• Follow our Instagram!
  • Curious about what we're currently doing about bots? Check out the latest updates from staff in this thread.

Announcement Roaring Moon Retest — Qualified Discussion

On a merely a priori basis, one would expect Roaring Moon to be insanely broken. It's a testament to how strong this stupid thing is that its most commonly cited "weakness" is its 105/71 physical bulk (making it naturally bulkier than Clefable). Since it cleanly lives a +1 adamant Tera Normal Dnite Espeed without any bulk investment, I'm not counting that as a genuine weakness.

Roaring Moon's virtues for a team are immense: the fastest booster energy user in the game, massive damage potential, considerable set variety (including tera type), strong utility/breaking moves in knock and taunt, recovery, and a statline second only to Zamazenta as far as OU mons go. Thus, there's plenty of fair reasons to be concerned about Moon, and I was pretty staunchly opposed to letting it back into the tier long before the suspect test was announced. I believed that Moon's return would pretty much kill balance as a viable playstyle, adding yet another dangerous breaking threat and wincon that would be impossible to wall in combination with the tier's other insane balance killers like Kyurem, Ceru, and Woger. Yes, balance has tools to deal with Moon in defensive Dnite, Moltres, Skarm and Corv, and even rarer picks like Mandi and Dondozo. But would balance structures be able to bear the total load of all of those breakers combined?

All of that being said, we need to go off of empirical data before rendering any decisive judgments on Moon. So in practice, does it actually kill balance? I noticed that a lot of the structures I tend to build really struggle into the Moon meta – not just Moon itself, but the entire ecosystem it creates. In fact, during my suspect laddering run, I noticed that hardly any teams I faced were of any archetype outside of offense, either, making midladder especially feel like a homogenous slog. I will grant that when an offensive mon is reintroduced to the tier, it's not surprising that players will gravitate toward offense to slot the new toy. I will also grant that I saw more variety in my last day of laddering, including two stall teams. Nonetheless, I was shocked to see classic meta staple structures like Ghold-Lu-Dnite seemingly abandoned in favor of near constant offenseslop.

For my suspects run, I wanted to build a balance team that would be able to defensively handle Moon well. The team I ended up earning reqs with is admittedly rather strange, but handles most meta threats fairly well. For the Moon matchup, fully physdef rocky helm Lu with rest and body press trades into pre-Tera Moon, while unaware Dirge can also trade Teras to wall it if necessary. Blissey's heal bell makes Lu reliable enough to potentially trade into several mons in a single game, while also making Rillaboom's knock off less of a risk into Moltres and Zapdos. The six mons together form a strong enough breaking core that I was able to beat an Amoongus stall as my final game to achieve reqs.

Back to Moon, though. Is this thing too broken to allow in OU? I do think that the tier would survive a Roaring Moon meta, but balance will suffer. Yet I also think that it will find ways to adapt. Storm Zone already posted a number of balance teams in the metagame discussion thread that he says work well into Moon, and those are all more conventional than the team I created. It seems that Skarm/Molt/Corv paired with appropriate priority moves to handle matchup-flipping teras (like body press helm Skarm paired with Bolt thunderclap and Weavile ice shard for the tera flying flip) is looking promising. I think my team also shows the value of grassy terrain for dealing with earthquake sets.

Altogether, I don't think Roaring Moon is quite as bad as I expected. There are legitimate trade-offs in each Moon set choice. On one hand, the set variety provides an epistemic advantage to Moon users, but no single set can do everything. In this respect, it resembles many of OU's top tier mons that I would call ultimately balanced, including Woger, Dnite, Zama, and Kyurem. However, I still have strong doubts about this thing's benefits to the tier, besides dampening the strength of the annoying Cresselia. I'm currently leaning in the direction of Do Not Unban.
 
There's already been a ton of discussion on whether :roaring-moon: is too broken/fishy/centralizing here so I wanna tackle this from a different angle. Let me preface this with the fact I am currently voting DO NOT UNBAN, but I am presenting this neutrally and am open to changing my mind.

The most obvious victims of RMoon are :cresselia:/:Ceruledge: which are both pokemon that can rot in hell. RMoon also brutalizes pretty much all of our current defensive structures with taunt, and still plenty without. The other key pokemon which suffer from RMoon's reintroduction sire clod and raffe touched upon are offense pokemon like :Zamazenta:/:ogerpon-wellspring:/:gholdengo:/:Darkrai:/:kingambit:. So rather than discuss about RMoon itself, lets theorize about how the tier will respond?

Stall/Balance in their current iterations are not making it in a RMoon meta. I don't think they're going to be unviable, but they have to adapt pretty wildly around RMoon. Offense is the most interesting to discuss; while lots of key pokemon are worse in a moon meta, it also gets to use moon which leads to an interesting dynamic. The types of Offense pokemon that get nerfed by RMoon is "(Somewhat) Bulky and Immediately powerful" that just click attacks, while the styles RMoon is best on are more one dimensional, aiming to end the game in one sweep/on matchup like Screens/HO/Sun. The sun discussion especially is an encapsulation of this, giving sun another broken tool that is checked by enemy RMoons.

I think it's safe to say reintroducing moon pushes styles to their extremities with balances getting fatter and offense getting further streamlined. That's not the kind of meta I really am looking forward to. While Offense is probably a bit too powerful right now, redistributing that power to teams trying to gun for that one boost which cleans house seems distastful as well (like :dragonite: isn't enough already). There's also a real possibility the already struggling balance simply doesn't have the sauce to fully adapt and ends up further outclassed by Offense. It's for these reasons I am currently still DNU.


Oh and as for the team I used to get reps? Take a wild guess lol
 
Last edited:
ok after a lot of struggle and games I finally got there after stealing the right sz teams also this took too long cuz I was grinding for that pirate token (still don't have it)
uF-_o3Au_BAJ9WxvOuH3hw.png

I didn't use moon too much myself but by the end of reqs I was fighting it just about every single game and I really do think it's fine. I'm pretty awful at explaining my thoughts but here's about how I feel:

Basically every time I fought it I could go into ting, or garg, or gweez, or clef, or a metal bird and somewhat comfortably hold it off, and if ting can whirlwind it out then that's even better. I will say that clef and metal birds seem like slightly shakier counterplay, with how much acro/eq and knock does to them respectively, and I can imagine a sequence of events where moon overpowers them (but I never saw that happen cuz they just get to +1 and keep clicking attacks)

If it's booster attack then you can position into something like weavile and outspeed and kill it outright, looking at the speed tiers I also see zama/pult/meow? raw above this speed range, to say nothing of scarfers/boosters. And yes moon is the fastest booster energy user but if even booster attack struggled to get through all that stuff then booster speed is doing even worse. Weavile especially was my mvp because ice shard really scares the hell out of moon.

