• Follow our Instagram!
  • Curious about what we're currently doing about bots? Check out the latest updates from staff in this thread.

Announcement np: SV OU Suspect Process, Round 20 - Fly Me To The Moon

Status
Not open for further replies.
So corny of me to have this post be longer than my original, but whatever. I want this pokemon unbanned.

My general arguments for the tl;drs are: 1) it checks most currently trending pokemon, making team composition less top-heavy 2) it's not as OP like before with tera blast that it can even play around zama/ 3) it checks most hyper offense which is always a good thing 4) balanced teams can properly deal with it now

moore's law said:
I don't think this helps your argument as much as you think it does. You are arguing for centralization around a few defensive pieces.
I disagree with your characterization of my post. I wasn't arguing (indirectly?) for centralization per se, just that balance can deal with Roaring Moon just fine now.

But i'll go further and say that it actually de-centralizes the meta now, at least given the current meta trends that Roaring Moon does check. I'll expound further in the next quote.
moore's law said:
- Each and every one of these can be beaten by Taunt or Sub Moon. Moltres and Zap are food for Moon, what do they even do against it if it taunts them or sets up a sub? Moltres can't roar (if taunt) or wisp it, and flamethrower does pathetic damage.
  • I haven't seen the sub sets that often. But if they have either taunt or sub, that is more likely to be an invested phys def/max HP set with less attack/speed investment.

    It'll be Sub/Taunt, DD, (your choice of Knock off, Acrobatics, Earthquake, Dragon Claw, Jaw Lock). Even at +1 proto they seem to be very counter-able now.

  • Back then a lot of people complained about the bulky tera fairy sets, because they could even 2HKO the pokemon that would normally counter them (zamazenta/ting lu), which just makes it less counter-able then.

  • (To go back to my earlier point), in this current meta though, Roaring Moon is checking a lot of currently trending Pokemon while at the same time not able to overpower past even their own checks:
    • It checks currently trending pokemon like Ceruledge. Ceruledge is surprisingly good vs. most special attackers right now, especially if you get Weak Armor's eff off.

    • In general, there has been a trending prevalence of special attackers. Special Attackers usually don't have Phys Def Bulk (exception Iron Valiant which is more of a mixed attacker). Not sure if this is an argument for or against making Roaring Moon more centralized, but at least it disrupts the meta in that fashion and makes physical attackers the wave again.

    • It will need at least 366 speed to be faster than Iron Valiant, so if you have Valiant with the proto speed boost (most common set), you should be able to at least stop Roaring Moon from setting up if not putting it within OHKO range of your priority attacker. Iron Valiant has around 200 base defense at level 100, so it is playable even with Roaring Moon at +1 and proto ATK.

      I've also been seeing Scarf Valiant much more often at around the 1500s-1700s. Not sure if that was because of Roaring Moon or it's just trending, but Roaring Moon can't really do anything about it after the proto use.

    • It checks currently the trending pokemon Cresselia somewhat, or at least chips it down significantly. Roaring Moon's SPD is pretty good, and at least makes it so that Cresselia would need to set up to +2 to just straight up OHKO Roaring Moon on a tera. Even without Tera, they have Moonblast like 25% of the time, and Ice Beam like 30% of the time (citation needed but Calcdex has proof).

    • Right now, Screens Zamazenta is trending so him and Roaring Moon don't even interact that much. But if First Turn Roaring Moon were to happen in that scenario, Screens Zama is usually max speed so there's 0 chance of a 2HKO with a proto-boosted Roaring Moon, because Reflect would be up already. So that's a counter to Roaring Moon that is still very viable.

    • Scarf Gholdengo has been very prevalent recently (personal anecdote). At least now the Razzle Dazzling Gleam will have to be their 4th move instead of something like Nasty Plot/Thunder Wave, moves which IMO makes it more annoying and harder to deal with.
  • With all things above being true, that is, in my opinion, a more varied meta than what we have now.
Anyway that's all lol hope that convinces people to unban
 
Last edited:
658Greninja said:
Ban. Keep this guy out of OU lmao.

