Pikiwyn said:Battle Subway Super Single Record: 123
Whimsicott @ Full Incense
Prankster, Bold
252 HP, 252 SpD, 4 Def
Stats: 167, 65, 116, 90, 127, 135
~Switcheroo
~Leech Seed
~Charm
~Flash
The idea of the team is to switcheroo the opponent first turn so that Butterfree is faster and the opponent won’t have items like Quick Claw, Chesto, Lum and Brightpowder. Full Incense also overrides Trick Room which is great. After Switcheroo I Flash or Charm depending on the situation, generally Flash opponents with Rock moves instead of Charming first. Leech Seed is mostly for Substitute threats but I hardly use it, I also use it if I want to set Chansey up on an opponent with Rest, Leech Seed and Seismic Toss almost always does enough damage to KO the opponent while Resting. If I retry this team I would definitely change the EVs to have max Defense because Special attackers aren’t a problem for the team.
Chansey @ Eviolite
Natural Cure, Bold
252 HP, 252 Def, 4 SpD
Stats: 357, 22, 62, 55, 126, 70
~Toxic
~Seismic Toss
~Minimize
~Softboiled
I tried the Butterfree-Whimsicott combo a bunch of times but could never find a good third teammate, it has to be able to switch in on weather inducers, Early Birds, Insomnia, some Taunters, Sap Sippers, Sound Proof Pokémon, and be able to set up on as many other Pokémon as possible in case something goes wrong. I tried things like Suicune, Porygon2, Togekiss and Garchomp, Porygon2 was the only one that did well (I got to 102 with it). I was really surprised at how defensive Chansey was and at how well she can take down a whole team after Minimizing. I switch into Chansey if the first opponent can’t defeat her otherwise I Switcheroo and set up with Butterfree. Chansey also did pretty well against taunters, after a Switcheroo followed by a Taunt, Chansey can switch in, outspeed the opponent to get to Toxic and then Seismic Toss.
Butterfree @ Leftovers
Compoundeyes, Modest
204 HP, 4 Def, 212 SpA, 84 Spe
Stats: 161, 58, 71, 139, 100, 101
~Sleep Powder
~Quiver Dance
~Substitute
~Bug Buzz
Back in the Battle Castle with my Smeargle-Breloom streak I realised that if you have a 100% accurate sleep move and you’re faster than the opponent then you’re almost guaranteed to win, so that’s basically how I got to this. Sleep Powder first turn, use Substitute and Quiver Dance when the opponent is asleep and make sure to always have a Substitute up. Sleep Powder was surprisingly accurate it missed 6 times in my streak, since I use Sleep powder about 5 times per battle that’s an accuracy of 99% that I had, and Butterfree only fainted twice because of a miss but Chansey was able to take the victory both times. The HP lets me rotate between Substitute and Sleep Powder for the most amount of turns, in case I get unlucky and the opponent wakes up on the second turn too many times. The speed lets me feel safe to knock out a dangerous opponent after 2 Quiver Dances, with 202 Speed Butterfree outspeeds all 130 base speed Pokémon. Dangerous opponents are Pokémon that will make me lose the battle if Sleep Powder happens to miss. Quiver Dance and Charm work great together, boosting Butterfree’s defences to let my Substitutes survive more than one attack. Bug Buzz is the best move Butterfree gets and it’s much better than having Signal beam just for Soundproof Pokémon, which I can Sleep Powder then switch to Chansey. After 6 Quiver Dances Butterfree OHKOs almost everything that doesn’t resist it, pretty much 50% of Pokémon do resist it though so if the opponents 2nd Pokémon is resistant I start with Sleep Powder. I also Sleep Powder if the Pokémon might have Sturdy or Focus Sash and I only Sleep Powder the last opponent if it might have something like Rock blast or if they can survive more than 2 Bug Buzzes. After set up the only thing Butterfree sometimes has trouble with is the Chandelure with leftovers and Calm Mind, but Chandelure will usually use Will-o-wisp instead of setting up. Butterfree’s low defense is actually an advantage against physical Taunters, if I don’t Charm them things that think they can OHKO Butterfree will rather attack the Substitute than Taunt
How I lost:
The opponent sends out Muk, I’ve never faced a Sticky Hold Pokémon before so I didn’t think it might have it, so I Switcheroo, it fails and Muk KOs with Gunk Shot, I send out Chansey and Minimize and KO it, opponent sends out Lickilicky, just before I KO it it uses Explosion, it hits and gets a CH and Chansey faints. I send out Butterfree and the opponent sends out Starmie, Starmie uses Ice Beam, Butterfree freezes, frozen solid and Starmie KOs with Ice Beam.
