• Follow our Instagram!
  • Curious about what we're currently doing about bots? Check out the latest updates from staff in this thread.

Format Discussion Past Gens Random Battle Sets

I've played over 8000 gen 3 random matches and have to say that the balancing is pretty good. My only complaint is when an attack fails to break a substitute (Move was neither super effective or not-very effective.) Without specific examples, the admins obviously can't do anything. But now that I know this thread exists, I'll share more examples in the future.

I second others ideas in the thread for more experimentation of move sets and monsters. I love that vigoroth and pikachu are in gen 3 randoms. I wouldn't mind seeing dragonair and onix added.

Oh... since it just popped to mind... I want to see a shuckle with the moveset Toxic, Swagger, Protect and Rest. Swagger lets it attack stuff like gengar and other special attackers. It works well in less competitive formats.
 
ed06288 said:
I love that vigoroth and pikachu are in gen 3 randoms. I wouldn't mind seeing dragonair and onix added.

From your perspective, what should Dragonair and Onix specifically be added to the format?

The way I see it, Vigoroth and Pikachu both have very clear cases for being in the Pokemon pool:
- Vigoroth is the pre-evolution of a Pokemon that has an utterly crippling ability, so Vigoroth is how a Pokemon in that evolutionary line can be used without being hindered by this ability.
- Pikachu has access to an item no other Pokemon does, and this item gives it immense immediate hitting power which far surpasses that of its evolution.

So what about Dragonair and Onix?
- Dragonair simply lacks one of the types that its evolution has. That's it. By that reasoning, should we also add Charmeleon? Nidorina/Nidorino? Poliwhirl? etc. Personally, I'd say no on all of these. I see no reason for Dragonair to be added. Please explain why you believe that Dragonair should be included and how it'd be distinct from Dragonite. Also, do you believe the aforementioned examples or other examples in the same category should also be included? If not, why? What makes Dragonair in particular special?
- On Onix, I'm slightly warmer. One of its types is fully replaced upon its evolution, which is a bigger change than simply having a new type added. Also, one of its base stats is higher than that of its evolution, so that strengthes the argument that Onix might have a unique niche to offer to the format. Can you provide some examples sets that prove Onix can viably be something fully distinct from Steelix, instead of just Steelix-lite?
 
Rigas said:
- On Onix, I'm slightly warmer. One of its types is fully replaced upon its evolution, which is a bigger change than simply having a new type added. Also, one of its base stats is higher than that of its evolution, so that strengthes the argument that Onix might have a unique niche to offer to the format. Can you provide some examples sets that prove Onix can viably be something fully distinct from Steelix, instead of just Steelix-lite?
Late reply, but I just like playing with the sprites so I suppose nostalgia is a factor here. I would make Onix similar to Luvdisc. It doesn't have high attacking power so being a toxic staller could be the way to go. I would have also suggested giving it Roar, but with baton pass now banned, there might not be a need for it as much anymore. I do wish they had added more roar and whirlwind to the format before banning baton pass. I don't mind conceding the point that dragonair is pointless, but maybe making it into a special attacker with thunder wave could be interesting.
 
Gsc rands: having setup + bp + heal in a mon is too much, when the other team might just be getting toxic / resttalk breakers. Even more so with a typing like psychic which is hard to hit se with common coverage. Espeon also isn't that much low-leveled, so wtf. (I had the espeon, i'm complaining bc my poor opp deserved better).

Setup is necessary imo bc it shakes up a bit what otherwise would be resttalk fests. But i strongly oppose having healing with it (in this case, morning sun?! Even more op).
(Even tho setup passing to a resttalker is strong af, rn I won't argue for that too)
 
PaperIrori said:
https://replay.pokemonshowdown.com/gen3randombattle-2673684239

My opp and I agree on reporting this shiftry set. It wasn't either chlorophyll, nor early bird rest
the team would prefer keeping early bird on shiftry (which does have use for sleep absorption) than having it always be chlorophyll just in case the opponent rolls a groudon.

as for your other post, i beg you to read the OP:
A Cake Wearing A Hat said:
Please do not post:
A Cake Wearing A Hat said:
- Posts complaining about unfairness, demanding certain Pokemon should be "banned" from the format, or complaining about hax.
 
