that archers of loaf song is probably my favourite of the songs i posted, i'm glad you like it. did you download icky mettle? 'representative of youth' is really the best way of putting it, it's so sloppy and genuine. sadly i don't know of any albums that really sound like it, but something that comes kind of close in a weird way is blood on the wall's awesomer. i really think that they're one of the most criminally unknown bands of the 2000s, and all three of their albums are incredible in different ways.
blood on the wall - reunite on ice
this isn't even one of the better tracks off awesomer, but it's one of like three of their songs that's on youtube, so it'll have to do. they sound almost identical to the pixies, but that kind of honesty is refreshing in a sea full of bands that pretend that they aren't aping the pixies. their first album is a bit less polished and their third is a bit more, but i think awesomer strikes the balance perfectly. it doesn't really sound much like icky mettle but for some reason they remind me of each other, maybe you'll like it.