What Pokemon do you misremember the generation they were introduced in?

Approved by DHR

With over a thousand Pokemon introduced, it’s hard to place them all into the generation they were introduced in! Are there any Pokemon you consistently misremember what generation they were introduced in?

And for those that started playing pokemon in a later generation, are you able to identify the earlier generations of pokemon? Maybe BDSP, LGPE, and ORAS help in this regard, but ORAS and BDSP also intermix 3-4 generations of Pokemon into their selections. I started playing with a gameboy color so I’m curious what if anything those who started Pokemon on 3ds or switch noticed (themes, design choices, etc).

There’s even a curious case of gamefreak doing this. In HGSS Meditite, a gen 3 Pokemon, appears when the gen 4 based Sinnoh sound is played.
 
:meltan: :melmetal:

Late Gen 7 and the entirety of Gen 8 was a weird transitional period for Mythicals. The Let's Go games are in a strange purgatory where they predate any of Gen 8's culling and thus are more in line with Gen 7 but are also considered part of the former maybe. This pair would be the mainline debut of Gen 8 Pokémon Meltan and Melmetal, who were initially available in GO before being allowed to be transferred back to a traditional game. The bizarre circumstances surrounding their inclusion make it really hard to remember what generation they're actually a part of, especially since they're prominent in the Sun and Moon anime.

:zarude:

Zarude is probably the only "traditional" Mythical of Gen 8, and it's very forgettable. It's just kind of sauceless to me? It also has a similar issue to Meltan and Melmetal in that it's a prominent part of the anime via a movie, but it was featured during the era where the anime staff decided to wind down the films but also experiment with the storytelling (read: delete the non-Ash regular characters from the big screen). I tend to associate that era with Gen 7, and that carries over to Zarude.

Gen 8 is also when Game Freak started to shift away from Mythicals to replace them with pay2win special Pokémon attached to DLC that fulfill a similar function, and those Pokémon just overshadow their elder brethren.

:hatterene:

This is less forgetting and more vibes. I skipped Gen 8 entirely and Hatenna was the first (and only) non-Gen 9 Pokémon that Liko caught in the Horizons anime. So I just associate the line with Paldea.
 
Last edited:
:sm/magearna:

Magearna was introduced to the franchise in 2016 during the pre-release cycle of Sun & Moon, but especially with Mega Megearna existing now, I wouldn’t be surprised at all if some younger kids out there who are only just getting into Pokémon for the first time thought this was from Gen 6. I actually think it should have been and would have fit perfectly into the whole Kalos Power Plant thing with those locked doors but that’s a discussion for another time. I can’t be the only one who initially thought “Magiana” was going to be some kind of Steel-Type Diancie for Gen 6, right?

:rs/meditite: :rs/roselia:

I distinctly remember seeing both of these Pokémon in Sinnoh before ever seeing them in Hoenn, as ORAS didn’t exist yet and I didn’t have access to the Gen 3 games for some time early on in my tenure as a fan of the series. The PokéGear in HGSS notably treats Meditite as a Sinnoh Sound Pokémon, too. Roselia, meanwhile, remains the only Pokémon to date to receive a pre-evolution and a new evolution simultaneously in the same new generation.

:dp/mantyke:

Being introduced to the franchise through Pokémon Ranger: Guardian Signs has its perks- one of the first things you do in this game involves getting your Styler back in an underwater chase with a Mantyke. The game’s Pokémon roster also includes both Mantine and Skarmory, which I feel like a surprising amount of people still don’t realize were meant to be statistical counterparts to each other. However, I’ve always had two questions, and we only have an answer to one of them. I know now that Mantyke is from Gen 4 and not Gen 2 like I briefly thought to be the case, and I always knew Mantine and Skarmory were added in the same generation as each other (thus saving me from the infamous “wait, this isn’t from Hoenn?” moment) but the lack of a baby Skarmory to exist alongside Mantyke and Mantine perplexes me to this day. And why wouldn’t this be the case? Johto was the region that introduced baby Pokémon in the first place.
 
