Welcome to Smogon! Take a moment to read the Introduction to Smogon for a run-down on everything Smogon, and make sure you take some time to read the global rules.
Oh yeah, forgot about them. But yeah, took some people long enough to get 2, now they need three people tp playtest their sets, and alot won't even have that happen because people only seem to playtest pokemon that they like.
No... It really seems most of the criticism / improvements of analyses comes from the output of normal members. Except Iconic, he seems to be really active.
Did I ever talk to you about not allowing distribution groupings (i.e. "this move goes to every ____-typed Pokemon" or "every pokemon who learns ____ also learns this move")? As long as you edit your distribution for Reincarnation the list looks fine. I actually really like all the moves, they each have a good purpose to them.
For that Gift/Flavor Zone, would there be a vote? I still think that the votes are final, I'm just wondering how it would be handled if that becomes the case.