Subjectively speaking I actually had a lot of fun playing this meta, and I feel like moon is about as explored as it can be (unless someone wants to bust out jaw lock again). Compared to how I felt playing this meta a few weeks ago it just felt a lot more interesting and dynamic. I want to read more thoughts but at this point I'd support unban
 
I was bored so I decided to get reqs , will be voting to keep moon banned and I encourage others to do so aswell. The last thing an offense heavy meta needs is another setup sweeper. It's still just as strong and broken as it was back when it got banned , tera blast ban is not enough to justify it in the tier (fairy blast wasn't even its best set fr). Most people who want it back in the tier are offense mains or are just bored of the meta which is lowk fair but it's definitely not the right way to move forward.

I think the meta rn is pretty decent , most playstyles are usable id love to see a kyurem resuspect tho that guy is crazy
 
Last edited:
I don’t usually write down my thoughts, but I think it’s necessary in this situation.

As fun as it is to set up and dish out absurd amounts of damage, realistically speaking, Roaring Moon is not what SV needs right now.

In my opinion, SV’s biggest issue is power creep, which makes it increasingly difficult to build consistent teams without having to fish for favorable matchups. In other words, you end up thinking: “This team is good, but it gets absolutely destroyed by X Pokémon.”


Offense is in a very good spot right now. The lack of knowledge regarding certain sets, combined with the sheer amount of damage these Pokémon can do, plays a huge role in the success of these teams. Scouting isn’t always an option, as in many cases, you’ll end up taking too much damage before you can even make a meaningful move in return.

On top of that, some revenge killers and other anti-offense options become significantly less viable when you consider that these Pokémon can also run bulky sets under screens (light clay may need a suspect imo btw) , making them much harder to take down.

Overall, I think this would hurt balance and BO teams the most. These archetypes already have a hard time dealing with the current threats in the tier, and adding yet another one to the mix would only make things worse.

I’d encourage everyone to consider what’s healthiest for the tier and try to get reqs so their voices can have a much more diverse opinion. But I encourage people to vote KEEP BANNED

I tried out several teams, but ultimately ended up using this one. S/O to Storm Zone:
https://pokepast.es/488ec02fa15e9793
 
Last edited:
Hey guys, just wanted to say that this is my first time getting reqs, so bare with me. I have a lot of thoughts.

I wanted to start off by saying that it was an absolute blast to use Roaring moon. Very chaotic, very powerful and clicking knock off felt more satisfying then ever since it actually deals damage unlike most knockers in the tier. That being said though, I really don't think RM adds anything positive to the tier. The pro-unban side doesn't have very convincing arguments. It's either "RM isn't that broken lol" or "RM counters Ceru and Cress slop". How in the world can a mon that has amazing stats, a very good offensive typing and also have access to very good set-up, reliable recovery and having one of the best moves in the game (knock off) be seen as not that broken?

Assuming RM is max speed adamant, there are only THREE mons that can outpace it. Those being: scarf Darkrai, scarf Meowscarada and booster speed Boulder. These sets (and the latter 2 of the 3) are basically almost never seen. Sure, if it isn't max speed your booster speed Ival could potentially encore it, but counterplay is quite limited. Priority is also not really a weakness. RM naturally resists almost every form of priority in the tier. And the ones it doesn't, it pretty much survives. I will say that Kyurem and Weavile have been the most consistent moon answers, Kyurem can most likely survive a hit and threaten massive damage, and Weavile naturally outpacing it barring no set up can pretty much KO moon in most cases.

The reason why these two have been the most consistent is because I basically have not seen any defensive tera type useage whenever I faced moon. It was always either tera flying or ground, which ice hits still hits for super effective damage. Tusk can be decent, although tera flying acro destroys it. Another issue I found was that it was simply just way too easy to set up on too many things, and I got away with stuff I shouldn't have gotten away with mainly thanks to RM's disgusting bulk. It's either: A mon hard counters RM, a mon "checks" RM but can be easily overwhelmed with the right set, or you're simply just fodder to set up on. What's even more ludicrous is the fact that all 3 of these categories have 1 thing in common: they can just be knocked off. Whenever I enter RM onto the field, it always managed to get value. It doesn't matter how small it was, even being able to knock off one thing will always be valuable. So RM has egregious bulk, good speed, coverage, borderline broken firepower and it will always get value no matter what.

One final thing that I wanted to touch upon: the mons that counter or somewhat check RM can't just be slapped on every team. Dozo, (unaware) Clef, Mandi, Ting Mobile, Lokix and potentially the birds too can really only be fit on bulky balances or stall. Do you see where this is going? RM just reinforces the exact same problems all other sweeper and breakers put onto the tier. And we absolutely do not need any more of that in the tier, especially considering how powerful Roaring moon is compared to a lot of other sweepers/breakers. Taking all of these things into consideration, I will happily (but also sadly, because it is genuinely very fun to use) banish RM once again. And I hope others will do the same. Thanks for reading this wall of text lol.
 
vk said:
I was bored so I decided to get reqs , will be voting to keep moon banned and I encourage others to do so aswell. The last thing an offense heavy meta needs is another setup sweeper. It's still just as strong and broken as it was back when it got banned , tera blast ban is not enough to justify it in the tier (fairy blast wasn't even its best set fr). Most people who want it back in the tier are offense mains or are just bored of the meta which is lowk fair but it's definitely not the right way to move forward.

I think the meta rn is pretty decent , most playstyles are usable id love to see a kyurem resuspect tho that guy is crazy
Pretty much agree w/ most of this post (and other posts supporting to keep RM banned).

After playing on my reqs account (and some sporadic games like a week ago asw on an older account) I don't really see any benefit RM actually adds to the meta currently that can't be flipped around and used as an argument against it. The defensive typing and speed tier helps vs guys like wellspring and ceru, but those teams can also just as easily run their own RM which overloads the actual checks to those mons (stuff like corv for wellspring or zama/tusk hp/tera for either of those), so it's hard for me to say the addition is purely positive from a defensive POV. Beyond that though I think the biggest issue is a combination of RM + other mons behind screens (granted, I think Clay should be banned regardless) which makes checking RM a massive headache both in the builder and in the game. The set variety can force weird interactions that generally benefit the RM side as well, such as when you're forced to use something like zama to check it, since realistically it's hard to gauge the set on preview in most cases, and it feels like a bit of a 50/50 in terms of clicking something like roar and risking taking a flying acro hit in base form, or tera'ing into something like fire or steel but then they end up clicking eq and you end up losing most/all of your zama's hp. That's not the only example of course but it's just the one I noticed a lot from playing, there's probably some better ones. It's not like stopping it from setting up is the easiest either, especially against bulky sets which feel super absurd to both use and play against, since you end up living a lot of hits you normally shouldn't, and can quickly snowball into a win. Counterplay definitely does exist but, in my opinion, I don't think its splashable or reliable enough for me to say in good faith that RM would be a balanced addition to the current meta (alongside feeling pretty unreasonable to answer consistently behind screens, which I already consider pretty broken) which is unfort because I actually think the mon is pretty fun to use. But yeah with all that said, I'll be voting to Keep Roaring Moon Banned.