:sv/roaring_moon:
First I just wanna say that it’s not cause of Moon is this unwallable demon. As a matter of fact, Balance was very popular during the last few days Moon was legal. The best answers to Moon (Ting-Lu, Tickle Mola, Lokix, Phys Def Gliscor, Molt, etc) are all Balance mons with Ting-Lu being splashable on BO. Moon’s strongest matchups are BOs and opposing HO offense structures. Moon often just needs 1-2 boosts to start tearing through these teams; its bulky enough with support from defense investment and/or screens while most priority in the tier struggles to pick it off. Moon Vs Moon matchups just become about who can position their Moon to win.

https://replay.pokemonshowdown.com/gen9ou-2709382794-ncat6c2l2vll0r7w0jw77283h6228r2pw

Testing Moon before suspecting Light Clay was not the right call. Screens is already a hot topic and Moon would be the best screens abuser. Before Moon’s ban, Deo and Ayy Tales were the primary screens setters but now Zama is used. Its bulk makes it incredibly consistent at getting them up.

Calcs with Screens + an 8 HP, 132 DEF invested Roaring Moon.

Zamazenta Life Orb Close Combat dealing 38 - 45% to Tera Ground Moon

Kingambit Max Supreme Overlord Sucker Punch dealing 30 - 35% to Tera Ground Moon

Kingambit Max Supreme Overlord Iron Head dealing 34 - 41% to Moon

Kingambit Max Supreme Overlord Sucker Punch dealing 61% - 72% to Tera Ghost Moon

Tusk Ice Spinner dealing 27 - 32% to Moon

Tusk Headlong Rush dealing 31 - 36% to Moon

Tusk Close Combat dealing 62 - 73% to Moon

Dnite Tera Normal Extreme Speed dealing 23 - 27% to Moon, with Choice Band it deals 34 - 41%

Valiant MOONBLAST dealing 82 - 97% to Moon

Proto Boosted Raging Bolt Dragon Pulse dealing 57 - 68% to Moon…without Tera

Specs Kyurem Ice Beam dealing 62 - 73% to Moon

Choice Band Tera Bug Lokix First Impression dealing 43 - 50% to Tera Ground Moon

Adamant Wellspring Ivy Cudgel dealing 64 - 75% to Tera Ground Moon.

People have invested even more bulk to survive even more hits. Its not difficult to grab 2 Dragon Dances behind Screens with Tera Ground or Ghost. Once it has 2 up there’s not a lot the opponent can do, compared to Dragonite at +2.

Moon makes Ceruledge easier to deal with, but Moon doesn’t fit on alot of Balance structures, and the teams Moon is primarily on have plenty of ways to pressure Ceru. Paradoxically, Ceruledge enables Moon. Everything that checks Moon also checks Ceru, so you can start by breaking these big physical walls with Ceru for a Moon sweep later. Other physical threats like Wellspring, Dnite, and Gambit do not share many of the same defensive checks as Moon, so they don’t overlap with it as much. Moon makes Balance teams better, the same Balance teams that Ceruledge is good against.

Dropping Moon would be trying to solve a few problems but accidentally making pre-existing problems even worse. If you don’t want the tier to become a funhouse of Tickle Mola + Lokix and Screens HO, Vote
I never felt very sure about commenting on any of these suspect tests before because I was an unknown player... Frankly, I had only limited myself to reading all of your posts during these years and trying to meet the requirements, although in the latter I always failed because I didn't have good teams... Until a little over a year ago I finally resigned myself to accepting that building was not my thing and I started using shared teams in different threads and thus I was able to learn much more about the metagame.

And the truth is, while I was reading the arguments put into this new suspect test, I was waiting for someone to say what I had in mind, precisely what you came to be... That's why I cited your post. And it seemed very obvious to me, at least what you mention about how the presence of Balance is already by default a challenge that does not allow Roaring Moon to play at will... I didn't understand the truth because almost no one talks about this...