(The gen8 thread’s last comment said to post here for gen8 randbats as it is an old gen now). Recommendation: (remember--I'm pretty sure I heard a moderator or some official PS person say--we are trying to make each pokemon's moveset as good as possible for that pokemon, not make it in any way 'worse to make the meta more balanced'.) Make haxorus be not just always lum berry but either life orb or lum berry (I suggest a high probability to be life orb and I'm thinking make it life orb 50% to 100% of the time). Life orb boosts it 1.3x with and without dynamax (scarf and band do not, at least in one strong technical sense, help with dynamax as they do not increase speed/attack while dynamaxed but life orb greatly helps); life orb boosts attack massively when dynamaxing and good players frequently both want to dynamax and do in fact dynamax haxorus right after 1 dragon dance (with life orb, after 1 dragon dance STAB wymrwind goes from BP315 to BP409.5 on top of a naturally massive base attack stat of 271 so it's basically OHKO'ing everything (obviously I am talking probabilistically--your opponent only gets 6 mons and doesn't get to choose them, but nothing wants to go against something faster with massive attack damage and massive coverage that has to come in when it is already set up) or putting them in range of max knuckle or reducing their attack stat so they do little damage back, and max quake from 130 to 169, etc.--because higher attack damage numbers compound higher and higher on each other multiplicatively instead of just linearly when you stack life orb on high base attack on dynamax increased base power of moves--and if you add iron head to the moveset--which by the way should replace poison jab on the moveset as it also deals with fairies and max steel gives a defense boost instead of the special attack boost from dynamax poison that does not help haxorus and the good 30% iron head flinch chance from a haxorus, especially after 1 dragon dance which it frequently gets off easily, is basically deadly/game-winning in some situations (with a massive offensive threat like haxorus) and can also scare opponents enough to want to dynamax just to avoid getting flinched and losing the game by being finished off the next turn, as dynamax prevents flinching, and also steel has no immunities unlike poison jab so your opponent cannot as easily switch around or gets punished more often--then you go from a mere base 120 for iron head after 1 dragon dance to max steel at BP253.5 after 1 dragon dance with life orb as max steel is BP130 or BP195 after dragon dance vs max ooze from poison jab is only BP90 or BP135 after dragon dance). Life orb is great for sweeping teams and/or forcing opponents to waste their dynamax to try to defensively stop haxorus (the same argument applies to adding iron head over poison jab) and life orb even helps counteract status conditions (to argue against lum berry) because after 1 dragon dance there is no one (ok, maybe a few mons out of the hundreds that you won't have on your team probabilistically, so the haxorus-user would be foolish to be scared of a 5% or so chance and not set up and dynamax right after if they know the meta very well and have a good feel for the probabilities of the opponent having counters) fast enough without prankster or tanky enough to give a status condition to haxorus when it outspeeds and OHKO's with huge coverage and damage with life orb (and dynamax), and prankster moves (which the opponent frequently does not have anyway) are often inaccurate (stun spore, thunder wave) and dragon dance boosts speed and attack anyway to help counteract paralysis and burn but honestly I almost never worry about haxorus getting statused because it just comes in strategically on sticky web users and a large number or even a majority of mons in the meta (with its defensive pure-dragon typing) and sets up in front of them as they have no reliable status moves besides ineffective elemental attacks like thunderbolt or fire blast or non-stab earthquake etc. (the opponent often has no access to status anyway on the turn hidden haxorus is suddenly unexpectedly brought in strategically or maybe only on 1 mon that is already fainted or cannot afflict haxorus without being OHKO'd by it first; also static and effect spore and flame body etc. don't affect dynamax mons (lum berry is less needed); also, even if the opponent somehow burns haxorus (which I feel rarely happens... who wants to click scald or discharge on a dragon type and lose the game when you do no damage and don't get the 30%?), it still has life orb to help counteract it. It has such good coverage and high attack stat and life orb and dynamax boosting its attacks that it is quite impractical to even try to status it on any turn it does not set up--and you can't status it anyway on that turn as it is brought in strategically--as you get OHKO'd before being able to). Life orb haxorus is something that instantly puts fear in any opponent (even if you make life orb the only item haxorus ever gets) and it would also be very scary to fight a haxorus while having to guess if it is 50% lum or 50% life orb because you can instantly lose the game or be put very far behind if you guess wrong (argument in favor of 50/50 lum/orb). Life orb is a haxorus item that arguably always has very high value in every game whereas lum is more situational and often may not help haxorus. The life orb attack boost compounds with dynamax rather than competing with it like other items (even lum to an extent). Life orb recoil is also reduced while dynamaxing (even more dynamax synergy). Also as I recall haxorus in gen8 randbat previously (always?) had life orb as I believe its only item (and it was a real menace, as I recall, with that item--actually it may have been a mix of life orb and band and scarf a long time ago, but I would not recommend band or scarf, as aforementioned). (ps: also max quake boosts spdef and max steel boosts def and max wyrmwind drops the opponent's attack = why it is one of the best offensive mons in the meta, as it can boost its own tankiness by dynamaxing while being hyper offensive at the same time. Also, in fact, I think life orb needs to be put more often on a lot more super strong offensive+fast mons in the meta in general)
 
Last edited:
I've spent some time figuring out how GSC Rands could be improved since last RBTT ended, and I've got a bunch of suggestions I'd like to make, which I've listed below.

The main aim of these suggestions is to reduce the risk of teamgen deciding games as much as possible, while trying to preserve the overall way the format plays as much as possible. A lot of this would be done by making it more likely for each player to generate breaking tools, so they are less likely to be walled by the opposing team. Given this is the case, the resulting format would be a bit more offensive as a side effect if these changes get implemented.

Although I've tried to keep it as short as I could, this will be a long post given the amount of suggestions and the fact I've tried to substantiate everything here. I may have went into more detail than necessary in places. Sorry if I have.

Part 1: Teamgen Suggestions
Team weaknesses
Teams with 3 weaknesses to a type are generated very frequently in GSC. Obviously this leads to major team flaws if you don't generate a resist to that type too, but allowing 3 weaknesses to a type often leads to weaknesses to completely unrelated mons too. I've gathered my RBTT/WCoR games this year where this teamgen rule has resulted in one-sided matchups if you'd like examples.
Examples
vs Yuudachi, g1, RBTT IX https://replay.pokemonshowdown.com/gen2randombattle-2522934815-53iloij3ml8xw2chcvnntuajjqfova7pw
Yuudachi's entire team is weak to Ice/Ground, and I have Piloswine. I also got Magmar which their team sucked into as well.
vs Yuudachi, g2, RBTT IX https://replay.pokemonshowdown.com/gen2randombattle-2522939103-flqjbfftykpn5vp8qgkqmjwb62mmxn2pw
I have 3 Electric weaknesses, and Yuudachi has 3 Flying weaknesses. I would've lost to Zapdos, but I lucked it with Magmar. Then their entire team lost to my Gyarados/Scizor.

vs Stallion, g1, RBTT IX https://replay.pokemonshowdown.com/gen2randombattle-2539826994
Stallion gets three Water-weak mons and nothing that can stop Perish Song Azumarill in the long term, especially since I had Spikes too.
vs Stallion, g2, RBTT IX https://replay.pokemonshowdown.com/gen2randombattle-2539841766
I have three Ground/Psychic weaks each, Stallion rolls Mr. Mime and Gligar. My team sucks into Ampharos too. I did end up having a chance to win, but I think this is because Stallion misplayed and gave up his Mime to preserve Ampharos when he had both Seaking and Togetic for my Vaporeon.

vs Zcarlett, RBTT IX https://replay.pokemonshowdown.com/gen2randombattle-2535526531-sbffem6ihu64etmrerpvukppvfrow3kpw?p2
Zcarlett rolls three Elec weaks, Porygon2, and Clefable, I get Primeape and Thunder + Hypnosis Mime. Even if you reduce the weakness limit, this matchup would still suck for her, but it might be a bit better at least.

vs Eeveeto, WCoR 2026 r1 https://replay.pokemonshowdown.com/gen2randombattle-2657350903-whktxok9qtr6kl19ty0oxtn2xdukwxrpw
I have 3 Rock weaks, Eeveeto gets Corsola which I have no switchins to. He gets Mewtwo, Bellossom, and RestTalk Hitmontop so I struggle to make progress with Pikachu/Nidoqueen/Primeape.

vs Yuudachi, WCoR 2026 r1 https://replay.pokemonshowdown.com/gen2randombattle-2662259267
Yuudachi has 3 Electric weaks and 0 resists, I get Raichu which also outspeeds their entire team.

vs Eeveeto, WCoR 2026 quarterfinals https://replay.pokemonshowdown.com/smogtours-gen2randombattle-964772
Here I generate 3 mons weak to Electric/Rock/Fighting. Eeveeto doesn't have any of these types, but he does have a Kingler, which is busted against my team too; my last is Earthquake Ursaring which also matches up poorly into it. I'd most likely have to rely on Dynamic Punch at some point to be able to win, and it might not be enough depending on his last.
I don't have the time to look at everyone else's games, but it's easy enough for these kinds of matchups to happen that restricting the weakness limit would likely be a decent teamgen improvement by itself.

Given all this, I'd suggest limiting a team to two weaknesses of any type. It won't fix every single matchup by itself, but it'll help.

