I'm responding to your most recent post in Policy Review.
You have seen all the complaints on weather, correct?
Now, imagine giving people what they wanted. A weatherless metagame. While the metagame with weather would be official, do you really think people would play in a ladder "full of fucking ubermoles and garchomps," when there is a "better place?" No, they'd run to the Weatherless ladder, and play there. Sure, Smogon could keep it official. But what'll a bunch of text do?! Maybe you weren't there in Gen 4 tiering, but as Justin#### said, "It's Smogon's rules, you don't have to follow it." No matter what Smogon says, we cannot change the community's preference of tiers.
This is why I personally believe the Weatherless tier is a terrible idea.
I fear I cannot post in Policy Review, so it is your choice to post it or not.