• Follow our Instagram!
  • Curious about what we're currently doing about bots? Check out the latest updates from staff in this thread.

Announcement ADV Subforum Tours - Current Direction and Discussion

Status
Not open for further replies.
I do not like removing the individual cups for slam. Mainly because most of the opportunities to play these tiers are in pls. If I’m not one of the people who is going to get drafted to play these tiers I’d have like 1-2 tours per year of those tiers I can play in slam being one of them. So if I wanted to play that tier in a tour to gain exposure or just for fun I’d have to spend a large portion of it playing tiers I don’t wanna play. In regards to it being a classic like tour for lower tiers it’s better, but it’s worse for anyone who just wants to play those tiers or give them a try outside of a spotlight ladder or another tour that is easily missable. If you are going to change slam to this to make the process of qualifying and experience of playing for people who want to be in play offs of that then at least keep some sort of individual tour that for the people who just want to try out or play those tiers casually.

With regards to the changes to advpl and ltl I don’t really see the point in fixing something that isn’t broken. Imo advpl was plenty competitive and I enjoyed teaming with people who likely wouldn’t have gotten a chance to play ou without the extra slots. Tyros for example had one of the best records and almost went undrafted. I also don’t see the benefit of removing the lower tiers especially when adv has some of the biggest communities and player bases for its lower tiers.

Probably controversial but I also don’t think LTL should have a CA prize. One of the best things about the tour for me is that a lot of the regular people who sign up for a tier didn’t, which gave people who are still good at the tiers but not so likely to get drafted for something like advpl a time to shine. Giving the tour a CA will just mean that the usual people who sign up for advpl will sign up and get drafted further reducing the opportunities for people to get to play. It’s not like this year we didn’t have enough sign ups for ltl if anything we had an over abundance of them.

Anyway those are my opinions.
 
RE: Adv slam - is this what other gens are doing? If not, I see no reason to change the current format but that's easy for me to say as I'm not hosting it. I don't really love the rotating aspect as it adds a more random element unless, I suppose, official tiers are the "main" tiers (Ubers, UU, NU) and it is guaranteed to be those? Seems a bit messy to me.

goldmason said:
ADVPL
8 Teams, 8 Slots, 11 players minimum. 110k. Manager selfbuys 15+25

ADV Ubers
ADV OU Bo3
ADV OU
ADV OU
ADV OU
ADV UU
ADV NU
ADV Draft

ADVLTL Proposal 1
8 Teams, 10 Slots, 13 players minimum. 130k. Manager selfbuys 15+25

ADV Ubers
ADV UU
ADV UUBL
ADV RU
ADV NU
ADV PU
ADV ZU
ADV LC
ADV DOU
Orre Colosseum

ADVLTL Proposal 2
8 Teams, 10 Slots, 13 players minimum. 130k. Manager selfbuys 15+25

ADV UUBL
ADV RU
ADV PU
ADV ZU
ADV LC
ADV DOU
Orre Colosseum
ADV 1v1
ADV Random Battles
+1
I'm not "opposed" to 4 OU slots, but I seem to be the only one that thinks the competitiveness of the OU games is not even close to the lower tier slots due to the sheer number. I thought the sweet spot was at 3 slots like we used to have. I recently tried draft (in DPP) and liked it, so I am not anti-draft but I do not think it's an official tier (I could be wrong) so it doesn't really fit in PL. I also think UU has more than enough for 16 starters if those people are not stuck playing RU, but I also think a bo3 of the official lower tiers works well there (especially if we are removing them from LTL).

In my view, the following would make the most sense:
ADVPL (heysups version)
8 Teams, 8 Slots, 11 players minimum. 110k. Manager selfbuys 15+25

ADV Ubers
ADV OU Bo3
ADV OU
ADV OU
ADV OU
ADV UU
ADV UU [OR Ubers/UU/NU Bo3]
ADV NU
ADV Draft

ADVLTL Proposal 2 (heysups version)
8 Teams, 10 Slots, 13 players minimum. 130k. Manager selfbuys 15+25

ADV UUBL
ADV RU
ADV PU
ADV ZU
ADV LC
ADV DOU
Orre Colosseum
ADV 1v1
ADV Random Battles
ADV Draft
+1
 
Last edited:
Despite the length of this, I don't have much strong opinion here, but I think that replacing slam with the proposed system seems odd. Loser picks, no repeats means that someone who is good across tiers possibly won't get to play the one they want because the loser is picking. And with the set tier it might be 5 weeks until that tier shows up guaranteed. Because pl and ltl are also so close in schedule, that means there's considerable gap in the year for a lot of tiers to play, especially if LTL format 2 is chosen. I think you could bump LTL to have a blend, where UU Ubers and NU are included with 2 slots for 1v1 and another experimental pick (no rands). But that's pushing a lot of slots, not sure how managers feel about operating that many different tiers. On the other side, I do think that mixing tiers together is purely beneficial to the tiers themselves, in team tours or getting individual players to try other formats.

Related, as some communities have said, simply being included goes a lot further than having a CA. Of course it would be cool for LTL to have that, but I think the priorities are flipped. Also to the point that better players would sign up for a CA and force out the middling players, I don't think that would be the case. When managers pick players idt the prize stakes affect who's who as much, and consistently drafted skilled players might have more CAs than they even care for.

Re: prestige, I'm kinda with FJ2k here, although "premiere league" should be held up as Pinnacle content, I don't think that having a certain number of slots tangibly affects anybody's opinion of it. I think the other stuff mentioned in OP for hyping it up would do far more for 'prestige' than reducing number of players..

I'm delighted to see draft included in PL, as it's possibly the second most popular meta behind ou, and I think PL is a good place for it, but in the light of "we're cutting slots to make it more prestigious and enhance manager/player experience" and "LTL might not have 3 lower tiers" and "reduction of individual lt tours," it kind of stands out logic-consistency-wise
 
Genesis77 said:
I’m a fan of the idea of advltl dropping UU and Ubers who already have advpl representation, but I think moving forward - with the custom avatar reward especially - including random battles as a tier seems unwise. It was very frustrating going undefeated personally and still not qualifying for top cut so I may be biased, but it was always disheartening to tie or barely lose a week where our rands player simply pulled worse teams and for some reason or another wasn’t able to claw back the win because of factors that just seemed outside of their control. As a doubles player I don’t have any experience with other tiers that could replace the slot but I think it’d be a conversation I want others to have.

