• Check out the relaunch of our general collection, with classic designs and new ones by our very own Pissog!

Popcorn Mafia 4 - Game Over, Village Wins

Status
Not open for further replies.
Tommy said:
Are you alright with phoopes and Evie being shot then celever?
Click to expand...
phoopes I think I'm settled with yeah

Evie is a really difficult one to land on but like if Pebble shoots her I'm not gonna roast Pebble in the postgame yk

I think frankly phoopes/Evie makes a lot of optical sense if you break the game down because we're kinda in the me/you/texas group which has I think confidently 1-2 scum, and then DBD feels like a bit of a coinflip, so that means there's prob 1 scum within phoopes/Evie

admittedly numbers wise we're on 50% atm anyway so it breaks even shrinking it down to that duo, but it's better than a duo who are both town LMAO

and phoopes/evie/dbd would be a hilarious solve I hope we live in that world
 
Celever said:
Texas have flipped pretty hard to come to that conclusion — Texas in particular had some buddying of DBD early on that he U-Turned on a while ago,
Click to expand...
Bull crap. The strongest comment I made on DBD was that I didn't think his wall posts were scummy when Tommy did, which I then changed my mind in when I reread.
 
If there’s 1-2 mafia in me and Texas, and dbd is a 50/50 then

You’re saying at best Evie and phoopes is a coin flip and at worst the least odds of flipping mafia by your reads

It doesn’t feel like you’re actually trying to solve and just bouncing around saying anyone can be mafia at this point
 
I don't even have the words for the emotion. If we're seriously going this many fucking rounds with no one listening to me then I genuinely don't care anymore. Shoot who you fucking want, I'm done shouting into the void.
 
Specifically marking this as not game related

Nice to be back for a game of mafia after so long, probably will pop in again eventually in the future but it's really not something I can give the time and investment to like I used to. Aside from the irl time investment, just not fun to deal with the emotional swings of the game anymore.
 
Texas Cloverleaf said:
Specifically marking this as not game related

Nice to be back for a game of mafia after so long, probably will pop in again eventually in the future but it's really not something I can give the time and investment to like I used to. Aside from the irl time investment, just not fun to deal with the emotional swings of the game anymore.
Click to expand...

Its been fun playing with you, popcorn can feel quite powerless at times it would be cool to play in a more normal game sometime hopefully with less idle slots

I do believe you’re town now and worst comes to worst there’s at least one mafia in phoopes Evie i believe so it’s not over yet

I do think your reads have been very accurate to now though and you do deserve to get to ask for at least one shot to go your way so it sucks if it does end here without you getting that
 
Texas Cloverleaf said:
Bull crap. The strongest comment I made on DBD was that I didn't think his wall posts were scummy when Tommy did, which I then changed my mind in when I reread.
Click to expand...
That’s what I had in mind ye, you and Tommy clashing over how scummy they are and then you changing your mind on it

We’re looking at interactions that’s a relevant one considering all players involved are still alive lol
 
Legit hate watching the Texas crash out over not being listened to when half of his shot pool is wrong

Also hate that rationally it makes sense to be from a scum pov considering I scumread DBD heavy earlier than Texas and he’s now revising history to make it seem like we’re partners

Initially when he put together the DBD/Cel shot pool I swear he said it was because there would be 1 scum in the pool because we’re unpartnered, now he’s saying both are scum and we’re partnered, nothing changed to make that progression make sense lol

Maybe I’m wrong on the last para I’d have to check ~~or someone else could~~
 
To answer the inquiries as to what I think…

As I’ve said, I believe Texas and Tommy to be town. Obviously I’m the third town, meaning that Evie/Celever/DBD are the remaining maf. So I’d be fine with any of them. In a world where Texas and/or Tommy are SOMEHOW maf (highly doubtful IMO), the person out of the three I listed that I’m most confident is maf is Celever, then DBD, then Evie.

So ShyPebble if you’re dead set on between me and Evie obviously I’m going to say shoot Evie but I would strongly urge you to listen to Texas and shoot Celever or DBD (with my preference being Celever).
 
Tommy said:
I’d be fine with dbd eating a bullet
Click to expand...
Tommy said:
Dbd id still lean mafia but I do think I am a little biased against him over like a certain period and I recognise that he’s killed fairly regularly and I haven’t played that much in recent times so maybe I’m making a mistake others are but I still think just looking at him to his face he seems scummy
Click to expand...
Tommy said:
Can you elaborate a bit on why dbd is mafia?
Click to expand...
Tommy said:
if texas is mafia then celever dbd are just town i think
Click to expand...
Tommy said:
Well I assumed airc was considering in pebble/dbd/phoopes right those were his top scumreads

I think pebble is most likely mafia out of that group but I would rather and have the gun if it’s the last shot of the game over a first time player and we happened to miss ngl
Click to expand...
Tommy said:
I’m fine with dbd shot today and also I’m fine with going with you today if it was in my power but obviously it’s not

I think like you could’ve distanced well enough to be mafia but oocams razor says it’s more likely it exists in celever/dbd

Could you be partner with one still possibly yes but I’m going to go for most likely option that you are town at this point and trust you I guess

Yesterday I kind of had a Texas and pebble or celever and dbd world, if pebble was mafia I was going to try get you shot next but obviously pebble was town so that is meaningful
Click to expand...
Tommy progression

Lowk is more anti-DBD than I had remembered but my impression still rides out, where DBD was shaded consistently but Tommy never really advocated for his death. Even when it came down to DBD or Pebble he tried to shield him over Pebble. And Pebble was obvtown so yk
 
Tommy said:
So like do you have any townreads
Click to expand...
And to answer this uh no not really lmao

40% of the remaining players are town it’s goofy to have strong townreads with those odds, and everyone is in a reasonably balanced state of could be town or could be mafia

It’s down to teams anyway, like phoopes and Tommy are probably mafia together but if they’re somehow the remaining town then the scumteam would be Texas / DBD / Evie, technically that scumteam shouldn’t make sense bc Texas has tunnelled DBD for a while by now (as have I, and apparently Tommy lmao) but I’m p sure Texas isn’t anti-bus and DBD has been a likely shot target for ages so sure it could have happened

It’s down to theories at this stage but tbc I think phoopes should probably be shot before Evie, using Pebble’s PoE
 
Tommy said:
You’re currently advocating for everyone in the game to be shoot though

Like if you’re mafia you either win today or claim credit because you’re literally calling everyone mafia and not making any town reads at all
Click to expand...
I’m not I advocated for DBD not to be shot today lol

I think shooting within the duos is gamebot strategy I made a while wallpost bout it !
 
Celever said:
Tommy progression

Lowk is more anti-DBD than I had remembered but my impression still rides out, where DBD was shaded consistently but Tommy never really advocated for his death. Even when it came down to DBD or Pebble he tried to shield him over Pebble. And Pebble was obvtown so yk
Click to expand...

Not really back end of yesterday before the shot went off I swinging more towards dbd, I asked airc to not shoot early and give us time and mentioned how I would prefer an experienced person have the gun in the case we hit town

Like sure I pushed pebble early and I thought pebble was more likely to be mafia but I was very clearly open to a dbd shot yesterday in a game where airc had a decent chance of shooting dbd

I take ownership of pebble blame but at the same time I pushed dbd similarly imo so whichever was shot it would be Tommy blame
 
Status
Not open for further replies.
Back
Top