RestTalk
RestTalk is a necessary defensive tool in GSC rands and many mons would struggle to put together a decent set without it. However, it's not something to put on a pedestal. It takes up two moveslots, leaving only one for coverage or setup. This is nowhere near enough to cover all the defensive threats in GSC rands. Curse RestTalk sets can easily find themselves walled by whatever resists their sole damaging move, while RestTalk sets opting for coverage instead can struggle to break things on their own. So despite RestTalk being essential for GSC rands, there's an undeniable issue with the fact that mons running it will always be wallable and that there are currently no limitations for it in teamgen. They are also often abusable by setup mons, which is a flaw the rest of your team might not be able to make up for. Being able to roll Rest isn't really a buff either; resetting your sleep turns takes control out of your hands for longer, which could hamper offensive gameplans, leave you vulnerable to setup mons for longer, and require you to use up more of your limited Sleep Talk PP if you want your mon to do something before it wakes up.

I'd suggest limiting a team to one (1) RestTalk user per type. This would help prevent overlapping roles and weaknesses between different mons on a team, making matchup issues less likely. I quickly looked through some of my WCoR games from this year, and here are a few example matchups that would've been more balanced with this rule in place:
Examples
vs hida, WCoR 2026 r1 https://replay.pokemonshowdown.com/gen2randombattle-2655778326
Once I paralyse their Porygon2, realistically my Curse RestTalk Wigglytuff + Kangaskhan just wins as long as I play safely. The reason this ended up being more complicated is because I unnecessarily risked a Fire Blast crit on Wigglytuff and got punished. Going off the way they played, their Dragonite is RestTalk which doesn't do anything here.

vs Eeveeto, WCoR 2026 quarterfinals https://replay.pokemonshowdown.com/smogtours-gen2randombattle-964776
I generate two RestTalk Waters here and end up with a team that loses to Curselax unless I play perfectly with Smeargle and Piloswine.

vs livid washed, WCoR 2026 semifinals https://replay.pokemonshowdown.com/gen2randombattle-2676250510?p2
I also rolled two RestTalk Waters here. I can only break Livid's team by playing perfectly and getting lucky with Hypnosis sleep turns and crits.

I'd also suggest removing, or reducing the likelihood of, RestTalk on mons that can't use it that well, or have better offensive sets they could use instead. This is heading into moveset territory though, so I've covered this in part #2 of the post.

I doubt that an overall RestTalk limit would improve the format. Introducing a limit of two RestTalkers would impact teamgen a lot and I think it'd lead to things like Electrics and Sunny Day Fires becoming unhealthier, whereas a limit of four or more feels kind of pointless as it won't affect most games. A limit of three could be worth a try, but Normals/Electrics/Waters are by far the best RestTalkers and generating something else would likely put you at a disadvantage. I therefore think it'd be better to make other teamgen changes for now and revisit this later on if more improvements need to be made.
Part 2: Moveset Suggestions
Poor or mediocre RestTalk sets
There's a handful of mons that run RestTalk in GSC rands that perform better with their offensive sets. I would suggest removing, or reducing the likelihood of, RestTalk on these mons. Sandslash, Dragonite, and Mr. Mime shouldn't be able to roll it in my opinion.

Sandslash 4hkoes at best a lot of the time without Swords Dance making it wallable by anything with recovery, and its typing combined with its mediocre bulk makes it nearly useless defensively. I've never seen a game where Sandslash wants RestTalk, but I've seen a lot of games where it gets screwed over from not having Swords Dance. It's crucial for Sandslash in general.
Dragonite has a strong, unwallable 4 attack set with HP Flying and Dynamic Punch. RestTalk ThunderBeam is much worse by comparison as no STAB means it lacks solid damage output against neutral targets, and leaves it especially open to exploitation by most physical mons with setup. You'd want HP Flying for Beedrill/Pinsir/Curse Fightings in particular. Dynamic Punch can also be necessary for breaking through certain walls sometimes.
Mr. Mime can get Encore, Hypnosis, Thief, Barrier + Baton Pass, all of which can stop opponent setup or support teammates. Despite that, it can also roll RestTalk despite its fragility and lack of utility, and it may not even have Thunder there, so you might not have that way to make progress with it.
Flareon is very useful and unique with GrowthPass. I'd find it hard to want RestTalk instead with how slow and fragile it is, and the way worse Rocks matchup.
Azumarill can be walled easily if it runs Curse+DEdge, and struggles to set it up if the opponent has any Thunder or especially Razor Leaf users. In addition, if you implement the one RestTalk user per type limit I mentioned, that means your only RestTalk Water will likely lose to Rocks if you generate this set. Its Surf + RestTalk set is better in this regard, and Light Screen/Toxic/Ice Beam can all be helpful.
Marowak is even more fragile and slow than Sandslash is. RestTalk is more justifiable on it since it doesn't need Swords Dance to do damage, but missing out on the ability to boost is still a loss. RestTalk Marowak's lack of coverage is commonly an issue too.
Rhydon isn't as bad as Sandslash with RestTalk as it hits more 3hko thresholds and the Rock typing gives it some defensive utility. Its Curse+Roar set is usually better at capitalising on these positive matchups though, and it can be useful in other matchups where RestTalk is unlikely to be. RestTalk Rhydon losing to Curse Normals is unpleasant.
Houndoom is very frail like Flareon, and has lots of great offensive tools like Sunny Day, SolarBeam, Pursuit, and Counter.

While RestTalk allows these mons to be status absorbers, you'll probably generate other RestTalk users, so it's not a major argument in their favour. Also, in games where you don't have to deal with Spikes, if you're smart about how you switch these mons in, you can heal most of them up via Leftovers instead, which can make Rest unnecessary.

Zapdos
I'd suggest adding a chance for a new offensive set, while keeping its preexisting RestTalk set:

Item: Leftovers
Thunderbolt / Thunder
Thunder Wave
Hidden Power Water / Hidden Power Grass
Drill Peck

This set is really scary against almost anything that's not pure Electric type, and Thunder Wave is huge for aiding breaking and supporting setup mons. It'd also be one of the only Electric types that carries coverage for Steelix/Quagsire. Here are some calcs:
Calcs
Lvl 65 Zapdos Hidden Power Water vs. Lvl 65 Steelix: 103-122 (44.3 - 52.5%) -- guaranteed 3HKO after Leftovers recovery
Lvl 65 Zapdos Hidden Power Water vs. Lvl 77 Magcargo: 156-184 (71.8 - 84.7%) -- guaranteed 2HKO after Leftovers recovery
Lvl 65 Zapdos Hidden Power Water/Grass vs. Lvl 65 Golem: 207-244 (86.6 - 102%) -- 15.4% chance to OHKO
Lvl 65 Zapdos Hidden Power Water/Grass vs. Lvl 65 Rhydon: 251-296 (92.6 - 109.2%) -- 56.4% chance to OHKO
Lvl 65 Zapdos Hidden Power Grass vs. Lvl 69 Quagsire: 197-232 (71.8 - 84.6%) -- guaranteed 2HKO after Leftovers recovery