I believe your issue here lied more with your managers drafting choices than the tier itself. Your team chose to rely on a player with 0 games logged in the random battles alltime sheet for the slot, which ultimately didn't pan out. Still available in auction was Mikon, who ranks top 50 on the sheet, was a first round pick this rbtt(rands pl), and has plenty of experience playing adv rands, and even won this most recent edition of advpl. If you didn't know the alltime sheet existed, you could have also referenced the current random battles circuit sheet, linked on all of the threads of the rands circuit, where you'd see Mikon in 4th place overall, making it to top 16 of adv rands open. Please don't blame the tier for your managers lack of playerbase knowledge and research.


random battles alltime sheet: https://docs.google.com/spreadsheets/d/10-_1Ytye7GNhw5FGDaZf1my7jN81IrMoYgbgRcY_dJA/edit?gid=1641562465#gid=1641562465
random battles circuit standings: https://docs.google.com/spreadsheets/d/1KC6-evJrLPsTJSO0u2RCIB8Mi1DihcAmzwpz0_OUink/edit?gid=1065342107#gid=1065342107
 
I don't have anything to say about advpl slots, aside from that whatever we do we should get rid of bo3 ou. I know I'm the old man yelling at the cloud here.

1v1 should 100% be included in advltl, I might sign up next year if it's there. I am not a player of any lower tier but I do think it's silly that the "Lower Tier League" would be missing the most important lower tiers, not that any of them or even ou are really important I guess. Is there a way to have all the tiers that everybody wants and not have like 40 slots? I am not sure.

Just from a logical standpoint as somebody with 0 experience in the specific tier (which puts me on the same level as almost everybody else talking about it) all the arguments against randbats inclusion in advltl have been pretty flimsy as well.
 
I am going to emphasize the negativity around changing the Grand Slam format. If other Gens are not making this change (which regardless, it is not a good one), then there is no real reason to change the format of the tour other than for hosting convenience and shortening it––which does not make the overall tour a better one at all. However, I do understand that the original format requires a lot from hosts, though.

The reason why I became an ADV LC player is because of a run I made in Slam, and by removing individual cups then we are barring new players from being able to enter tiers which are already significantly less accessible than others. Like many others have said, most of the action the Slam tiers get are in PLs, which are only being played by a small few. Players new to ADV lower tiers are not going to be able to learn five new tiers in a week to get ready for a BO5. In the original Slam format though, the slower unraveling of tiers allows players who lack proficiency in certain ones to learn and think about that tier before the next Open pops up.

BO5 is excellent for playoffs, but changing the whole format to BO5 just makes the tour less accessible for new players and less fun for experienced players who want to BO3 in tiers that they enjoy.
 
I hope my contributions to this topic will be useful for the community and staff, and I'm open to any feedback/comments that anyone has:

ADV Slam
I pretty much agree with the other comments here - if the system isn't broken, don't fix it. I think it's fine as it is - one tournament for each tier taking place each week. The other gens have done it this year, and it's gone smoothly.

I think the formats should also stay the same as last year - Ubers/UU/NU/RU/PU/ZU/LC. It would be nice to add DOU as well, but I understand why people may be against it (e.g. It's included as part of the doubles old metagame circuit).

Sign ups can take place throughout October, with the tournament starting from October/November and likely ending in December/January while ADV WC goes on (primarily OU).

BO3 single elimination, and then potentially BO5 for the playoffs.

A 5,000 react prize would be a nice incentive for the overall slam winner, especially as we near the annual like shop.

ADV Last Chance
Last Chance as a tournament is cool and many gens do this, but for the love of god, please do not make this a no-john tournament, and instead host it as a standard Monday - Sunday week tournament.

With different timezones and in real commitments, scheduling within a tight window can be difficult, especially as some people may not be able to respond to your wall/messages until Tuesday or Wednesday minimum.

There's no need to overcomplicate this, and it anything it just confuses people. This recent post is a perfect example of why we should not do this.

ADVPL
I'm probably not in the best position to comment on this as I've not featured in the competition before, but I think it would be good to keep the lower tiers and keep OU BO3. I think the recording and build-up would be really hype, but there's not too much for me to say here.

ADVLT
Having recently managed ADVLT II with the Chinchou's, I feel I am definitely in a better position to comment here rather than ADVPL. I really loved this tour, as it was a really tight-knit community with great vibes. That's not to say it isn't the case with other team tours, but I felt the prize helped to reduce the pressure from players.

I may be in the minority, but I would be against adding a Custom Avatar prize next year as I feel it would hinder the chances of many players who have invested in ADV and instead attract non-mainers/people who purely care about a Custom Avatar prize (I've seen this so many times). We had a lot of sign ups already over the last two years, and I think that people who are interested in playing the lower formats in a team tour environment would do so regardless of whether there is a CA or not.

In terms of formats, I would personally have the following:

ADV Ubers
ADV UUBL
ADV UU
ADV NU
ADV PU
ADV RU
ADV ZU
ADV LC
ADV DOU
ADV ORRE
ADV 1v1
ADV Draft (replacing random battles)

Random battles is a popular format, but I feel that regardless of the skill involved, it is hugely match up dependant and I don't think it feels right to have it in a team tour.

I personally thought 12 slots went fine, as it gives exposure to as many lower formats as possible, and there was an in-depth pool for each tier this year (from my personal experience at least, as we pretty much had at least 2-3 solid options for each slot).

ADV World Cup
I think it's a good idea to have a World Cup, regardless of whether there is a Custom Avatar prize or not. It's nice to have people come together from the same country and compete, so it would be a shame to not see this introduced next year.
 