Think if we want to look at metagame changes, personally I'd still look at a Light Clay suspect and a Solgaleo suspect, since I feel like either action passing would be a net positive for the tier atm.


Hope regardless of what people vote though we can see some more posts, they're always pretty interesting to read, and it's also always beneficial to the tier when people discuss their meta thoughts imo.

(sorry if the post is a bit sloppy or has some grammar issues/is hard to read, wrote it p quickly while bored and didn't bother double checking stuff)
 
Yo wsp chat, I never really write posts like this, but seeing people Suspect my boy Roaring Moon made me feel like I gotta do try it out . Voting to KEEP BANNED.
Playing on the ladder right now, balance and bulky offense teams are already out here fighting for their lives just trying to cover all the threats in SV. The power creep is already crazy enough as it is with all those Powerhouses sitting around. You try to build a solid six, load it up on sum calm, and still just auto-lose to random matchups because you can't possibly prep for everything which isnt enjoyable at all.
Throwing another nuclear threat like Moon back into the mix is just gonna completely deep fry those playstyles that are alr struggling.
Offense is already eating way too good. You don't even know what set they're running, and everything hits so hard that trying to scout just gets half your team wiped before you can even click a move back especially when it is adamant booster dd which js instawins a majority of Games.
Plus, when Moon can just run bulky spreads behind screens in :Ninetales-Alola: offense teams, revenge killers and anti-offense mons barely even work against it anymore.
Look, I get that clicking buttons, setting up, and blowing teams up is super fun, no doubt especially for the average gamer but you have to keep the whole Playerbase in mind with these decisions. But keeping it real, it’s just not what the meta needs right now there are other building stones we have to adress.
Everyone should definitely go grind for reqs so we get a good mix of opinions just really think about what’s actually healthy for the tier and keep this thing locked up.
For reference this is the team I used for making suspects : https://pokepast.es/fc48b22423d64e2f
A good chunk of my losses concluded in :roaring-moon: clicking dd and winning the game which is boring
x7JmzAeT_rix64nO1sfhOg.png
 
Last edited:
Hi all, I just got finished with my reqs and I'm seeing quite a bit of back and forth but it seems like moon will probably be banned. I can understand both arguments, but I sway to the side of DO NOT BAN. My reasoning for this is mainly that it didn't truly feel overwhelming in my time playing. This was my first reqs where I decided I would fully devote myself to the feature mon and use teams that only feature roaring moon and having used it the entire time, I can say it is definitely powerful but does not auto win the game like some of these posts suggest. I honestly think the reason it was so powerful was due to every other team on ladder being other screen moons or ho moons. The reason he feels so powerful is because no other team is trying to solve the moon problem, the distinct lack of tera normal espeed dnite, tera bug lokix, and tera steel scizor was astounding. Even Iron Valiant was pretty easy to position into opposing moon, I never found it too troubling to either play around it getting a dd up or playing around it to avoid it getting a dd. It is easy to sweep with moon when nobody is building to stop it. When I did run into a team that had roaring moon in mind when building, it was SO much harder for it to do anything. It would almost always result in wasting booster to get a knock off and then being forced to switch or maybe trade 1 for 1 if you're lucky. A lot of teams that I saw getting reqs here don't even have moon on it (this itself doesn't mean moon isn't broken, but if it is THAT broken that it needs definitive banning, why isn't it on every team?) If more counterplay is implemented, I think the threat of moon would be neutered. Towards the end of my reqs run, outside of the 1300-1550's where moon can absolutely crush every game, it felt pretty mediocre. If anything, moon is being hard carried by screens which allow for the bulkier sets to function properly. Despite this test being about roaring moon, I left feeling like more like screens are the bigger issue and that we should run a light clay test in its place. Without a reflect up, moon is getting blown up by the 3 aforementioned anti offense threats and dnite was running around on basically every team before this test. I also think above moon being broken, most people don't want another physically offensive breaker to pair all of the other ones with, but I don't believe that's a fair metric to go by. If moon was in the tier and wellspring was being retested, would that argument hold? Maybe I'm thinking about it wrong, but in my eyes it just doesn't. Ultimately, I think moon should stay and light clay should be banned, and I'd like to see more people get creative in the builder. I don't say this as "cope" for trying to keep moon, I mean it as there are clear ways to adapt to it and offense itself. And I won't take "moon is skill-less" as an argument either, we have wellspring around still. Seeing psy fangs and brick break (even if it was mainly on moon) was really refreshing and shoutout to the 1 guy I ran into running scarf brick break lando. Also shoutout to waffle04 who I haxed crazy style for my last game to get reqs.

Edit: adding cuz I forgot but legit even helm lando can be a check to this thing, very easy to add to an offense team if you’re scared of moon
 
Last edited:
I've had a long time to collect my thoughts on this suspect, since it was announced long before it even went up, before i say anything, i wanna address some stuff, for one, back when moon was in the tier, it was the pokemon i hated the most, thats just my personal bias, my friends would hear me complain about roaring for the longest while, and even still, i put my own sentiments aside and defended both sides and let people think for themselves, but that was due to me not knowing what a moonless meta would look like, now i do, having a suspect for something that was in ou before, and in ubers, is easier to have a perspective on than something that has only been ou, now, again, i still hate the mon, but id be lying if i sat here, looked at the tier fairly and said it was broken, so before i get into my argument, before anyone says "i thought u hated it", im completely burying my own personal sentiment here for a fair assessment(if i was being biased, yes, still hate moon), but i am still setting aside my personal feelings toward the mon, something many dont have the ability to do during suspects evidently.

Now, this thread is strictly supposed to be about moon so im gonna keep it that way, i just had to state what i said above so i dont get called a hypocrite or get quoted, let me get into the arguments:

- Moon is very strong, im not denying that at all to be very clear, but sometimes a pokemon adds to a meta indirectly, u gotta ask urself, did not having roaring around enable too much cheese? Screens deoxys was more popular than ever in moonless meta, psyspam tr was here and there, look at the olt trends, bolt, ogerpon zamazenta gambit, cresselia cheese everywhere, screens deoxys, and protect stall, theres too much variety, but roaring can limit that variety, because the more threats that get banned to ubers, the higher the variance because strong teams/styles that pokemon was restricting here, which is quite a bit, is now free to be explored and experimented with, which leads to more and more broken trends arising, and as long as we have tera it will never stop increasing variance, this is why im so critical when a suspect happens, i rarely take the ban side because i know the variance will increase and new stuff will step up, wellspring will be stronger and so will kyurem, moon gone buffs bolt too, and kingambit bc they no longer have to tera into a type that beats moon.