Lvl 65 Zapdos Drill Peck vs. Lvl 65 Heracross: 265-312 (113.2 - 133.3%) -- guaranteed OHKO
Lvl 65 Zapdos Drill Peck vs. Lvl 81 Parasect: 204-240 (81.6 - 96%) -- guaranteed 2HKO after Leftovers recovery
Lvl 65 Zapdos Drill Peck vs. Lvl 65 Machamp: 127-150 (50.3 - 59.5%) -- 84.5% chance to 2HKO after Leftovers recovery
Lvl 65 Zapdos Drill Peck vs. Lvl 77 Hitmonchan: 108-128 (47.1 - 55.8%) -- 20.8% chance to 2HKO after Leftovers recovery
Lvl 65 Zapdos Drill Peck vs. Lvl 73 Hitmontop: 102-120 (45.7 - 53.8%) -- 2.7% chance to 2HKO after Leftovers recovery
Lvl 65 Zapdos Drill Peck vs. Lvl 73 Hitmonlee: 142-168 (63.6 - 75.3%) -- guaranteed 2HKO after Leftovers recovery
Lvl 65 Zapdos Drill Peck vs. Lvl 73 Primeape: 132-156 (55.2 - 65.2%) -- guaranteed 2HKO
Lvl 65 Zapdos Drill Peck vs. Lvl 81 Sunflora: 124-146 (43.2 - 50.8%) -- guaranteed 3HKO after Leftovers recovery
Lvl 65 Zapdos Drill Peck vs. Lvl 67 Venusaur: 122-144 (49.5 - 58.5%) -- 70.3% chance to 2HKO after Leftovers recovery
Lvl 65 Zapdos Drill Peck vs. Lvl 69 Victreebel: 134-158 (52.9 - 62.4%) -- guaranteed 2HKO after Leftovers recovery
Lvl 65 Zapdos Drill Peck vs. Lvl 69 Vileplume: 114-134 (48.5 - 57%) -- 43.1% chance to 2HKO after Leftovers recovery
Lvl 65 Zapdos Drill Peck vs. Lvl 65 Exeggutor: 122-144 (50.2 - 59.2%) -- 79.9% chance to 2HKO after Leftovers recovery
Lvl 65 Zapdos Drill Peck vs. Lvl 67 Meganium: 107-126 (43.4 - 51.2%) -- guaranteed 3HKO after Leftovers recovery
Lvl 65 Zapdos Drill Peck vs. Lvl 73 Bellossom: 108-128 (41.5 - 49.2%) -- guaranteed 3HKO after Leftovers recovery
Lvl 65 Zapdos Drill Peck vs. Lvl 79 Beedrill: 149-176 (59.1 - 69.8%) -- guaranteed 2HKO after Leftovers recovery
Lvl 65 Zapdos Drill Peck vs. Lvl 81 Ariados: 112-132 (40.1 - 47.3%) -- guaranteed 3HKO after Leftovers recovery
Lvl 65 Zapdos Drill Peck vs. Lvl 77 Venomoth: 129-152 (52.2 - 61.5%) -- 98.1% chance to 2HKO after Leftovers recovery
Lvl 65 Zapdos Drill Peck vs. Lvl 65 Blissey: 133-157 (28.5 - 33.6%) -- 97.4% chance to 4HKO after Leftovers recovery
Hidden Power Grass can also be a more reliable way for Zapdos to hit Waters if it generates Thunder.

Offensive Zapdos sets similar to this are used in GSC OU.

Vaporeon and Politoed
I'd suggest adding a chance for a new Substitute set, while keeping their preexisting RestTalk sets:

Item: Leftovers
Hydro Pump
Growth
Substitute
Ice Beam (or 50/50 Ice Beam / Baton Pass for Vaporeon)

Hydro Pump hits nice ranges at +1, being able to 2HKO a lot of bulky non-resists, including Raikou and Ampharos, and makes sense with the lack of Rest recovery. Surf may still be runnable though.
Substitute helps against Thunder users, especially sleeping ones that will only have a ~23% hit chance with it, and it can really punish any mon that can't reliably break it, like other Waters or RestTalk mons.
Ice Beam is mainly for hitting Grasses and Dragonite, which Vaporeon and Politoed are weak to at the moment.
Baton Pass is self-explanatory, but it would be nice to have it on Vaporeon as it would make it the only SubPasser in the format. It would also give it a better matchup against Swords Dance Waters.

Substitute Vaporeon has had decent success in GSC OU.

Dodrio
I'd suggest adding a chance for a new Flail set, while keeping its preexisting RestTalk set:

Item: Pink Bow/Polkadot Bow
Return
Endure
Flail
Drill Peck

Dodrio is pretty fast, gets STAB from Flail unlike Reversal Yanma, and has a great Spikes immunity unlike Reversal Primeape so you can reliably preserve it when it's at 1%. I've included some example 1HP Flail calcs in the spoiler below:
1HP Flail Calcs
Lvl 69 Pink Bow Dodrio Flail (200 BP) vs. Lvl 65 Machamp: 255-255 (101.1 - 101.1%) -- guaranteed OHKO
Lvl 69 Pink Bow Dodrio Flail (200 BP) vs. Lvl 67 Charizard: 247-247 (101.6 - 101.6%) -- guaranteed OHKO
Lvl 69 Pink Bow Dodrio Flail (200 BP) vs. Lvl 77 Hitmonchan: 217-217 (94.7 - 94.7%) -- guaranteed 2HKO after Leftovers recovery
Lvl 69 Pink Bow Dodrio Flail (200 BP) vs. Lvl 73 Pidgeot: 237-237 (91.1 - 91.1%) -- guaranteed 2HKO after Leftovers recovery
Lvl 69 Pink Bow Dodrio Flail (200 BP) vs. Lvl 67 Kangaskhan: 243-243 (86.7 - 86.7%) -- guaranteed 2HKO after Leftovers recovery
Lvl 69 Pink Bow Dodrio Flail (200 BP) vs. Lvl 69 Ampharos: 252-252 (94.3 - 94.3%) -- guaranteed 2HKO after Leftovers recovery
Lvl 69 Pink Bow Dodrio Flail (200 BP) vs. Lvl 77 Arbok: 234-234 (93.2 - 93.2%) -- guaranteed 2HKO after Leftovers recovery
Lvl 69 Pink Bow Dodrio Flail (200 BP) vs. Lvl 77 Azumarill: 213-213 (68.2 - 68.2%) -- guaranteed 2HKO after Leftovers recovery
Lvl 69 Pink Bow Dodrio Flail (200 BP) vs. Lvl 65 Suicune: 198-198 (74.7 - 74.7%) -- guaranteed 2HKO after Leftovers recovery