Read through everyone's opinions on this. I'm not as involved with ADV as I am with RBY and GSC, but I think I'm still involved enough to give my thoughts. I get that these changes aren't necessarily worse than what we had before, but they aren't necessarily better either. I don't really have much to say on Grand Slam, since I basically just completely agree with BFM. In regards to ADVPL and LTL, I have to agree with Incognition. If the only reason for the change is to add a custom avatar, then the change shouldn't be made. I signed up for ADVLTL because I wanted to play, not because of a prize. If the tour was struggling to get people to sign up, I get how adding a custom could help with that, but there was no shortage in signups this year. As was stated many times in the ADVPL format discussion, this is the most active old gen on the site, so decreasing the amount of tours that a tier has makes no sense to me. I can see how changes would need to be made in order to include even more tiers (such as draft), but I feel like less drastic changes can be made in order to accomplish that.
 
Wanted to make a post regarding the random battle slot. It feels important for me to give my say about this.


'It's just random'


Rands is, despite its name, not a random slot and the people claiming this is the case are saying so without considering what even happened this past ADVLTL. Drift, Ananke and me were the only 'gen 3 randbats mains' that ended up being drafted (for quite cheap) and ended up going 4-0, 3-0 and 3-2 against the rest of the field. So any conclusion from this past tournament cannot possibly be that it's too random and honestly its just a null argument against its inclusion. There is a lot of skill expression in random battles. Yes, you can still get haxxed and yes, you can still get horrible match-ups. This happens in (nearly) every pokemon tier. Rands was also bo3 which made this even less of an issue.


My argument for why it should not be included


As the main rands player of the team, the slot did feel kind of weird to be in, and the biggest argument against this slot is its isolation. Rands is the only slot that does not need to prep. You just log in and play the match, and while your teammates are teambuilding, calcing and thinking about lines before the match, this is just not necessary for your slot besides perhaps scouting for potential habits. The experience is just so different over being in any other slot.

To be honest, this is probably also where a lot of the opinions against rands comes from. It's the only slot where you just don't see anything being prepped, the match just happens. And for a lot of people, that just means it looks really random if that teamslot wins or loses and I completely understand that this can feel really meh.


Anyways, if the difference ends up being the reason the slot gets removed I would be fine with it. Just want to make sure it's done for the right reason. Overall it's still one of the largest ADV formats and if there is any place for it to be featured it's here.

(Side note: would be sick to see draft being included)
 
I'm speaking mostly as a tournament spectator in general, but I agree with other posters here that removing individual cups from Slam would be non-preferred. At least for the viewing experience, I really enjoy getting the chance to see individual cups progress so that the games in later rounds are interesting to watch. While I don't doubt that the players (tier "generalists" that are competent in most formats) who will succeed in the last stage of Slam will still put up good games, they won't always reach the same heights as tier mainers playing their preferred format in a bo3 in later rounds of cups. I'll echo other users that these cups are some of the few opportunities to see certain formats develop, so limiting how many games and sets are played is a negative. If this revised Slam format is something people really want to see, I'd rather see it as a separate tournament to what Slam is now.
 
Regarding the switch to the PLs, I have one question: is the change only because of the CA situation? If that's the case, my opinion would be to just move CA somewhere else and dont toucht what already works (i have been nicely suprised of how much people doesnt want the CA) . Or is it because, as has been mentioned several times this year, there is starting to be very little differentiation between the PLs and they are lacking their own identity?

If it's the latter, then for the proposed PL structure I would replace Draft with a BO3 of the low gens and move Draft to LTL. That said, I would still try to find a way to fit 10 tiers while keeping OU at 50%. Going from 12 slots to 8 when good players were already left without a spot with 12 feels pretty bad. There would obviously be fewer tiers, but still...

For LTL, I would take the second proposal, add the three "old low gens", and swap Rands with Draft. I'm not going to discuss Rands quality as a tier or its competitiviness, but if the doubles tiers on Smogon are currently basically forced to either stay together or not be included because their playerbases exist "on an island", then with Rands that problem is a thousand times bigger.

That said, with this system we would be taking a tournament away from some tiers, so I would propose "some kind of " farm league to compensate for that, (assuming it can actually be hosted. If Slam is also staying unchanged, I understand that this would mean a lot of tournaments and a lot of work for the hosts/mods.)

I say "some kind of" farm league because I think that, rather than running it alongside the main PL as is usually done with undrafted players, it could be held between the two PLs and effectively serve as a showcase for players who could then be picked in LTL.

My reasoning is that, if it is considered a farm league and treated as one, a lot of established starters probably wouldn't sign up, which would preserve that more accessible tournament environment and give less well-known players more opportunities. and at the same time, it would still give the more dedicated mains of the affected tiers the chance to play a second tournament, since this new structure would otherwise be taking one tournament away from them.

I also assume it could be useful for evaluating potential new hosts and captains. For example, you could aim for something like 50% captains who would already be expected to captain in LTL and 50% newer people.
 
Points I feel strongly about:
-ADVPL back to 10 slots. I loved managing last year but 12 slots feels like a lot and there’s a reason most tournaments don’t do it. each individual game matters more with 10 slots compared to 12. I don’t like 8 slots because of my next point,
-At least 5 OU slots in advpl, last time the OU games were great and I didn’t feel it was hard to draft at least 5 solid OU players as a manager. we should lean into adv being one of the most popular tiers on showdown.

unfortunately this means some low tiers will have to be cut from the tournament. I think the mod team and playerbase has done a great job making advltl a competitive and fun tournament so any tiers that aren’t in advpl will have a team tournament where they’ll see high quality play. I also wanted to point out all of the other team tours on the website where you can also play these tiers because obviously i love all of them. If these tiers were ever in danger of seeing significantly less play i wouldn’t support removing any from ADVPL.