Personally, I think it is very important, because I notice that there is a lot of aversion to how powerful Roaring Moon is... But in my opinion it is a poorly founded aversion because Roaring Moon has several consistent responses, responses that you very well mention in your post and that I will not repeat, that is why I have quoted you, because I consider that you already said it perfectly... So it ends up giving me the impression that consciously or unconsciously everyone is simply defending the metagame that is most ideal for them but... Isn't it supposed to be objectively evaluated whether Roaring Moon is truly far above the tier or not?

I mean, maybe the approach I see in most of the arguments seems to be more aimed at what the person likes the most or that coincides more with their way of playing or their teams, but... It is assumed that if a Pokémon is Uber it is because there are simply almost no options in OU to stop it or because the Pokémon simply has a set of characteristics that allow it to generate victory situations in almost any context and without much difficulty... So the question is... Is Roaring Moon really this type of Pokémon?

Definitely in offensive build battles Roaring Moon has a devastating presence, there is no doubt about that... But it is also undeniable that in the face of Balance Roaring Moon variants it has very clear difficulties in even being able to enter the battlefield in a favorable context to do free DD... In fact, the presence of Dozo and Ting Lu already makes it difficult on its own for Roaring Moon to make a viable entry to sweep... Landorus is also problematic in that sense, I have seen many times the classic game of simply entering with Intimidate and making unfavorable changes for Roaring Moon's next move...

Roaring Moon also has another problem and that is outspeed... In offensive build duels this is key... Why is this worth mentioning? Because the simple fact that there are faster Pokémon on the field already prevents free Roaring Moon tickets... Since Roaring Moon usually needs to do DD, but a build with Iron Valiant or Iron Moth with booster energy or Dragonite with its full HP can be deterrent tools against Roaring Moon... In what sense? In the sense that these teams can seek a favorable entry for their sweepers before Roaring Moon can do so... So using outspeed in favor can be an instrument to considerably reduce Roaring Moon's offensive pressure, since if the turns are played well, Roaring Moon can be eliminated before he even enters the field...

Of course you have to take into account the use of Tera, but that's why I mentioned that playing correctly each turn can force the opponent to use Tera with a Pokémon other than their Roaring Moon... The use of Tera is never reserved only for Roaring Moon, the use of Tera depends on the development of each battle really...

The truth is that there are so many variables to take into account that make me notice that Roaring Moon is much more manageable than some people want to believe... And not only manageable, the contexts to be able to use its destructive power are measured... Roaring Moon cannot go in and DD and win 6-0 as if the opposing player did not have enough tools to avoid that situation... It's a matter of knowing how to play too... A very broken Pokémon does not need so many conditions to be able to destroy a tier, this is not the case Roaring Moon...

Furthermore, I have only mentioned a few examples from my experience in Ladder, and as I said at the beginning I have never been able to meet the requirements to vote because I am not good enough for an 80% GXE... My GXE is always around 70% (currently 71.4 and I'm at 1501 ELO, I think I could still achieve it but because of my current number of battles I already find it very difficult to go up to 80%), I could mention more real things and situations in multiple games but I don't think anyone will read this in its entirety... So I don't want to extend it any longer
 
Levkher said:
I never felt very sure about commenting on any of these suspect tests before because I was an unknown player... Frankly, I had only limited myself to reading all of your posts during these years and trying to meet the requirements, although in the latter I always failed because I didn't have good teams... Until a little over a year ago I finally resigned myself to accepting that building was not my thing and I started using shared teams in different threads and thus I was able to learn much more about the metagame.

And the truth is, while I was reading the arguments put into this new suspect test, I was waiting for someone to say what I had in mind, precisely what you came to be... That's why I cited your post. And it seemed very obvious to me, at least what you mention about how the presence of Balance is already by default a challenge that does not allow Roaring Moon to play at will... I didn't understand the truth because almost no one talks about this...

Personally, I think it is very important, because I notice that there is a lot of aversion to how powerful Roaring Moon is... But in my opinion it is a poorly founded aversion because Roaring Moon has several consistent responses, responses that you very well mention in your post and that I will not repeat, that is why I have quoted you, because I consider that you already said it perfectly... So it ends up giving me the impression that consciously or unconsciously everyone is simply defending the metagame that is most ideal for them but... Isn't it supposed to be objectively evaluated whether Roaring Moon is truly far above the tier or not?

