Dusk composed himself so terribly at EoD I kinda feel dumb for not noticing at the time.
-
Welcome to Smogon! Take a moment to read the Introduction to Smogon for a run-down on everything Smogon, and make sure you take some time to read the global rules.
-
Congrats to the winners of the 2023 Smog Awards!
NOC 11p gen 1 closed setup (D4 End: Dec 25 at 5 PM PST)
- Thread starter Nuxl
- Start date
do you think we have Tp
what do you mean? we have 48 hours, right?
Unvote: BGB
Vote: Duskfall
Probably better to do this one first, that EoD (End of Day) along with the Former flip definitely warrants elimination.
Vote: Duskfall
Probably better to do this one first, that EoD (End of Day) along with the Former flip definitely warrants elimination.
ignore that, I was thinking and posted by mistake
Yeah w/e if I die here I should probably be townread but I have no doubt you guys will scumread me. Blame former for this game regardless he shitted up the thread with nonsense, he has a responsibility as an experienced player and he trolled I'm not taking blame postgame I would kill him 100 days in a row if there were that many phases to kill him.
I'll have to look into dusk more. But My Vote Starts here Vote Shubaka17
So do you town read shubaka17? Do you have anything on him?
I've already given thoughts on Shubaka.
I'll have to look into dusk more. But My Vote Starts here Vote Shubaka17
So do you town read shubaka17? Do you have anything on him?
Null.
I'd rather vote you or Tommy
Interesting. Now we wait for Clever to say that they town read shub? Something ain't right with Caff/Clever/Shub core. They all may not be scum but there has to be something fishy going on.
Of course
Rn I don't think we have any reason not to vote up Dusk.
bluegummybear have you been mafia before?
it's at my own discretion
sec
Right now I think I’m against it. Haven’t dissected EoD yesterday yet but Tommy seems very town by first impression the entire time, and he was very town before Former’s BS the entire time as well as shown in my ISO yesterday.
My hold up is that if Former hadn’t randomly jumped ship from me to Tommy, we’d currently be in the exact same situation questioning whether a town could truly play so badly so as to accuse another town as hard as Former did. And since I’m town, I can say that yes, Former really was that bad this game. Tommy and I both treated his BS with towny aggression and it made me townread Tommy more.
The main issue IMO is that if this is 8v3 and we mislynch today, we’re in LYLO tomorrow (outside of town PR interference), and I think if Tommy is town and we spend today voting him we’re really stuck for information come D3. There are a whole plethora of fairly equally suspicious people IMO, and today could be better spent focussing on them.
Speaking of Vote CaffeineBoost your EoD was a real mess bro
I don’t think I can spot this tbh interested in what you say. I noticed something else that I think is dumb but not scummy.
I’d identify that yes BGB is playing terribly only focussing on you and tinfoiling largely unconnected players as definite partners with you, but it reads more as really bad town than scum I think.
But then I’m still incredulous that your wagon picked up any steam yesterday when you were the counterwagon. I could honestly see bgb’s bud being on that wagon if bgb flips mafia and this is an interesting lead.
I don’t think Tommy was thinking straight enough to do this. He was clearly pissed off at Former (which, rightly so, how did he flip town I’m still annoyed at him for taking away out D1 with his trolling) and I think largely he was using this thread to vent rather than to make complex mechanical plays like this.
I see the concept of this — experienced player targets experienced player to get them out of the way and win uncontested — but Former was so bad this game that I don’t think the logic works. If Former had been a particularly contentious or reachy wagon, or if there had been other similar options, I think this theory is pretty valid. But Former ruined our D1 with trolling and Tommy was right to advocate his lynch almost as a policy so we could move on with D2 without an active troll.
Personally I’m not thinking of Former as experienced in the context of this game. He was the worst player on D1 and that’s irrespective of his prior experience.
Wdym
CB and TBZ are scum leans to me. TBZ hasn’t anything towny this game really, while CB is a very mixed bag weighted to scummy. I do agree shooting here is viable today and is probably the camp I’m in right now.