Ubers: UPL, UCL, UWC, UWL, ALTPL
UU: UUPL, UUCL, UUSRPG (or UUFPL), ALTPL
RU: RUPL, RUCL, RUWC, RUFL
NU: NUPL, NUCL, NUFL, ALTPL
PU: PUPL, PUCL, PUFL
ZU; ZUPL, ZUCL
LC: LCPL, LCSL, LCCL
this is a lotttt of tournaments in my view, and i would be the first person to continue supporting our low tiers in these tours should they be cut from advpl
 
xGang said:
Drift, Ananke and me were the only 'gen 3 randbats mains' that ended up being drafted (for quite cheap) and ended up going 4-0, 3-0 and 3-2 against the rest of the field
To add some more data to this, we have collectively gone 22-6 in gen 3 vs players not named drifttrick, xGang, and anankaios in the last 2 RBTTs. Combined with LTL we have an 80% match winrate vs others, and it's very likely some, if not almost all, of those 20% lost sets could've been won if we played better. But if losing 1 in every ~10 sets to mu/hax is too "matchup-dependent" then so be it.

I'm not informed enough to comment on the inclusion of rands in ADVLTL moving forward, but I do feel it is an oddball of the included formats for the reasons xGang listed. However, I believe that excluding ADV rands even partly because of excessive "factors outside the players' control" or lack of competitiveness is unjustified.
 
Hello fellow ADVers, time to throw my 2 cents worth in here:

ADV Slam

This should stay as it has been. It's worked, people love it, why change it right? I love the individual Cups as the other gens do. I love hosting them, I love playing in them, what more needs to be said. As others have said: if it isn't broken, don't fix it! Top 16 get into playoffs and a reacts prize should be given.

ADV PL

This should not be reduced to 8 slots, that would be a big mistake. I'm fine with 12 slots but if 10 slots had to be the case, then I'd be good with that too. 2 managers would be good, maybe a 3rd; both would be allowed to self-buy. The metas should be either

12 Slots
Ubers
OU x5
OU Bo3
UU
RU
NU
PU
LC

OR

10 slots
Ubers
OU x4
OU Bo3
UU
RU
NU
PU

But I'd stick to the former here since there's more variety and thus more likely for a higher volume of signups.

ADVLTL

With regards to ADVLTL, this is where the metas that aren't included in PL can shine. Especially now that a 3rd CA is going to be included, I'm loving that 1st format. 8 teams and 10 slots seems like the best fit and should still fetch a good number of signups that PL gets.


Regarding circuit tours, I'm not opposed to any ideas at this time. Again, sticking with what works
 
Last edited:
This post will contain my opinion as a player, not as a moderator.

Slam:
I think the format that is being played now is fine, especially because it boosts the number of games played in the low tiers which is always good.

ADVPL and ADVLTL:

This new format is exciting. To me, a big issue with the current advpl format is the lack of quality in the ou games. While opening more slots favors the development of new talents on the tier, the side effects are currently hurting the prestige of the tournament too much, which results in the accomplishments of those who perform well and get a good sheet score being diminished. At the same time, the new additional advou slots contribute to the drafting of non mainers who can just pilot well in the tier. Such players go for cheap on draft and beat the newcomers on fundamentals, which is not necessarely the intent of the new advou slots. The newcomers fighting newcomers/less experienced players is actually detrimental for their development, since, if the tournament had a more strict list of names drafted, the players would punch up and have a more competitive environment to fight upon.

In the other hand, ADVLTL is also in need of some action. The addition of a new custom avatar prize should be accompanied by a rise in prestige in the tournament. The ammount of low quality matches in the tournament is not insignificant either, but this tournament was supposed to be more inclusive to lure in ouers and other players to try new tiers, while also bettering the quality of the current players. However, this agenda is not having much success in both ends. The lack of a competitive environment and high level matches does not contribute much for the development of players, and the newcomers do not tend to make new teams and develop the tiers. At the end of the day, its a fine tour as a farm league, but not good enough to have an avatar prize.

The new format proposed has ideas that can help both tournaments walk towards the desired outcomes. Reducing the ammount of ou slots in advpl is a must, in my opinon. It benefits the new players by making the tour more competitive, encourages the old players by having challenging games and matchups to face, creates more exciting content for the spectators and makes the manager job less intense. The inclusion of draft is also really interesting and should be considered. Draft has a bigger playerbase then any other lower tier, and with a lot of experience in the format i can confirm it is extremely developed and complex. Draft tiers in team tours are also extremely fun, since they bring the whole team together to build a squad.

With the removal of one or two ou slots, the ammount of low tiers become disproportional. Moving some of the non classic low tiers to advltl is a great idea to both solve the advpl problem and contribute to the prestige growth and quality uprising of advltl. In advpl, some low tiers like ru suffer from their playerbase being split up between ou, uu and ru. By moving ru to advltl, the quality of the games and of the tournament in general goes up significantly, since the playerbase wont be split anymore. The players will also feel more encouraged to play the tour, since the matchups will be more challenging and the tier was not featured in the past tournament. More ou players will also be able to join and try out other low tiers; the funtamental fueled other tier players would be essencial to contribute to advltl quality. As mentioned about advpl, bettering the competitiveness of the environment also makes the newcomer experience much more complete, resulting in better development of those players.

Its important to recognize that the goal of moving some advpl low tiers to advltl is to build prestige and amplify the culture around that tournament. It is not a case of "kicking the tiers to the side". My goal is not to make the tournaments less inclusive necessarely, but some level of exclusivity is beneficial to all the involved parties.

My proposed formats would be exemplified by:

ADVPL:
ADV Ubers
ADV OU Bo3
ADV OU
ADV OU
ADV UU
ADV NU
ADV PU (or a fourth ou; the pu playerbase is huge and distinct enough to be justified in this slot)
ADV Draft

ADVLTL:
ADV Ubers
ADV UUBL
ADV UU #the inclusion of uu and nu in both tournaments, while contradictory with some points made previously, benefits the tiers and the tournament. Its expected that the experienced players will have less pressure of playing on their main tier here and would be able to migrate to other metagames, reducing the playerbase split issue.
ADV RU
ADV NU
ADV PU
ADV ZU
ADV LC
ADV DOU
Orre Colosseum
ADV 1v1
ADV Random Battles

I would be really satisfied with those changes. I know its a lot and it looks scary to touch on a tournament that is already doing well, but i am confident the revamp of both tournaments will be great long term.
Feel free to ask anything! Dms always open.
 