I mean, maybe the approach I see in most of the arguments seems to be more aimed at what the person likes the most or that coincides more with their way of playing or their teams, but... It is assumed that if a Pokémon is Uber it is because there are simply almost no options in OU to stop it or because the Pokémon simply has a set of characteristics that allow it to generate victory situations in almost any context and without much difficulty... So the question is... Is Roaring Moon really this type of Pokémon?

Definitely in offensive build battles Roaring Moon has a devastating presence, there is no doubt about that... But it is also undeniable that in the face of Balance Roaring Moon variants it has very clear difficulties in even being able to enter the battlefield in a favorable context to do free DD... In fact, the presence of Dozo and Ting Lu already makes it difficult on its own for Roaring Moon to make a viable entry to sweep... Landorus is also problematic in that sense, I have seen many times the classic game of simply entering with Intimidate and making unfavorable changes for Roaring Moon's next move...

Roaring Moon also has another problem and that is outspeed... In offensive build duels this is key... Why is this worth mentioning? Because the simple fact that there are faster Pokémon on the field already prevents free Roaring Moon tickets... Since Roaring Moon usually needs to do DD, but a build with Iron Valiant or Iron Moth with booster energy or Dragonite with its full HP can be deterrent tools against Roaring Moon... In what sense? In the sense that these teams can seek a favorable entry for their sweepers before Roaring Moon can do so... So using outspeed in favor can be an instrument to considerably reduce Roaring Moon's offensive pressure, since if the turns are played well, Roaring Moon can be eliminated before he even enters the field...

Of course you have to take into account the use of Tera, but that's why I mentioned that playing correctly each turn can force the opponent to use Tera with a Pokémon other than their Roaring Moon... The use of Tera is never reserved only for Roaring Moon, the use of Tera depends on the development of each battle really...

The truth is that there are so many variables to take into account that make me notice that Roaring Moon is much more manageable than some people want to believe... And not only manageable, the contexts to be able to use its destructive power are measured... Roaring Moon cannot go in and DD and win 6-0 as if the opposing player did not have enough tools to avoid that situation... It's a matter of knowing how to play too... A very broken Pokémon does not need so many conditions to be able to destroy a tier, this is not the case Roaring Moon...

Furthermore, I have only mentioned a few examples from my experience in Ladder, and as I said at the beginning I have never been able to meet the requirements to vote because I am not good enough for an 80% GXE... My GXE is always around 70% (currently 71.4 and I'm at 1501 ELO, I think I could still achieve it but because of my current number of battles I already find it very difficult to go up to 80%), I could mention more real things and situations in multiple games but I don't think anyone will read this in its entirety... So I don't want to extend it any longer
There's no such thing as an uncounterable Pokémon. Every Pokémon has plenty of ways to deal with it.
At the end of the day, banning a Pokémon isn't just about whether it has counters. It's also about whether the Pokémon itself, or the things people have to run to counter it, make the game less enjoyable for most players.
Ultimately, it's all about making the overall metagame more enjoyable.
 
saw war newnew said:
There's no such thing as an uncounterable Pokémon. Every Pokémon has plenty of ways to deal with it.
At the end of the day, banning a Pokémon isn't just about whether it has counters. It's also about whether the Pokémon itself, or the things people have to run to counter it, make the game less enjoyable for most players.
Ultimately, it's all about making the overall metagame more enjoyable.
Well, I understand your point, but if you have to be objective, you have to say that what you mention is not entirely true... Annihilape, Espathra, Flutter Mane, Iron Bundle, Ursaluna-Bloodmoon and Urshifu are compelling examples that what you say is not entirely true... There are Pokémon that simply destroy the tier because their characteristics allow it and because there are not clear enough answers among the Pokémon available in the tier.