Lvl 69 Pink Bow Dodrio Flail (200 BP) vs. Lvl 67 Scizor: 105-105 (47.2 - 47.2%) -- guaranteed 3HKO after Leftovers recovery
Lvl 69 Pink Bow Dodrio Flail (200 BP) vs. Lvl 65 Golem: 90-90 (37.6 - 37.6%) -- guaranteed 3HKO after Leftovers recovery
Lvl 69 Pink Bow Dodrio Flail (200 BP) vs. Lvl 65 Rhydon: 96-96 (35.4 - 35.4%) -- guaranteed 4HKO after Leftovers recovery
Lvl 69 Pink Bow Dodrio Flail (200 BP) vs. Lvl 73 Sudowoodo: 88-88 (34.7 - 34.7%) -- guaranteed 4HKO after Leftovers recovery
Lvl 69 Pink Bow Dodrio Flail (200 BP) vs. Lvl 65 Steelix: 65-65 (28 - 28%) -- guaranteed 5HKO after Leftovers recovery

Drill Peck is most likely the best fourth move as it lets Dodrio threaten Bugs/Fightings/Grasses without having to lose HP. I've thought about HP Ground, but I don't think it's worth it as it drops Attack DVs and is outdamaged by 1HP Flail except against Magcargo.

Quagsire
Quagsire used to run Belly Drum in Randbats, but it ran Rest at the time, which didn't work out as Quagsire doesn't have the bulk for it. However, with the prevalence of RestTalk users, Quagsire would absolutely be able to find setup opportunities. Electrics are particularly weak against it for instance as they only have one move that can damage Quagsire while they're sleeping. I'd suggest adding a chance for a new Belly Drum set with Protect instead, while keeping its preexisting RestTalk set:

Item: Leftovers
Earthquake
Belly Drum
Sludge Bomb / Hidden Power Rock
Protect

Protect helps Quagsire get Leftovers recovery after using Belly Drum, potentially allowing it to heal out of KO ranges while boosted. If Quagsire is forced to switch out, the easier healing can help it be able to eventually use Belly Drum again later in the game.

Belly Drum calcs:
+6 Calcs
The Earthquake calcs are assuming HP Rock is being run. If SBomb or AP is used instead, the Earthquake calcs are 0.5%-2% higher depending on target. HP Rock also slightly drops bulk, leading to Quagsire taking roughly 1.5%-2% more from physical attacks.

+6 Lvl 69 Quagsire Earthquake vs. Lvl 67 Tauros: 284-334 (118.8 - 139.7%) -- guaranteed OHKO
+6 Lvl 69 Quagsire Earthquake vs. Lvl 67 Kangaskhan: 316-372 (112.8 - 132.8%) -- guaranteed OHKO
+6 Lvl 69 Quagsire Earthquake vs. Lvl 73 Lickitung: 302-355 (107 - 125.8%) -- guaranteed OHKO
+6 Lvl 69 Quagsire Earthquake vs. Lvl 65 Suicune: 257-303 (96.9 - 114.3%) -- 82.1% chance to OHKO
+6 Lvl 69 Quagsire Earthquake vs. Lvl 67 Donphan: 243-286 (95.6 - 112.5%) -- 74.4% chance to OHKO
+6 Lvl 69 Quagsire Earthquake vs. Lvl 65 Cloyster: 184-217 (92 - 108.5%) -- 51.3% chance to OHKO
+6 Lvl 69 Quagsire Earthquake vs. Lvl 77 Azumarill: 278-327 (89.1 - 104.8%) -- 30.8% chance to OHKO

Sludge Bomb OHKOes all Grasses weak to it at +6.

+6 Lvl 69 Quagsire Hidden Power Rock vs. Lvl 81 Jumpluff: 272-320 (99.2 - 116.7%) -- 94.9% chance to OHKO
+6 Lvl 69 Quagsire Hidden Power Rock vs. Lvl 81 Parasect: 245-288 (98 - 115.2%) -- 87.2% chance to OHKO
+6 Lvl 69 Quagsire Hidden Power Rock vs. Lvl 81 Togetic: 236-278 (92.5 - 109%) -- 56.4% chance to OHKO
+6 Lvl 69 Quagsire Hidden Power Rock vs. Lvl 61 Lugia: 233-274 (90.6 - 106.6%) -- 41% chance to OHKO

I have also done Ancient Power calcs, but they're worse. HP Rock is better (and more honest).
Ancient Power
+6 Lvl 69 Quagsire Ancient Power vs. Lvl 69 Pinsir: 217-256 (98.1 - 115.8%) -- 89.7% chance to OHKO
+6 Lvl 69 Quagsire Ancient Power vs. Lvl 69 Gyarados: 258-304 (98 - 115.5%) -- 89.7% chance to OHKO
+6 Lvl 69 Quagsire Ancient Power vs. Lvl 73 Pidgeot: 253-298 (97.3 - 114.6%) -- 84.6% chance to OHKO
+6 Lvl 69 Quagsire Ancient Power vs. Lvl 77 Noctowl: 292-344 (93.5 - 110.2%) -- 61.5% chance to OHKO
+6 Lvl 69 Quagsire Ancient Power vs. Lvl 77 Mantine: 241-284 (93.4 - 110%) -- 61.5% chance to OHKO
+6 Lvl 69 Quagsire Ancient Power vs. Lvl 73 Crobat: 236-278 (89.7 - 105.7%) -- 35.9% chance to OHKO
+6 Lvl 69 Quagsire Ancient Power vs. Lvl 81 Jumpluff: 236-278 (86.1 - 101.4%) -- 10.3% chance to OHKO
+6 Lvl 69 Quagsire Ancient Power vs. Lvl 81 Parasect: 214-252 (85.6 - 100.8%) -- 7.7% chance to OHKO
+6 Lvl 69 Quagsire Ancient Power vs. Lvl 81 Togetic: 205-242 (80.3 - 94.9%) -- guaranteed 2HKO after Leftovers recovery
+6 Lvl 69 Quagsire Ancient Power vs. Lvl 61 Lugia: 202-238 (78.5 - 92.6%) -- guaranteed 2HKO after Leftovers recovery

Venusaur
I don't think Growth Venusaur can work in a high level game. It's far too slow, too weak, not bulky enough for the amount of time it needs to set up, has a worse defensive typing than Sunflora and Tangela, and on top of those issues it'll always have coverage problems. You can't really buff its level either as all its core problems will still remain, so you'd just be making it more matchup reliant. I would therefore remove the Growth set, and have Venusaur generate the below set instead:

