• Follow our Instagram!
  • Curious about what we're currently doing about bots? Check out the latest updates from staff in this thread.

SPOILERS! General Pokémon Anime Discussion

Ash should have gotten Mega Diancie in Kalos instead of that Greninja form thing. Diancie was at that time the only Gen 6 mon that could have mega evolved and would have been his first fairy-type. Speaking of gender discussions this would have also allowed Ash to train a more "girly" mon, which I presume is required if you want to become a Pokemon master.

Diancie could have gone in place of one of his three flying types so Greninja could stay as well.

It could have had its own arc, with Ash catching it as a Carbink earlier on and suspecting nothing, but then it would be mutated into a Diancie by Team Flare or something and eventually mega evolve in a bonding moment with Ash before beating Team Flare, then being used against Wulfric and in the Kalos league.
 
Last edited:
I always said type-specialists like Misty and Iris should feel bad Ash had stronger water and dragon types than they did. For example:

Ash's water types: Greninja, Squirtle, Corphish, Buizel, Kingler, Lapras (although released), Palpitoad, Totodile, Oshawott.

Ash's dragon types: Dragonite, Dracovish, Noivern, Goodra, Gible.

Ash's water Pokemon were stronger than all of Misty's water pokemon, with the only weak links being Totodile and Oshawott. I mean Ash's Greninja is arguably the strongest non-legendary water pokemon in the anime. Outside of Misty's Mega Gyarados, none of her pokemon really come close. Hell, Ash's Squirtle, Buizel and Corphish alone would likely beat the rest of Misty's team easily, only having a bit of a tough time with Gyarados.

For Iris, Ash already beat her Haxorus/Dragonite in JN, but assuming Iris got stronger by the Master Class time, Ash would still have a slight leg up due to using two pokemon he beat Leon with.

Like with Ash as a main character...doesn't it kind of screw over Misty and Iris since Ash's Pokemon inevitably wind up being stronger while they were companions?
 
precita said:
I always said type-specialists like Misty and Iris should feel bad Ash had stronger water and dragon types than they did. For example:

Ash's water types: Greninja, Squirtle, Corphish, Buizel, Kingler, Lapras (although released), Palpitoad, Totodile, Oshawott.

Ash's dragon types: Dragonite, Dracovish, Noivern, Goodra, Gible.

Ash's water Pokemon were stronger than all of Misty's water pokemon, with the only weak links being Totodile and Oshawott. I mean Ash's Greninja is arguably the strongest non-legendary water pokemon in the anime. Outside of Misty's Mega Gyarados, none of her pokemon really come close. Hell, Ash's Squirtle, Buizel and Corphish alone would likely beat the rest of Misty's team easily, only having a bit of a tough time with Gyarados.

For Iris, Ash already beat her Haxorus/Dragonite in JN, but assuming Iris got stronger by the Master Class time, Ash would still have a slight leg up due to using two pokemon he beat Leon with.

Like with Ash as a main character...doesn't it kind of screw over Misty and Iris since Ash's Pokemon inevitably wind up being stronger while they were companions?

Who says being a Type Specialist means you should have the strongest Pokemon of that Type?

Sure, Ash may have the stronger Water- and Dragon-type Pokemon, but if those Pokemon for some reason were not feeling well who would be better at diagnosing and remedying what's wrong with them?
Who would be able to spot potential physical issues or notice strange behavior atypical of that Species/Type of Pokemon?
Who would know what is the best diet, medicine, exercise, play, and Circadian Rhythm that Pokemon should be on?
Who would know how and under what conditions would be the best to train these Pokemon to better understand & extend their physical limitations and master their powers & skills?

As a trainer focused on battling to strengthening himself & his Pokemon's body & bond, Ash would naturally have an edge in Pokemon battles even against a Type Specialist as he has specialized in utilizing his Pokemon's capabilities to adapt & come up with strategies to achieve victory.

But Type Specialists, while there are those who take up battling roles such as a League Trainer or member of another group, are expected to have a deeper connection with Pokemon of their Type. And not just the Pokemon they own, but of all Pokemon of that Type, from Wild to another Trainer's. The League Trainers also take up a role as a pillar of their community, as an official that can be approached about a Pokemon situation (especially of their Type Specialty) and to take action to resolve.

