimm with charlie and charlie is an eimm host, and in eimm people are notified if their BPV is gone(I'm also used to mafia games where this is the case) so I don't see why they wouldn't be notified.

I mean clouds was holding an item. You'd thinking flavour wise if your item breaks you'd know about it.
 
I'm kinda mad that the argument for genisu was "safelynch" or "backup lynch" when it was pretty clear that his role would've been a horrible safeclaim.

But its also my fault for not defending him harder, not sure how much it would've changed things but ya.
 
bluedoom said:
I'm kinda mad that the argument for genisu was "safelynch" or "backup lynch" when it was pretty clear that his role would've been a horrible safeclaim.

But its also my fault for not defending him harder, not sure how much it would've changed things but ya.
Click to expand...
I still would've voted him bc I felt his conduct in the thread was actively anti-town
 
bluedoom said:
speaking of which, why did you act like a moustache-twirling villain at EoD2? I get that you were happy with the wagons but you can't deny that that EoD2 play was scummy af from your end
Click to expand...
I had a nagging feeling in the back of my mind because of just how much anti-Celever sentiment there was. What if Cel really is scum? What if my biggest mindmeld is a lie? Did he really start pocketing me D1 instead of pushing the oligarchy stuff himself?

Forcing a claim from him accomplishes two things:
1. It puts these questions in my head to bed (at least for D3) if he makes a really towny claim like doctor.
2. It throws a wrench into the frantic frenzied fracas of EoD wagonomics. I may have liked all the wagons, but I would've liked a Shane wagon in place of the Celever one. If I vote Celever it looks super scummy, which makes the Celever wagon look more scum-motivated, which encourages Shane countervoting since it's largely agreed that Shane and Cel are not T/T. As a result I almost got what I wanted, only missing out on one vote to beat genisu.

It's worth noting that I wouldn't have ever thought such a stunt was reasonable unless HyHy had the public doublevote. Creating a speedwagon is way easier when Mr. Speedwagon himself can carry so much weight.
 
StupidFlandrs48 said:
It's worth noting that I wouldn't have ever thought such a stunt was reasonable unless HyHy had the public doublevote. Creating a speedwagon is way easier when Mr. Speedwagon himself can carry so much weight.
Click to expand...
if only people actually wanted to go through with my speedwagons :puff: the one time i get the perfect role for my Mr. Speedwagon-ness my cfds never go throguh..
 
StupidFlandrs48 said:
It's regrettable that Clouds wasn't around for DL, I bet he'd have taken the bait and scored the tying vote. Not sure about bluedoom tho
Click to expand...
I would've probably stuck a vote on celever tbh, doc claim 2 minutes before dl without outing n1 target is sus

but that EoD was so chaotic I'm still bewildered. Hard for me to tell what I'd have done between genisu/Shane since I'm coloured with hindsight now, and both were people I townread.
 
bluedoom said:
speaking of which, why did you act like a moustache-twirling villain at EoD2? I get that you were happy with the wagons but you can't deny that that EoD2 play was scummy af from your end
Click to expand...

this is such a good way to describe flanders eod2, he was borderline psychopath vibes
 
StupidFlandrs48 said:
I had a nagging feeling in the back of my mind because of just how much anti-Celever sentiment there was. What if Cel really is scum? What if my biggest mindmeld is a lie? Did he really start pocketing me D1 instead of pushing the oligarchy stuff himself?

Forcing a claim from him accomplishes two things:
1. It puts these questions in my head to bed (at least for D3) if he makes a really towny claim like doctor.
2. It throws a wrench into the frantic frenzied fracas of EoD wagonomics. I may have liked all the wagons, but I would've liked a Shane wagon in place of the Celever one. If I vote Celever it looks super scummy, which makes the Celever wagon look more scum-motivated, which encourages Shane countervoting since it's largely agreed that Shane and Cel are not T/T. As a result I almost got what I wanted, only missing out on one vote to beat genisu.

It's worth noting that I wouldn't have ever thought such a stunt was reasonable unless HyHy had the public doublevote. Creating a speedwagon is way easier when Mr. Speedwagon himself can carry so much weight.
Click to expand...
Its not scummy to vote someone who claims a towny role in a game with safeclaims especially if you think his behaviour throughout the game is scummy.
 
bluedoom said:
well I've played eimm with charlie and charlie is an eimm host, and in eimm people are notified if their BPV is gone(I'm also used to mafia games where this is the case) so I don't see why they wouldn't be notified.

I mean clouds was holding an item. You'd thinking flavour wise if your item breaks you'd know about it.
Click to expand...

if mafia strong armed and attacked clouds doesnt he die through BPV
 
If we're looking at every possible scenario its possible also that JALMONT shot clouds night 1 and broke the vest, and I think that is marginally more likely than JALMONT shooting saber, but both of those scenarios are still completely delusional
 
You must log in or register to reply here.
Back
Top