- "Moon invalidates balance" , no it does not, and i think what im about to say is more relevant to the suspect than anything else, all ive been spamming on the ladder recently, are balance teams and psyspam, teams that people say moon would typically beat, and ive been winning consistently with said balance teams, i made a big post on how i was exploring balance, both in moon meta and moonless meta, and there was not much adjustment to be made with moon's arrival, arguably those balance teams got even better with moon around, psyspam has been winning more aswell, what im attempting to do here is laddering with styles people generally think moon would restrict to see how much moon really strains these styles, and its not alot at all.

- Some of my friends who were nice enough to give me arguments for why moon is good for the meta, and the people that used valid arguments to convince me that moon was not broken, i.e. hellom vk and many others, (i have logs btw i screenshot EVERYTHING), have now completely changed their minds on the mon and are posting "do not unban" posts, which is strange, because again, they were the ones that convinced me that moon was okay. Truly a "i want this till i get it now im realising i cant handle it, i was wrong about it" moment, and thats okay. Let me say something about this, nobody, not a single soul has more experience in the meta or in the builder for that matter than me, i build as a hobby it relieves my stress, so i of all people would feel a strain in the builder when a mon is broken, the bigger the strain the more broken the mon, ive felt a bigger strain for a select few pokemon than i have moon, ive played 500+ games both in moon and moonless meta, and i just wanna say, in the moonless meta, with the higher variance since people dont have to worry about moon, some cheesy styles feel uninteractive to play against, and you have no way to measure how good a team is if thats what you are testing against, with the moon meta, im playing vs a good team every game, and old friends i teambuild with dating back to gens 6/7/8, who were very technical in the builder, have come back to build and play again with moon around , i.e. Iodyne , so its not that "moon is restricting this or that, as a result, ban it, is it hitting a sweet spot where its restricting just enough to keep lots of variety and promote mons that ive proven in tour performances were good without moon around, i.e. scizor/weavile/clefable/skarm, and make them better, and allow for new styles to arise and new innovations, while keeping out un interactive styles, promoting a more interactive skill based meta, ive been under the belief that, if it requires more skill to limit a mon than it requires to beat an uninteractive style, that uninteractive style has no precedent over the mon, and therefore the mon staying to invalidate it actually raises the skill floor. lax talked about this briefly, part of the skill in sv was limiting the moon. If we were tiering for casuals, chi yu and chien pao would still be ou, we are tiering for a tournament setting, the higher the skill floor, the better the meta, broken checks broken will always exist if this gen's mechanic is around so u cannot lump my post into the broken checks broken category. My argument here is, the metagame with roaring, feels more interactive and skill based than a meta without it, im not saying its not strong, its one of the strongest mons in the meta, but it aint the top dog, and it certainly adds to the meta given the argument im presenting here.

- Splashable knock off user with type synergy, with the lack of knock off users this gen, i.e. only gliscor,samu,darkrai, tusk can use it effectively, u cant use those on every team, moon makes it easy for scizor structures to thrive, which also, just like volc did, curbs kyurem, weavile structures aswell, they also curb kyurem, i have presented many ways to curb kyurem in the past and yet still i hear complaints about kyurem even in this thread (which is not the place for it), even tho the only reason kyurem is banned was bc people didnt wanna get their own reqs, this thread is not the place for that so im getting off this topic, mpon promotes structures with good underrated mons, like scizor/weav, which were good in moonless meta, scizor curbing val, dnite and glim structures, weav being good into cind structures and those ting lu hazard stacking structures that people used alot even in moon meta, this meta is too warped around hazards and realistically youll never have safe, good removal unless you run triple removal, many fat ghosts, and over 10 spikers, surely a good knock user that limits or forces the tera on a pokemon like gholdengo is good for limiting this recurring problem in the metagame, because realistically, gholdengo is NEVER gonna get enough support for a test, so we have to look for other solutions. Sand is a good one aswell, sand becomes better with moon around, because sand curbs offense, so people saying moon buffs offense, is cancelled out by sand curbing it, ive tried to evolve sand this gen myself, devin and i inventing sub drill gave it a resurgence, and my adaptations, eject gweez/pex, have made it even more consistent, and unlike brainless offense, sand requires skill to pilot, and thus ultimately, the skill floor is raised. I see nobody arguing for a zard x ban in gens 6/7 even tho its role is similar to moon's and yeah moon can hold an item but atleast moon can be tricked/burned, Xard cant be burned, now, this is relevant to moon because it doesnt affect the sm meta any less than moon is affecting the sv meta, a dragon dancer that fires off strong attacks, atleast its not gambit which can sd and 1v6 entire teams, and have people using triple fighting + flame body + encore and still be scared of it. Roaring promotes good teams and good structures which ultimately give you a better meta.

- Roaring moon is not "super bulky", without sacrificing some of its evs, you have to ditch either speed or some of ur power, which makes u vulnerable to stuff like encore ival if u ditch the speed, and corv/skarm if u ditch the attack, people say "too many viable teras/sets" goes for any sweeper, every mon can tailor a tera to pick its counters, moon doesnt even have the most viable sets and teras in this meta, that role goes to dnite/gambit/zama, moon can only run tera ground, ghost, flying, tera fire scale shot as a niche set in the sun is also good, tera dragon outrage is the last one, tell me if im missing any, surely its more than the 9 viable sets for zama, the 15 viable gambit sets (a new one with red card tera ghost sd was just discovered which unironically invalidates its biggest answer zama, and the mental herb one which beats encore), or the 20 viable dnite sets, you can tailor a dnite to beat every team and ulike roaring, multiscale gives u a free dd on any mon if u have the right set, i will admit, moon does dd on and force out alot, but if it wins the game on the spot thats a skill issue, a free dd doesnt mean auto win if u have a good team, every good team needs priority unless its stall, moon has to have the right tera and thats a tera issue not a moon issue. I sometimes nod and say "yeah moon isnt the correct way forward" but what if im wrong and the meta gets worse without it, i had to step back and look at the development of each meta, moon and moonless, i dont even see alot of moon on the high ladder, i just see stall, balance, webs, contrary to people saying moon limits fat structures, even though those fat structures continue to evolve and dominate the ladders, whether moon is around or not. One day the wrong mon will get banned, another favorite, and itll turn people against terastal atp. People vote based on personal bias, i vote from a neutral perspective.