I'm not saying that they couldn't be stopped in concrete ways, but the available options are definitely quite scarce, which allowed these Pokémon to do and undo as they pleased almost without any opposition, technically it was enough to put them into battle and that's it... They are Pokémon that in this metagame do not require much skill or adequate contexts to be able to maneuver, they are Pokémon that were played without much effort and destroyed teams... That's why they were banned, that's a fact, the case of Roaring Moon is not the same, if so it would not have 3 suspects tests to date...
 
every mon can be handled given enough resources, said resources are just incredibly limited. 6 slots to deal with the tier's 37 potential threats - and those are just the most common, tier-exclusive ones. Yes, tiering policy is ultimately in the name of making the tier fun, but this is a community where we play in a competitive manner, where we find the process of playing to win fun, maximizing our chances of winning fun, and doing what it takes to win fun, and I could tell you right now, keeping mega mence legal in ORAS would NOT have made that tier a very fun grounds for competition, no matter how consistently scarf greninja's ice beam shut it down.
 
saw war newnew said:
There's no such thing as an uncounterable Pokémon. Every Pokémon has plenty of ways to deal with it.
At the end of the day, banning a Pokémon isn't just about whether it has counters. It's also about whether the Pokémon itself, or the things people have to run to counter it, make the game less enjoyable for most players.
Ultimately, it's all about making the overall metagame more enjoyable.
While this is true the burden to prove that it will make the game less fun / Moon will overcnetralise the meta. Has not been met in this thread imo. This sentiment by itself really doesn't serve as a counter to Levkhers argument.
 
Taliheim said:
every mon can be handled given enough resources, said resources are just incredibly limited. 6 slots to deal with the tier's 37 potential threats - and those are just the most common, tier-exclusive ones. Yes, tiering policy is ultimately in the name of making the tier fun, but this is a community where we play in a competitive manner, where we find the process of playing to win fun, maximizing our chances of winning fun, and doing what it takes to win fun, and I could tell you right now, keeping mega mence legal in ORAS would NOT have made that tier a very fun grounds for competition, no matter how consistently scarf greninja's ice beam shut it down.
Fully agree with the sentiment. We don't keep mega ray because we have choice banded ice shard Mamo and Weav. However Mega Mence is a whole other demon. I don't think the two mons are equivocal at all.
 
saw war newnew said:
ban roaring moon to save stall!
Gliscor was already max hp/max def-ing on stall for Roaring Moon to not be a decent counter to stall.

Snaky said:
While this is true the burden to prove that it will make the game less fun / Moon will overcnetralise the meta. Has not been met in this thread imo
agreed

Levkher said:
There are Pokémon that simply destroy the tier because their characteristics allow it and because there are not clear enough answers among the Pokémon available in the tier.

I'm not saying that they couldn't be stopped in concrete ways, but the available options are definitely quite scarce, which allowed these Pokémon to do and undo as they pleased almost without any opposition
And on that note, Roaring Moon has NOT been proven to be this type of Pokemon thus far.
 
Levkher said:
Well, I understand your point, but if you have to be objective, you have to say that what you mention is not entirely true... Annihilape, Espathra, Flutter Mane, Iron Bundle, Ursaluna-Bloodmoon and Urshifu are compelling examples that what you say is not entirely true... There are Pokémon that simply destroy the tier because their characteristics allow it and because there are not clear enough answers among the Pokémon available in the tier.

I'm not saying that they couldn't be stopped in concrete ways, but the available options are definitely quite scarce, which allowed these Pokémon to do and undo as they pleased almost without any opposition, technically it was enough to put them into battle and that's it... They are Pokémon that in this metagame do not require much skill or adequate contexts to be able to maneuver, they are Pokémon that were played without much effort and destroyed teams... That's why they were banned, that's a fact, the case of Roaring Moon is not the same, if so it would not have 3 suspects tests to date...
The point is that these Pokémon were so strong that the entire metagame basically revolved around them and the few mons that could actually deal with them. Every other Pokémon pretty much lost its viability, which really sucked for people who wanted to use something different.
If there really were no answers to them, shouldn't there have been barely any difference between being #1 and K5 back then? After all, matchup variety would have been so limited that you could practically exhaust every possible scenario
 
