Not saying that Jal couldn't be a scum, but my reason felt weak
vote DS.
And tommy likes DS and I’m kinda going with it
Not bothered reading heals post so I'm assuming he's town
All of DS's posts in this thread have been super short and either biting or some kind of sarcastic. Maybe it's bitterness from 451, maybe it's being snippy to try to start fights between townies. Overall DS seems to be trying to cause conflict instead of comradery, which is fairly anti-town, but there's other anti-town salt in this thread too.
The sharp tongue could be viewed as scumhunting but to me it's coming across as more of conflict-promoting. So yeah at this time and place I have to scumlean DS, would love to hear more from them tho.
let's keep it on topic, folks
no zombies no ex-dates no nuffin'
m2h
doggo/hal/hannah
energy/tbz/moody/texas
clarinet/dusk/fenrir
jalmont/ds
Oh so you scum huh
I kind of have to question why clarinet feels so confident in Texas
from the few games I've dealt with clarinet I don't think I've gotten him right once so my lean here is scum so he's probably town
M2H's towncore/scumpile on page 11 has problems already mentioned. Curious how he decided on positions for me/Moody/Clarinet/Energy there; currently think there's TMI involved.
Hannah gives me bad vibes for reasons I can't explain well; her fixation on not reading DS (either due to a lack of content or inability to accurately do so) doesn't feel natural.
hot take if clarinet is scum, then texas is lock town
how is this type of post helpful at all. how does this post advance the gamestate. what does this even mean.
what's the point of these hypotheticals when its just complicating things when we can barely formulate coherent thoughts on who might even be mafia in the first place let alone if x, then y then z but if and only if j and then that leads to u and then we win.
maybe its plain english for the 451 gang but im retarded and i need help.
help.
K so taking a break from my player analyses, hit me up if you want to hear my thoughts on any player in particular that I haven't gotten to yet, or feel free to ask follow ups for the ones I did talk about.
Mfw game feels slow/stagnant despite 25 pages.
I disagree with the consensus on Moody's vote also but find it NAI as opposed to scummy. How do you feel now that I'm posting :eyes:
I disagree with the consensus on Moody's vote also but find it NAI as opposed to scummy. How do you feel now that I'm posting :
This is based on the v early pages so yes; there are parts of this list I agree with:
But I'm generally feeling more reluctant to put more people as town just because not many people are jumping out to me as towny. Not feeling strongly on Jalmont/DS beyond the latter's unusual lowposting; Clarinet I can see with all the hanging questions in his ISO, not a lynch I'd say no to. I'm probably suffering heavily from the lack of posts from some people, and yes I of all people claim the right to say that.
I enjoy being right. I also just enjoy putting my thoughts out there. I dont tend to worry if a post will hurt my w/l because its legit hard for me to control myself and I find that these games tend to work themselves out if I just play and trust my gut.
But establishing who can't be partners IMO is always useful. I think clarinet is never with Texas and probably not with doggo. That isn't winning us the game, but it is helpful
Huh??????????????????????????????????????????
A post will hurt your win/loss? What??? pls tell me i dont know what that means
are you keeping track of everything you're writing down? i hope so because otherwise its just wasting space. i aint keeping track of any of these thats for sure. im not saying dont post, im saying dont post for the sake of posting.
im just retarded so i was just wondering. sryI do post in a stream of consciousness style. I think there's value in the vast majority of my posts. If you want to school me on play style pref, go ahead.
regarding Hannah, I think Hannah's desire to not read DS. makes perfect sense. She still beats herself up for getting pocketed by him by DS. months ago.
Re-read thread, reads list
Towny
HealNDeal - no agenda, tone is v pure, #127 is a very self-aware post which is a bit scuzzy but that's also how they are on discord too so don't think its bad
DS - iirc scum meta is to be an absolute bastard and he's pretty much not done that so. thought he might be doing some posturing earlier but is hasn't held p
M2H - has been kind of weird with overexplaining some things and sounding awkward but he also sounds natural at the same time and i don't see the awkwardness coming from scum, unsure on this one but gun to head call it town
Null
Clarinet - is in the game but not doing anything yet, tonally seems comfortable
apricity - see above, will deal with you later
Thunder~Ballz - see above, will ignore you later
Scummy
Duskfall - calls out two things as scum slips that actually aren't and gets weirdly aggro on his pushes on m2h, this looks like dusk is hiding an agenda behind a tunnel
Play the game?
Energy
JALMONT
MoodyCloud
Fenrir Aesir
Hannahh (you get a pass for whatever thing you said you were busy with)
lurker pool probably has one scum, maybe two, annoying to try and solve this when half the game isn't playing >:[