Item: Leftovers
Razor Leaf
Synthesis
Sleep Powder / Leech Seed
Reflect / Light Screen / Leech Seed

This would have a number of advantages over the existing Growth set.
  • It still scares out most Waters/Rocks/Grounds, which is one of the main things Venusaur is useful for
  • It can use screens to support setup mons, or help with recovering slow Rest/Recover mons at low HP
  • It can use Leech Seed to annoy bulky/setup mons, especially in conjunction with screens. Razor Leaf is also significantly more threatening against Leech Seeded mons. For example, Razor Leaf is a guaranteed 4HKO on Leech Seeded Tauros, so a single crit would break through it if it tries to Rest loop. Razor Leaf also has plenty of PP so you can justify going for this if you need to.
  • It needs less time to be useful than Growth
  • It's unique; hardly anything runs Leech Seed or screens, but Venusaur does not have good offensive options so it should run them
GSC UU tested Venusaur recently and people ran similar sets to the one I proposed above.

Ho-Oh
I'd suggest removing the Whirlwind + Toxic set. It makes sense in GSC Ubers due to the Pokemon that are viable there, but in Randbats Ho-Oh's Level is far too low for Flamethrower to be threatening and there's a huge prevalence of RestTalk Normals/Fires/Waters/Electrics etc that wall it forever. Whirlwind isn't enough for setup mons by itself either.

I think Ho-Oh had another set in its place before, though I don't remember what it was, maybe it was Curse + HPFlying + Whirlwind + Recover? If it was that, it'd be more useful as an offensive threat that can beat a lot of Curse users and win some endgames. That being said, it's got a worse defensive typing for this than Lugia, so it's not unreasonable for it to stay gone.

Aerodactyl
I'd suggest removing the Curse 3 Attacks set. While I get it can be appealing to have both Rock and Flying coverage on the same set on paper, I don't think it's practical. Unless it gets absurdly lucky, this set is unable to break through Curse Normals with recovery and eventually loses to them. With the Roar set, Aerodactyl can boost up against Normals a lot of the time, and then phase them out to gain an advantage, while its Rest set allows it to remain healthy and stall them out. With the 3 Attacks set, you get neither of these benefits, and you're also less likely to have other strong answers to Normal types on your team due to type and weakness limits, which is an issue as Normals tend to be solid progress makers. Setting this aside, it's not a good lategame cleaner either, as Curse ruins Aerodactyl's speed stat and makes it easier for Waters and Electrics to answer it. Put simply, it's weak offensively and doesn't offer much defensively unless the opponent generates a bad team.

With regards to Aerodactyl's other sets, I think it should be able to generate either HP Flying or Rock instead of just Rock. HP Flying is important coverage for Aerodactyl too to avoid it losing to Fightings and Growth Grasses, and even without HP Rock, Aerodactyl would still have moves for Bugs/Fires. It'd only miss out on having coverage for Flyings/Ices, and Aerodactyl still matches up well into a decent amount of Flyings anyway.
Part 3: Level Balancing Suggestions
If you decide to implement the other suggestions I outlined, I think it's best to hold off on level balancing changes until people are familiar with the new format, with a few exceptions I talk about below, as they'll be broken no matter what else you do.

Shuckle
Shuckle comfortably walls most mons in the format, only fearing Waters running STAB Surf or Hydro Pump and the rare Rocks/Fightings that carry boosting moves. Combined with its extremely potent DCurl + Rollout combination, it's often an unbreakable wall and an unstoppable force in the games it generates in, and if you don't generate something that can break it, your best bet is to fish for good luck with things like Psychic SpDef drops or Ice Beam freezes or sleep moves, and teamgen of course isn't guaranteed to give you these things.

I think testing out nerfing Shuckle to around level 63 would be a good first step towards balancing it, and then its level can be tweaked afterwards if necessary. If you're apprehensive about nerfing it that hard in one go, I get it, but I think it's necessary if you want it to be halfway reasonable. Here are some calcs:

Level 63 Shuckle calcs
Special attackers
Lvl 69 Magneton Thunder vs. Lvl 63 Shuckle: 59-70 (37.8 - 44.8%) -- guaranteed 3HKO after Leftovers recovery
Lvl 69 Ampharos Thunder vs. Lvl 63 Shuckle: 58-69 (37.1 - 44.2%) -- guaranteed 3HKO after Leftovers recovery
Lvl 65 Zapdos Thunder vs. Lvl 63 Shuckle: 56-66 (35.8 - 42.3%) -- 94.7% chance to 3HKO after Leftovers recovery
Lvl 65 Raikou Thunder vs. Lvl 63 Shuckle: 53-63 (33.9 - 40.3%) -- 50.9% chance to 3HKO after Leftovers recovery
Lvl 71 Raichu Thunder vs. Lvl 63 Shuckle: 53-63 (33.9 - 40.3%) -- 50.9% chance to 3HKO after Leftovers recovery
Lvl 71 Raichu Surf vs. Lvl 63 Shuckle: 56-66 (35.8 - 42.3%) -- 94.7% chance to 3HKO after Leftovers recovery
Lvl 69 Electabuzz Thunder vs. Lvl 63 Shuckle: 51-61 (32.6 - 39.1%) -- 12.5% chance to 3HKO after Leftovers recovery
Lvl 69 Electrode Thunder vs. Lvl 63 Shuckle: 45-54 (28.8 - 34.6%) -- 99.9% chance to 4HKO after Leftovers recovery
Lvl 65 Alakazam Psychic vs. Lvl 63 Shuckle: 45-54 (28.8 - 34.6%) -- 99.9% chance to 4HKO after Leftovers recovery
Lvl 65 Exeggutor Psychic vs. Lvl 63 Shuckle: 43-51 (27.5 - 32.6%) -- 84.2% chance to 4HKO after Leftovers recovery
Lvl 59 Mewtwo Psychic vs. Lvl 63 Shuckle: 40-48 (25.6 - 30.7%) -- 5.8% chance to 4HKO after Leftovers recovery
Lvl 67 Moltres Fire Blast vs. Lvl 63 Shuckle: 58-69 (37.1 - 44.2%) -- guaranteed 3HKO after Leftovers recovery
Lvl 67 Moltres Fire Blast vs. Lvl 63 Shuckle in Sun: 87-103 (55.7 - 66%) -- guaranteed 2HKO after Leftovers recovery
Lvl 77 Magcargo Fire Blast vs. Lvl 63 Shuckle: 56-66 (35.8 - 42.3%) -- 94.7% chance to 3HKO after Leftovers recovery
Lvl 71 Magmar Fire Blast vs. Lvl 63 Shuckle: 57-67 (36.5 - 42.9%) -- 98.9% chance to 3HKO after Leftovers recovery
Lvl 71 Magmar Fire Blast vs. Lvl 63 Shuckle in Sun: 85-100 (54.4 - 64.1%) -- guaranteed 2HKO after Leftovers recovery
Lvl 67 Houndoom Fire Blast vs. Lvl 63 Shuckle: 53-63 (33.9 - 40.3%) -- 50.9% chance to 3HKO after Leftovers recovery
Lvl 67 Houndoom Fire Blast vs. Lvl 63 Shuckle in Sun: 79-94 (50.6 - 60.2%) -- 91.5% chance to 2HKO after Leftovers recovery
Lvl 73 Ninetales/Rapidash Fire Blast vs. Lvl 63 Shuckle: 51-61 (32.6 - 39.1%) -- 12.5% chance to 3HKO after Leftovers recovery
Lvl 73 Ninetales/Rapidash Fire Blast vs. Lvl 63 Shuckle in Sun: 77-91 (49.3 - 58.3%) -- 69.2% chance to 2HKO after Leftovers recovery
Lvl 67 Entei Fire Blast vs. Lvl 63 Shuckle: 46-55 (29.4 - 35.2%) -- guaranteed 4HKO after Leftovers recovery
Lvl 71 Qwilfish Hydro Pump vs. Lvl 63 Shuckle: 81-96 (51.9 - 61.5%) -- 98.6% chance to 2HKO after Leftovers recovery
Lvl 67 Tentacruel Hydro Pump vs. Lvl 63 Shuckle: 86-102 (55.1 - 65.3%) -- guaranteed 2HKO after Leftovers recovery
Lvl 71 Kabutops Hydro Pump vs. Lvl 63 Shuckle: 86-102 (55.1 - 65.3%) -- guaranteed 2HKO after Leftovers recovery