I don't because I have an odd kind of brain that memorizes Pokemon and the region they were introduced in to the exact T. That said, there are certain Pokemon who I at times think they feel more like a Pokemon from another generation than the one they are actually introduced in.

Two of those cases are Slugma and Skarmory. Both of them are Gen 2 Pokemon, but because Slugma isn't seen until the Kanto segment of GSC and Skarmory is extraordinarily rare, it's often easy to miss that they are in fact Gen 2 Pokemon. They end up feeling at times more like Gen 3 Pokemon instead, since they are both much more prominent in Hoenn than they are in Johto/Kanto. Skarmory is still rare but it's in one route you cannot miss and the one with a unique theme and a unique atmosphere with a unique gimmick (volcanic ash), and it's one of the few Pokemon you can meet there alongside Spinda, so Hoenn players will know of it. Not to mention it's used by Winona and Steven. It feels like an honorary Hoenn Pokemon in that regard. Slugma is also prominent in another prominent area, the Fiery Path, which is a volcanic area, and is very prominent among NPCs and Flannery.

That's probably a very generic answer but it's one that comes to mind.
 
Ironically while I do joke about Slugma being a Gen 3 Pokemon and such, I never thus for mistook a Pokemon being from a generation it isn't not. Mainly because I was very invested in getting every Pokemon for completionist sake in a generation. Maybe before gen 2 came out I might have looked for Togepi but I don't recall. My brain might have just unremembered its existence even thought I saw it every episode in the anime until Gold and Silver came out.
 
:rs/meditite: :rs/roselia:

I distinctly remember seeing both of these Pokémon in Sinnoh before ever seeing them in Hoenn, as ORAS didn’t exist yet and I didn’t have access to the Gen 3 games for some time early on in my tenure as a fan of the series. The PokéGear in HGSS notably treats Meditite as a Sinnoh Sound Pokémon, too. Roselia, meanwhile, remains the only Pokémon to date to receive a pre-evolution and a new evolution simultaneously in the same new generation.

Obviously Meditite was used by Brawly there but it doesn't help that they were unavailable in Emerald, so I really couldn't blame anyone for thinking Roselia is from Sinnoh.

While I generally don't have issues with the old gens because I was super involved with Pokemon during Gold and Silver, collecting sticker albums etc, I kinda struggle with some mythicals that were released later into the gens. Since I didn't follow the movies I always have to give it more thought to remember that Volcanion is gen VI and Zeraora is VII instead of VII and VIII, respectively. It doesn't help that Zeraora got that shiny raid event. Funnily enough I don't have the same problem with Meltan and Melmetal because I know they existed alongside Megas in the Let's Go games.
 
Ironically while I do joke about Slugma being a Gen 3 Pokemon and such, I never thus for mistook a Pokemon being from a generation it isn't not. Mainly because I was very invested in getting every Pokemon for completionist sake in a generation. Maybe before gen 2 came out I might have looked for Togepi but I don't recall. My brain might have just unremembered its existence even thought I saw it every episode in the anime until Gold and Silver came out.
Blaine has a Macargo in GSC so the line isn't even that obscure. Some random Kanto trainers might also have Slugma but I don't feel like trying to find a text dump of Gen 2 NPC teams to check lol.

Skarmory is at least a version exclusive without any prominence in-game. Someone who only owned Gold had a very good chance of never seeing it before RSE.
 
Blaine has a Macargo in GSC so the line isn't even that obscure. Some random Kanto trainers might also have Slugma but I don't feel like trying to find a text dump of Gen 2 NPC teams to check lol.

To memory, no-one but Blaine has a Slugma or a Magcargo on their team but it's one of those Pokémon the game obliquely hints at through NPC dialogue like Slowking or Porygon2: a boy in Fuchsia City tells you that he "saw these weird, slow Pokémon on Cycling Road".
 
Ngl I blanked that Wally used it but my point still stands that it became so prevalent in Sinnoh that it would be a reasonable mistake to make (I remember using it the first time I played Ruby and thinking Magical Leaf had a really cool animation, if it had evolved at the time it would've been amazing).
 