The team wasn’t a serious attempt but it did surprisingly well. It’s definitely the most fun team I’ve used and the battles are really interesting and stressful sometimes, which I really enjoyed. And sweeping with a Butterfree is just an awesome feeling!
I didn't play this gen contemporaneously (was busy barely graduating from college at the time) so never really read through this thread too much, but this was one of my favorite old teams that I came across while catching up. I used a very similar concept in the Battle Tree where the lead (Krookodile, since that was the first gen Prankster was nerfed to not affect Dark types) was dedicated to slowing things down for a set-up sweeper that abused sleep (Smeargle) with a Chansey in back to try to salvage things if the lead couldn't do anything.
That team was rolling along before it lost through my own ignorance (I threw Smeargle away assuming Mega Venusaur became slower upon Mega Evolution) and the team being pre-transfer where Chansey had no access to Seismic Toss (in addition to bad Moody luck that left Smeargle slower than -2 Mega Venusaur and unable to evade enough attacks to stay healthy behind its Sub, there was also bad matchup luck where the trainer used the only two Toxic-immune Pokemon on their roster and forced Chansey to run out of PP). I left it behind because I was just messing around with it until Durant became available, but I think an ironed-out version of such a team could easily get at least 500, probably 1000+ in the Tree. It has to have similar potential in the Subway where Prankster isn't nerfed, Grass types aren't immune to powder moves, sound moves don't bypass Subs (no Infiltrator either), there are no Megas or Z moves, and the AI is dumber/more forgiving.
Based on the team report and just common sense I'd assume Whimsicott does pretty well in its role of being a Prankster crippler, so I'm not going to look too much at that for now besides pointing out that Encore or Sunny Day could be good options over Leech Seed. In the 3rd slot, just switching Chansey to the more optimized set with more speed + Substitute over Toxic is low-hanging fruit for improvement in both the aggregate sense and in likely turning the quoted loss into a comfortable win if the Chansey was already lucky enough to boost against Muk before KOing it. Gliscor could certainly also fulfill a similar role as a super defensive mon that outstalls evasion users, doesn't use Leftovers, and can pull off sweeps on its own, and it would be easy to imagine Gliscor directly switching in on Muk (the only Sticky Hold Pokemon that also can KO itself) and either setting up on it or making it take itself out and bring in a 2nd Pokemon that a full health Whimsicott still has a great chance of crippling.
For the sleep abuser, probably the biggest opportunity to try something new comes from the fact that even Compound Eyes Sleep Powder is not accurate enough to trust over hundreds of battles when you're counting on it to hit multiple times per battle. Looking at Spore users, we have:
1) Breloom @ Toxic Orb
Poison Heal
Jolly
- Spore
- Substitute
- Low Sweep
- Double Team/Bulk Up/Protect/Leech Seed
potatobagel here's my shot at letting Breloom shine! I think
Meuhforever addressed the main issues with it where with item clause it directly competes with Gliscor and the main unique moves it has over Gliscor to make up for its worse defenses/speed/defensive typing (Leech Seed and Spore) are counterproductive to PP stalling. Additionally, if I were dedicating at least one whole teamslot just to make the opponent slower so I could PP stall, my first question would be whether Breloom could set up so much more reliably than a Moody Pokemon to offset being a less potent sweeper against the two opposing non-crippled Pokemon.
Spore and Substitute would definitely be mandatory. Low Sweep echoes the use of Bulldoze on Gliscor where slowing something down so you can better stall it matters more than higher-damage options, especially since Breloom can't boost its Speed. Boosting stats is always my default option over more coverage when I'm using a Pokemon that can stall/wall a lot of stuff. Bulk Up worries me a bit since it seems like it would be relatively common to OHKO a 2nd Pokemon on the turn it wakes up, outspeeds Breloom, and breaks the Sub, leaving you vulnerable to being OHKOed by the 3rd. You could try playing around that by using Bulk Up a lower number of times against certain trainers, but I think Double Team is probably a bit safer. That would also echo my Gliscor set where being able to chip something down and KO it on your own terms while boosted and behind a Substitute can be preferable to trying to power through bulky defense boosters that you could just stall out of attacks. You could even say that being walled by Ghosts is better than being walled by Ground immunities since there aren't any speed boosting Ghost types, and obviously something like Chansey also does fine without hitting them.