- Moon limiting cresselia and screens is a good thing, you force cress to either run fairy offensive or physdef for other teras, limiting screens is good, mons like ceru and wellspring that realistically wont be leaving this tier due to lack of support from the majority, i used to be pushing for a light clay ban but that is not going to curb screens much, 5 turn screens is still dangerous cuz sweepers like ceru wellspring only need 1-2 turns behind a screen to end a game, which is ridiculous, the optimal way forward is adding a new knocker that curbs screens, instead of eliminating the mon that limits screens, and banning clay which result in 5 turn screens teams still winning bc all the screens games ever played usually end before the extended screen turns even come around, and we cant ban the moves bc tiering policy, moon curbing screens is a net positive. And yes, ik its an abuser, but atleast it directly threatens/invalidates the main setter, deoxys speed, and forces people to set with zama, which is a good limitation, bc screens deo structures are stronger bc zama as an abuser is disgusting, zama as a whole is an uber just saying it like it is thats okay if you dont like this opinion, anyway, the main summary here for the "too long dont read" and the "i aint readin allat" people, is moon limits screens more than it helps it, because even as an abuser, ting lu still whirlwinds it out, if it taunts it gets chipped by ruination, forced to tera and revenged by prio anyway, physdef gliscor also completely owns it, this is what people dont realise, forcing gliscor to run physdef toxic sets, or physdef sd sets, is directly curbing strong mons like dnite/zama/kingambit, which is a net positive for the metagame, theres a positive domino effect involved, moon forces glisc to run physdef >> gambit/zama/dnite is curbed, moon promotes good, interactive and consistent structures with mons that are good even without it like scizor/weav >> kyurem, glowking is curbed, garg structures are the strongest they've ever been, and surely if you want a balanced meta, the fatter structures must thrive, they thrive now more than ever in this meta. They also require skill to pilot because u are required to find the correct lines vs the new offense structures that are rising, which promotes interactive gameplay.

- The last argument i wanted to provide here is speed control, one thing ive noticed in the moon meta that the moonless meta just does not have, is structures with good speed control, many of the roaring moon metagame structures have good speed control, while the ones in the moonless meta are lackluster and are usually the same mons, this is not an argument that directly defends roaring moon but i will say a metagame with good speed control and flowing ingame lines is better than a slower paced meta that just has uninteractive switching and passive playing.


To conclude this post, i want to reiterate, that if i was voting based on personal sentiment, then i would vote do not unban, but, im aiming to give a fair assessment with my own research in both the metagame and the builder, which ultimately leans me towards the unban side, not because i dont think its strong, you cant argue that moon isnt powerful, that would be ridiculous, i am leaning towards unban because i think the skill floor is higher and the metagame is more interactive with more healthy developments with it than it is without it. This is just my opinion, i predict this opinion may be unpopular among many given the general sentiment of moon and how many of my friends that have initially convinced me to give roaring moon a chance (especially top players with influence) have switched stances on it and is now voting do not unban, and i dont expect it to stay ou, nor do i even like roaring moon personally, but this is not going to stop me from fairly assessing the mon and giving a fair, unbiased argument to determine my stance with good reasoning, and it is certainly not going to stop me from voting to unban this pokemon.
 
To be perfectly honest I'm not currently 100% sure if roaring moon is banworthy or not, and I just want to make this post so I can have a place I can go back to and look at all my thoughts on moon before I make the vote for whether or not to ban it. In this post I want to look at roaring moon on hyper offence (webs, hazard stack and screens) because I don't think it's broken on balance or standard offence.

First off is webs, I feel that out of all the ho teams moon fits on it works least well on webs this is because webs usually don't run rocks or spikes so knocking off boots doesn't feel as impactful rocks also punishes pivots like lando-t and rocky helmet corv/skarm. Due to the lack of hazard chip roaring moon on webs is kinda bad vs stall unless it has taunt, if it has taunt it's worst case it will kill one of dozo or corv and best case it will kill both which can be enough to let gambit clean up in any case I think it's better to leave stall breaking to psyshock gholdengo on webs. The advantages of webs are that the moon can invest less in speed (would do somewhere between 296 and 310) and more into bulk and attack the other advantage is booster attack tusk is a reliable spinner for ho standards and moon is not the best at handling opposing hazards the same goes for moth absorbing toxic spikes. One thing I will add is most webs teams are weak to ground + ice coverage and moon can't act as a one time switch in so it doesn't really help in that aspect.

Next up is screens, screens is similar to webs in that it's hard to fit hazards (not impossible tho glim and samu-h have use on screens) onto a screens team but screens moon can offset this by simply dding again because it's no longer afraid of not being able to tank two hard hits because of this moon behind screens is probably the version that best facilitates shredding balance and bulky offence teams apart. However the lack of hazards also means this moon has the same problem of lacking utility vs stall without taunt plus gambit (every time taunt, roost or sub is used you give up coverage) it's also notable that moon has anti-synergy with screens best stall breaker in lo ceru because it knocks of the ceru checks' item and then the ceru can no longer use poltergeist. I think the best argument that this version of moon isn't busted is that with time balance can find ways to adapt like maybe red card clef plus stuff like psychic fangs zama.

Third up is hazard stack ho, this one is objectively the most fun to use (because fun is objective) it usually doesn't run reliable removal so you can get bulled over by hazards but other than that I expect it's what most ppl imagine when roaring moon is brought up. Funnily enough I think that this set isn't broken vs balance because it gets bullied by their hazard onslaught and it gets one chance to sweep because it looses a lot of breaking power without the booster energy. This moon set is probably the best vs stall in a vacuum even without taunt but the teams it fits on always seem to be fighting an uphill battle vs gliscor. I used CTC and Vert's triple dark sample team for most of my suspect run and it was unironically the most fun I've had in the tier in recent memory https://pokepast.es/d9df62e9be9b2385 for anyone who wants to try it out.

Originally I wanted to talk about sun here but I don't really have a lot to say. It can't run acro, band and scarf are bad, lo and scale shot seem cool but might also sneakily be the most absurdly broken moon sets idk I haven't used or faced either of them enough.

One final thing is my Wishlist for sv ou:
1) make sv ou (casual) a separate ladder with more unbans so it's a more fun but less fair tier and make it that you don't have to get suspect recs to ban/unban stuff to make it more representative of the casual player base and hopefully it will bring more ppl back to playing/laddering in the tier
2) ban light clay
2) retest sleep
3) please don't ban wellspring or dnite they have so much good defensive utility and they don't crush balance as much as people pretend they do
4) test a tera preview where you can see both teams tera types from team preveiw

Thank you for taking time reading this and thank you to all the people who posted on this thread as Hellom said discourse is always a net positive for the tier.
 