Blaine has a Macargo in GSC so the line isn't even that obscure. Some random Kanto trainers might also have Slugma but I don't feel like trying to find a text dump of Gen 2 NPC teams to check lol.
If someone told me they had beaten GSC repeatedly and did not remember a single mon from the Kanto leaders' teams, I would believe them.

I have made the mistake of thinking Gliscor was in Gen II on a few occasions. It's just such a logical progression from Gligar.
 
Hoenn's selection of fire types is Torchic, Slugma, Numel, Torkoal and Vulpix, and Slugma is the more common one in the cave you have to go through in the story.

The Chinchou line is something you won't see in GSC unless you fish, and Skarmory is a Silver and Crystal exclusive found in an optional route with no trainer using it.

Johto has an inane ammount of lines that aren't used by trainers, are found just in Kanto, or are incredibly rare in the sole places they are found. AND they are weaker than Kanto Pokemon.

Seriously, Sentret is a rare encounter in the first route (and not at night), while Rattata is even more common in Johto than in Kanto.

Hoothoot is the sole common Johto species, and that's because it is a Spearow equivalent that takes over it AND Pidgey at night. At day it is both Kanto birds everywhere.

Seriously, let's go over the non-starter lines:

- Sentret and Hoothoot already covered.
- Ledyba and Spinarak are early game bugs, version exclusives AND only found at specific times of the day. Weedle and Caterpie are more common. Oh, and they evolved at levels 18 and 22 respectively, into Butterfree/Beedrill tier stuff.
- Chinchou is a common finding if fishing at sea but you won't have any clue it is a thing. Lanturn is quite more solid than stuff like Seaking tho.
- Togepi is a story 'mon, but not really useful in-game, and even if evolved Togetic doesn't really do much.
- Natu is something trainers use, but to get one you need to go explore caves. And, well, no Psychic until level SIXTY FIVE, and Kadabra syndrome.
- Mareep is common, cool and useful (although it coming JUST after the flying gym is a bummer). Sorely missing in Crystal.
- Marill is one of the faces of the gen, but also INCREDIBLY rare in Gold and Silver; you'll fight trainers with it but not find it in the wild. And of course without Pure Power it is uselessly weak.
- Sudowoodo is a story encounter, and a massive downgrade over Snorlax, although pure Rock was a novelty at the time. Still throughly inferior to the very common Geodude.
- Hoppip is common just after the Flying gym, yet makes Chikorita look like a sweeper. Bellsprout is found earlier.
- Aipom is a run off the mill Normal type that is lowkey the thing that may grab your attention for using Headbutt, but still you have to go out of the way to see it.
- Sunkern was literally the weakest Pokemon for 17 years, getting its better moves requires withholding its stone evolution for a long while, and Sunflora is still not too good. Also found in a single area at day.
- Yanma has a 1% encounter rate in a single route. Also quite meh.
- Wooper is a cool bugger that you will likely find, and Quagsire consistently pulls an underdog success performance. Still not quite strong.
- Murkrow is used by a few Rocket Admins and Karen, but it is only found in Kanto. Also a quite weak single stage.
- Misdreavus is literally found ONLY in the final dungeon. No trainer uses it.
- Unown is a gimmick and the focus of an out of the road sidequest, even if they got a movie.
- Wobbuffet is a gimmick found in an optional cave near the 8th gym. No trainer uses it.
- Girafarig is an uncommon encounter in a single route with eh stats yet unique typing. Missing in Crystal.
- Pineco is a rare headbutt encounter in specific trees in specific areas. Forretress is used by Koga, but that's it.
- Dunsparce is a 1% encounter rate in an optional cave near the 1st gym, which also doesn't really bring anything to the table.
- Gligar is a Gold and Crystal exclusive found in an optional route at the 8th gym, 15 levels below the leader, and without STAB.
- Snubbull was also a face of the gen, but 1% encounter rate in a single route, and, even if it does hit hard, it is otherwise quite average before the Fairy type.
- Qwilfish is used by trainers but it has a 1% reel rate in a single route, and Tentacruel is better.
- Shuckle is given to you, but it holds the record for most polarized stats in the game, and the only thing it can do is take hits while you heal something else.
- Heracross is a great 'mon, best bug in the first 2 gens, but it has the same con as Pineco, and nobody uses it.
- Sneasel is used by your rival, but suffers the same issue as Misdreavus in Gold and Silver, which Crystal relocating it to just before the 8th gym. Screwed up by physical/special types, and likely intended to be Gligar's version counterpart.
- Teddiursa and Phanpy are quite solid version exclusives which are also found in the optional route near the 8th gym. Crystal has both of them early in the game, but at morning and with a 1% encounter rate. Phanpy has also no moves pretty much.
- Slugma is the weakest Fire type in the first 2 gens and is a Kanto-only species, even if Blaine uses Magcargo.
- Swinub is heavily used in the 7th gym and is quite common in the cave that opens immediately afterwards, but Piloswine is still not too strong and can't quite use Ice moves.
- Corsola has the same issue as Chinchou, fishing only with no trainers using it. Also can't be reeled at night, and is highly meh in terms of stats.
- Remoraid has the same issue as Qwilfish, 1% reel rate in a single route. Getting Ice Beam in GS is also not enough to make it work.
- Delibird is a gimmick that for some reason was a Silver exclusive. Useless.
- Mantine and Skarmory are defensive version exclusives found at opposite ends of the map, with Mantine in Gold being likely encountered on the way to Cianwood, but Skarmory in Silver being YET ANOTHER optional area near gym 8 encounter. Skarmory is a competitive mainstray but doesn't do much in-game, and there are better waters than Mantine.
- Houndour is a solid 'mon that otherwise has the same issues as Murkrow.
- Stantler is the same deal as Girafarig, but only without the Psychic type, and the route you find it is very short.
- Smeargle is a gimmick found in the same place as Natu, and this one nobody uses it.
- Tyrogue and thus the expanded Hitmon lore is a gift down into an optional cave requiring plenty of HMs.
- Miltank is solid and a daunting boss. Found in a single route alongside Tauros, but they are quite easy to find.
- Raikou, Entei and Suicune are an utter hassle to catch, far less productive than going after the legendary birds in Gen I, but may come far earlier if you are lucky. Suicune in Crystal is pretty much mandatory, but it isn't a tideturning legend.
- Larvitar is a pseudo-legend that comes 25 levels below the other wild 'mons in the final dungeon, the one place it can be found.
- Lugia and Ho-Oh are no gen I Mewtwo in terms of dominance, but getting the version mascot before the 8th gym can do wonders.
 