Maybe you could even go extra stally with something like Spore/Sub/Protect/Double Team and a teammate that boosts its offenses, and at that point it would probably be worth seeing whether some Sub/Protect/Double Team Pressure users with Leftovers (Aerodactyl, Weavile, Dusknoir, Johto/Kanto legendaries) could fulfill a similar role with either more speed or bulk alongside a non-Leftovers set-up Pokemon like Gliscor, Drapion (or Tentacruel!), or Lum Dragonite/Salamence as the 3rd.
2) Smeargle @ Leftovers
Moody
Timid
- Spore
- Substitute
- Stored Power
- Low Sweep/Soak/Protect/???
Like Butterfree this doesn't have the most reliable sleep either due to the potential for Moody accuracy drops. However, you can work around this pretty well by either switching in the defensive teammate (in this case you'd most likely want Gliscor for the Sandstorm immunity plus ability to beat leads with physical priority) to reset bad stats and try again or trying to Sub/Protect stall for accuracy boosts; between possible accuracy reduction from the lead (edit: or probably even better, evasion reduction such as Sweet Scent), possible evasion boosts from Smeargle, the opponents' propensity for using status moves, and good old-fashioned PP stalling, even something as frail as Smeargle can buy itself more turns than you might think. Failing all that, risking an inaccurate Spore would be fine a lot of the time due to how safe Gliscor is as a sweeper. In fact, if you weren't running Protect it would probably be wise to set Gliscor up and go for a sweep first most battles, where the kinds of things it fails to KO tend to easily be stalled out of attacks for Smeargle to then come in safely.
With no later-generation moves for Smeargle such as Spiky Shield to chip down most physical attackers regardless of speed/accuracy boosts and Power Trip to reach ludicrous BP with no immunities, the main problem to solve is obviously the inability to hit Dark types. In my experience with Smeargle, its stats are bad enough that you should neither count on keeping an intact Substitute if the opponent connects with a damaging move nor OHKOing anything with any non-ludicrous BP move. Stat-wise, this means full Special Attack and likely full Speed (at the very least the highest speed tier it hits with no ties) EVs, a slightly reduced HP IV to hit a Leftovers number (too lazy to look up exactly what that would be right now, but 29 sounds right), and whatever's left in Defense. Movewise, this means you're not going to see me suggesting some 4th move like Aura Sphere simply because it hits most Dark-types super-effectively.
Low Sweep would be my first guess where Gliscor should be able to deal with any Dark type that's had its speed reduced even in the rare event that Smeargle couldn't just chip one down itself while continually putting it to sleep (just +2 with a 31 Attack IV is sufficient for Timid Smeargle to 2HKO Weavile, which is all pretty much anything besides a set-up Cloyster can hope to do against a Sash Weavile anyways). Reducing the 2nd/3rd mon's speed in the event of bad boosts/a lead that KOs itself too soon could turn quite a few battles, and due to Smeargle's horrible offenses it will even get plenty of opportunities to be used like Glalie's Taunt to just advance through another turn of Moody boosts while conserving PP of the more essential Sub/Spore and not KOing the crippled lead.
Soak does no damage so is an even better turn-waster, and of the moves that remove Dark's immunity to Stored Power I'd consider it a better alternative to Miracle Eye since it removes STAB and makes Stored Power neutral on all of them as opposed to something like Bisharp still resisting - Miracle Eye bypassess accuracy checks and nullifies evasion boosts, but Gliscor can outstall evasion users on its own and get them to a point where Smeargle comes in freely and just waits for accuracy boosts or the opponent to Struggle. Toxic or Will-o-Wisp could waste turns against a sleeping opponent and slowly take out Dark type backups while the Drapion/Houndoom that would wall such a Smeargle could at least be PP stalled and put to sleep so Gliscor can easily set up. There are probably other options that I haven't thought of - let me know!
unexplored Durant teammates/goodstuff PP stallers
Sub/Protect/Low Sweep/Stored Power Smeargle is also worth considering as a replacement for Glalie on Durant teams, although my inclination would be that since you'd still have to wait for positive speed and accuracy before sweeping, despite the much higher damage potential of Stored Power the set-up isn't going to be so much faster to offset it being more frail for the battles where you're getting bad speed/accuracy boosts and need the Substitute to tank some hits. The ability to have a guaranteed OHKO on all Cobalion sets when set up and not having to worry about the infamous Lax Incense/Psych Up combo puts Smeargle in rarified air among even the best Durant sweepers.