Last edited:
Storm Zone said:
Some of my friends who were nice enough to give me arguments for why moon is good for the meta, and the people that used valid arguments to convince me that moon was not broken, i.e. @hellom @vk and many others, (i have logs btw i screenshot EVERYTHING), have now completely changed their minds on the mon and are posting "do not unban" posts, which is strange, because again, they were the ones that convinced me that moon was okay.

IVWTueZX6fy0JFs20_1gQA.jpg
bro what
 
Storm Zone said:
I've had a long time to collect my thoughts on this suspect, since it was announced long before it even went up, before i say anything, i wanna address some stuff, for one, back when moon was in the tier, it was the pokemon i hated the most, thats just my personal bias, my friends would hear me complain about roaring for the longest while, and even still, i put my own sentiments aside and defended both sides and let people think for themselves, but that was due to me not knowing what a moonless meta would look like, now i do, having a suspect for something that was in ou before, and in ubers, is easier to have a perspective on than something that has only been ou, now, again, i still hate the mon, but id be lying if i sat here, looked at the tier fairly and said it was broken, so before i get into my argument, before anyone says "i thought u hated it", im completely burying my own personal sentiment here for a fair assessment(if i was being biased, yes, still hate moon), but i am still setting aside my personal feelings toward the mon, something many dont have the ability to do during suspects evidently.

Now, this thread is strictly supposed to be about moon so im gonna keep it that way, i just had to state what i said above so i dont get called a hypocrite or get quoted, let me get into the arguments:

- Moon is very strong, im not denying that at all to be very clear, but sometimes a pokemon adds to a meta indirectly, u gotta ask urself, did not having roaring around enable too much cheese? Screens deoxys was more popular than ever in moonless meta, psyspam tr was here and there, look at the olt trends, bolt, ogerpon zamazenta gambit, cresselia cheese everywhere, screens deoxys, and protect stall, theres too much variety, but roaring can limit that variety, because the more threats that get banned to ubers, the higher the variance because strong teams/styles that pokemon was restricting here, which is quite a bit, is now free to be explored and experimented with, which leads to more and more broken trends arising, and as long as we have tera it will never stop increasing variance, this is why im so critical when a suspect happens, i rarely take the ban side because i know the variance will increase and new stuff will step up, wellspring will be stronger and so will kyurem, moon gone buffs bolt too, and kingambit bc they no longer have to tera into a type that beats moon.

- "Moon invalidates balance" , no it does not, and i think what im about to say is more relevant to the suspect than anything else, all ive been spamming on the ladder recently, are balance teams and psyspam, teams that people say moon would typically beat, and ive been winning consistently with said balance teams, i made a big post on how i was exploring balance, both in moon meta and moonless meta, and there was not much adjustment to be made with moon's arrival, arguably those balance teams got even better with moon around, psyspam has been winning more aswell, what im attempting to do here is laddering with styles people generally think moon would restrict to see how much moon really strains these styles, and its not alot at all.

- Some of my friends who were nice enough to give me arguments for why moon is good for the meta, and the people that used valid arguments to convince me that moon was not broken, i.e. hellom vk and many others, (i have logs btw i screenshot EVERYTHING), have now completely changed their minds on the mon and are posting "do not unban" posts, which is strange, because again, they were the ones that convinced me that moon was okay. Truly a "i want this till i get it now im realising i cant handle it, i was wrong about it" moment, and thats okay. Let me say something about this, nobody, not a single soul has more experience in the meta or in the builder for that matter than me, i build as a hobby it relieves my stress, so i of all people would feel a strain in the builder when a mon is broken, the bigger the strain the more broken the mon, ive felt a bigger strain for a select few pokemon than i have moon, ive played 500+ games both in moon and moonless meta, and i just wanna say, in the moonless meta, with the higher variance since people dont have to worry about moon, some cheesy styles feel uninteractive to play against, and you have no way to measure how good a team is if thats what you are testing against, with the moon meta, im playing vs a good team every game, and old friends i teambuild with dating back to gens 6/7/8, who were very technical in the builder, have come back to build and play again with moon around , i.e. Iodyne , so its not that "moon is restricting this or that, as a result, ban it, is it hitting a sweet spot where its restricting just enough to keep lots of variety and promote mons that ive proven in tour performances were good without moon around, i.e. scizor/weavile/clefable/skarm, and make them better, and allow for new styles to arise and new innovations, while keeping out un interactive styles, promoting a more interactive skill based meta, ive been under the belief that, if it requires more skill to limit a mon than it requires to beat an uninteractive style, that uninteractive style has no precedent over the mon, and therefore the mon staying to invalidate it actually raises the skill floor. lax talked about this briefly, part of the skill in sv was limiting the moon. If we were tiering for casuals, chi yu and chien pao would still be ou, we are tiering for a tournament setting, the higher the skill floor, the better the meta, broken checks broken will always exist if this gen's mechanic is around so u cannot lump my post into the broken checks broken category. My argument here is, the metagame with roaring, feels more interactive and skill based than a meta without it, im not saying its not strong, its one of the strongest mons in the meta, but it aint the top dog, and it certainly adds to the meta given the argument im presenting here.

- Splashable knock off user with type synergy, with the lack of knock off users this gen, i.e. only gliscor,samu,darkrai, tusk can use it effectively, u cant use those on every team, moon makes it easy for scizor structures to thrive, which also, just like volc did, curbs kyurem, weavile structures aswell, they also curb kyurem, i have presented many ways to curb kyurem in the past and yet still i hear complaints about kyurem even in this thread (which is not the place for it), even tho the only reason kyurem is banned was bc people didnt wanna get their own reqs, this thread is not the place for that so im getting off this topic, mpon promotes structures with good underrated mons, like scizor/weav, which were good in moonless meta, scizor curbing val, dnite and glim structures, weav being good into cind structures and those ting lu hazard stacking structures that people used alot even in moon meta, this meta is too warped around hazards and realistically youll never have safe, good removal unless you run triple removal, many fat ghosts, and over 10 spikers, surely a good knock user that limits or forces the tera on a pokemon like gholdengo is good for limiting this recurring problem in the metagame, because realistically, gholdengo is NEVER gonna get enough support for a test, so we have to look for other solutions. Sand is a good one aswell, sand becomes better with moon around, because sand curbs offense, so people saying moon buffs offense, is cancelled out by sand curbing it, ive tried to evolve sand this gen myself, devin and i inventing sub drill gave it a resurgence, and my adaptations, eject gweez/pex, have made it even more consistent, and unlike brainless offense, sand requires skill to pilot, and thus ultimately, the skill floor is raised. I see nobody arguing for a zard x ban in gens 6/7 even tho its role is similar to moon's and yeah moon can hold an item but atleast moon can be tricked/burned, Xard cant be burned, now, this is relevant to moon because it doesnt affect the sm meta any less than moon is affecting the sv meta, a dragon dancer that fires off strong attacks, atleast its not gambit which can sd and 1v6 entire teams, and have people using triple fighting + flame body + encore and still be scared of it. Roaring promotes good teams and good structures which ultimately give you a better meta.

