of star wars? the cgi is laughable but other things are ok, i like maori bobba tbh
-
Welcome to Smogon! Take a moment to read the Introduction to Smogon for a run-down on everything Smogon, and make sure you take some time to read the global rules.
Smogon Forums
GatoDelFuego
Hulavuta
yeah the CGI seems pointless. and I liked the old Return of the Jedi song better too (in Jabba's palace). The new CGI one is seriously cringeworthy. I actually don't mind Greedo and Han shooting at the same time because it is kind of nice actually, like there was a tension building up in that scene and then they both decided to fire at the same second like they were on the same page. Kinda dumb how Greedo could miss from that close but whatever.
I don't mind Maori Boba but...like I just cannot get behind completely removing an actor's work from a movie after 20 years. Just doesn't seem right. Did he still get royalties and credit for that role? Not sure. I mean he's dead now but he wasn't when his voice was replaced.
tbh though I wouldn't wanna watch them despecialized either. Because not having the windows in Cloud City would make it look claustrophobic af, the windows really add a lot. And I like the music that was added to the end of Return of the Jedi too. IDK, it's a mixed bag.
I don't mind Maori Boba but...like I just cannot get behind completely removing an actor's work from a movie after 20 years. Just doesn't seem right. Did he still get royalties and credit for that role? Not sure. I mean he's dead now but he wasn't when his voice was replaced.
tbh though I wouldn't wanna watch them despecialized either. Because not having the windows in Cloud City would make it look claustrophobic af, the windows really add a lot. And I like the music that was added to the end of Return of the Jedi too. IDK, it's a mixed bag.
GatoDelFuego
this song haunts my nightmares https://www.youtube.com/watch?v=2gnHu1M7jxs
Hulavuta
ok what about the rest of what I said
GatoDelFuego
yeah, agreeing with the rest. I can understand why people that think maori boba isnt right because its what they grew up with, but the original voice gets SUCH praise for no apparent reason, just annother overreaction to a lucas edit
Hulavuta
Yeah the voices really are interchangeable for me in terms of quality. I just don't think an actor should ever be replaced from a film that already exists that just ain't right mang
Also I don't think a clone would talk the same as his dad anyway since accents aren't genetic. So it just doesn't really have a strong argument to exist.
Also I don't think a clone would talk the same as his dad anyway since accents aren't genetic. So it just doesn't really have a strong argument to exist.
GatoDelFuego
so why did all the clones sound identical as adults hmm
Hulavuta
lol is this a troll question? all the clones grew up together and were trained together on Kamino. so of course they all sound the same.
Boba Fett on the other hand was on his own since age 11. PLUS he shows up in The Clone Wars and doesn't have his accent anymore so it's a continuity error anyway.
Boba Fett on the other hand was on his own since age 11. PLUS he shows up in The Clone Wars and doesn't have his accent anymore so it's a continuity error anyway.
GatoDelFuego
twins dont have same accents sometimes tho