• Follow our Instagram!
  • Curious about what we're currently doing about bots? Check out the latest updates from staff in this thread.

Metagame SV OU Metagame Discussion v4

For people who don't understand why Terapagos is still banned to this day, refer to this:

Marty said:
I think what people on the "tier them separately" train are missing here is it's not actually possible to separate Terastal Form from Stellar Form in a way that works with usage-based tiering as it exists today. Let's ignore the fact that you can't separate Normal Form from Terastal Form either.

Usage stats only take into consideration the Pokemon on a player's team as they are before the battle starts. The reason Megas could start to be tiered separately is that a team with "Charizard @ Charizardite X" was changed to have it count as "Mega Charizard X", regardless of whether the player's Charizard actually Mega Evolved in any given battle. "Rayquaza with Dragon Ascent" is counted as "Mega Rayquaza" in formats that don't have Mega Rayquaza Clause. "Greninja with Battle Bond" was counted as "Ash-Greninja" prior to this gen. Obviously, the equivalent to this logic with Terapagos is to count every single Terapagos as Stellar Form whether or not it Terastallizes, because there is no item or move or Ability that changes its form. Which means Terapagos the Pokemon as a whole should be banned in this case.

The functionality you're looking for doesn't exist; how do you objectively count Stellar Form instances separately from Terastal Form, and would you then argue for the same thing with Darmanitan, or Meloetta, or Aegislash, or Ogerpon, or...? (This is rhetorical, I'm not really interested in engaging in a tiering and/or usage philosophy debate, or encouraging more discussion of something that evidently isn't going to happen. Just pointing these things out!)

As long as Smogon uses a usage-based tiering system, it's just not feasible to have Terapagos-Terastal allowed in OU unless Tera itself were to be banned, and the tiering heads already vetoed an outright ban on Tera, so Terapagos getting freed just won't be happening.
 
Avira said:
For people who don't understand why Terapagos is still banned to this day, refer to this:



As long as Smogon uses a usage-based tiering system, it's just not feasible to have Terapagos-Terastal allowed in OU unless Tera itself were to be banned, and the tiering heads already vetoed an outright ban on Tera, so Terapagos getting freed just won't be happening.

haha yeah let's scroll a little further down that thread though and see how people have responded

Celever said:
banning Terapagos as a whole is probably fine if policy supersedes common sense, but many players are dissatisfied with that outcome. It isn’t hard for the average player to understand that Terapagos-Terastal is broken because it adds a bunch of stats when it clicks Tera, so there is no pragmatic reason to ban both. Comments that it “starts a Tera banlist and once that’s started there’s no stopping it” are strange, because the purpose of this forum is to create policy and failsafes for that can just be… written into the policy. “Tera Clause: Pokémon whose base stats change upon Tera cannot Tera” is the rule that people are seeking and it opens up no such slippery slope. That slippery slope is opt-in, and no one wants to opt-in to it, so it doesn’t matter.

The purpose of current policy is not to pre-empt precedent. Future policy uses precedent under the assumption that the last similar decision was made correctly and in good faith for the situation it was made in. Future policy also has the option to disregard said precedent if the situation is satisfactorily different. Banning Terapagos as a whole Pokémon is currently both disregarding past precedent because the situations are satisfactorily different, while the decision made is because it doesn’t want to set a precedent that may be misused in the future. These are incommensurate positions.
(like ratioed btw)

I don't understand why gentlelady agreeing to not tera terapagos is any different from agreeing not to bring sneasler to a local cartridge OU battle (because it's banned. because smogon tiers aren't "real" but they do exist to be competitive and fun. and we're allowed to just do things if they make tiers competitiver and funner. cough cough ahem we had sleep clause for 20 years btw)
 
Last edited:
Demon Queen said:
(like ratioed btw)

I don't understand why gentlelady agreeing to not tera terapagos is any different from agreeing not to bring sneasler to a local cartridge OU battle (because it's banned. because smogon tiers aren't "real" but they do exist to be competitive and fun. and we're allowed to just do things if they make tiers competitiver and funner. cough cough ahem we had sleep clause for 20 years btw)

Nobody should give a fuck about being ratioed 'cause it doesn't actually contribute to discussion in anyway. Who cares about Internet clout? It's not the own you think it is.

'Cause Sneasler exists itself by itself and isn't tied to something else that triggers a BST boost through an item, and there being no item-lock for Terastalization means that there's no functional way to differentiate Terapagos-Stellar from Terapagos-Terastal in usage statistics like one could for Mega Evolutions. That's why I don't support Terapagos-Terastal being in OU unless Tera itself were banned.

And Sleep Clause had always been a mistake, and the SV OU decision to nuke it and replace it with a Sleep Moves ban was correct, and we should have followed BW's case in 2020 by applying it to all tiers.
 
Last edited:
Avira said:
For people who don't understand why Terapagos is still banned to this day, refer to this:



As long as Smogon uses a usage-based tiering system, it's just not feasible to have Terapagos-Terastal allowed in OU unless Tera itself were to be banned, and the tiering heads already vetoed an outright ban on Tera, so Terapagos getting freed just won't be happening.
This argument from Marty fundamentally doesn’t make sense because it ignores the fact that Terepagos already exists in a tier where it can’t terastalize that has its own usage stats, that being National Dex. If Terapagos is in a tier where it can’t terastalize, it’s tiered as Terastal form, and if it’s in a tier where it can, it’s tiered as Stellar form. Rayquaza knowing the move Dragon Ascent is tiered similarly; base Rayquaza in Ubers, Mega Rayquaza in Anything Goes. This is already existing precedent…
 
Last edited:
Back
Top