The main issue with the Johto mons I think they were meant to be rare since it was the first time a new generation of Pokemon where introduced. So people would get excited (at the time where the internet was not as accessable) if they figured out how to get some of them. Tho I still don't get why they made them this weak. Sure, a lot were baby Pokemon too but I would say some of the new Pokemon make Elekid look like a high tier Pokemon. Wish instead of something like Unown, we got that Farfetched or Pinsir evolution.
I think of all the hops you have to go figuring out how to get Gen 2 Pokemon, I think Eevee stands out as in GS you have no reliable way to get the original evolutions for your story team and this may accidently lead you to discover its evolution to Espeon or Umbreon. This is how I rationalize it but who knows what Gamefreak was actually planning. Espeon after all is also just dollar store Kadabra.
 
Pinsir is a full fledged 'mon with the same attack stat as Gyarados, and one of the better recipiets for a Mega. Its evolution being retooled into Heracross was great.

Also, "baby Pokemon" is a bit of a mess as a cathegory. Electabuzz has higher stats than Raichu, and thus Pichu and Elekid are nowhere near comparable. And good thing we didn't get a PARAS preevolution as with the demo.

Preevos are IMO good enough as a concept, but don't give them to friggin' JIGGLYPUFF. Elekid, Magby, Budew, Munchlax... those were neat, but Pichu I'm sorry but should have never existed.

And the "only can be found through breeding" gimmick, or the incenses? Good riddance.

But, Pikachu, Clefairy, Jigglypuff and Marill are perfectly serviceable as they are as early game 'mons. They never required a lower form. They are already marketable as cute.
 