saw war newnew said:
The point is that these Pokémon were so strong that the entire metagame basically revolved around them and the few mons that could actually deal with them. Every other Pokémon pretty much lost its viability, which really sucked for people who wanted to use something different.
If there really were no answers to them, shouldn't there have been barely any difference between being #1 and K5 back then? After all, matchup variety would have been so limited that you could practically exhaust every possible scenario
You have said quite key things that make me see that deep down you are understanding what I mean... So I want to clarify again something that I have said in each message, and that is that each of those Mons who are ubers themselves have limited answers, very limited in the OU metagame, you have mentioned it yourself and it is the truth, I have never I have said that they don't have any answers, I have said in every message that the responses available to each of these perfectly banned mons are simply scarce...

I really liked how you described it: "the metagame revolved around these mons" and it was logical that this was the case, because the answers were so limited that yes or yes you had to make a team prepared to face them... And yet... I insist that they were mons who needed few conditions to cause destruction... They are simply monsters, that's why they are not in OU... And I only gave a few examples, but there were also cases like Baxcalibur... Baxcalibur was special, because it's like a fusion between Kyurem and Roaring Moon... Kyurem and Roaring Moon simply do not have that combination that only Baxcalibur has and that is why it is not in OU today... For this reason I must humbly insist once again on a fact, Roaring Moon is not at that same level of making the metagame as uncomfortable as the great monsters that have been banned practically since their first suspect test and have not lasted long in OU...

Honestly, it has always mortified me a lot when I see that the community only wants to make a metagame tailored to specific tastes and preferences... And I apologize if it seems that I am being very bold with these words, perhaps I am rushing to say them, but honestly that is the impression it gives me many times... That the aversion to certain Mons like Roaring Moon does not raise sufficiently objective facts, but is an aversion based on the fact that Roaring Moon threatens the tastes and preferences of certain users to play, and from what I read in the rules of the Finchinator post this does not It should be like this... At least that's the impression it gives me.
 
I wrote in the qualified discussion posts but after getting reqs, I definitely think the finger needs to be pointed at screens/light clay over roaring moon. I did not run into a single team trying moon outside of screens, MAYBE 1 or 2 on a different version of HO, but the bulkier sets that were the most frustrating felt enabled by screens being available, and the amazing screen setters that are in the tier. I do not think moon gets as easy of turns if screens are neutered. Outside of all of this as well, the counterplay to moon like tera normal dnite, tera bug lokix, tera steel sciz, was NOT present on ladder. In the games I played where my opponent clearly had thought about moon when building their team, it was much harder for moon to do anything.
 
My stance on this suspect has definitely changed since it started. I used to be in the camp of "we need to reduce threats, not add another", but after actually playing in the tier, I actually think that the adaptations that teams do to handle moon end up making them... less greedy. Ironpress zama/other ironpress mons, fighting coverage, corvs/skarms, status, phazing, fairies esp. physdef fairies; these are up in power and usage with moon's presence, and are healthy things to be strong in the current meta. On the flip side, the teams that are the most likely to lose to the most "problematic" moon sets, the booster energy DD tera ground/flying 50/50 - the ones that can only afford to have an answer to one, but not both - are frailer, greedier offenses that are more prone to matchup fishing, hax, and cheesing. it's also another strong knock user, which always indirectly buffs bulkier structures and more passive mons that put more stock in hazards to deal damage and make it stick.
 
10 users who have earned voting requisites have not voted yet, but their votes will not affect the outcome of the vote.

Eligible Voters: 102
Votes: 92

Roaring Moon
Keep Ubers: 41
Unban: 51
Unban %: 55%

60% pro-unban majority is required for Roaring Moon to remain OU, and the outcome will not be changed by more votes. Thus, Roaring Moon remains banned from SV OU. Tagging Marty and dhelmise to make the change on PS when they have the time; thanks!

The vote will remain open for 24 more hours to allow the remaining people with voting requirements to vote here and have their vote count towards the Tiering Contributor badge if they so please. Voting will be closed at this time.

Votes will be made public at the formal deadline or whenever all 102 eligible voters have voted, whichever comes first
 
Status
Not open for further replies.
Back
Top