Last edited:
So, these kinds of posts are probably my least favorite to make here on Smogon for a couple of reasons, but I’ll bite the bullet. I should make it clear that my perspective likely isn’t unique among those who have already chimed in with their opinions previously — I haven’t read everything here thoroughly, but I skimmed over the thread enough to have a general idea of what’s going on — but ADV lower tiers are very near and dear to me, so I thought it wise to try and help make these tournaments the best I think they can be. Because apparently these sorts of things are about which crowd has the most amount of people being the most vocal about what they think, I guess.

Incidentally, I’ve played lower tiers in this year’s ADVPL, both editions of ADVLTL, and came up just short of ADV Slam playoffs last year, so I do have a vested interest and qualified stance on these matters, at least in my opinion. If you’re around in the ADV RU server, you may have seen me make a lot of these points there, and the only difference is that they’ll be a bit more coherent in this post.

the slam
Alright, I’ll start with what is probably the least contentious of my takes. I don’t want people to disregard this post too soon, after all. As with quite a few others, I don’t like the proposed format for ADV Slam. The idea is evidently that the tournament becomes more approachable for both the playerbase and hosts with the new format, but I think that logic is fundamentally flawed.

Regarding approachability for the players, I actually think the opposite effect would take form. Someone who is only interested in UU, for example, doesn’t want to play Ubers or NU or any other tier just so they can play one game of UU in their ADV Slam set. While I think the idea of being a [TIER] main isn’t as logically sound as being a [GENERATION] main, a ton of people on the site make that choice, and many of those people are at least mildly interested in ADV such that they participate in ADV slam just for their one tier (this, of course, is not specific to any one generation’s Slam tournament).

The natural increase in variance born of removing cups is also worth noting. I think double elimination is great, I think BO5 is great, I don’t think that necessarily makes for a great replacement here. If you lose in a cup for getting particularly unlucky, you have the other four (or, in ADV’s case, six) cups to salvage your points with. With one double elimination tournament, you only get to lose once while keeping any chance at a decent performance. Sure, BO5 formats can reduce the impact of RNG on a given set, but all else equal, nothing is stopping someone from critting you in game 5 in a BO5 just as often as they can crit you in game 3 of a BO3.

We can also examine the validity of the number of tournaments taking place with the current ADV Slam format. From a hosting point of view, I do understand the workload that seven cups demand; I don’t have a ton of experience hosting, but the few times I have helped with hosting a tournament, I learned just how exhausting that can be in some cases. However, the ADV community is large enough that, as an outsider looking in, I think you could certainly get enough people who are motivated enough to let ADV Slam, as it currently exists, run smoothly again this year and for many to come. (hell, I’d even volunteer to help out there if absolutely necessary; I care far too much about these lower tiers to let this tour die off on the insane off-chance that hosting is somehow the limiting factor)

I have heard points about players not wanting to enter seven tournaments just so they have the best odds at qualifying for playoffs, which is probably the fairest criticism yet. Beyond the exhaustion of playing in that many tours concurrently, it’s also obviously a sizable time commitment. Personally, I never found that to be a problem despite being occupied full time and having a life outside of Smogon, but this counterargument to the current Slam format could lead to a serious case for cutting down the total number of cups.

Don’t get me wrong, I’m glad ZU and LC have a spot where they’re both represented like this, even if I’m not terribly invested in either tier. I think it’s interesting that ADV is the only generation whose slam includes both ZU and LC (with some generations featuring neither), but as far as I’m aware, they are some of the less popular tiers among ADV players. If you were to make any changes to the ADV Slam format, I think downsizing in this way is the only one I’d be on board with. If you want even more of a case for that downsizing, it would make the current BO5 format of Slam playoffs easier to prep for since you know which tiers are viable for being played, even if the set does go to game 5.

Also, 5k reaction score as a prize doesn’t even come close to making up for how bastardized I think the proposed Slam format is. Maybe I’m the odd one out here, but I’ve never locked in for a tournament just because it has a reaction score prize. Let’s also not forget that this was all announced a week and a half before the scheduled start date of ADV Slam, with (to my knowledge) no notice ahead of time regarding the potential direction of the tournament. That somehow just adds to the reaction score prize feeling like jingling keys in front of ADV lower tier players’ faces, if that makes sense.

the premier
I originally planned to talk about my thoughts on ADVPL last because I probably have the hottest takes regarding it, but my stance on ADVLTL kinda requires me to set things up with ADVPL. Because we are on the internet, and more importantly we are on Smogon, I’m going to add the disclaimer that I, DONBONEJONES, AM NOT, NOR DO I ENDORSE TIERBASHING. ALL SMOGON FORMATS ARE EQUALLY VALID AND I DO NOT CARE WHICH ONES PEOPLE CHOOSE TO PLAY. THIS IS EXCLUSIVELY A CRITICISM OF THE PROPOPSED TOURNAMENT FORMATS FOR THE FOLLOWING YEAR(S). Alright, time to get some (more) people mad.

Let’s talk about why specifically most of the tiers got pruned from ADVPL. The OP states that this is due to most of them not being considered official by the end of ADV as a current generation, leaving only Ubers, OU, UU, and NU. I obviously wasn’t around on Smogon when ADV ceased being current, so I welcome anyone who was to correct me on this, but I’m pretty sure NU wasn’t even considered official at that point in time. Ok, sure, people may have played it as an ADV tier long before any of the other lower tiers came about, but I don’t see any logical reason to exclude other tiers at that point.

This makes the post almost seem like it’s contradicting itself, stating that “Ubers UU and NU were chosen for their historical inclusion in ADVPL, to avoid arbitrary decision making on tier inclusion”. If we want to discuss what is or isn’t arbitrary, we can call into question the idea of having tiers labeled as official (that’s right, we’re getting philosophical). If you want to look at this matter with any sense of objectivity, you should question what actually makes a tier official, because if it had anything to do with the pokemon that make up those tiers or the power levels, then RU would be official (or even UUBL by that logic, but I at least understand the thought process behind why that one isn’t official).