Also, "baby Pokemon" is a bit of a mess as a cathegory. Electabuzz has higher stats than Raichu, and thus Pichu and Elekid are nowhere near comparable. And good thing we didn't get a PARAS preevolution as with the demo.

Preevos are IMO good enough as a concept, but don't give them to friggin' JIGGLYPUFF. Elekid, Magby, Budew, Munchlax... those were neat, but Pichu I'm sorry but should have never existed.

And the "only can be found through breeding" gimmick, or the incenses? Good riddance.

But, Pikachu, Clefairy, Jigglypuff and Marill are perfectly serviceable as they are as early game 'mons. They never required a lower form. They are already marketable as cute.
Raichu, Clefable and Wigglytuff not evolving further is likely a byproduct of evolving via Evolution Stones, which does have an intentional or coincidental similarity to Mega Stones given there is no Stone Evolution that evolved further as of this writing… But that sure never excuse giving an even weaker form of Pikachu, Clefairy, Jigglypuff and Marill (granted, Marill and Azumarill also got Huge Power to compensate) and I can only feel those Baby Pokémon given to these Pokémon were made to make even more cash on the cute baby critters tropes.

When I see a fanmade Baby Pokémon for Pokémon with already very low BST (400 or lower), I can only say “Really?” unless the OG gets upgraded stats or an Ability akin to Huge Power to compensate.

It’s rather telling that Baby Pokémon has made an overall lesser good impression compared to new evolutions, to the point that the latter are still created time to time even with Mega Evolutions being created, while the only Baby Pokémon created since Riolu is Toxel, and no whole new pre-evo for existing Pokémon since the 4th Generation.

While existing Baby Pokémon still get some nice spotlights time to time, it’s easy to tell that many people ends up preferring “whole new evolution of an already existing Pokémon” because the latter proved more productive, even with suckers like Probopass and Lickilicky, because it both allows GF to have fun with coming up with new lore and wordlbuilding bits while simultaneously making either forgotten or alteady popular Pokémon to have a limelight. This expands into Mega Evolution, Regional forms (a few with their own evolutions!), Gigantamax forms, and more.

This can positively result a where Pokémon Gligar and Sneasel are honorary Gen 4 Pokémon thanks to how popular Gligar and Weavile proved to be, and that continues with the likes of Girafarig, Dunsparce and even Duraludon thanks to Gen 9’s Farigiraf, Dudunsparce and Archaludon, respectively. Gen 2’s cross-gen Baby Pokémon mostly don’t have the same honor when it comes to this, with few exceptions like Magby, Elekid and Tyrogue, due to feeling like a product of the time that didn’t aged as good as the good cross-gen evos does.

Special mention goes to Bloodmoon Ursaluna - a special, single individual form of a cross-generational evolution of Ursaring! No other cross-generational evolution has such a special treatment in a short amount of time.
 
Honestly, only a small handful of mythicals. Pretty sure I've mistaken Volcanion for a Gen 5, and Marshadow and Zeraoara as Gen 8 before. Marshadow in particular I tend to have a lot of trouble with. Think that's genuinely it, though, at least within at least the last decade.
 
Special mention goes to Bloodmoon Ursaluna - a special, single individual form of a cross-generational evolution of Ursaring! No other cross-generational evolution has such a special treatment in a short amount of time.
TBH Bloodmoon feels a lot like things such as Ash Greninja, not just a visual change but has practical in-game differences. Completely flipping the stats of regular Ursaluna and having things such as a signature move and ability. (Also having lore akin to (heh) Spiky-Eared Pichu) Admittedly they overcooked it cause Bloodmoon is stupidly overpowered but I kinda gel with the idea.

Though when it comes to babies, people did say giving one to Chimecho was a huge mistake, but it feels like Chingling exists cause they felt Chimecho was too 'big' or w/e to be a standalone mon or to get an evo. With things like Girafarig and Duraludon getting evolutions but no prevos though, seems they threw that idea out the window once they returned to doing cross-gen evolutions.
 
Back
Top