- Roaring moon is not "super bulky", without sacrificing some of its evs, you have to ditch either speed or some of ur power, which makes u vulnerable to stuff like encore ival if u ditch the speed, and corv/skarm if u ditch the attack, people say "too many viable teras/sets" goes for any sweeper, every mon can tailor a tera to pick its counters, moon doesnt even have the most viable sets and teras in this meta, that role goes to dnite/gambit/zama, moon can only run tera ground, ghost, flying, tera fire scale shot as a niche set in the sun is also good, tera dragon outrage is the last one, tell me if im missing any, surely its more than the 9 viable sets for zama, the 15 viable gambit sets (a new one with red card tera ghost sd was just discovered which unironically invalidates its biggest answer zama, and the mental herb one which beats encore), or the 20 viable dnite sets, you can tailor a dnite to beat every team and ulike roaring, multiscale gives u a free dd on any mon if u have the right set, i will admit, moon does dd on and force out alot, but if it wins the game on the spot thats a skill issue, a free dd doesnt mean auto win if u have a good team, every good team needs priority unless its stall, moon has to have the right tera and thats a tera issue not a moon issue. I sometimes nod and say "yeah moon isnt the correct way forward" but what if im wrong and the meta gets worse without it, i had to step back and look at the development of each meta, moon and moonless, i dont even see alot of moon on the high ladder, i just see stall, balance, webs, contrary to people saying moon limits fat structures, even though those fat structures continue to evolve and dominate the ladders, whether moon is around or not. One day the wrong mon will get banned, another favorite, and itll turn people against terastal atp. People vote based on personal bias, i vote from a neutral perspective.

- Moon limiting cresselia and screens is a good thing, you force cress to either run fairy offensive or physdef for other teras, limiting screens is good, mons like ceru and wellspring that realistically wont be leaving this tier due to lack of support from the majority, i used to be pushing for a light clay ban but that is not going to curb screens much, 5 turn screens is still dangerous cuz sweepers like ceru wellspring only need 1-2 turns behind a screen to end a game, which is ridiculous, the optimal way forward is adding a new knocker that curbs screens, instead of eliminating the mon that limits screens, and banning clay which result in 5 turn screens teams still winning bc all the screens games ever played usually end before the extended screen turns even come around, and we cant ban the moves bc tiering policy, moon curbing screens is a net positive. And yes, ik its an abuser, but atleast it directly threatens/invalidates the main setter, deoxys speed, and forces people to set with zama, which is a good limitation, bc screens deo structures are stronger bc zama as an abuser is disgusting, zama as a whole is an uber just saying it like it is thats okay if you dont like this opinion, anyway, the main summary here for the "too long dont read" and the "i aint readin allat" people, is moon limits screens more than it helps it, because even as an abuser, ting lu still whirlwinds it out, if it taunts it gets chipped by ruination, forced to tera and revenged by prio anyway, physdef gliscor also completely owns it, this is what people dont realise, forcing gliscor to run physdef toxic sets, or physdef sd sets, is directly curbing strong mons like dnite/zama/kingambit, which is a net positive for the metagame, theres a positive domino effect involved, moon forces glisc to run physdef >> gambit/zama/dnite is curbed, moon promotes good, interactive and consistent structures with mons that are good even without it like scizor/weav >> kyurem, glowking is curbed, garg structures are the strongest they've ever been, and surely if you want a balanced meta, the fatter structures must thrive, they thrive now more than ever in this meta. They also require skill to pilot because u are required to find the correct lines vs the new offense structures that are rising, which promotes interactive gameplay.

- The last argument i wanted to provide here is speed control, one thing ive noticed in the moon meta that the moonless meta just does not have, is structures with good speed control, many of the roaring moon metagame structures have good speed control, while the ones in the moonless meta are lackluster and are usually the same mons, this is not an argument that directly defends roaring moon but i will say a metagame with good speed control and flowing ingame lines is better than a slower paced meta that just has uninteractive switching and passive playing.


To conclude this post, i want to reiterate, that if i was voting based on personal sentiment, then i would vote do not unban, but, im aiming to give a fair assessment with my own research in both the metagame and the builder, which ultimately leans me towards the unban side, not because i dont think its strong, you cant argue that moon isnt powerful, that would be ridiculous, i am leaning towards unban because i think the skill floor is higher and the metagame is more interactive with more healthy developments with it than it is without it. This is just my opinion, i predict this opinion may be unpopular among many given the general sentiment of moon and how many of my friends that have initially convinced me to give roaring moon a chance (especially top players with influence) have switched stances on it and is now voting do not unban, and i dont expect it to stay ou, nor do i even like roaring moon personally, but this is not going to stop me from fairly assessing the mon and giving a fair, unbiased argument to determine my stance with good reasoning, and it is certainly not going to stop me from voting to unban this pokemon.
finally, my opinion dropped
 
vk said:
IVWTueZX6fy0JFs20_1gQA.jpg
bro what
"To conclude this post, i want to reiterate, that if i was voting based on personal sentiment, then i would vote do not unban"

"i still hate the mon, but id be lying if i sat here, looked at the tier fairly and said it was broken, so before i get into my argument, before anyone says "i thought u hated it", im completely burying my own personal sentiment here for a fair assessment(if i was being biased, yes, still hate moon), but i am still setting aside my personal feelings toward the mon, something many dont have the ability to do during suspects evidently."

" i predict this opinion may be unpopular among many given the general sentiment of moon and how many of my friends that have initially convinced me to give roaring moon a chance (especially top players with influence) have switched stances on it and is now voting do not unban, and i dont expect it to stay ou, nor do i even like roaring moon personally, but this is not going to stop me from fairly assessing the mon and giving a fair, unbiased argument to determine my stance with good reasoning, and it is certainly not going to stop me from voting to unban this pokemon."

^^
Quotes from my post, just say u didnt read the whole thing and skimmed through it without going through all the context mr. "I aint readin allat", because if you read everything i said you wouldn't have posted this, if i was biased i would still call it broken, and i want you to read this twice, if i was biased, i would STILL call it broken, but this aint my personal opinion, its a fair assessment, im voting based on data and reasoning, not my own personal bias, which is why im voting unban. Oh, and in your screenshot, you called it broken not me lol, it says "vk (to pyukumuku guru): ye i mean moons broken lol.", so this entire screenshot is pointless, you're proving me right with your stance change, for many many months before this suspect dropped, all you would say in stallcord or any other discord server was free moon, i have all the logs, im gonna ask sire clod to pull them up since hes a mod in stallcord so people can see you saying free roaring, you look even crazier now bro, not worth engaging further.
 