If there's a lake where aquatic Pokemon have suddenly started attacking each other, Ash wouldn't know what to do. Ash would probably get in the middle of the conflict, tell everyone they should be friends... and then be blasted back to shore via streams of Water Gun so the Pokemon can get back to fighting. Meanwhile Misty would immediately recognize the species of Pokemon fighting and whether its a free-for-all or if there are sides. Then she'd dive into the lake to take a look around, seeing if there's something off that is causing the aquatic Pokemon to start fighting. Is this a fight over territory or resources? Did one Pokemon or group wrong another that built up into a conflict/war? Could it be one Pokemon/side is actually protecting something/someone? Whatever it is Misty would be much more capable in figuring out and resolving it than Ash.

If there's a Dragon-type Pokemon going on a rampage, sure Ash could send out his Pokemon to battle it, but that's not going to solve the core issue of why its angry (infact it might just make it angrier and less likely to calm down/cooperate). Iris however has a special connection with Dragon-type Pokemon, able to listen to their "hearts" and form an immediate connection. Even if she can't fully calm it down, through presence alone the Dragon Pokemon knows it can trust her and likely to lead her to what is bothering it. This is a trait which Iris innately has which Ash doesn't, just how it is but its the reason Iris would be more suitable in resolving this rampage for good.

Ash is a capable trainer able to bring out the strength of his Pokemon, but there are many more knowledgeable and wiser trainers than him in ways he'll never have. But that's alright, as Ash knows by now, being a Pokemon Master doesn't mean you need to know everything about Pokemon; there's plenty of room for Type Specialists to help people better understand and form bonds with Pokemon of all Types.
 
Last edited:
Ash also isn't really about becoming the strongest for the sake of becoming the strongest to begin with. Even though battling is his personal language (and catching is Goh's ftr), it's more a way to connect with Pokémon and understand them. He outright said at the end of his show that being the strongest Trainer in sheer battle prowess and strength isn't everything to him, and to him, being a Pokémon Master means to befriend and connect with Pokémon.

He's been very transparent about that throughout his tenure in the show, and adding to that, he's happy to be a best friend not just to his Pokémon but to other Trainers. The very last person he travelled with was Goh, who was more like a ride-or-die bestie and partner to him than a mere companion, and Ash took more of a backseat in Journeys and SM than in previous seasons because he was more than happy to witness the growth of Goh in Journeys (and in SM his entire friend group), a friend he came to cherish deeply, and see him flourish as a Trainer and connect with Pokémon in his own way on his own path. He doesn't see his friends as people to compete with but people to support and root for, and who he acknowledges have their own strengths that he doesn't and can be great Trainers in their own rights. Misty and Iris being type specialists is one example in that they understand Pokémon of those types at a much deeper level than he does. To him, it's not really about himself; it's about how much he loves and cares for others, Pokémon and Trainers alike.

There's a pretty good reason why hardcore battling took a backseat after XYZ in that regard, imo. SM and Journeys were really much more about connections and relationships, and Ash learning to connect with Pokémon and Trainers in various contexts and in new ways.

And that carried over into Horizons and Liko's story; her whole thing is about understanding and connecting with Pokémon, and that also means connecting with them in ways that aren't just battling. She's got a pretty small and concentrated squad but aside from good ol' Meowscarada, she has one very battle-oriented Pokémon who fights to protect (Armarouge) and one healer who understands the feelings of others at a deep level (Hatterene), which highlights her adaptability with her strength and compassion and the ability to work with and raise different kinds of Pokémon alongside her own drive to connect and protect. And that was also hammered in by the villain Liko and her friends defeated being someone who was utterly obsessed with power and knee-deep in distrust, who convinced himself the Trainer's only job is to increase the raw strength of the Pokémon and in the end lost everything, including the one Pokémon friend he had.

The throughline of the show's protagonists thus far in that regard isn't so much about raw battling prowess but an ability to connect with others. Not just their own Pokémon and an adaptable ability to bring out the best in them but an ability to understand other Trainers and be supportive of their own strengths. It shows when the seasons from SM onwards have been much more ensemble-centric than before, and Ash and Liko have both shared the role of protagonist with someone like Goh and Roy respectively in the latest series, and the show also runs on the two having a complementary partnership rather than just one person alone and their own path. The show has always been about the bonds between Pokémon and their Trainers, and connection is the core of this franchise as a whole.
 
Back
Top