Also, I might be reading too much into things here, but the OP literally puts “official” in quotation marks under the ADVPL and ADVLTL section. It’s like these people know that a tier being “official” doesn’t practically mean anything. Strange

If you go by when exactly those tiers came into existence, then Ubers/OU/UU/NU definitely predate the other tiers, but NU and PU have been featured in teamtours for similar amounts of time anyway. After a bit of research, it seems ADV NU was first featured in a teamtour in NUPL 2016, whereas ADV PU’s first team tour was PUPL… 2017… that whole historical inclusion thing is holding up a bit less to me at this point.

The counterargument you’re likely thinking of at this point is that the actual historical inclusion nonsense is about the first two editions of ADVPL featuring only those tiers, then like… yeah? That is certainly true, but as more tiers got introduced into ADVPL over time (DOU in 2022, PU and LC in 2023-2026, and RU in 2024-2026), most players seemed to be fine with these changes. Scanning through ADVPL Format Discussion threads of years past, we see many cases of people saying the format was totally fine and didn’t need to be changed, or that only very minor changes were ideal to them. Of the limited amount of people I actually talk with on Smogon, none of those who have a vested interest in lower tiers and participated in ADVPL in any capacity said much, if anything, about needing to change the format.

I can’t fully speak to the managerial side of things, but it didn’t seem like there was an inherent struggle to field and prep a good lower tier lineup, especially from the perspective of my team (Degenerate Delibirds). It’s entirely possible that I’m advertising my lack of knowledge regarding how specifically the ADV playerbase felt about this year’s ADVPL, but given all of this context, I see no logical reason to change a format that most people were totally on board with.

Okay, sure, you wanted to cut down the number of OU slots in favor of increasing the average quality of OU games in the tour. I can’t speak to how much having five total OU slots affected that, but I at least understand where that sentiment comes from. What doesn’t make sense to me beyond arbitrary principle is the requirement of 50% of ADVPL’s slots being dedicated to OU. I see absolutely no reason that this specific metric is the case aside from sounding nice. To be clear, I have no problem with having a significant portion of [PREMIER LEAGUE]’s slots involving its respective current gen or OU metagame, but look at it this way: if we guarantee that OU gets four slots in next year’s ADVPL, the difference between four and six (or even eight but I understand that’s very ambitious) lower tier slots has no innate effect on the quality of those OU games. Does the (yet arbitrarily defined) prestige of ADVPL diminish due to greater inclusion of lower tiers? Honestly, I think you could make a solid case that the answer is yes, but I don’t know how exactly to make that case, and either way I don’t believe for a second that the prestige would diminish by very much, short of having like ten lower tier slots.

By the way, if we care so much about the “historical inclusion” of these tiers, why in the world is Draft in ADVPL? Yeah, I get that “It is also especially popular”, and Draft players are maybe louder than anyone else when it comes to getting their format into these tours, but you could have just as easily given that slot to another tier based on this criterion. To put it lightly, this feels selective, and plenty of other ADV tiers have just as dedicated followings as Draft (based on my experience with those tiers, I should make clear I am completely detached from Draft).

If having a break week to write PR’s while running the drafts is as major of a reason for its inclusion as the OP makes it out to be, then I must say I find it ridiculous that we are putting PR’s and that sort of content as such a high priority. We’re here to actually play the game, so that kind of stuff should be tertiary, maybe secondary matters compared to everything else. I may not be able to tierbash here (AND I’M NOT) but I can certainly PR-bash: I have never teamed with a single soul who’s seriously invested in PR’s and doesn’t help produce them. Maybe some of the spectators care a little about PR’s, and I highly doubt that number of people is as high as what the OP is written with in mind, but again, it feels like less focus on the game itself is being taken here.

I’m not calling for Draft to be removed from ADVPL, in fact I think it’s a fine addition to team tournaments, with DPPPL finding success including it in their format this year (even if Farc had to die for the cause…), but I just think if you’re going to include Draft in ADVPL despite your reasoning outlined elsewhere in the post, that should absolutely warrant at least two other unique lower tier slots.

going back to ou stuff…

SSPL, for example, has used a 12-slot format with 4 OU slots for the past two years, and I haven’t seen any major complaints about that from a significant amount of people. I’m really trying not to cross-reference generations here, but I think that’s a great example of how focusing on the number of OU slots rather than the percentage can still make for a great tournament.

Yes, I am aware “[t]he custom avatars of this subforum are meant to serve the ADV OU community”, but when an absolute bare minimum of 32 players will play OU in the next ADVPL, assuming we stick with four OU slots, that seems sufficient to me. Most other generation or tier premier leagues feature a similar number of slots for their current gen/OU metagame, and they seem to have no problem giving out custom avatars despite not meeting that 50% threshold. I don’t think you can tell me in good faith that ADV is particularly special such that the 50% rule has to apply to ADV but doesn’t have to for other subforums. Of course, I’m a lower tier player saying anything about OU, so I’ll be sure to take a drink for every haha react I get here as a result.

But seriously, with all of this context in mind, I have to ask:

the lower
Why does ADVLTL get a custom avatar exactly?

(if that question sounds a little out of context to you just read the last paragraph of the previous section)

Again, this just seems contradictory. I wouldn’t put it past myself to get too deep into semantics, but if these custom avatars are meant to “serve the ADV OU community”, then giving one to a lower tier tournament feels out of place. I have no issue giving a custom to ADVLTL; I think it’s a great tournament and people should be rewarded for their success in tiers like UUBL or ZU (yes ZU has other custom avatars but that’s not really the point I’m getting at anyway). I have issue with having your reason for changing ADVPL so drastically being derived from a custom avatar policy that falls apart when this tournament is considered. A player only interested in OU is not served by this in the slightest. If you’re going to move things around like that, I think a sounder reason is owed.