Last edited:
Decided to pick up S/V again for this test mainly out of curiosity of how the tier has changed in the past year and if Moon is really OP in the current metagame, and imma just rip the bandaid off, ts is not broken, atleast relative to the shit around it. Moon got nice stats yeah but theres also a mon that gets a free choice band boost for losing the game thats also fatter than a suicune running around. If balance somehow manages to exist with that thing running around, I'm pretty sure they can handle moon. Moon also benefits the tier because it DEMOLISHES SKILLESS MONS like ogerpon and ceruledge. Y'all whine about cress nonstop so, here you go! I agree fat DD behind screens can be obnoxious, but so is every sweeper p much, I just used roar tusk during my reqs run to absolutely farm these teams. So vote unban unless you want to play nothing but wellspring mirrors for another year

Suspect Reqs (I did this like 2 days after the test began so I decayed a lot)

c5prpPM0Q_vMl55Av7hsXA.jpg
 
Last edited:
Roaring Moon presents a most intriguing dilemma to the metagame: is another fast offensive attacker that further oversaturates threats worth subduing a select few uncompetitive components? At the cost of reducing set variance amongst Cresselia, Ceruledge, Kingambit, and Pecharunt, to name a few, Roaring Moon threatens to push offense even further over the edge, obliterating common BO and balance structures and forcing adaptation in the ways of Tinkaton, Clefable, Mandibuzz, etc. To some longtime players of SVOU, this is but a siren's call, a necessary act to bring greedy Cresselia and Kingambit sets to a kowtow, while the consequence is perhaps cloaked by a nostalgia - we had a tier that welcomed the darkest dragon for so long, how could it be that unhealthy?... but I digress.

The crux of the matter is this: that to subject Roaring Moon to the label of "just another", to erase its uniqueness, is to do it an injustice. While claims have been made by others that few mons are quite as threatening after a single turn of setup, few powerful setup threats so difficult to revenge or to deny, I would further these claims by illuminating that Roaring Moon is uniquely situated to force apart checks that would otherwise be able to address the threats in the back, by proxy of Knock Off, a treasure few other HO sweepers hold. No longer is the phazer Dragonite able to check the Ogerpon in the back, no longer the Moltres able to serve as an answer to both Dragonite and Great Tusk, no longer the Zamazenta able to check Kingambit. While this may be claimed for Roaring Moon's most similar counterpart, Dragonite, the latter's inability to remove Boots, Leftovers, and Helmets usually means its checks will be able to hold up much better into the incessant barrage of physical offense. This is further exacerbated by the unassuming amount of 50s Moon forces - if you switch in on DD with Corviknight, do you Iron Defense and risk being 2hkod after rocks if Moon clicks Knock Off, or do you Roost and lose as Moon dances once more? If you seek to revenge it with Zamazenta, do you take 80 from Acrobatics or simply Tera to take 80 from Earthquake? To these questions I have not an answer, but I do have a response to the inquiry this thread poses upon us:

Do Not Unban.
 
Last edited:
AquiIo said:
Roaring Moon presents a most intriguing dilemma to the metagame: is another fast offensive attacker that further oversaturates threats worth subduing a select few uncompetitive components? At the cost of reducing set variance amongst Cresselia, Ceruledge, Kingambit, and Pecharunt, to name a few, Roaring Moon threatens to push offense even further over the edge, obliterating common BO and balance structures and forcing adaptation in the ways of Tinkaton, Clefable, Mandibuzz, etc. To some longtime players of SVOU, this is but a siren's call, a necessary act to bring greedy Cresselia and Kingambit sets to a kowtow, while the consequence is perhaps cloaked by a nostalgia - we had a tier that welcomed the darkest dragon for so long, how could it be that unhealthy?... but I digress.

The crux of the matter is this: that to subject Roaring Moon to the label of "just another", to erase its uniqueness, is to do it an injustice. While claims have been made by others that few mons are quite as threatening after a single turn of setup, few powerful setup threats so difficult to revenge or to deny, I would further these claims by illuminating that Roaring Moon is uniquely situated to force apart checks that would otherwise be able to address the threats in the back, by proxy of Knock Off, a treasure few other HO sweepers hold. No longer is the phazer Dragonite able to check the Ogerpon in the back, no longer the Moltres able to serve as an answer to both Dragonite and Great Tusk, no longer the Zamazenta able to check Kingambit. While this may be claimed for Roaring Moon's most similar counterpart, Dragonite, the latter's inability to remove Boots, Leftovers, and Helmets usually means its checks will be able to hold up much better into the incessant barrage of physical offense. This is further exacerbated by the unassuming amount of 50s Moon forces - if you switch in on DD with Corviknight, do you Iron Defense and risk being 2hkod after rocks if Moon clicks Knock Off, or do you Roost and lose as Moon dances once more? If you seek to revenge it with Zamazenta, do you take 80 from Acrobatics or simply Tera to take 80 from Earthquake? To these questions I have not an answer, but I do have a response to the inquiry this thread poses upon us:

Do Not Unban.
Finally, my opinion dropped!
 
No one gaf abt this gen atp so I'm not really going to say that much. I think storm pretty much summarized it but Imma do my own bullet points anyways.

1. It limits set diversity on top mons. Gambit is seeing more balloon now, certain teras are worse. Same with zama being more Idef/boots than lorb ime now to keep hp. Woger is highly encouraged to run one of u turn, trailblaze or disruption to avoid free turns. Dnite gotta be espeed more now. Probably a few more but this is just off dome.

2. Makes anti-offense mons like sciz, weavile better. These mons overall enjoy the resurgence of offense + the top dogs being more linear.

3. Forces smarter positioning. This is probably moons best or 2nd best trait. It damn near always needs the free turn to do it's job & there's a myriad of ways between hazards, would be fodder packing twave or encore or just heads up navigating the game that denies it it's goal.

4. Being a strong knock user is something that imo is valuable to the tier & is the other one of its 2 best traits. Adds a degree of consistency to offense, more specifically ho, that makes games a little less of a dice roll.

5. It's a lot more linear than last time, with ground, flying, ghost being the big 3 tera types and having a pretty fixed 5 move rotation.

6. This one is a little more loose but even with ladder being dead the % of moon feel lower than pala by far and even volc.

7. Meta trends ebb & flow but a quick glance at the scl sheet is pretty grotesque, ting lu barely top 20, cress in the top 10 + a rather interesting 11-20 range. Moon does promote that 2nd segment while limiting the top 10, which is pretty notable since a lot of the mons on that 2nd half are checks to the top dogs that have ways to be exploited by upper half. I guess this ties in with the 1st point but it really does limit these mons to a point where the standard checks are more consistent.

If you couldn't figure it out already, unban
 
Back
Top