Actually, Acupressure Tentacruel can do that too! Sub/Protect/Acupressure/Scald seems great to me. Compared to Drapion (stuck in an awkward spot between its perch on the top of gens 4 and 6 with the Sacred Sword users introduced and Knock Off not yet being strong enough for a boosted Drapion to power through them and other heavy resists, especially with Dark being NVE against Steel) its main disadvantages are what, being walled by Water immunities and a lack of Battle Armor? Those really don't seem like too big of a deal to me if using Tentacruel alongside Gliscor, in fact, a more than fair tradeoff for not having to care about Cobalion or contact abilities.
Battle Armor is definitely essential when using a Rest Drapion, but in my time using Durant-Drapion in the Maison I felt it was not really doing anything aside from causing marginally fewer Substitutes to get broken while setting up. It was superfluous when my stats were boosted enough, and the team was built in a way that meant I was able to either avoid setting up against most of the leads that tend to KO themselves early or at least safely get Durant back in if a sparsely-boosted Drapion couldn't handle what came out 2nd. In the times I lost or was in trouble, Drapion was either beyond the point of being saved by any possible ability except like Wonder Guard or Moody (have to use Red Card, Red Card brings in Explosion user that explodes early into SD Garchomp) or had much more to worry about from secondary effects than crits (couldn't get up a Sub 1v1 against Floatzel because of 2 Waterfall flinches, incidentally Tentacruel matches up great against this. Hmm...).
With Gliscor switching in on so many of the same threats that Red Card users come in on (I don't think the item itself would work as well with Durant this gen due to that redundancy plus crits hitting harder), I think Tentacruel would similarly get consistently long set-up opportunities. A partially boosted (or even unboosted) Tentacruel still has the ability to Sub/Protect stall, wall plenty of things with its typing and inherent special bulk, grant Gliscor free switch-ins by drawing Ground and Electric moves, just set up Acupressure anyway against a gen 5 opponent that tries to status a Sub, or failing all that spam Scald and hope for a burn. Tentacruel, like Drapion, should be fine with an ability that doesn't give it a huge benefit. I'd have no idea which of its three abilities would even be 'best' - Liquid Ooze would be the one where I feel you'd be incurring its effect most frequently (for an idea of how low that bar is, I count 10 Giga Drain users post Ingo and the overwhelming majority of them are far more interested in using Leech Seed/Protect/Ingrain type moves than trying to do damage) but I'm not even sure whether that effect would be positive or negative!
As for Water Absorb/Storm Drain, it seems straightforward enough that between the combined PP of Tentacruel and Gliscor and Tentacruel resisting Water and Ice, you can stall them out without much worry. Oh yeah, you'd even have the option to remove those abilities a lot of the time. Compared to Glalie, Tentacruel seems like it'd need to worry more about Special Defense boosters with HP recovery, but in practice you'd be PP stalling their limited number of attacking moves and wearing down the ones without Rest with a burn that's still dealing that extra thicc passage damage chunk of 1/8th HP. It would be more a concern with making battles take longer than making battles unwinnable (e.g. against a lead CM-Rest Suicune you're probably best off wasting a bunch of PP with the other teammates first before going in and setting up with Tentacruel so Suicune's about to Struggle by the time you've got 21 boosts and are ready to attack).
Tentacruel could even have some advantages over Glalie where it absorbs Toxic Spikes (lead hazard Forretress uses Toxic Spikes turn 1 super rarely, is obviously not that common in the first place, and even if it happens it's not the end of the world to just set up Gliscor instead - still, definitely a plus) and has a better matchup against some of the Quick Claw/Protect Water types like Wailord, Slowbro, Dewgong, and Floatzel that can can give both Durant and Gliscor problems. I feel like Glalie would still be better because in those rare battles where you don't get to set up as much as you'd like and are missing that one boost in Speed or whatever that would guarantee a win, you're more likely to get it eventually through Sub/Protect stalling for more Moody boosts than by leaving yourself vulnerable to go for another Acupressure. That could just be because that's what I'm used to though; Tentacruel is 100% worth trying.