Physical attackers
Lvl 65 Heracross Megahorn vs. Lvl 63 Shuckle: 56-66 (35.8 - 42.3%) -- 94.7% chance to 3HKO after Leftovers recovery
Lvl 67 Scizor Hidden Power Steel vs. Lvl 63 Shuckle: 71-84 (45.5 - 53.8%) -- 3% chance to 2HKO after Leftovers recovery
Lvl 65 Steelix Iron Tail vs. Lvl 63 Shuckle: 73-86 (46.7 - 55.1%) -- 12.8% chance to 2HKO after Leftovers recovery
Lvl 77 Raticate Iron Tail vs. Lvl 63 Shuckle: 64-76 (41 - 48.7%) -- guaranteed 3HKO after Leftovers recovery
Lvl 73 Furret Iron Tail vs. Lvl 63 Shuckle: 56-66 (35.8 - 42.3%) -- 94.7% chance to 3HKO after Leftovers recovery
Lvl 65 Forretress Hidden Power Steel vs. Lvl 63 Shuckle: 52-62 (33.3 - 39.7%) -- 29% chance to 3HKO after Leftovers recovery
Lvl 73 Dugtrio Earthquake vs. Lvl 63 Shuckle: 44-52 (28.2 - 33.3%) -- 96% chance to 4HKO after Leftovers recovery
Lvl 67 Donphan Earthquake vs. Lvl 63 Shuckle: 46-55 (29.4 - 35.2%) -- guaranteed 4HKO after Leftovers recovery
Lvl 69 Sandslash Earthquake vs. Lvl 63 Shuckle: 44-52 (28.2 - 33.3%) -- 96% chance to 4HKO after Leftovers recovery
Lvl 67 Nidoking Earthquake vs. Lvl 63 Shuckle: 39-46 (25 - 29.4%) -- 0.1% chance to 4HKO after Leftovers recovery
Lvl 67 Nidoking Ice Beam vs. Lvl 63 Shuckle: 24-29 (15.3 - 18.5%) -- possible 8HKO
Lvl 73 Gligar Earthquake vs. Lvl 63 Shuckle: 41-49 (26.2 - 31.4%) -- 25.2% chance to 4HKO after Leftovers recovery
Lvl 69 Piloswine Earthquake vs. Lvl 63 Shuckle: 44-52 (28.2 - 33.3%) -- 96% chance to 4HKO after Leftovers recovery
Lvl 69 Piloswine Ice Beam vs. Lvl 63 Shuckle: 31-37 (19.8 - 23.7%) -- possible 6HKO
Lvl 77 Hitmonchan High Jump Kick vs. Lvl 63 Shuckle: 46-55 (29.4 - 35.2%) -- guaranteed 4HKO after Leftovers recovery
Lvl 77 Hitmonchan Hidden Power Rock vs. Lvl 63 Shuckle: 52-62 (33.3 - 39.7%) -- 29% chance to 3HKO after Leftovers recovery
Lvl 73 Hitmontop High Jump Kick vs. Lvl 63 Shuckle: 41-49 (26.2 - 31.4%) -- 25.2% chance to 4HKO after Leftovers recovery
Lvl 73 Hitmontop Hidden Power Rock vs. Lvl 63 Shuckle: 45-54 (28.8 - 34.6%) -- 99.9% chance to 4HKO after Leftovers recovery
Lvl 65 Machamp Cross Chop vs. Lvl 63 Shuckle: 48-57 (30.7 - 36.5%) -- guaranteed 4HKO after Leftovers recovery
  • Shuckle would still inarguably be the best wall for Normal-types in the format at level 63, and it would still wall plenty of other things on top of that:
    • Various physical setup mons, notably numerous overpowered Swords Dance users (Beedrill, Pinsir, Victreebel, etc)
    • Fightings/Grounds without setup moves
    • Weaker Fire Blast/Thunder users like HPGrass Ninetales, Entei, Electabuzz, and Electrode either 4HKO or, at best, have small 3HKO chances
    • Everything relying on weaker STAB moves (Flamethrower, Thunderbolt, HP Flying, Drill Peck, etc)
    • Keep in mind a lot of the mons I listed in the spoiler above that would be able to break Level 63 Shuckle would still have problems like bad accuracy/PP/potential wallability by other mons
  • Adding onto the above, I want to bring up Skarmory as a comparison. It's the only mon that comes close to Shuckle at walling Normals, but it's incapable of walling anything with Thunder or Fire Blast coverage, it can't wall special attackers, and it doesn't have anywhere near the offensive prowess Shuckle does. Skarmory is currently level 65, eight levels below current Shuckle, so surely you can't justify Shuckle being any higher than that. Don't buff Skarmory either by the way.
  • Curse Rocks/Fightings without RestTalk would be more reliable at beating Shuckle. Currently, Rhydon and Sudowoodo are outsped by Shuckle after a single Curse, which can make them far less reliable at beating it than you might think.
  • DCurl-boosted Rollout 5 still OHKOes most non-resists from full at Level 63, and it wouldn't be difficult for Shuckle to get there with correct play. It walls a lot of things and sleeping RestTalk mons can't reliably damage it well.
  • Allowing other mons to break Shuckle would help prevent unwinnable matchups.
I feel like I've demonstrated sufficiently at this point that you can drop Shuckle 10 levels and it'd still be a great mon. Likely it'd still be overpowered. However, if this isn't convincing yet, let's say you only nerfed it 5 levels instead. I'll explain why that isn't enough.
Level 68 Shuckle calcs and comments
Lvl 69 Magneton Thunder vs. Lvl 68 Shuckle: 56-66 (33.3 - 39.2%) -- 13.6% chance to 3HKO after Leftovers recovery
Lvl 69 Ampharos Thunder vs. Lvl 68 Shuckle: 54-64 (32.1 - 38%) -- 0.7% chance to 3HKO after Leftovers recovery
Lvl 67 Moltres Fire Blast vs. Lvl 68 Shuckle: 54-64 (32.1 - 38%) -- 0.7% chance to 3HKO after Leftovers recovery
Lvl 67 Moltres Fire Blast vs. Lvl 68 Shuckle in Sun: 81-96 (48.2 - 57.1%) -- 44.4% chance to 2HKO after Leftovers recovery
Lvl 71 Magmar Fire Blast vs. Lvl 68 Shuckle: 53-63 (31.5 - 37.5%) -- 0.1% chance to 3HKO after Leftovers recovery
Lvl 65 Alakazam Psychic vs. Lvl 68 Shuckle: 41-49 (24.4 - 29.1%) -- possible 5HKO
Lvl 65 Exeggutor Psychic vs. Lvl 68 Shuckle: 39-46 (23.2 - 27.3%) -- possible 5HKO
Lvl 71 Qwilfish Hydro Pump vs. Lvl 68 Shuckle: 76-90 (45.2 - 53.5%) -- 1% chance to 2HKO after Leftovers recovery
Lvl 67 Tentacruel Hydro Pump vs. Lvl 68 Shuckle: 81-96 (48.2 - 57.1%) -- 44.4% chance to 2HKO after Leftovers recovery
Lvl 71 Kabutops Hydro Pump vs. Lvl 68 Shuckle: 81-96 (48.2 - 57.1%) -- 44.4% chance to 2HKO after Leftovers recovery