You could look at this with the idea that it’s a trade-off: ADVLTL gets a custom avatar, so ADVPL cuts down on lower tiers. Honestly, this is probably the most logical counterpoint to my criticisms here. With an even further projected increase in prestige of next year’s ADVLTL, we can more easily justify moving the higher-level competition in RU/PU/LC to that tournament. The people who play those tiers can still vie for a respectable prize, and ADVPL remains pure with only the most official tiers + Draft & Knuckles…

But it’s not like ADVPL was worse off for including those lower tiers. I wouldn’t say the prestige of winning ADVPL is much less, if at all, now compared to when it only featured Ubers/OU/UU/NU, especially given the amount of growth ADV has seen within the past few years. To me, it feels like trying to solve a problem that never existed in the first place, at least to most people.

However, I don’t find custom avatars nearly as interesting as the actual game, so let’s discuss the proposed format for ADVLTL. I think the idea of excluding Ubers/UU/NU due to their inclusion in ADVPL is very interesting, but this goes back to the issue of those tiers not having a negative effect on ADVLTL in the first place. Sure, cutting ADVLTL down to 10 slots does make things more difficult with deciding which of the many, many ADV lower tiers to include, but Ubers/UU/NU have at least just as dedicated playerbases as the other metagames competing for one of those slots.

I have outlined at the bottom of this post what would be my ideal tour formats for these tiers (without going totally scorched earth on ADVPL), but I think Ubers/UU/NU absolutely deserve a spot in ADVLTL. This would have what is potentially a drawback of reverting to the first ADVLTL format, and while I don’t have enough of a stake in the other tiers that would get snubbed as a result to say without bias, I don’t think this would be the end of the world.

On the subject of giving these metagames more chances to be played in team tournaments, I’d like to address a point made by THE_CHUNGLER regarding the quantity of games these tiers get. His post in particular stuck out to me due to how few other people were talking about that subject, and it’s a bit misrepresentative. His idea is that these tiers already get plenty of coverage in other team tournaments, but the way he cites them isn’t accurate.

“Ubers: UPL, UCL, UWC, UWL, ALTPL
UU: UUPL, UUCL, UUSRPG (or UUFPL), ALTPL
RU: RUPL, RUCL, RUWC, RUFL”

This is what I take issue with most because it inflates the apparent number of times these tiers get played. He mentions UWC and UWL for Ubers, but those tournaments have never both been run in the same year, as they both serve as the Winter team tournament for that subforum. Additionally, UCL uses a system similar to other farm leagues, restricting the amount of people that can play a given tier based on whether they played it in UPL so far that year. While this does let more people participate in team tournaments by playing those tiers, the quality of games does take a not insignificant hit, and while that’s not the biggest factor ever here, I think it should at least be considered if we’re going to look at this critically.

Same thing applies to RU, with RUCL and RUWC having never been held during the same year, and RUGL (not RUFL, a clear erratum) using the farm league system. UUSRPG and UUFPL also have no business being here, because neither tournament plays with standard ADV UU, allowing varying numbers of UUBL pokemon each year. Yes, these tiers get played in team tournaments year-round, but ADV subforum tours are a major contributor to that, and removing some of the more important tournaments for those tiers is a step backwards in my opinion.

the idea
For as much griping as I’ve done about these proposed changes, the whole point of this post and this thread is to be solution-oriented, so here are each of the tournaments (that I’ve discussed) in formats that I think are perfectly reasonable and improvements on what the OP suggests:

ADV Slam: keep unchanged, or maaaayyyyyybe get rid of ZU and/or LC if you deem such action absolutely necessary (which personally I don’t)

ADVPL: Ubers/OU Bo3/OU*3/UU/NU/Draft/Two of (RU/PU/LC, yes im aware making this choice will get one playerbase really mad)

ADVLTL: Ubers/UUBL/UU/RU/NU/PU/ZU/LC/DOU/ORRE

if you want to further discuss these matters with me my discord is moochem please friend request me and dm me there

thank you for reading
 
Last edited:
Thoughts

ADV Slam​


-If the main focus of ADV slam is to just reward/crown the best ADV generalist then the proposed idea is fine since it is in line with that thinking. I'm sympathetic to the LTs losing a dedicated tour tho, which I'll touch on for ADVPL and ADVLTL
-No Johns for ADV last chance is fine but it should def run the full week. 4 day weeks = employed folks + students that care about their academics got 0 shot

ADVPL + ADVLTL

-For ADVPL: 8 slots is low for a tour with a community that is this active and full of talent. 10 slots would be more reasonable if we are cutting, but IMO 12 was fine. 10 allows for one of RU/PU/LC to be retained along with the addition of adv draft: I'd personally prefer RU but we should just see what the overall ADV community favors. I don't see going back to the basics as an improvement--we've come a long way from those days, Blissey is #1 on (some) VRs now. Would put it like this: Keep current format>Cut to 10>>>>>>>Cut to 8

-For ADVLTL, keep it as it is tbh it was great this year. If we must cut formats for the sake of a CA (I am a little confused on this, I don't think there is a need to go to 10 slots) then drop 2 of Ubers/UU/NU and keep everything else as is but honestly if it ain't broke then don't fix it.
-1v1 and randbats were fun and competitive inclusions that have their own mainers: rands in particular had xgang + drifttrick who ended up having the best records in ADVLTL2 at 5-1 each. The format has its BS moments here and there with team gen but I don't see that as any different then getting c-teamed in a tier and crying about MU afterwards.


​

 
Hi, I'm not very involved in any ADV tier bar RU but I really enjoy playing the generation so I'm interested to tune into this thread. Keep in mind that I mostly speak as an RU player here.

It has been mentioned countless times in this thread already so it's probably as worth as a grain of salt, but it goes without saying that ADV Slam should remain the same to me.
I'm one of those people who just enjoy playing one single tier, as in if I can just play ADV RU best of threes every now and then without having to pay attention to tiers I have zero experience/interest/skill in, then I'm perfectly fine with it, and I'm pretty sure most people from other tiers think this way too. I really don't like the idea of having to play best-of-fives both before and during the playoffs stage, one should remain "free" to sign up for whatever cup they want to play in instead of being "forced" to play five to six tiers in which they may have little to zero knowledge. If you wanna sign up for all tiers because you're aiming for a playoffs spot or you simply just like all of them, then do it. If you only know about PU, NU or LC with or without any goal in mind, then you should be free to sign up for the said tiers only. It should never be forced and Slam was always made this way in any generation.

