• Follow our Instagram!
  • Curious about what we're currently doing about bots? Check out the latest updates from staff in this thread.

(Little) Things that annoy you in Pokémon

Garganacl was made in the wrong generation. The concept is amazing: after a lot of failures to make a strong physically defensive Rock-type, we get something good recovery, a strong defensive Ability, and a unique damage-over-time that's tailored to hit two of the best defensive types especially hard, but all of that fits the flavour (heh) so well you can still barely tell these are done for power reasons. Heck, the theme probably could have let them get away with having Salt Cure hitting the other top 3 defensive type (Fairy) as well.

And then all that effort gets wasted by making it no longer a Rock type.
 
Ironmage said:
Garganacl was made in the wrong generation. The concept is amazing: after a lot of failures to make a strong physically defensive Rock-type, we get something good recovery, a strong defensive Ability, and a unique damage-over-time that's tailored to hit two of the best defensive types especially hard, but all of that fits the flavour (heh) so well you can still barely tell these are done for power reasons. Heck, the theme probably could have let them get away with having Salt Cure hitting the other top 3 defensive type (Fairy) as well.

And then all that effort gets wasted by making it no longer a Rock type.
Well, an unexpected upside to the "new gimmicks every gen that get forgotten in a gen or two to make room for the all the other gimmicks" is that sooner or later Garganacl will exist in an official environment without being able to change types.
 
Ravenson said:
Well, an unexpected upside to the "new gimmicks every gen that get forgotten in a gen or two to make room for the all the other gimmicks" is that sooner or later Garganacl will exist in an official environment without being able to change types.
Garganacl exists currently in an official environment without being able to change types and they nerfed the shit out of Salt Cure.
 
One little thing that still gets on my nerves, even after all these years, is how many otherwise ordinary Pokemon are locked behind trade evolutions or version exclusives. I can understand keeping a few rare ones special, but it feels strange when a perfectly normal line is basically unfinished in your own game unless you find someone else to trade with. It is even worse when you are trying to finish a Pokedex in Scarlet and Violet, because you can do almost everything yourself and then hit that one evolution that just stops you in your tracks. I know trading is meant to be part of the social side of Pokemon, and I do enjoy it when it works out, but relying on a stranger or a second copy of the game for something so basic always felt like a chore rather than a feature. The same goes for version exclusives that are not even particularly rare or powerful, since they just turn a casual playthrough into a checklist of things you cannot get on your own. I would much rather have an in-game item or a simple level requirement for those evolutions, even if it took a bit longer, because then the reward would actually feel earned instead of borrowed.
 
AgnieszkaWojcik said:
One little thing that still gets on my nerves, even after all these years, is how many otherwise ordinary Pokemon are locked behind trade evolutions or version exclusives. I can understand keeping a few rare ones special, but it feels strange when a perfectly normal line is basically unfinished in your own game unless you find someone else to trade with. It is even worse when you are trying to finish a Pokedex in Scarlet and Violet, because you can do almost everything yourself and then hit that one evolution that just stops you in your tracks. I know trading is meant to be part of the social side of Pokemon, and I do enjoy it when it works out, but relying on a stranger or a second copy of the game for something so basic always felt like a chore rather than a feature. The same goes for version exclusives that are not even particularly rare or powerful, since they just turn a casual playthrough into a checklist of things you cannot get on your own. I would much rather have an in-game item or a simple level requirement for those evolutions, even if it took a bit longer, because then the reward would actually feel earned instead of borrowed.
I think ever since trading became widespread with the advent of Online interaction, Trading has inherently lost its "mystique" or novelty as an evolution method, since you always have the option, just not necessarily convenient (per someone else's availability).

At that point, they should pick a lane and reserve trades for very unique interactions like Shelmet and Karrablast, and version exclusives should be less common/done away with in favor of rarity differences. RB (Yellow has its own pool) you had things like the Caterpie family and Weedle family being in both games, but rarer in one and more common in the other. Doing them like this means you CAN complete the dex on your own or use every option in the campaign, but it is easier to put together with help from other friends, obviously.

In general I think the way to push a feature is to emphasize it as convenience rather than a necessity. The latter will make players resent the requirement instead of appreciating any ease of access since they "have" to do it and thus it should be "easy."
 
AgnieszkaWojcik said:
One little thing that still gets on my nerves, even after all these years, is how many otherwise ordinary Pokemon are locked behind trade evolutions or version exclusives. I can understand keeping a few rare ones special, but it feels strange when a perfectly normal line is basically unfinished in your own game unless you find someone else to trade with. It is even worse when you are trying to finish a Pokedex in Scarlet and Violet, because you can do almost everything yourself and then hit that one evolution that just stops you in your tracks. I know trading is meant to be part of the social side of Pokemon, and I do enjoy it when it works out, but relying on a stranger or a second copy of the game for something so basic always felt like a chore rather than a feature. The same goes for version exclusives that are not even particularly rare or powerful, since they just turn a casual playthrough into a checklist of things you cannot get on your own. I would much rather have an in-game item or a simple level requirement for those evolutions, even if it took a bit longer, because then the reward would actually feel earned instead of borrowed.

Haven't they made lots of formerly trade-exclusive species accessible in other ways though? Off the top of my head without checking, Steelix, Gorebyss, Huntail, Trevenant, Kingdra, Gengar, Machamp, and Politoed at least have all been catchable without having to trade them in all the recent games they've been in.

Version exclusives are irritating for sure but I personally find it less so when they're more or less the same Pokemon (Lunatone and Solrock, Volbeat and Illumise, Petilil and Whimsicott). When there's a more protracted difference in types and builds (Zangoose and Seviper, Dragalge and Clawitzer, Murkrow and Misdreavus) it bugs me a lot more because there's more of a sense of missing out. Though as PP notes above it's kind of a hangover from when trading was generally harder to do and I agree that they should go more in the direction of changing up appearance rates between versions, or do what the Unova games did where Clamperl was catchable in both but each of its evolutions were only wild in one title. FRLG also does something similar where Grimer, Koffing, Krabby, and Horsea are catchable in both titles but wild Weezing and Seadra are exclusive to FR, with wild Muk and Kingler being exclusive to LG.
 
Back
Top