Most mons still have poor damage calcs against Level 68 Shuckle, and this is without taking into account that a lot of these moves have other drawbacks. The best Thunder users will still generally only 4HKO it, and they of course need to hit that 70% several times. Fire Blast has terrible PP, imperfect accuracy, and can be easily wallable depending on what's running it. Psychic needs the 10% special defence drop to actually win, but it only has 16PP and your opponent can often switch out of it safely if you do manage to get the drop.

I've also listed some weaker Hydro Pump calcs. They similarly suck, considering it has only 8 PP in this gen. Shuckle can switch out and tank the pumps with something else, or Rest to stall a bit if it needs to; if they manage to run out your PP, Shuckle walls these mons afterwards. Also, at the moment not all Water types are guaranteed to generate Water moves - Azumarill and Lapras are examples, and having them means you're less likely to have other Waters too. Even RestTalk Waters with Surf can be pretty wallable by other mons. Therefore, even if you do generate a Water, it might not be enough depending on the situation.

One positive thing that can be said about 68 Shuckle is that Rocks/Fightings with setup would be more reliable at breaking it. However, this is a really flimsy nerf. First off, there's only around like 10 Rocks/Fightings that break Shuckle more reliably from this change, but most of them will still need boosting moves to break it, and almost none of them are guaranteed to roll them. If they do generate setup moves, oftentimes it's easily wallable Curse RestTalk sets. It's not going to matter that you have a Curse RestTalk Hitmontop for Shuckle if your opponent has a hard counter to it. Other sets like Curse + Roar Rhydon are vulnerable to Toxic instead and won't have that much time to break Shuckle if you don't have a Water to scare it out as it Rests. Needing to hit Cross Chop/Rock Slide/High Jump Kick multiple times in succession becomes an issue in these cases.

I could say more, but the bottom line is Shuckle can still play around even the few mons that can break it, so simply generating one mon for it may not be and often isn't enough. This is why there needs to be other ways to threaten it.

Poliwhirl and certain Swords Dance mons
Poliwhirl requires no introduction at this point and other people seem to agree with nerfing it again, so there's no need for me to go into detail here. 209 speed is still too good when Poliwhirl has both an accurate sleep move and a boosting move that lets it reach +6 in one turn. I don't have a specific level suggestion since I've been focusing on other things in this post, but I think it'd be fair for Poliwhirl to be unable to OHKO anything from full at +6 except fragile mons or mons weak to its coverage.

Lots of Swords Dancers are overpowered for similar reasons to Poliwhirl. I'm referring to Seaking, Kingler, Victreebel, Pinsir, Beedrill, and Scyther here. Not only do a lot of them hit extremely hard, they run Substitute to take advantage of the many RestTalkers in the format that can only break it with one of their moves. Substitute also makes it safer for Seaking and Kingler to try and force their way past Electrics that have to rely on Thunder to threaten them, especially if the Electrics have been pressured into using Rest beforehand. Most of these SD users have great defensive typings and bulk as well that allow them to set up on a plethora of mons even if they aren't sleeping. They also often have problematic speed tiers. Scyther is outsped by only 15 mons in the entire format which is a bit silly given it has Baton Pass, and its own speed tier is crowded, making dealing with it unreliable sometimes. Seaking also has an annoying speed tier that ties Nidoking and Misdreavus. Due to all of this, these mons are so strong that it takes barely any skill to get mileage out of them, and a lot of teams don't have the resources to handle these Swords Dance users well or reliably.

As broken as these mons are, they're not on the same level as Poliwhirl, so I can see why you'd want to hold off on nerfing them until you know how they're affected by other suggestions in this post. However, I'd speculate that they would almost definitely continue to be broken. I'd expect the suggestions I've made to cut down on redundancy and lower quality sets more than RestTalk as a whole, and that as a result most teams would still have 1-2 or maybe 3 RestTalkers for these mons to take advantage of. Setting that aside, these mons would still have all of their other upsides and be able to set up on most things that they'd be able to before, so they'd only be slightly worse. Given that, I think it'd be fine to go ahead with nerfing the Swords Dance users I mentioned one or two levels, although waiting is still understandable.

That's everything I think is worth considering at the moment. In short, I think the best way to start improving GSC Randbats right now would be to limit teams to two weaknesses of any given type and one RestTalk user per type, make moveset changes to allow useful offensive sets to be generated more often, and level nerf only a few mons that will be broken no matter what other changes you make.

Thank you for reading.
 
Back
Top