I mean, Cloyster was locked because it didn't really need a revamp in the first place and because most of the thread was devoted to people telling you not to use super-unviable stuff, and that delightful segment with me, you and some QC's telling you to talk about natures and not leave out information because of noobs.
And the Magnezone analysis is just badly written. The GP team doesn't exist to rewrite stuff for you and they'd have to do that for large sections of your writing. At that point, they can just cut out the middleman-you-so they did.
If you want to contribute, you can do it without doing stuff you're really bad at.