But even let alone the personal preference, I also think that the BO5 format would probably be less competitive than the standard separated cups, BO3 one? Not sure how to explain, but something about winning a chain of BO5s from the start to the end instead of playing several BO3s of several tiers through several rounds sounds... less rewarding of skill probably? I don't know.

===​

I have played both ADVPL and ADVLTL but I don't really have a strong opinion on what's being decided for those, tiers speaking as well as "number of slots" speaking.
I will say though, if we aim for the changes that are suggested in the OP, I'm lowkey afraid for the few lower tiers slots remaining that they end up being quite isolated for next year's ADV PL. I cannot speak for any other team, but my ADV PL team felt way easier to work in and prep for than any other tours with a majority of OU slots I've ever played in. While our tiers are definitely different, it really made me feel more confident to have a lot of lower tier players around me mixed with the OU ones, none of us ever felt like we were playing some mystery nonsensical metagame created by a bunch of weirdos in isolated plains, which is usually what happens for many people in OU tours.


Unrelated, but I agree with Aurist that we probably don't need yet another custom avatar prize for ADV LTL. Let alone that there's already three tons of them across the whole site, I'm not sure how helpful it will be to a tournament that was already pretty successful without even having one.
 
Going to provide an update for this:

ADV Slam:
We will be keeping the same format from last year. The tournament will start October 11th.

ADV Last Chance:
We will be keeping the No Johns format this year, and monitor the turnout and other factors while deciding what to do next year. The tournament will start October 11th.

ADVLTL:
The new plan is to run the same format as this year (12 slots with the same tiers) after the overwhelming positive feedback and defense for basically every tier in the tournament.

Ultimately the big question is whether the community wants a custom avatar for this tournament, and it seems fairly split (in large part because of the changes to ADVPL that MUST happen in order to provide this tournament with a custom avatar). Please weigh in if you have further opinions; we do have quite a while until ADVPL so it isn't urgent.

ADVPL:
The new plan is that this tournament will have 10 slots. We will be keeping the same 8 in the OP, including Draft.

The 2 remaining slots depend on how the ADVLTL discussion goes. If ADVLTL has a custom avatar, we will add a 5th OU slot and one of the lower tiers back guaranteed. If ADVLTL does not have a custom avatar, the last slots will likely be 2 of the lower tiers, though a 5th OU is not impossible.

We'd like to hear more feedback about all of the above; thank you everyone for chipping in opinions so far.
 
Keeping this one shorter because it's a pretty simple stance: if ADVLTL having a custom absolutely requires 50% OU slots in ADVPL (which I still think is asinine but I've already made that point), then I'm completely fine with removing ADVLTL's custom avatar prize.

From what I read, most, if not all people who commented on the quality of games resulting in five total OU slots suggested cutting back on that number, so in the interest of the actual game, removing the custom avatar prize from ADVLTL is sensible enough to me. This also makes the prospect of "we won't give ADVLTL a custom avatar on the premise that ADVPL won't have 5/10 slots be OU, but sike that was a false premise 5/10 slots are now OU" really funny to me in the worst way possible.

This year proved that tournament could be a great success regardless of the prize (reminder, there was originally no planned prize before the end of the tournament and people were still locking in). We're here to play the game, and I don't necessarily want to speak on the behalf of others, but the playerbase can absolutely get over a team tournament not having a custom avatar prize.

I know I said in my original post that I wanted ADV UUBL/ZU/whatever other tier that isn’t in ADVPL players to be rewarded for their skill in those tiers, but admittedly the lack of clarity in what exactly I meant was one of my bigger regrets with how thay post turned out. I certainly wouldnt mind ADVLTL getting a custom, but I'm more ambivalent to the matter than I originally let on, that's my mistake (and I was too lazy to edit the post).

TL;DR in the interest of the actual game, if ADV is holding itself to these restrictions, then just don't give a custom avatar to ADVLTL
 
Last edited:
Regardless of what changes with ADVPL, I am supportive of ADVLTL keeping the same format and adding a CA prize. As the creator of that tournament, it would be really cool to see that its success lead to the addition of a CA. I don’t agree with the notion that since it’s been successful without a prize, we should just keep it as is.

That said, this is only if 12 slots are to be maintained because the community aspect of bringing all these tiers and players together is much more important than a prize. I also acknowledge that including a prize may result in some players missing their chance to play in the tournament due to attracting bigger names but I think it’s overall a better choice for the tournament. Keeps community together and increases skill ceiling.
 
I think making ADVPL 50% OU kind of kills the identity of the tour without much (if any) benefit. To my understanding, 5 OU's was a pain to prep, and keeping the amount of OU slots in ADVPL the same with fewer places for tournament players to go barely sounds like a consolation prize for World Cup not having a CA to me.

While this next part is entirely my own opinion, I'm speaking as someone who really enjoys the tiers on the fringe of being eligible for ADVPL like RU, PU, LC, and ZU, and removing these tiers from ADVPL but giving a CA to ADVLTL feels like a slap in the face. I understand that there is no active malice behind the decision and it is made entirely within good faith trying to promote all of these formats equally while placing more emphasis on ADVLTL, but it can kind of feel like we're being kicked out of the main event but being given a side event as compensation.

Additionally, cutting LC and PU feels especially weird since those tiers have been in ADVPL for the past 3 editions and were added at the same time as the Bo3 OU slot. With LC in particular the idea of cutting it from LCPL occasionally gets floated and a big component of the argument for that has been that ADVPL gets a comparable, if not better turnout from the top players of the pool.

Imo the ideal format for ADVPL is probably just the format from ADVPL V but with Draft over RU if Draft is being included with a 100% guarantee. 3x OU Bo1, 1x OU bo3, 1x Ubers. UU, NU, PU, LC, Draft
 
Status
Not open for further replies.
Back
Top