I used a Sub/Protect/DD/Crunch Tyranitar to get through the Subway boss, although that was again a function of seeming good enough + being ready to go on my cartridge with a generic max HP and Attack spread than it being super optimized. The endless Sand Stream was cool to break Sash, undo Snow Warning without requiring an additional moveslot for Durant (or it to not get KOed or frozen while using Entrainment), wear down some Flame Body/Static/evasion item 2nd mons to not risk getting statused or missing, or allow Gliscor to beat more Ground immunities without having to fully PP stall them, but I could also see it creating opportunities for like Sand Veil Garchomp to be a pain and with 6 boosts + Sand Stream messages it's not way faster than Glalie anyways. Other than that Tyranitar probably functions similarly to Dragonite where both stack some weaknesses with Gliscor while having about the same damage output (Dragon not having any 4x resists is an edge for it for sure, especially where Cobalion is concerned) and the natural bulk to maintain a Sub against weaker hits despite not boosting defenses.
Cloyster with Leftovers and Sub in place of Sash and the non Icicle Spear attacking move boosts up faster than a Dragon Dance (or Quiver Dance I suppose - haven't thought about it too much, but a mono-attacking Volcarona with Sub should be fine walling the Flash Fire/Soundproof stuff that comes out 2nd/3rd when there's a Gliscor or some other staller backing it up) and the mons that heavily resist Icicle Spear or evade it with Bright Powder/Lax Incense could be Sub/Protect stalled with both Cloyster and Gliscor. Obviously the Ice/Ground synergy is tried and true as well - having the flexibility to passively recover HP in both Sandstorm and Hail is great.
The Pressure users mentioned alongside Breloom also deserve some mention here. Similarly to Gliscor, they can function without a dedicated crippling lead, but using one allows you to conserve Sub/Protect PP while getting the first KO and makes you substantially more likely to either sweep through the remaining two or run something out of PP so that a teammate can safely boost instead. I haven't run calcs, but a lot of these Pokemon are sure to be surprisingly bulky when they're invested in defenses rather and not the speedy attackers most people are accustomed to using them as. It's commonly said that power creep increases with each generation, and since the 5th gen is the last generation with critical hits doing 2x rather than 1.5x damage, it's fair to assume that the Subway would be where the share of a Pokemon's defensive value that belongs to how many of the opponents' PP it can safely stall behind a Substitute would be at an all-time high relative to everything else (typing, recovery moves, actual defensive stats).
Sub/Protect/Double Team plus some kind of speed control attack is a proven template. Aerodactyl (Bulldoze), Weavile (Low Sweep), and Moltres (Flame Charge) seem like good candidates there. The legendary birds all get Agility too and the legendary beasts get Bulldoze, but while I seemingly eschewed damage dealing to run Bulldoze over Earthquake on Gliscor, my hunch would be there's still some minimum threshold of damage you should be dealing in order to outdamage the passive recovery of whatever potential threat without it setting up on you or you running out of PP (actually in a preview of the next sentence, Poison Heal Breloom would be a good example), and Gliscor at least reaches that by having STAB and 95 base Attack (plus better healing than Leftovers). I wouldn't be 100% sure about the efficacy of running zero damaging moves since a lot of things, even if you wall them, would waste more of the staller's PP than you'd think due to all the times they'd try to Leech Seed or whatever against Substitutes, resulting in fewer PP before Struggle to provide a free switch to a teammate you'd want to bring in to boost offenses; it could certainly work though. Maybe something like Zapdos has the stats and typing to get by with no speed control, just using Thunderbolt as an attack to deal enough damage to any Dragon Dance threats it couldn't PP stall (it actually would stall a lot of them since anything with Rest or Earthquake is down to at most 2 damaging moves).
Some of these sets could probably be ported into Doubles as well. PP stalling has more slowly made its way there in later generations, but I believe it can really simplify things in Doubles when you can downgrade opposing evasion/status users from threats that must be taken out quickly before they become unhittable to liabilities that allow you to go 2v1 on their teammates while you have a backup that can easily stall them out once the dust settles.